Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Really?!? Small synod rant


Recommended Posts

Posted

Sorry if I missed this elsewhere today, but a Quebec bishop went and said some silly things today.

http://www.catholicherald.co.uk/news/2015/10/06/synod-should-reflect-on-possibility-of-allowing-female-deacons-says-canadian-archbishop/

 

I really thought the Quebec episcopacy was getting better. TL;DR - Bishop says women should be ordained deacons, diaconate was never ordered towards the priesthood (I already feel the tremors in the earth), and that women should be given more institutional authority.

Now I'm not sure how the Chanceries are run in other places, but in the number that I've dealt with, chanceries and parish committees are often 50%+ women.  I'm not even sure there's an emoticon that adequately represents what I feel for this statement.  :stubborn::idontknow: (some sort of this combination). 

bardegaulois
Posted

Now if all this dissent is bubbling up to the top in this synod, why is it even being held in the first place?

Posted

In some ways, I've been trying to not pay attention to the synod, but when I saw this headline I was curious as to who exactly was suggesting it (suspecting one of the German contingency - I was so wrong). 

Posted

If one is not a transitional deacon why cant women take such a position? I think its an amesome idea!

Nihil Obstat
Posted

If one is not a transitional deacon why cant women take such a position? I think its an amesome idea!

Because women cannot and never will be ordained. Period, end of story.

Posted

Because women cannot and never will be ordained. Period, end of story.

A permanent deacon is never ordained and sometimes he is even married. I feel like this is similar to having a female cardinal. 

PhuturePriest
Posted

A permanent deacon is never ordained and sometimes he is even married. I feel like this is similar to having a female cardinal. 

The diaconate is an ordained clergymen. They are ordained just as much as priests are.

Posted (edited)

The diaconate is an ordained clergymen. They are ordained just as much as priests are.

Are cardinals ordained as well? Could you say nuns are ordained too just in a different way?

Edited by CrossCuT
Posted (edited)

giphy.thumb.gif.b98c91713c2e01ec32c8d6b5

 

Deacons, priests and bishops are the three major orders (that is ordained clerics).  The canonist Ed Peters has been writing about the problems he sees within canon law about there being no differentiate between transitional and permanent deacons and the requirement for continence.  But that's a rabbit hole: the point being a deacon is a deacon and they're all ordained.  Cardinals are not ordained; it's an honorary position - them being made a cardinal in no way resembles the ordination ceremonies.  There has been some language about nuns being ordained, but again, this is normally said by those who are not Catholic writing about them.  Nuns are consecrated or professed (depending on the community, its vows, and constitutions).  Ordination is a sacrament, and thus imparts an indelible mark upon the soul.  

Edited by truthfinder
gif didn't want to gif
Posted

giphy.thumb.gif.b98c91713c2e01ec32c8d6b5

 

Deacons, priests and bishops are the three major orders (that is ordained clerics).  The canonist Ed Peters has been writing about the problems he sees within canon law about there being no differentiate between transitional and permanent deacons and the requirement for continence.  But that's a rabbit hole: the point being a deacon is a deacon and they're all ordained.  Cardinals are not ordained; it's an honorary position - them being made a cardinal in no way resembles the ordination ceremonies.  There has been some language about nuns being ordained, but again, this is normally said by those who are not Catholic writing about them.  Nuns are consecrated or professed (depending on the community, its vows, and constitutions).  Ordination is a sacrament, and thus imparts an indelible mark upon the soul.  

Thank you for the explanation. 

bardegaulois
Posted

Are cardinals ordained as well? Could you say nuns are ordained too just in a different way?

Cardinals are elevated, usually from the ranks of the episcopate. Nuns profess vows. Deacons are, like bishops and priests, ordained according to the sacrament of Holy Orders, a sacrament which grants an ineffaceable character to the soul. The rite of ordination of deacons may be found here: http://www.diocesepvd.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/Ordination-1-13.pdf.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

There were deaconesses in the early Church, there's no evidence they were ordained (whereas there IS evidence that men were ordained deacons). Back then deacons were almost exclusively doing service work, plus helping people get baptized (naked, in the dark, by full immersion and a full rub-down with sacred oils) during the Easter Vigil. A lot of widows joined the order of deaconesses. They'd be more like your St. Vincent de Paul or Knights of Columbus today. The whole point of deacons is to do that service work so that the Apostles could spend more time preaching the Gospel, because it was more important for them to be doing that, and they could get others to distribute food and whatnot. 

