Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

+Chaput of Philadelphia: shelve 'disordered' language around homosexuality


Recommended Posts

Posted

Interesting, coming from a prelate who has a reputation for being 'conservative'. Thoughts?

 

Yes. An unfortunate sign of the times.

dominicansoul
Posted

The Church doesn't call anyone "disordered."  The Church calls homosexuality disordered.  BIG BIG HUGE difference...

 

Posted

While I agree with Nihil and DS, I have to say this terminology is, in my experience, the Catholic Church's most often misunderstood and offensively received. Should we change our terminology because other people totally misunderstand it? Because they won't take the time or make the effort to learn the theology behind it so they can interpret it in context?

If our mission is to evangelize, it may be a good idea to at least adopt other terms that we can use when first introducing the Church's teaching about homosexuality. Then, once defenses are down, we could explain the deeper "disordered" teaching.

So I'm not saying ditch it. But we do need to figure out some way to share the Church's teaching on homosexuality without immediately raising people's hackles. If they get offended, they shut down, and then we've got no chance of converting them.

KnightofChrist
Posted

If the Church surrenders to the world in this matter it will embolden her enemies and will make no difference to how she is judged and hated by the world. Any word used to describe the homosexual act as sinful or the desire as disordered will be rejected by the world. Any word that decribes the act and the desire in a negitive light will be seen as just as hateful and rigid as the words she uses now. Only when the Church surrenders her position completely will the world accept her.

Posted

If the Church surrenders to the world in this matter it will embolden her enemies and will make no difference to how she is judged and hated by the world. Any word used to describe the homosexual act as sinful or the desire as disordered will be rejected by the world. Any word that decribes the act and the desire in a negitive light will be seen as just as hateful and rigid as the words she uses now. Only when the Church surrenders her position completely will the world accept her.

How can we know this until we try using other words?

We need to be able to enter into a dialogue with people about this. If they shut us out immediately because we keep saying one really loaded, "offensive" word, we can't do that.

You may be right: Maybe it's not possible to enter into dialogue with people about this at all. But the fact that some homosexuals do eventually come to understand and occasionally even accept Church teaching on homosexuality suggests that someone did something right. We could learn from those experiences.

Posted

It appears Chaput wants to express the same message with a softer tone because some interpret a few words as hateful.   Unfortunately some say he is being too soft and has changed the message.  Both point to each other as swallowing camels while themselves choking on gnats.  

Often, it seems Christian love/salvation is simply being on the other side of the iron fist of judgement.  Same old turn or burn.  Meh. 

KnightofChrist
Posted (edited)

We have used over words. The homosexual act traditionally and bibically is known as sodomy and as a grave sin that crys out to heaven. Now it is known as a unnatural and disoredered act and the world still hates us.

Edited by KnightofChrist
KnightofChrist
Posted

Other*

Basilisa Marie
Posted

Come on guys, it's Chaput. He'd never say we should change Church teaching on something like this. 

The Church changes it's language all the time. Well, all the time might not be the best phrase. But look at proselytize vs evangelize. We don't talk about proselytizing anymore, because it has the unfortunate connotations of forced conversions, shouting incomprehensibly on street corners, and smacking people in the face with catechisms. Evangelize, on the other hand, is associated with preaching and living the Gospel in a whole multitude of ways. It's way better. And both refer to how we spread the Gospel. 

If someone doesn't understand what you're saying, the solution isn't always to talk louder. If a word is a stumbling block for people and causing more confusion (because "disordered" is a technical Church term and means something totally different in common English), why would we keep using it if we can spread the same Gospel message without it? Particular words shouldn't be what's most important. 

Posted (edited)

Any word used to describe the homosexual act as sinful or the desire as disordered will be rejected by the world. Any word that decribes the act and the desire in a negitive light will be seen as just as hateful and rigid as the words she uses now. Only when the Church surrenders her position completely will the world accept her.

Why?

You could have said the same thing about many things taught by Christians that were rejected by society at large at one point in time, and then came to be accepted by larger society at a later point in time. You seem to assume defeat. You seem to assume that the Church is incapable of influencing or changing popular opinion on moral matters. But history shows that is not the case. The Church has had a huge historical influence on societal values at large.

