Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Silence in Church


Recommended Posts

MarysLittleFlower
Posted

How can we promote quiet in church after Mass? And if you're trying to pray after Mass and others around you are chatting, how do you fight frustration or judging them? 

puellapaschalis
Posted

Tape everyone's mouths shut.

(From someone who suffers muchly from this...although probably not as much as others suffer from me in other ways in church, I suppose)

MarysLittleFlower
Posted

Lol! :) in the parish where I usually go, signs appeared at the back asking for quiet in church. I thought it was before a wedding or a funeral but the signs stayed up after. But my parish is way quieter than anywhere else I've been.

During the summer, like now, I'm in another city. A few times I had the urge to ask the people to go into the hall, but that came from frustration so I'm glad I didn't! I just keep praying. But it would be nice to get less annoyed :(  I try to remember maybe they weren't catechised about this.

I read a letter from St Padre Pio to his spiritual daughter about keeping silence in church to respect the Eucharist and that just stayed with me. I think we can also do prayers of reparation because the result of this is that Jesus is ignored. 

puellapaschalis
Posted

Once I was praying in church and two parishoners (both of whom I kind of knew anyway) were yacking whilst cleaning. After a while I went over and asked if they could keep it down a bit - got a prissy look from the lady, but it was quiet again. But I wouldn't do that where I am now: different church, different culture, different situation, all that shebangle. Here I really have no option other than bow the head and offer it up. It's far from easy, but these little things at least 100% my RDA of Small Offerings And Sacrifices.

MarysLittleFlower
Posted

Yea sometimes all we can do is offer it up! 

CountrySteve937
Posted

I think the best way we can promote quiet is first by prayer. Pray for the people talking and pray for inner quiet as well. Maybe you can ask your Pastor to mention it in one of the sermons?

Posted

Pastors rarely take responsibility for such a thing. It'd "upset too many people".

My solution: Wait for the VII generation to die. That should improve the situation quite a bit in many parishes.

Until then: earplugs. They work for me.

MarysLittleFlower
Posted

At the parish i go to during the 'school year', my priest did comment on the noise level before a funeral (very gently) and later signs were put in the church :) its a very traditional parish though...

He is Risen!
Posted

Before I started attending the FSSP mass, this was an issue for me, too.  I was tempted to wear a pair of those big construction worker ear muffs but thankfully  the noisy church also had a sealed off cry room chapel where you could still see the sanctuary through a big glass window.  My strategy was to wait until it cleared out (usually that was pretty fast after mass) and I go in and shut the door behind me.  If your church has an adoration chapel, that might also be a good option.

DominicanHeart
Posted

:dontlike:The crowds right before weddings are usually the worst.

Posted

My confessor agreed to do an infant baptism for a family that weren't regulars at the parish. It took place at the beginning of the Liturgy, and the church was packed on one side with all the relatives of that family. The baptism was beautiful etc. etc. but when it's over, you just go straight into the Liturgy, which I guess this family didn't know, because they immediately started celebrating and mingling right there in the church. Not even just a bit of noise as everyone cuddles the baby and congratulates the parents, eventually settling down, noooooo... these guys were intent on starting the party right then and there. I don't think anybody would have minded if it was just ignorance and they'd shut up when they noticed that the liturgics were continuing around them, but they blatantly just couldn't care less. It just carried on, and on, and on! I think I was singing that day so I couldn't go and throw the baptismal water at them, but one of the servers cleared them out after a while.

~non-judgment fail~

IgnatiusofLoyola
Posted (edited)

I'll pipe in with what at least some Episcopalians do. Often the organist will play as the priest, servers, and choir process out, and then continue playing as the congregation leaves. Especially if the organist is particularly good, some people in the congregation will sit quietly and listen to the rest of the organ music. This could also be a chance to kneel quietly and pray. 

Having the organist playing also discourages people from starting their conversations until after they leave the sanctuary. 

