Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Not The Philosopher
Posted

Indeed, the first religious order to arrive would have bragging rights for centuries.

PhuturePriest
Posted

idk i don't think its a competition. like, far be it from me to decide which things are more important and dignified. Maybe there's an old lady in Brooklyn saying a Hail Mary this very instant, and it could be the greatest most consequential act of heroism in the last thousand years. God knows. So on that I would check yourself before you wreck yourself.

Making sure that the first Martian civilization has Catholic representation seems a dignified mission to me. Making sure the arrival of humanity on extraterrestrial soil includes the arrival of Christianity ... yeah put me down.

Imagine being the first person to bring prayer and worship of the one true God ... to Mars. Wow.

I don't think it's a prideful or magnanimous statement to say that Saint Isaac Jogue's mission to America was more important than a mission to a planet with no known life whose mission is not even for evangelization purposes. It's certainly a commendable mission, and I would certainly not have the stomach for it, but salvation is always more important than scientific discovery.

Not The Philosopher
Posted

I think what Lillallillalillabett is trying to say is that sooner or later someone is going to colonize Mars, and that having a Catholic presence in that colony is better than not.

We can debate the accuracy of the first clause, but the second seems obvious.

Posted

I don't think it's a prideful or magnanimous statement to say that Saint Isaac Jogue's mission to America was more important than a mission to a planet with no known life whose mission is not even for evangelization purposes. It's certainly a commendable mission, and I would certainly not have the stomach for it, but salvation is always more important than scientific discovery.

that word, magnanimous. i don't think it means what you think it means.

I think what Lillallillalillabett is trying to say is that sooner or later someone is going to colonize Mars, and that having a Catholic presence in that colony is better than not.

We can debate the accuracy of the first clause, but the second seems obvious.

yes

early bird gets the worm when it comes to setting up civilization.

Posted

Could I volunteer some in-laws?

Posted

I will stay home and comfort your womenfolk.

MarysLittleFlower
Posted (edited)

PhuturePriest basically said what I was trying to say too. There's no one to evangelise on Mars. As for starting a civilization there... Not sure there either. In our fallen state, are we sure we want to colonize other planets? And Mars was clearly not meant for human life - minus 28 C temperature and no breathable air. Earth was designed for us. I'd rather stay here to concentrate on working out my salvation and living my vocation. Any vocation would be barely possible on Mars because of the conditions - and I don't think they'd be allowed to have children, for the married people. It just doesn't seem exactly like earth exploration. Also - I don't think these people would be coming back from what I read. There's only enough for one way journey. So if you come without a priest, I don't think there's any way to have the Sacraments ever. So far no priest has volunteered and I think there's more work for them on earth - priests are not scientists. Even if there was hope of this in the future, why would I deprive myself of the Blessed Sacrament for years just for science? The only way I would do that is it wasn't my own choice but circumstance. Having Communion is infinitely more important than any worldly pursuit IMO. 

Edited by MarysLittleFlower
Posted

There's no one to evangelise on Mars. 

How about the other people that go? 

And Mars was clearly not meant for human life - minus 28 C temperature and no breathable air.  

Meh, there's plenty of places on earth that are inhospitable, hasn't proved to be an absolute dealbreaker yet, this is just a more extreme version.

So far no priest has volunteered and I think there's more work for them on earth - priests are not scientists. Even if there was hope of this in the future, why would I deprive myself of the Blessed Sacrament for years just for science? The only way I would do that is it wasn't my own choice but circumstance. Having Communion is infinitely more important than any scientific pursuit IMO.

There are priests who are scientists. Vatican Observatory anyone? Certainly I agree with you, sacraments over science, but I'm not necessarily convinced that one has to be sacrificed for the other.  

Posted

PhuturePriest basically said what I was trying to say too. There's no one to evangelise on Mars. As for starting a civilization there... Not sure there either. In our fallen state, are we sure we want to colonize other planets? And Mars was clearly not meant for human life - minus 28 C temperature and no breathable air. Earth was designed for us. I'd rather stay here to concentrate on working out my salvation and living my vocation. Any vocation would be barely possible on Mars because of the conditions - and I don't think they'd be allowed to have children, for the married people. It just doesn't seem exactly like earth exploration. Also - I don't think these people would be coming back from what I read. There's only enough for one way journey. So if you come without a priest, I don't think there's any way to have the Sacraments ever. So far no priest has volunteered and I think there's more work for them on earth - priests are not scientists. Even if there was hope of this in the future, why would I deprive myself of the Blessed Sacrament for years just for science? The only way I would do that is it wasn't my own choice but circumstance. Having Communion is infinitely more important than any worldly pursuit IMO. 

