Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Views On Science?


Views on Science  

21 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

I'm curious to know what this small portion of the Catholic population thinks about science, both in general and especially when it comes to explanations of our origins (Big Bang and evolutionary theory). While being religious and into science are not mutually exclusive by any means, it seems the general trend is the more scientifically-minded people are, the less religious they tend to become, or at least the more likely they are to gravitate to deism rather than theism. 

I do know plenty of people of various denominations who are scientists and seem to have no problem keeping their faith, however.  

So...any scientists among you? Any science enthusiasts? :smokey: 

Edited by xSilverPhinx
typo
Archaeology cat
Posted

I'm an archaeologist, so social science (I didn't do the hard science part with radiocarbon dating, etc). I believe God gave us ways of observing our world and universe through science. So yeah, I trust the radiocarbon dating (note - that isn't just C-14 dating; second note - even dendrochronology has the world older than 6,000 years). I'm fine with theistic evolution, as well. The Big Bang was postulated by a Catholic, and genetics was also pioneered by a Catholic. 

When I was younger and starting out studying archaeology, my grandmother cautioned me that I'd lose my religion. I never have, and in fact the wonders of science deepen my faith. From her perspective, though, maybe I did since I'm no longer Baptist. I tended to get in trouble as a Baptist who didn't hold to YEC. 

Posted

I can't imagine a better discription of the Big Bang than and God said let there be light. I've also thought that the seven days of creation were seven nights of dreams to an ancient scribe kind of like Joseph's dreams. 

MarysLittleFlower
Posted

I just wanted to say that the Big Bang theory was actually formulated by a Catholic priest as an effort to try and argue against atheism, maybe because many people wondered if the universe is eternal (which it can't be theologically). This is not a well known fact and its strange how so many think that this theory supports atheism when its purpose was the opposite. 

Posted

The Church even says that you can be a Catholic in good standing and believe in evolution. For all we know, God could've used it. Scripture has multiple senses to it which are not mutually exclusive; literal, allegorical, anangogical, and moral.

https://www.catholicculture.org/culture/library/catechism/index.cfm?recnum=467 

http://w2.vatican.va/content/pius-xii/en/encyclicals/documents/hf_p-xii_enc_12081950_humani-generis.html

 

Faith and reason are not opposed to each other, but complimentary. http://w2.vatican.va/content/john-paul-ii/en/encyclicals/documents/hf_jp-ii_enc_14091998_fides-et-ratio.html 

Posted

I'm an archaeologist, so social science (I didn't do the hard science part with radiocarbon dating, etc). I believe God gave us ways of observing our world and universe through science. So yeah, I trust the radiocarbon dating (note - that isn't just C-14 dating; second note - even dendrochronology has the world older than 6,000 years). I'm fine with theistic evolution, as well. The Big Bang was postulated by a Catholic, and genetics was also pioneered by a Catholic. 

When I was younger and starting out studying archaeology, my grandmother cautioned me that I'd lose my religion. I never have, and in fact the wonders of science deepen my faith. From her perspective, though, maybe I did since I'm no longer Baptist. I tended to get in trouble as a Baptist who didn't hold to YEC. 

I would have guessed that based on your username. ;) I think archaeology is a cool science, and began liking to learn about old human settlements after I visited Egypt (back when I was 11). Old Middle Eastern, North African and Italian (especially Pompeii) settlements and historical artifacts fascinate me. Mummies and their sarcophagi would intrigue me. 

What sort of things do you specialise in, if you don't mind my asking? 

 

  

I can't imagine a better discription of the Big Bang than and God said let there be light. I've also thought that the seven days of creation were seven nights of dreams to an ancient scribe kind of like Joseph's dreams. 

"I've also thought that the seven days of creation were seven nights of dreams to an ancient scribe" 

That's an interesting view, I haven't heard it before. 

Posted

I just wanted to say that the Big Bang theory was actually formulated by a Catholic priest as an effort to try and argue against atheism, maybe because many people wondered if the universe is eternal (which it can't be theologically). This is not a well known fact and its strange how so many think that this theory supports atheism when its purpose was the opposite. 

Ironic how that turned out isn't it? 

I think it might be because most of the erm...louder Christians are usually YECists and since the Big Bang suggests the universe is around 14 billion years old they reject it. Not to jumble up Christians of different denominations and beliefs together but that at least has been my experience.  

Just an addendum: "theory" in science lingo is a collection of facts, not a hypothesis, as it is in common language. There's the theory of gravity, germ theory, evolutionary theory, etc., all of which have ample evidence to support them.     

It's tricky to say that science supports atheism or even religious beliefs. Science is materialistic and is a way of trying to understand the natural world. Is your God part of that world? Can his existence be tested by natural means or measured? Religion is metaphysical and subjective interpretations attached to scientific facts are philosophical. I think the late Stephen Jay Gould had it right when he came up with NOMA, or non-overlapping magisteria. 

