Peace Posted October 29, 2015 Posted October 29, 2015 So what's so great about the "Latin Mass" for all of you Latin Mass heads out there? I've been twice. Mostly didn't get it. Seem to prefer the Mass in a language that I can speak. I am not saying that one is better/worse than the other. They are both from the Church and both good. But I am just wondering for folks who prefer the Latin Mass, what are the reasons for that preference? I usually go to a "new mass" at a fairly conservative church here in Arlington VA. Actually the parish I go offers the Latin Mass, and even during the new mass the parts that can be said in Latin usually are said in Latin (such as the Gloria, etc.) One thing I thought that was cool about the Gloria in Latin is that it actually flows better than when it is said in English, rythmatically. One thing that I thought about the Latin Mass was that, depending on one's mental approach to it, it seems that it can become rather Protestant in that it becomes "entertainment". I thought that perhaps there was a danger that one could get too caught up in the beauty of the rite itself, such that the focus turns more inward or becomes more about one's own experience, rather than on worshiping God. Peace
chrysostom Posted October 29, 2015 Posted October 29, 2015 I go to one most of the time. I find myself at home there. I don't really worry about the details of the differences. Much ink has been spilled over the differences that I won't repeat. I just like it and I like the community I found at the particular church I go to. If there is any particular element I would mention, it is the silence. But I've been to very quiet OF Masses too. I like those very much as well. At Mass all I want to do is unite myself to Jesus Crucified. Whatever is going to help me do that is a plus.
chrysostom Posted October 29, 2015 Posted October 29, 2015 One thing that I thought about the Latin Mass was that, depending on one's mental approach to it, it seems that it can become rather Protestant in that it becomes "entertainment". I thought that perhaps there was a danger that one could get too caught up in the beauty of the rite itself, such that the focus turns more inward or becomes more about one's own experience, rather than on worshiping God. Sure, maybe. But I think that could be equally said of any Mass if we're being hypothetical here. And I am very hesitant to apply the label "Protestant" to any form of the Mass. In fact, I wouldn't. Regarding the focus being "inward" (now we're not really talking about EF or OF or anything) ... that's a separate but interesting discussion. For example, there is always a lot of inwardness in my own experience of any Mass. I look inward and tell my soul to adore. It's hard to "lose myself" in God, though of course I would like to. I'm always aware of the interiority of the encounter with Christ. I guess what I mean is that I'm struggling to understand your comment about something becoming about one's own experience. Everything is filtered through my own experience. I don't know how to do things otherwise.
beatitude Posted October 29, 2015 Posted October 29, 2015 One thing that I thought about the Latin Mass was that, depending on one's mental approach to it, it seems that it can become rather Protestant in that it becomes "entertainment". I thought that perhaps there was a danger that one could get too caught up in the beauty of the rite itself, such that the focus turns more inward or becomes more about one's own experience, rather than on worshiping God. Interestingly, this is how some EF attendees feel about the OF - that it's as if the priest is giving a performance, because celebrating Mass facing the people puts more attention on him than on the Eucharist itself. I think anything that you are unfamiliar with can leave you feeling like it's entertainment. When I attended an EF Mass for the first time (I was twenty and in university), I was reduced to treating it as a translation test or just a beautiful aesthetic experience. I didn't know the prayers or the customs, so I was feverishly trying to translate the Latin instead of being able to immerse myself in prayer; and when I couldn't keep up, I just enjoyed the music and tried to pray that way. But for people who grew up with this Mass as their own or who attend it regularly, it's different. It's as familiar to them as the OF is to me. Now I am equally at home in both Masses. It just took some work. I was in Krakow in Poland when I realised that I had grown to love the EF Mass. It was celebrated there in a way I'd never seen before - it was held frequently, so it had become part of the life of the Church again, and the churches were packed out. It didn't feel like something arcane that was just for people who see themselves as very traditional, it was just Mass. Looking back on it, the period in which the EF Mass felt alien to me was valuable in its own right, because God, while being our loving and intimate Friend, is also the same awe-inspiring Power who passed by Elijah on the mountain and who told Moses, "No man can see my face and live." The EF Mass brought home some of that mystery and awe to me, a real sense of the distinction between the everyday and the holy. I love the OF too. I don't like the superiority squabbles over the two, because I think someone who is humble enough and devoted enough to Christ in the Eucharist doesn't have any need for them. Both of them bring us Christ. I do, however, understand why people might have a personal preference for one or the other.
