Archaeology cat Posted August 24, 2015 Posted August 24, 2015 if you have a problem with dress codes at Church, you should take it up with the Pope: I was thinking of that, actually. If my pastor or Bishop said no bare shoulders, I wouldn't have a problem with it. Yes, most of my dresses are sleeveless, but it wouldn't be a problem to pull on a shrug for Mass if needed.
julianneoflongbeach Posted August 25, 2015 Author Posted August 25, 2015 I didn't start this to complain about dress codes. I was actually looking for reasons why shoulders would be considered immodest, particularly from a Catholic perspective. (Thank you MLF for basically being the only person who tried.) Not just more, "Oh, well 'cus it's done and it's done and it's been done and get over it". And, "another modesty thread? " ... Well, don't read it or post in it then.
Ice_nine Posted August 25, 2015 Posted August 25, 2015 if you have a problem with dress codes at Church, you should take it up with the Pope: orange just doesn't look that great on me. I guess I can't visit THAT stupid church.
Maria_Faustina Posted August 25, 2015 Posted August 25, 2015 orange just doesn't look that great on me. I guess I can't visit THAT stupid church. You know, the orange I could live with. It's the midriff-baring style that I just refuse to do.
Maria_Faustina Posted August 25, 2015 Posted August 25, 2015 (edited) I didn't start this to complain about dress codes. I was actually looking for reasons why shoulders would be considered immodest, particularly from a Catholic perspective. (Thank you MLF for basically being the only person who tried.) Not just more, "Oh, well 'cus it's done and it's done and it's been done and get over it". And, "another modesty thread? " ... Well, don't read it or post in it then. But seriously though, I get what you're saying. (Or at least I think I do). You seem to be asking for logical, faith-based answers as to why this is a practice--why we do it now, or why it was ever started as a thing at all. (If I'm wrong, correct me!). As someone whose personal "modesty dress code" includes not wearing sleeveless tops, I actually had to stop and think about a specific source for my reasoning. I did think of the Vatican visitors dress code, as was mentioned, and also of Marian modesty, as was also mentioned. Pope Pius XI's statement on appropriate dress also came to mind--that's "A dress cannot be decent which is cut deeper than two fingers breath under the pit of the throat; which does not cover the arms at least to the elbows; and scarcely reaches a bit beyond the knees. Furthermore, dresses of transparent materials are improper", if you didn't know. All of those I took into account when deciding what I would and would not wear. Quite frankly, two fingers breath under the pit of the throat is hard to find in a shirt, so I go with "high enough to be noticeably modest when standing and high enough AND flush enough to be modest when bending over too" for my necklines. By noticeably modest, I mean at least two inches above where any cleavage could even BEGIN to show. Hence, I wear a camisole with straps adjusted all the way up pretty much every day! I know you weren't talking about necklines, but I just wanted to give an example of where I'm coming from other than just with sleeves. I don't wear sleeveless tops/dresses because it's just one more line I don't want to cross. I don't mean that in the sense of sinning; I mean that it simply helps in the elimination process of picking clothes. So, I suppose it's basically a practicality thing for me (within a faith foundation). When I go shopping, I already have my options greatly narrowed down, because too low/too tight/too short/sleeveless/strapless are all pretty much out of the question. (Sleeveless I can wear with a cardigan, so depending on what the item is/if I'll actually wear it enough to be worth having to wear a cardigan with it, cause when it's hot, boy do I want to be able to take off my cardigan). It does make finding clothes a little hard sometimes, but not impossible. For that reason, I treat it as a little sacrifice to make for the Lord. Trust me, there are plenty of super cute neon cut-out body-con club-type dresses that I know I would feel (and probably look) sexy in, but the only one who I would let see that would be my (future) husband, even though sometimes I'm really tempted to say "Screw it, who cares" and just buy/wear the cute backside-emphasizing thing anyway. Because, well, celebrities/everyone else/my sister can do this, so why can't I? I deserve to feel attractive/look