Today, permanent deacons can't actually marry again once their spouse dies, or if they're unmarried they can't get married. 

We COULD actually have female cardinals. They might even have full voting privileges during a conclave. But hey could only vote for a Catholic man (if he weren't already a bishop he'd be ordained deacon, priest, bishop when he accepted his office). 

As far as religious orders go, I once heard someone say that religious vows are a perfected state of the regular lay Christian's duty and life. That's why it's not a separate sacrament for religious vows (unlike ordination or marriage). 

blazeingstar
Posted

I like Simcha Fisher's take on the matter.  It dosn't cost us anything to hear people out.

http://www.ncregister.com/blog/simcha-fisher/shush-your-mother-is-trying-to-listen/

In the end it may give us a nugget of truth that they are going off of that we can change an adapt to (perhaps a lay community of women who are commissioned by the dioceses and are as well educated as deacons) or perhaps we can hear in the presenter something about them that will allow us to council them with greater understanding.  (eg apologize for sins of the church, correct their mistaken beliefs, etc)

Posted

I like Simcha Fisher's take on the matter.  It dosn't cost us anything to hear people out.

http://www.ncregister.com/blog/simcha-fisher/shush-your-mother-is-trying-to-listen/

In the end it may give us a nugget of truth that they are going off of that we can change an adapt to (perhaps a lay community of women who are commissioned by the dioceses and are as well educated as deacons) or perhaps we can hear in the presenter something about them that will allow us to council them with greater understanding.  (eg apologize for sins of the church, correct their mistaken beliefs, etc)

I'm by no means against innovation that leads to better evangelization and the like.  But the ordination question is settled.  It seems highly irresponsible for a bishop to suggest the contrary especially at such a meeting where he's probably aware it's going to be publicized.  It's all fine and dandy to have pet theological ideas that are privately discussed, but on such an open stage, it's really not a defensible position.  It's reckless, and it sows doubt amongst not only the believers but also those outside the church.  

blazeingstar
Posted

I'm by no means against innovation that leads to better evangelization and the like.  But the ordination question is settled.  It seems highly irresponsible for a bishop to suggest the contrary especially at such a meeting where he's probably aware it's going to be publicized.  It's all fine and dandy to have pet theological ideas that are privately discussed, but on such an open stage, it's really not a defensible position.  It's reckless, and it sows doubt amongst not only the believers but also those outside the church.  

But that's completely the opposite of Simcha (and my) point. It dosn't matter if it's the worlds stupidest position.  Just like a mother will never let her child eat rat poison, she, in her wisdom, can let her child speak to her on the matter of why they think they should be permitted to do so.  It dosn't mean that she will ever let her child eat rat poision, all it means is that she's not shutting her child down.

This is what the Synoid is doing.  They are hearing out all the stupid positions.  They are not going to give creedance to the rumor that the church won't listen.  This open stage is just the place...for many indefensible positions.  If it sows doubt among people as to what is possible, it's not the synoid's fault.  People have come up with crazy ideas since the dawn of time.  People have aired it out.  Lets hope that we have found a better way to deal with it since Martin Luther.

Posted

I think at the end of this synod, the Vatican should just release this: JPII Letter to Families

And say "WHAT HE SAID" in big bold letters at the top.

 

Posted

from the article

Another thing, he said, “would be to look at the possibility of allowing married couples — men and women, who have been properly trained and accompanied — to speak during Sunday homilies so that they can testify, give witness to the relationship between God’s word and their own marriage life and their own life as families.”

 

:wall:

 

 

Posted

When permanent deacons were reinstated, our archbishop was so excited that he started a program immediately before the regulations were sent down. The first class had women. They were close to ordination before the archbishop was informed it would be men only. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...