Aragon Posted October 29, 2015 Posted October 29, 2015 I like both forms of the Mass and usually attend the OF, but I probably like the EF more. There are few things more beautiful than the hushed tones of an early morning Low Mass as the sun rises.
Credo in Deum Posted October 29, 2015 Posted October 29, 2015 I've been twice. Mostly didn't get it. Seem to prefer the Mass in a language that I can speak. I've been to hundreds of EF Masses and still do not 'get it' which is why I love them so much. The Mass is a Mystery which I will never be able to 'get' and the EF helps me to always remember this fact. The sacred language in the liturgy help me call my attention to fact that the Mass, while in the world, is not of the world. I also continue to attend because oddly enough I believe the EF is the closest Mass which resembles what the Magisterium wanted for the OF after Vatican II. I've been to very few OF Masse where Gregorian chant is sung, or where Latin is preserved or even given pride of place. I feel one of the greatest errors which came from the false "spirit of Vatican II" was that the Novus Order was suppose to be the "Vernacular Mass", just because the vernacular was allowed. Anyway there are other reasons but I'll just leave it at this for now. Gotta go to work.
John Paul Posted October 29, 2015 Posted October 29, 2015 About not understanding the Language St.Theresa of the Child Jesus said She did not know latin well and all the prayers were in latin.So she thought of it telling Jesus and only he knew so it would be a mystery.Just like our Catholic Faith.
MarysLittleFlower Posted October 29, 2015 Posted October 29, 2015 (edited) I like the Latin Mass because of its sense of the sacred (using another language and music gives that impression too - that this is not the everyday), silence, mystery, and I find I can pray more easily there. This wasn't the case at first but only when I got used to the silence. I think its great for mental prayer. Its also very reverent so I can more easily express worship to Our Lord. The OF has the Eucharist too of course but I find I pray better at the Latin Mass. I also like the richness of it in the symbolism - there's so much detail, and it adds to that sense of the sacred too. I don't think its an aesthetic feeling only, it lifts the mind and heart to God. Edited October 29, 2015 by MarysLittleFlower
Not The Philosopher Posted October 29, 2015 Posted October 29, 2015 Pretty much any form of the liturgy can be soured if you approach it with the wrong intentions. But I don't think it's necessarily wrong to be awed by the beauty of the Latin Mass - beauty is after all one of the transcendentals, and, like goodness and truth, is worth appreciating for its own sake. I definitely appreciate the contemplative quality of the TLM. Paradoxically, I find it easier to participate prayerfully if I have less to say/do. Maybe it's because I'm an introvert....
Lady-Indis Posted October 29, 2015 Posted October 29, 2015 I go to both forms. Some reasons I go to the Latin Mass when I can is because it's slower, (I think) more reverent, and is steeped in years of tradition. I go to English masses because sometimes, the EF is not available, or I can't fit an EF mass into my schedule and the Mass is Mass. I am NOT anti-OF in any way--sometimes I am mildly sour about music/homilies/art but that's mostly it.
Peace Posted October 30, 2015 Author Posted October 30, 2015 Regarding the focus being "inward" (now we're not really talking about EF or OF or anything) ... that's a separate but interesting discussion. For example, there is always a lot of inwardness in my own experience of any Mass. I look inward and tell my soul to adore. It's hard to "lose myself" in God, though of course I would like to. I'm always aware of the interiority of the encounter with Christ. I guess what I mean is that I'm struggling to understand your comment about something becoming about one's own experience. Everything is filtered through my own experience. I don't know how to do things otherwise. Hmm. When I talk about it being "inward" or about one's own experience I guess here is kind of what I meant. A very typical question among non-Catholics when they ask about a church service is "what do you get out of it?" I have been asked that so many times by people when I told them that I attended XYZ church or ABC type of church. I also have a good non-Catholic friend who stopped going to her parents church recently in favor of another church, because she felt that she did not vibe with her parents church. She had said that she did not like the music there so much, or that she did not relate to the sermon so much, did not like the community, etc. So to her that church was not worth going to, and she switched. Based on that it seems that the reason for going to church for many people kind of boils down to their own "experience", or how the Church makes them "feel". The view is primarily what I would call inward. It focuses on one's own experiences and one owns feelings. I think that the Mass for the most part is different. It is not so much "what you get out of it" (although we do get a lot of out of it - for obvious reasons) but rather "what we put into it". Our view is more outward looking. We are there to worship. We are there to participate in the sacrifice of the Mass. So even if we find the homily to be bland (which I often do) or even if we find that the church service does not excite us or that the sense of community is lacking (I feel that way sometimes too), I would not consider the Mass to have been a "bad" or "unsuccessful" Mass, because I am not primarily there to have a good experience or have good feelings (although I often do feel good and have a good experience). I am there to keep my focus on God, to worship, to participate in the Mass, and I would call the Mass "good" or "successful" if I accomplish those things. I think the Mass is more "outward" or "vertical" in this sense.