hot, don't I? Buuuut in the end, I don't. Even though I may pout at the Lord at little bit. My friends and family know I have this "rule" and they know it's because I'm Catholic. It's a little witness, at least. For one more little rational reasoning behind it, like someone said, it's because sleeveless tops/dresses come a lot closer to showing off areas that should be kept more covered. Tank tops/sleeveless dresses, even the nice Talbot's/Chaps/church-y floral Mom kind, still almost always tend to pucker around the armpit area, so as a result I see many bras even in church. They don't even have to be cute bras, seeing them at all is still distracting. Like if a little girl is in front of you during Mass and keeps pulling up her dress to admire her new Barbie underwear. No, it's not sexual or impure at all--in fact, it's probably cute--and she is certainly hardly at fault. It is, however, distracting, and I guess that's the bottom line. Many sleeveless dresses for women also tend to be immodest in the length/neckline area too. I find it's usually better to just avoid them altogether (although the attraction to the cute styles is always there. I love cute clothes, and I will not lie). As far as the distracting aspect again, I also won't wear something to Mass if it is too "flashy", even though it may be modest. I have a nice cotton, pleated, scoopneck dress that is by Maggy London (so business/career nice), and has like, pinks and oranges and greens and leaves and stripes and flowers and all sorts of patterns on it. I love it, but uh, I just want to go to Mass and look nice--not under-dressed, but not over-the-top either--for the Lord, not distract people with my outfit. If I'm wearing a skirt and a cardigan, I know I will look nice, feel pretty and feminine, yet not look out of place. I want people to--if they look at me--think, she must be going to church. And outside of church, I want people to think--if they look at me--she must be a Christian; or to at least view my outfit neutrally, not giving them CAUSE for either extreme ("look how much skin she's showing off" to "look how much she's trying to cover her body"). Because in the end, it is not me they should be looking at, but Him. Edited August 25, 2015 by Maria_Faustina Fonts were being weird
Maria_Faustina Posted August 25, 2015 Posted August 25, 2015 shoulders are hot. Who doesn't know that? Try sunscreen?
CatherineM Posted August 25, 2015 Posted August 25, 2015 My shoulders are enormous. My neck has been described as Cardasian. So my shoulders often show out of the neck of my shirts.
Ash Wednesday Posted August 26, 2015 Posted August 26, 2015 I didn't start this to complain about dress codes. I was actually looking for reasons why shoulders would be considered immodest, particularly from a Catholic perspective. I've always understood is that it had to do with the visibility of skin and the body in general -- i.e. avoiding occasions of sin. So tightness of clothing would also apply. I don't know if the Church has ever taught much specifically (like given a prescriptive list to be followed at all times), I've never come across anything about it. Of course, cultural and social norms have influenced what is immodest by society at large. In the past, a woman's bare shoulders were viewed as more risqué than they are now. Certain things considered acceptable in church dress code have changed (length of skirts, formality of dress (both men and women), and .........pantaloons...........) but covered shoulders in dress codes has remained pretty common in my experience. I think as others have pointed out, covering the shoulders at churches imposing a dress code probably has less to do with a Victorian hangover and more to do with formality and avoiding tourists coming in dressed like they just came off the beach.
puellapaschalis Posted August 26, 2015 Posted August 26, 2015 My understanding was that it was partly because (women's) shoulders are also erogenous zones, though I doubt that word would be the one used in any document.
CrossCuT Posted August 26, 2015 Posted August 26, 2015 Everything is an endogenous zone to someone so are we going to resign ourselves to wearing comforters over our heads while we go to the grocery store? At some point we gotta hold dudes responsible for their pervy thoughts.
Ice_nine Posted August 26, 2015 Posted August 26, 2015 your face is an endogenous zone. Or erogenous. Oh whatever this thread is weird.
Gabriela Posted August 26, 2015 Posted August 26, 2015 And, "another modesty thread? " ... Well, don't read it or post in it then. Wait.
