Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Soldier4Him
Posted

Anybody seen the Leelee Sobeiski version of Joan of Arc that was a tv mini series? It's available on video and DVD now. I own it! I was just curious about what everyone thought of her portrayal.

GirlInTheWhiteArmor
Posted

I love Joan of Arc!!!!! The Leelee Sobieski movie is really good, but some parts are not that accurate, like her relationship with her father. Her martyrdom broke his heart and he died. If you like that movie, you should see the older one with Ingrid Bergman. That one's good too.

Posted

[quote name='GirlInTheWhiteArmor' date='Jun 17 2004, 02:13 PM'] I love Joan of Arc!!!!! The Leelee Sobieski movie is really good, but some parts are not that accurate, like her relationship with her father. Her martyrdom broke his heart and he died. If you like that movie, you should see the older one with Ingrid Bergman. That one's good too. [/quote]
That is a really good version. I haven't seen the newer one, though. :unsure:

Soldier4Him
Posted

I didn't know the older version existed. I'll look into it.

Hey Girlinwhitearmor, where'd u come up with your name?

crusader1234
Posted

I always laugh at the commercials for that movie...


im just a messenger...

spooky

Posted

I thought that version, while probably better than the one with Milla Jovovich, it missed the mark cos in the battles, the Maid just rides around, waving a flag and holding up a shield to block arrows. That, to me, was disappointing, because I'm sure that St Joan [i]did[/i] actually fight...
The one with MJ seemed a bit too much like a Hollywood action blockbuster to me. Not that I remember it too well...
I'll have to see if I can dig up the older version at the vid store or something...

ilovechrist
Posted

Joan of Arc is AWESOME--course i never saw the older one.... the newer one rocked!

Soldier4Him
Posted

I just wanna clarify which version of Joan I'm talking about. The one where Leelee Sobeiski played Joan. It was a tv miniseries they showed in 2 parts over 2 nights. And she DID fight in that version. I'm not talking about the version that was in theatres called "The Messenger". Anywho. Moving on!

Posted

oh well not like I have the best memory of the movie, but anyway...

Posted

I thought it was brilliant. I own the 2set Video and DVD.. :D Leelee, plays the part well, and the whole 'grey/blue scale' theme works well. There are a few parts that are off, especially at Orleans, but still its a kool movie, and a bit emotional to. <_<

Soldier4Him
Posted

I agree Morph. I was very impressed with LeeLee. And she did a lot of research too. I watch the DVD all the time.

Posted

Ive seen it 72 times. I was so 'into' it, I watched it 2-3 times a day sometimes. ** Can remember every scene almost **..:D

WHat religion is LeeLee?

Soldier4Him
Posted

Hmmm....I'm not sure Morph. But I will investigate!

Posted

Could she be Jewish? Ski?...

daugher-of-Mary
Posted

I really, really liked the old black and white version..mostly because the expression the actors put into their parts was beautiful. :D

Posted

I REALLY LOVE ST. JOAN OF ARC!!!! :wub:^_^ :hearts: She is by far my favorite saint. I really like the LeeLee movie. There are a few things I don't like. For example the way Joan is a little feministic in the movie. The facts are pretty straight though. I like the Ingrid Bergman (sp) one too. The only thing is she is a little too soft. If they made a St. Joan of Arc movie that combined the two then it would really be awesome!!!!

Pax out!
meg

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...