MarysLittleFlower Posted October 30, 2015 Posted October 30, 2015 (edited) I agree with not going to Mass to seek an experience, but I think what I meant - maybe the others too - is that the reverence and beauty of the Latin Mass can really lift the mind and heart to God, and help to have better dispositions to worship Him... Than in a very casual liberal liturgy - like a folk Mass. This has been my personal experience... It just helps me to have better dispositions to receive and give more we can also find this more in a more reverent Novus Ordo compared to a more casual one. The graces we receive does depend on our dispositions and though the intrinsic merit of the Mass is always infinite, the extrinsic merit can differ. There have been cases where I went to more casual liturgies and God helped me to worship Him, but it was something despite the aspects that I found troubling, not because of them. When the Mass is done reverently and seriously and there is time to pray, it can raise your prayer life to a new level over time - once you get used to that much silence! i struggled at first with that but now my mind is used to it. I found for me the TLM helps me to worship God even more than a very 'conservative' Novus Ordo Mass. I mean precisely about worship not sense of community etc which is not a primary aspect of it for me. Edited October 30, 2015 by MarysLittleFlower
Gabriela Posted October 30, 2015 Posted October 30, 2015 I prefer the EF, but when I first went to one, I absolutely hated it. (It's a terrible thing to say that about any Mass, but it's true in this case.) Now, I love it for the quiet (I've always preferred low to high Mass), and for its facilitation of prayer and reflection. It's simple—simpler than any NO I've ever been to—which I prefer. I just feel closer to Christ at an EF Mass, because I'm better able to focus on Him there. At NOs, I'm constantly distracted by other people moving around and doing stuff. There's too much activity and my mind is scattered. For me, the EF is a more "inward" (with Jesus) experience.
truthfinder Posted October 30, 2015 Posted October 30, 2015 My first EF, I liked, but I was pretty sure I wasn't going to make it my usual Sunday Mass. My first low Mass, which I had only gone to after being pretty comfortable with the high Mass, was really 'painful' in the sense that there was so much silence. Now, however, sometimes I just really enjoy not having to do anything at Mass. Usually I'll follow the Mass texts, others my prayers, and sometimes just be in the silence.
Kateri89 Posted November 1, 2015 Posted November 1, 2015 During this last year, I've gradually been transitioning to making the EF my regular Sunday Mass. I still attend the OF during the week because it fits in with my work schedule better and I think it keeps me balanced. When I first attended the Latin Mass I was completely lost. I didn't have a missal to help me follow along, plus the parishioners stood, knelt, and sat at different times than I was used to. There were two things that drew me in though. The first was the fact that so many people came to Mass dressed like they were there to meet a King which of course they were. Most women were veiled and everyone was modest. The second (and probably more important) factor that made me fall in love with the Mass was the way our Eucharistic Lord was received. Everyone knelt at the altar with their hands folded in prayer and received Him on the tongue. Now, I know that there have been many debates about Communion on the tongue vs. in the hand and I'm not trying to stir up that debate. All I'm saying is that it overwhelmed me to see such reverence and it made me think about when Thomas Merton attended his first mass and how when the priest elevated the Host, he just had this powerful sense that it was really Jesus. At this point, I'm far more used to the EF and the novelty of it has worn off. I still love it deeply though, in part for the reasons previously listed but also because I feel connected to the saints who celebrated it in the same way (that's a nod to All Saints Day). And for what it's worth, it may just take you time to get used to it. I imagine you may have felt the same way if you had only attended the EF your whole life and then suddenly attended the OF. If you give it a few more tries and still struggle with it, by all means continue with the OF. When I attend the OF I focus on showing Jesus as much reverence as I can. We get as much out of the Mass as we put into it. Hope that answers your question!