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-overlapping_magisteria 

 

The Church even says that you can be a Catholic in good standing and believe in evolution. For all we know, God could've used it. Scripture has multiple senses to it which are not mutually exclusive; literal, allegorical, anangogical, and moral.

https://www.catholicculture.org/culture/library/catechism/index.cfm?recnum=467 

http://w2.vatican.va/content/pius-xii/en/encyclicals/documents/hf_p-xii_enc_12081950_humani-generis.html

 

Faith and reason are not opposed to each other, but complimentary. http://w2.vatican.va/content/john-paul-ii/en/encyclicals/documents/hf_jp-ii_enc_14091998_fides-et-ratio.html 

Interesting, especially the last link. I'll have to read those when I have the patience. ;) 

I'm interested to know how Catholics define "reason", it seems to me like it's more intuitive and emotional than logical. 

SaintOfVirtue
Posted

I split atoms for a living so science is pretty important.

Not A Mallard
Posted

I'm not a science aficionado, but I can trust that many of the Church's teachings are based in science.

3ebd156f6119a18c2f1d2077916d4f4d.jpg

 

Posted (edited)

Some people would call what I do "social science", but I'm a hardcore Popperian, so I wouldn't dream of it. I'd rather call it "social studies".

I have no problem with science as a method, but it's often treated like an idol. Scientists can be extremely arrogant, and not just with regard to religion, but with regard to science itself. They think that since the method "meets the highest epistemological standard" known today, the method is inerrant. Maybe the method is (I doubt it), but the people who use the method are not. I would like to see much more humility in the interpretation of scientific data than we presently do.

Particularly irksome to me personally is the presumptuousness of those science enthusiasts who think that, since science supposedly meets the highest epistemological standard, all other ways of knowing are worthless. The arrogance of this makes me want to punch people. It's also incredibly ignorant, since 99% of what we "know" we know on faith or from personal experience.

Also: A theory isn't a collection of facts. A collection of facts is just a dataset. A theory is an attempt at explaining the facts. Which really is more like a hypothesis than like the facts themselves, although of course theories must (or, at least, should) take facts into consideration. (But then, so do hypotheses.)

Edited by Gabriela
Not The Philosopher
Posted

One time when I was in high school, Science beat me up and took my lunch money.

Posted

I voted that science is an important human endeavor. I'm not a scientist, though; I'm an English major!

The discussion about evolution and religion reminds me of an interesting book that I read for a class: Finding Darwin's God, by the biologist Kenneth R. Miller. Miller (who I believe is Catholic) tries to reconcile evolution and theism, and he deals with topics like YEC and intelligent design. Even if you don't agree with his conclusions, it's still a thought-provoking read.

Posted

I split atoms for a living so science is pretty important.

That's pretty cool! :smile2:

Is it true that you can create a mini black hole that soon disintegrates itself in a particle accelerator? 

Archaeology cat
Posted

I would have guessed that based on your username. ;) I think archaeology is a cool science, and began liking to learn about old human settlements after I visited Egypt (back when I was 11). Old Middle Eastern, North African and Italian (especially Pompeii) settlements and historical artifacts fascinate me. Mummies and their sarcophagi would intrigue me. 

What sort of things do you specialise in, if you don't mind my asking? 

Should have said I'm a former archaeologist ;) My undergrad was Near Eastern & Classical archaeology, and I have my MA in Egyptology. My field work was all in the US, though (Big Sandy period settlement in KY, then CRM work in FL). Bad knees have stopped me doing fieldwork. Now I teach my kids about it. Actually, I was doing the religion lesson with my 5-year-old recently and wasn't specific enough in asking her who the first humans were, and she answered "Homo Erectus." Not bad for 5. ;) She'd overheard part of her big brother's lesson but not all of it. 

I'm not a science aficionado, but I can trust that many of the Church's teachings are based in science.

3ebd156f6119a18c2f1d2077916d4f4d.jpg

 

Science, I said science again!

Posted

I'm not a science aficionado, but I can trust that many of the Church's teachings are based in science.

3ebd156f6119a18c2f1d2077916d4f4d.jpg

 

Forget the floating test tube, the clean lab coat is the oddity... 

Some people would call what I do "social science", but I'm a hardcore Popperian, so I wouldn't dream of it. I'd rather call it "social studies".

I have no problem with science as a method, but it's often treated like an idol. Scientists can be extremely arrogant, and not just with regard to religion, but with regard to science itself. They think that since the method "meets the highest epistemological standard" known today, the method is inerrant. Maybe the method is (I doubt it), but the people who use the method are not. I would like to see much more humility in the interpretation of scientific data than we presently do.

Particularly irksome to me personally is the presumptuousness of those science enthusiasts who think that, since science supposedly meets the highest epistemological standard, all other ways of knowing are worthless. The arrogance of this makes me want to punch people. It's also incredibly ignorant, since 99% of what we "know" we know on faith or from personal experience.

Also: A theory isn't a collection of facts. A collection of facts is just a dataset. A theory is an attempt at explaining the facts. Which really is more like a hypothesis than like the facts themselves, although of course theories must (or, at least, should) take facts into consideration. (But then, so do hypotheses.)