Basilisa Marie Posted August 26, 2015 Posted August 26, 2015 I think the bigger problem is how people are treated when they come to Mass, dress code or none. I'd rather be at a parish with no dress code and everyone wearing jeans and T-shirts with a friendly, welcoming community than a parish with a strict dress code and everyone giving me the evil eye or coming up to me to complain about how my clothing is inappropriate. No matter how beautiful the liturgy was at the second parish, I'd never want to go back. When I go to Mass at my work parish I wear skirts that are at least to my knee or dress pantaloons, nothing low-cut, and shrugs over my shoulders if my top is sleeveless. It's more modest than my personal "line" for church modesty (I don't have a problem with nice dark jeans with a fancy blouse, or even sleeveless shirts if they're truly sleeveless and not a one-inch or less strap), but many of the people at my work parish make next to no effort to dress up for Mass in the slightest, wear sports jerseys and t shirts with writing on them and shorts, etc. Even many of the liturgical ministers don't always get it. I'm trying to set an example because I'm staff and highly visible. But these people are very warm and welcoming, and would treat me no differently if I wore shorts or a wrist-length dress and a mantilla. If a pastor wants to enforce a dress code, there's a lot of good that can come from it. And people seem to be pretty quick on the uptake if they're the only ones wearing shorts and t shirts to Mass and everyone else is in skirts and jackets. People have eyes, and they'll want to fit in.
BarbTherese Posted August 26, 2015 Posted August 26, 2015 (edited) Any case for custody of the eyes and heart, thoughts? - and to remember that the poor most often do not have a wardrobe from which to make selections. Most often they cannot select and buy clothing but are dependant on charity. I really do think that I should rejoice at those brothers and sisters attending Mass with me, my worship community, rather than casting critical eyes over whatever they might wear. "Man judges by appearances, but The Lord knows the heart" (First Book of Samuel Ch16) I recall one Sunday many years ago a young teenage male coming in to Mass wearing sloppy jeans and Tshirt with a baseball cap. When the collection went round, he took off his baseball cap and put it in the plate. After Mass some ladies were quite disgusted with what he had done. I was quite surprised indeed at their comments, since I had thought that he had probably put into the plate what he valued most. Life is most often all perspective and attitude. Edited August 26, 2015 by BarbaraTherese
Ash Wednesday Posted August 27, 2015 Posted August 27, 2015 At some point we gotta hold dudes responsible for their pervy thoughts. And women. Nowdays it's considered socially acceptable for women to openly objectify and lust after men just the same. Really, custody of thought and having respect for one another applies not only to both sexes, but gay and straight as well. I think so often we focus on modesty for women and the wandering eyes of men, we forget that the responsibility applies to everyone.
Ice_nine Posted August 27, 2015 Posted August 27, 2015 And women. Nowdays it's considered socially acceptable for women to openly objectify and lust after men just the same. Really, custody of thought and having respect for one another applies not only to both sexes, but gay and straight as well. I think so often we focus on modesty for women and the wandering eyes of men, we forget that the responsibility applies to everyone. While lust is immoral regardless of your gender, it's much less threatening coming from a female to a male. I think that's part of why it's seen as acceptable amongst some folks.
CrossCuT Posted August 27, 2015 Posted August 27, 2015 And women. Nowdays it's considered socially acceptable for women to openly objectify and lust after men just the same. Really, custody of thought and having respect for one another applies not only to both sexes, but gay and straight as well. I think so often we focus on modesty for women and the wandering eyes of men, we forget that the responsibility applies to everyone. That is a given of course. But thus far in the thread we are only talking about women.
Basilisa Marie Posted August 27, 2015 Posted August 27, 2015 While lust is immoral regardless of your gender, it's much less threatening coming from a female to a male. I think that's part of why it's seen as acceptable amongst some folks. I agree, which is why I think we have to be more careful to actually talk about the fact that yes, women do physically objectify men and yes, it's a commonplace thing and not only socially acceptable but often encouraged. The implication being that it's easier for a man to sexually assault a woman than a woman to sexually assault a man, so a woman objectifying a man must be harmless! Which is a total farce. Yeah, we women should make sure we wear stuff that we aren't going to pop out of when we move. But that's because we're respecting our human dignity and making it easier for ourselves to focus on Christ and what we're doing and not being distracted by making sure our outfits are behaving. Any effect our appearance has on men has to be a secondary consideration to that.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now