Socrates Posted November 2, 2015 Posted November 2, 2015 So what's so great about the "Latin Mass" for all of you Latin Mass heads out there? I've been twice. Mostly didn't get it. Seem to prefer the Mass in a language that I can speak. I am not saying that one is better/worse than the other. They are both from the Church and both good. But I am just wondering for folks who prefer the Latin Mass, what are the reasons for that preference? I usually go to a "new mass" at a fairly conservative church here in Arlington VA. Actually the parish I go offers the Latin Mass, and even during the new mass the parts that can be said in Latin usually are said in Latin (such as the Gloria, etc.) One thing I thought that was cool about the Gloria in Latin is that it actually flows better than when it is said in English, rythmatically. One thing that I thought about the Latin Mass was that, depending on one's mental approach to it, it seems that it can become rather Protestant in that it becomes "entertainment". I thought that perhaps there was a danger that one could get too caught up in the beauty of the rite itself, such that the focus turns more inward or becomes more about one's own experience, rather than on worshiping God. Peace Ironically, I think one of the biggest differences between the old Latin Mass, and the typical Novus Ordo, is that the old mass definitely does not feel like entertainment, but a solemn ritual before God - as befits the Sacrifice of God's Only Son. Especially if you go to a Low Mass (silent mass), with no singing or chanting, and only the priest performing the actions and quietly reciting prayers in Latin. If you're not in a properly prayerful mood, it's more likely to be boring than entertaining from a worldly perspective. And if you attend on a regular basis, the novelty factor wears off quickly. Contrast with many (not all) celebrations of the "new mass," with contemporary pop-style music, lots of clapping and applause, priests cracking jokes, etc. There's more emphasis on entertaining the people, as well as more influence from Protestant services. In contrast, in the Traditional Latin Mass, the attention seems directed more straight to God, rather than on entertaining ourselves (or attempting to do so). I don't consider myself a Rad Trad or Latin Mass fanatic, and done properly, a "NO" mass can be just as reverent, though in many places they're not. I like the Latin Mass for the (usual) greater reverence, and feeling of an ancient and timeless ritual. At least that's my superficial, subjective experience. If interested, you can always learn Latin enough to follow along, and most parishes provide missals with translations. Of course, people can always have the wrong "mental approach" to attending any mass.
Peace Posted November 2, 2015 Author Posted November 2, 2015 (edited) Ironically, I think one of the biggest differences between the old Latin Mass, and the typical Novus Ordo, is that the old mass definitely does not feel like entertainment, but a solemn ritual before God - as befits the Sacrifice of God's Only Son. Especially if you go to a Low Mass (silent mass), with no singing or chanting, and only the priest performing the actions and quietly reciting prayers in Latin. If you're not in a properly prayerful mood, it's more likely to be boring than entertaining from a worldly perspective. And if you attend on a regular basis, the novelty factor wears off quickly. Contrast with many (not all) celebrations of the "new mass," with contemporary pop-style music, lots of clapping and applause, priests cracking jokes, etc. There's more emphasis on entertaining the people, as well as more influence from Protestant services. In contrast, in the Traditional Latin Mass, the attention seems directed more straight to God, rather than on entertaining ourselves (or attempting to do so). I don't consider myself a Rad Trad or Latin Mass fanatic, and done properly, a "NO" mass can be just as reverent, though in many places they're not. I like the Latin Mass for the (usual) greater reverence, and feeling of an ancient and timeless ritual. At least that's my superficial, subjective experience. If interested, you can always learn Latin enough to follow along, and most parishes provide missals with translations. Of course, people can always have the wrong "mental approach" to attending any mass. I think that it really has a lot to do with the particular church and the intentions of the people celebrating the Mass, and also the cultural context in which the Mass is being conducted. I remember watching this video by Cardinal Arinze, where a person asked him about the subject of dancing during Mass. He basically said that in an American / Western European context it would not be appropriate, because here people generally associate dance with entertainment and not with worship. He said that it could be acceptable in some parts of Africa, because in some of those cultures certain forms of dance are generally used as forms of worship. This weekend I went to check out that St. Augustine parish here in the DC area - it is the parish of that gospel choir that sung at Pope Francis's visit to the white house. It is for the most part an African American congregation, and looking at it from the