That hasn't been my experience working around scientists, going as far as thinking the method is inerrant. The best we have, yes, but not inerrant. just the other day I attended a seminar held by neuroscientists in which they brought up the subject of the perils of human biases in scientific analyses.

On theories, Ok, I stand corrected. However, they aren't merely hypotheses because they explain a broader set of phenomena, whereas an hypothesis is narrower. A hypothesis is an explanation which can be tested and a theory has predictive power and can be falsifiable.    

"The arrogance of this makes me want to punch people." 

:huh:

One time when I was in high school, Science beat me up and took my lunch money.

I'm shocked! The same Science I fell in love with?

Posted

I voted that science is an important human endeavor. I'm not a scientist, though; I'm an English major!

The discussion about evolution and religion reminds me of an interesting book that I read for a class: Finding Darwin's God, by the biologist Kenneth R. Miller. Miller (who I believe is Catholic) tries to reconcile evolution and theism, and he deals with topics like YEC and intelligent design. Even if you don't agree with his conclusions, it's still a thought-provoking read.

Yes, Ken Miller is a Catholic and is a prominent voice in the anti-YEC and intelligent design debate. I haven't read that book, however, added to my reading list. :)   

Posted

Should have said I'm a former archaeologist ;) My undergrad was Near Eastern & Classical archaeology, and I have my MA in Egyptology. My field work was all in the US, though (Big Sandy period settlement in KY, then CRM work in FL). Bad knees have stopped me doing fieldwork. Now I teach my kids about it. Actually, I was doing the religion lesson with my 5-year-old recently and wasn't specific enough in asking her who the first humans were, and she answered "Homo Erectus." Not bad for 5. ;) She'd overheard part of her big brother's lesson but not all of it. 

Science, I said science again!

Egyptology! That's amesome. :cool:

One event that left a lasting impression on me was when I entered a burial chamber in the Valley of the Kings. The feeling is difficult to put into words, it's almost like being transported back in time, seeing the paint still on the wall...

I would like to go back again but now with all the issues plaguing the Islamic world I don't think I'll ever be able to. :(  

Smart 5-year-old! They're like sponges at that age. My 6-year-old niece seems to pick up on and remember everything that's both relevant and non relevant in conversations.  

Posted
That hasn't been my experience working around scientists, going as far as thinking the method is inerrant. The best we have, yes, but not inerrant. just the other day I attended a seminar held by neuroscientists in which they brought up the subject of the perils of human biases in scientific analyses.

On theories, Ok, I stand corrected. However, they aren't merely hypotheses because they explain a broader set of phenomena, whereas an hypothesis is narrower. A hypothesis is an explanation which can be tested and a theory has predictive power and can be falsifiable.

Of course scientists discuss methodological and other errors in science. But when you ask them (not all of them, of course) about, say, the safety of genetically engineered foods, they get as political and errant as anyone else. The truth is that the research as it stands tells us very little about the (long-term) safety of genetically engineered foods, but since "there's no evidence of harm", most scientists will tell you they're fine.

No evidence does not mean they're safe. It just means there's no evidence.

That kind of fallacy is hands-down the most common one, and it comes from scientists (and others) wanting to say we know when we don't. That's the kind of arrogance I'm referring to. There's nothing shameful in saying "scientists don't know that yet", and very often they're willing to do that, but when they've got some kind of other interest in an issue (genetically engineered foods are a product of science, after all, so they wouldn't want to claim there's a risk of them being harmful), they too often want to claim they do know when, in fact, there's very little known as yet.

Yes, theories explain broad sets of phenomena, and hypotheses are more narrow. But a hypothesis isn't an explanation, but a prediction about a relationship that is then tested. A theory can also be tested. Typically, hypotheses that stand up to testing are rolled into theories (or, at least, into models, which often become theories). Hence my mention that theories are more similar to hypotheses than they are to facts. Facts really play the same role in both hypotheses and theories. Theories are like a bunch of verified hypotheses woven together into a bigger explanation that accords with the facts.

I don't mean to be nitpicky, but you'd be amazed how often these things are misconstrued in my department, so I'm kind of a Nazi about them. ;) 

Archaeology cat
Posted

Egyptology! That's amesome. :cool:

One event that left a lasting impression on me was when I entered a burial chamber in the Valley of the Kings. The feeling is difficult to put into words, it's almost like being transported back in time, seeing the paint still on the wall...

I would like to go back again but now with all the issues plaguing the Islamic world I don't think I'll ever be able to. :(  

Smart 5-year-old! They're like sponges at that age. My 6-year-old niece seems to pick up on and remember everything that's both relevant and non relevant in conversations.  

In one of my undergrad classes looking at Near Eastern archaeology (shortly after 9/11), probably half the slides we were shown were of things that had just been destroyed or stolen. That number is higher now. Egypt has its own issues now, too. So I can't see going any time soon since I'm not in the field now. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...