The question we now face is - how do we adapt to get our message across in the present culture?

Edited by Peace
Posted

Also, continuing Basilisa's point:

"confession" >> "reconciliation"

KnightofChrist
Posted

Why?

You could have said the same thing about many things taught by Christians that were rejected by society at large at one point in time, and then came to be accepted by larger society at a later point in time. You seem to assume defeat. You seem to assume that the Church is incapable of influencing or changing popular opinion on moral matters. But history shows that is not the case. The Church has had a huge historical influence on societal values at large.

The question we now face is - how do we adapt to get our message across in the present culture?

This is how drama gets started. People judge others personally, so I will not respond in kind, nor will I prop anyone that makes seemly personal judgements of others.

So long as the Church keeps the meaning of her language against the act and desire of homosexuality the same it isn't going to make a beaverdamn's difference to the world what words are used. It is the teaching and meaning that the world hates and finds hateful. And if we change the Church's language to make it 'nicer' or 'softer' we risk loosing the meaning and teaching of the Church.

We've had this discussion many times on Phatmass, but those who advocate changing the Church's language never offer any 'better' words that have the same meaning without watering down the Church's teaching.

Posted

This is how drama gets started. People judge others personally, so I will not respond in kind, nor will I prop anyone that makes seemly personal judgements of others.

So long as the Church keeps the meaning of her language against the act and desire of homosexuality the same it isn't going to make a beaverdamn's difference to the world what words are used. It is the teaching and meaning that the world hates and finds hateful. And if we change the Church's language to make it 'nicer' or 'softer' we risk loosing the meaning and teaching of the Church.

We've had this discussion many times on Phatmass, but those who advocate changing the Church's language never offer any 'better' words that have the same meaning without watering down the Church's teaching.

Knight,

At this point it's personal opinion what words mean to other people. 

I'm sure there is a point in the stories of Jesus eating with tax collectors and talking to women who were prostitutes.   Maybe it is only changing how you say it, not what you say.   

I do note how Catholics get so upset with each other about this teaching on homosexuality and then are confused and dismissive when non-Catholics are hurt and negative in their interpretation of what the Church is saying.  Are non-Catholics blamed when they simply hear condemnation instead of a call to a better way?   Same goal, two different paths. 

Posted

This is how drama gets started. People judge others personally, so I will not respond in kind, nor will I prop anyone that makes seemly personal judgements of others.

I made a judgment based on what you wrote.  You wrote that "Any word used to describe the homosexual act as sinful or the desire as disordered will be rejected by the world. Any word that decribes the act and the desire in a negitive light will be seen as just as hateful and rigid as the words she uses now. Only when the Church surrenders her position completely will the world accept her." This implies that no matter what the Church does larger society will reject what she teaches. It is an attitude that assumes defeat.

So long as the Church keeps the meaning of her language against the act and desire of homosexuality the same it isn't going to make a beaverdamn's difference to the world what words are used.

Again - why? You seem to think that it is impossible for the Church's position on homosexuality to be accepted by society at large. I do not see why that has to be the case.

It is the teaching and meaning that the world hates and finds hateful. And if we change the Church's language to make it 'nicer' or 'softer' we risk loosing the meaning and teaching of the Church.

We've had this discussion many times on Phatmass, but those who advocate changing the Church's language never offer any 'better' words that have the same meaning without watering down the Church's teaching.

 FYI - I do not advocate changing the Catechism on that point. I think the language of the Catechism is fine, but I think that individual Catholics could do a better job of explaining the reasons why the Church teaches what it does.

For better or worse, many people do perceive the Catholic Church's positions on various matters as hateful, and in some cases that is because they do not fully understand the reasons or rationale behind what she teaches. And they see the Church as just being dogmatic and caring about rigidly following rules than about caring about people. That was definitely the case with my sister before I explained some things to her, after which she able to change her view of the Church a bit. She is actually thinking about becoming Catholic now.

How you present yourself does matter. If you come of as angry and unwilling to look at things from the point of view of other people, or consider their concerns, you usually aren't going to get very far with them. And you have to shape your message taking into account the culture of the people that you are attempting to persuade. I think St. Paul talks about that.