standpoint of someone like myself who was brought into the Church in more "Traditional" parishes - one might look at St. Augustine and call it a very liberal parish. It was definitely not "Do the black, say the red". Basically their Mass has been adapted in a way that makes it seem very similar in many respects to the Baptist church that I was raised in. Most of the parts of the Mass were set to gospel type music, the style of the homily was a lot more similar to what you would see at an African American church, they took a moment to welcome people visiting the church, etc. It was very much culturally "black" and "Protestant" feeling, yet at the same time in no way would I call it less reverent than any other Mass that I have attended, and in no way would refer to what was going on there as "entertainment" although I can understand how some people who might be used to something different might look at it and see it as entertainment. In many respects during the Mass at St. Augustine I thought to myself "Now this is the way the Mass should be." Like, for example, when they sung the "Glory to God in the Highest . . ." - they sung it with a real passion that was very apparent to me. In some way I felt God's presence at this Mass in a way that I have not experienced before. The people there were genuinely passionate about worshiping God and you could just really feel that throughout the entire Mass. So I don't know if there is necessarily one way that is better or worse than another. I think that some people express reverence in a way that is quiet or somber, but there are other people who express reverence in a way that is more energetic. A lot of it has to do with the intention behind it, I think . . . People who were brought up in a church like St. Augustine might look at the Latin Mass or some more "traditional" parishes and think "Wow. These people are so dull - they don't seem to have any passion for our Lord". But that would be a wrong assessment too, just like some folks who might look at their service and incorrectly think "this is all just about having fun or entertaining oneself." Perhaps the best way of looking at it is just to realize that people at various churches around the world are all Catholics, that we all have the same (good or bad) intentions, and that there are a variety of ways of expressing those same intentions in different contexts . . . But that is not to say that I am a believer in "anything goes" at Mass, of course. . . Edited November 2, 2015 by Peace
Benedictus Posted November 3, 2015 Posted November 3, 2015 I'm not keen on the EF. I prefer the NO in Latin and attend that if I can. If I could I would merge elements of the EF and NO that I think work really well and create a new rite I find that having Latin marks the time apart as 'holy time' or 'God language' time. I feel those masses tend to have more tradition: ritual, incense and practices that I like too. I find it also helps shift my focus away from distractions than if I have mass in English, Welsh or Spanish etc. I personally think the shift to each language was an idealism of the 60's, that obviously has benefits in many ways, but it does seem fairly fragmented to me in practice a lot of the time .I like the idea that everyone across the world could be reciting the prayers/mass in the same tongue. The shift to varying languages has, maybe as a consequence, also placed more focus on blocs of Bishops conferences based on national, ethnic or cultural grounds that brings challenges in a univeral/global church. There is a risk, and I think it's a consequence, that everything becomes about the language (and the stuff that comes with that) and something of the universal is lost. If Latin was used in masses, with each person having a written translation (or picture guide) in their own language, there could be greater diversity within masses as they wouldn't exclude certain ethnic/language groups from taking part. Some of the translations into each langauge have also been shoddy or clumsy too and it would be less of a drama to alter wording if the text was merely an aid to the mass (rather than the form of the mass itself)
DominicanHeart Posted November 3, 2015 Posted November 3, 2015 I didn't like it at first. But I fell in love with it over time. The peace of the atmosphere, the difference in the overall behavior of the congregation, and knowing that it's the Universal language of the Church, this is how the Mass should be. It's so much more reverent. I just love it. It's so beautiful
Basilisa Marie Posted November 3, 2015 Posted November 3, 2015 I go to the NO exclusively, maybe a couple times a year will go to an EF. The things I love about the EF are that it has a different kind of worship experience than the NO. It feels otherworldly, because it's easy to see that this isn't something "usual." The Latin reminds me that the Mass isn't about me, and it's ancient and universal. The priest is praying on behalf of the whole people, as our representative. He's taking all of our prayers, too, not just his own to the altar. He's at our service. But yeah, the biggest thing for me is to remember that the Mass is about God, not about me and my desires or needs.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now