When I started attending Roman Catholic Mass regularly with my then-fiance, it was the first time I saw people regularly leaving Mass right after Communion. :idontknow:

Edited by IgnatiusofLoyola
Nihil Obstat
Posted (edited)

 

I'll pipe in with what at least some Episcopalians do. Often the organist will play as the priest, servers, and choir process out, and then continue playing as the congregation leaves. Especially if the organist is particularly good, some people in the congregation will sit quietly and listen to the rest of the organ music. This could also be a chance to kneel quietly and pray. 

Having the organist playing also discourages people from starting their conversations until after they leave the sanctuary. 

When I started attending Roman Catholic Mass regularly with my then-fiance, it was the first time I saw people regularly leaving Mass right after Communion. :idontknow:

Our organist often does that too. It is an invaluable asset to the community.

Edited by Nihil Obstat
puellapaschalis
Posted

In my experience, the organ playing after Mass just encourages people to talk louder so that they can hear themselves and the conversation over the racket of that tiresome organ.

Posted (edited)

I don't know how to train people to do it, but in any traditional parish I've been in, after Mass has ended, and the priest processes out, as soon as he is out of the church the majority of the congregation just kneels and prays. Those who are visiting either quickly leave or catch on that they should be quiet. It also helps though if someone is trying to talk to you after mass to sort of usher them out: "let's continue talking in the reception area/outside".  But how to get this started is a mystery. I once had a priest who gave a homily about quiet after mass and the congregation literally stampeded out. The next week they were back to their chatty selves. I find the worst offenders are the greeters and ushers. They typically stand the door and talk loudly among themselves and it echoes through the whole church. 

Edited by truthfinder
Basilisa Marie
Posted

How can we promote quiet in church after Mass? And if you're trying to pray after Mass and others around you are chatting, how do you fight frustration or judging them? 

As per the fighting frustration/etc part, what I find helpful is remembering that the Mass isn't about you. You bring your personal prayer to it, of course, and the priest offers up your sacrifice and his and ours together on the altar, but it's not about you. Go home and pray in your room if you want prayer about you. Mass is where we come together as a community, as a church, warts and all. 

It's harsh, and I struggle with it, but so far it's been the most helpful thing. 

 

Posted

I once had a priest who gave a homily about quiet after mass and the congregation literally stampeded out. The next week they were back to their chatty selves. 

I was of the opinion that no change could ever be made without a priest insisting on it. So this is discouraging.

Maybe a priest who repeatedly brings it up and puts signs on the doors and whatnot could pull it off? :idontknow:

Posted

I was of the opinion that no change could ever be made without a priest insisting on it. So this is discouraging.

Maybe a priest who repeatedly brings it up and puts signs on the doors and whatnot could pull it off? :idontknow:

I'm not so sure.  I think what did help a little was when they started offering snacks outside after Mass. Those who wanted to pray stayed in the Church, and those who wanted to mingle probably also wanted a snack.  Considering there have been numerous signs over the years about not wearing tank tops and shorts during the summer, it still happens (and peculiarly enough it's always the older parishioners who think they're exempt from the rules - they're also the chattiest). 

Spem in alium
Posted

Oh yes, older parishioners seem to be the worst! Talking before Mass, after Mass....even during Mass.

I agree that organ music is invaluable after Mass. I generally notice it does stop people from talking.

But it really does depend on where you are, and upon the culture of the place. In Rome, it's very common for people to use churches as a meeting or gathering place, which shocked me the first time I saw it --- people chatting while the Mass is going on, yakking away through the Consecration, etc. One of my Sisters mentioned to me that it even happens during weddings - I'm not sure that she was at the particular wedding she was telling me about, but she said that only the bride, groom, and the priest were participating in the Mass --- everyone else was having a right old time chatting in the pews. 

 

Posted

My solution: Wait for the VII generation to die. That should improve the situation quite a bit in many parishes.

True. Also my thought when confronted with people-not-kneeling, receiving Communion in the hand, never confessing, shaking hands with everyone at the Sign of Peace, singing idiotic Evangelical songs, etc. etc. 

The post-VII generation can be compared to people who migrate at fifteen, never speak their native language anymore, and are thus unable to speak their mother tongue when they visit their birth country after fifty years. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...