The only way there wouldn't be people to evangelize on Mars would be if all the people who go are already Christian Catholics. Right. 

Posted

Ermmmm...priests are not scientists?  Haven't there been many very famious priest-scientists?  Maybe most priests aren't scientists but there are still some....I'd say especally among those in religious orders.  I know a diocean priest who's was considered a late vocation and did some notable engineering work on some electronics for planes that are an integral part of safety today  (he was an engineer for 30 years before becoming a priest).  I've know many of those Bronx priests to also be extremely well educated in the sciences.

As other posters pointed out, there's way more inhospitable places.  -28c is a fairly balmy -18F....which if we excluded all places that got that cold, there'd be no one north of the mason-dixon line.  There's places in Canada where people live that only get up to the 30's and 40's during summer.  Mars technically has better weather than that.

God has obviously given us the ability to reach this place and perhaps develop an atmosphere and enable a true colony.  Those people will still need God.

MarysLittleFlower
Posted (edited)

I'm sorry but Im not going to reply. I've said my view and I don't feel like having to debate it or defend it. If you disagree then you disagree. I'm sorry but I just can't debate anymore. 

Edited by MarysLittleFlower
Posted

I'm sorry but Im not going to reply. I've said my view and I don't feel like having to debate it or defend it. If you disagree then you disagree. I'm sorry but I just can't debate anymore. 

No ones attacking you.  You have a legitimate view but you stated some very silly reasons which are basically not true or are irrelevant. (Scientists priests and the weather)  You're allowed to hold that opinion....its not like you are alone...you do have the pheatus on your side.

Posted

And me! I'm against it too. For myself. Because of the exploding heads thing. No no no no

dominicansoul
Posted

We've seen many tragedies in space exploration.  This would be just another to add to that list.  I don't think man has the capability of pulling this off safely.

With that said, I don't even like leaving this earth for a few hours on a plane, so I can't imagine leaving this earth for good on a space ship...

Posted

 Having Communion is infinitely more important than any worldly pursuit IMO. 

pffft seeking the Truth is not a worldly pursuit. guessin you ain't a Dominican.

I think you need to read C.S. Lewis' space trilogy 

veritasluxmea
Posted

veritas!

What 

Oremus Pro Invicem
Posted

I will pass the glory on to someone else and happily stay here on planet Earth (Matthew 5:5)! ;)

 

Posted

We could send a couple Carthusians along for the ride.  They would be better equipped to deal with the isolation than anybody.  They could literally separate themselves from the world.  Maybe they could sneak a first-class relic on board.

Hmmm...if, one day, a real colony were founded, who would be its patron saint?  St. Bruno for the irony?

Basilisa Marie
Posted

So like, we do all know that there's a Russian Orthodox Chapel in Antarctica, right? No humans live naturally on that continent. 

The pursuit of truth is always a noble cause that gives great glory to God. We study Mars not just for its own sake, but because there's a strong possibility it can help us understand our own planet better, and good stewardship for creation is one of our duties as humans. Plus Christ is King of everything, not just our little dust speck of a planet. :)  Our belief in "the resurrection of the body and the life of the world to come" also means the Paschal Mystey has eschatological implications for the whole of the cosmos. 

People bravely put themselves at great risk of dying without the sacraments all the time, here on earth. We can pray for a happy, peaceful, viaticum-filled death but whether or not we're given such a gift is entirely up to God. The astronauts brought their protestant version of communion to the moon. There's no reason why we couldn't take viaticum to Mars. Talk about food for the journey, right?

There's absolutely nothing wrong with saying you don't see the point of a mission to Mars or that you'd rather die with a well founded hope to get last rites and viaticum. I think the thing people take issue with is that you're setting it up like it's either one or the other. That's a false dichotomy, it doesn't have to be science vs sacraments. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...