Posted

I do note how Catholics get so upset with each other about this teaching on homosexuality and then are confused and dismissive when non-Catholics are hurt and negative in their interpretation of what the Church is saying.  

This is worthy of reflection and prayer.

dominicansoul
Posted

Sexuality comes up alot in highschool catechism classes.  When I teach highschool students, I do focus more on positive terms, the beauty we all encompass in our sexuality and how Christ and the Church teach us that it is very sacred and how our bodies do not belong to us, but that our bodies in fact belong to God for we were bought at a very very high price (the price of Christ's blood.)  I talk to all the students in this same vein, whether they be struggling with heterosexual desires or homosexual attractions or who knows what else!  (I don't want to hear their confessions! lol )  I don't think it's the language itself that needs to be changed, but just the way and manner and attitude that we preach about sex, period.

I also tend to focus more on our relationship with Christ and death to ourselves because the world around us and society as a whole wants us to forget about Christ and our relationship with Him and focus more inward, more selfishly to our own concupiscence---society demands we  focus on ourselves sooo much and what we "deserve" and what we want, regardless of the consequences.

I teach them what truly defines us is our relationship with God...and that we need to work constantly and stay focused on this relationship.

Archbishop Chaput has a point, but at the same time,  just know that there are people who are eager to change the Church's teaching entirely, and they will definitely use his advice to do just that...This was the case with Vatican II, peeps took the documents and did whatever they wanted in "the spirit of Vatican II."

I do emphasize to my students that Sin is ugly!  Sin is disordered...!  I think you will find the Church teaches this for every action that tears you away from the grace of God...

Not The Philosopher
Posted (edited)

I don't have an issue with 'disordered'. It's an important moral theological term. But like a lot of other technical terms, I don't think it needs to be used in every conversation we have, especially if it is liable to be misunderstood or misinterpreted in the context. If you're talking to your co-worker about the the Eucharist, you don't have to start by saying that the substance changes while the accidents remain the same - or, if you do, be prepared to explain Aristotelian terminology as well. I mean, the term disordered is part of natural law reasoning, and a lot of people have a poor understanding of what natural law is, and, frankly, a lot of Catholics don't do a good job of articulating it. You gotta learn the grammar as well as the vocab.

Edited by Not The Philosopher
KnightofChrist
Posted

I made a judgment based on what you wrote.  You wrote that "Any word used to describe the homosexual act as sinful or the desire as disordered will be rejected by the world. Any word that decribes the act and the desire in a negitive light will be seen as just as hateful and rigid as the words she uses now. Only when the Church surrenders her position completely will the world accept her." This implies that no matter what the Church does larger society will reject what she teaches. It is an attitude that assumes defeat.

Again - why? You seem to think that it is impossible for the Church's position on homosexuality to be accepted by society at large. I do not see why that has to be the case.

FYI - I do not advocate changing the Catechism on that point. I think the language of the Catechism is fine, but I think that individual Catholics could do a better job of explaining the reasons why the Church teaches what it does.

For better or worse, many people do perceive the Catholic Church's positions on various matters as hateful, and in some cases that is because they do not fully understand the reasons or rationale behind what she teaches. And they see the Church as just being dogmatic and caring about rigidly following rules than about caring about people. That was definitely the case with my sister before I explained some things to her, after which she able to change her view of the Church a bit. She is actually thinking about becoming Catholic now.

How you present yourself does matter. If you come of as angry and unwilling to look at things from the point of view of other people, or consider their concerns, you usually aren't going to get very far with them. And you have to shape your message taking into account the culture of the people that you are attempting to persuade. I think St. Paul talks about that.

I believe we're using the word "world" differently. Which is part of the issue with the Church's language. There are people who do not have the same understanding of the words that the Church uses. However, having different understandings or meanings of words is no good reason to drop use of those words. Changing the language risks changing the teaching just as changing the way one prays can change what one believes.  Anyway, the word "world" can have many meanings. It can mean Earth, or other planets, a continent, etc etc. I'm use the word as Christ used it in relation to the enemies of the Church. The world is the dominion of the Devil and those within that domain who's spiritual father is the devil. So this is why the world will never accept Church teaching. 

So I am not assuming the Church's defeat, the Church will over come the world but the world will never accept and obey her teachings. Even at the height of Christendom (which did not cover most of the Earth) the Devil was the prince of this world. Many did not actually follow or obey the Church's teachings, there where even those in the Church who did not. We should all be able to think of many such examples without me having to list them out.

Still the Church should strive for the salvation of every group of people and generation it encounters. The Church, like any good mother who warns against something that would cause the horrible death of their children, uses clear and strong language against sin to save us from the fires of Hell. Grave sin is a deadly poison and using soft and gentle language to warn against it will cause people to not take it seriously.

Yes, many people do perceive the Catholic Church's positions on various matters as hateful. But many people today also accept many grave sins as normal and acceptable. Many view good as evil and evil as good. The Church's unchanging Dogma is such an example, to the world and to many that is bad, but the Church's unchanging Dogma is actually good. Whatever language the Church uses, without changing teaching, it will still face this problem of trying to reach people across the void of the understanding of Good and Evil. The language that the Church does use is going to depend on people explaining it to others as you did with your sister and as I attempt to with the word world.

As for making personal character judgements I'm not going to make it my place to judge your character on what you seem to feel even if you choose to continue to judge mine. I see no good in that. I only wish to discuss the topic not our characters, at best it will divert the topic and at worse lead to bickering. I'm strong in my beliefs and I try to speak as clearly as possible. I am human and I can fail to do that and fail to be understood but I'm what you seem to think about me lol.

Posted

I believe we're using the word "world" differently. Which is part of the issue with the Church's language. There are people who do not have the same understanding of the words that the Church uses. However, having different understandings or meanings of words is no good reason to drop use of those words. Changing the language risks changing the teaching just as changing the way one prays can change what one believes.  Anyway, the word "world" can have many meanings. It can mean Earth, or other planets, a continent, etc etc. I'm use the word as Christ used it in relation to the enemies of the Church. The world is the dominion of the Devil and those within that domain who's spiritual father is the devil. So this is why the world will never accept Church teaching. 

Hmm. I have heard the "world" distinction made before but mainly among evangelical protestants (not that there is anything wrong with that).

Precisely, how do you define "world" as you use it above? What people are included in the "world" and what people are not included in the "world"? For example, are you putting all non-Catholics in the world? Are you putting all non-Christians in the world? What about Catholics who reject certain Church teachings such as her teaching on contraception? How about people who through no fault of their own have not heard the gospel?

Or are people who are in the "world" restricted to a more limited set of people, such as satanists, atheists, etc.?

However, having different understandings or meanings of words is no good reason to drop use of those words. Changing the language risks changing the teaching just as changing the way one prays can change what one believes. 

Sure. But sometimes it can be good to change words. It is cool to have the Mass in Latin, but if you get to a point where nobody on the Earth speaks Latin anymore, it could be a good idea to do it in English or Spanish.

Still the Church should strive for the salvation of every group of people and generation it encounters. The Church, like any good mother who warns against something that would cause the horrible death of their children, uses clear and strong language against sin to save us from the fires of Hell. Grave sin is a deadly poison and using soft and gentle language to warn against it will cause people to not take it seriously.

Fire and Brimstone works for some people. For other people not so much. I think that for some folks rather than shouting Fire and Brimstone, showing them a better alternative might be a better approach. I mean, let's take pre-marital sex as an example. If you approach someone who is not a Christian and enjoying a lewd lifestyle, and are just like "The way you are living is an abomination to the LORD and you will burn in HELL!" you probably aren't going to get so far. But can you offer the person something more appealing than what he already has? I think you can.

Anyway. I am not sure if we really disagree on it so much. It seems that to a certain extent we have been talking past each other.

As for making personal character judgements I'm not going to make it my place to judge your character on what you seem to feel even if you choose to continue to judge mine. I see no good in that. I only wish to discuss the topic not our characters, at best it will divert the topic and at worse lead to bickering. I'm strong in my beliefs and I try to speak as clearly as possible. I am human and I can fail to do that and fail to be understood but I'm what you seem to think about me lol.

It's not like I called you a harlot, you know. I haven't made any firm conclusions about your character. I thought that you were implying that the Church is unable to influence the moral view of society at large, and I don't think that conclusion was all that unreasonable based upon what you wrote.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...