Anastasia13 Posted November 8, 2015 Posted November 8, 2015 I though this was interesting. http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/nov/06/religious-children-less-altruistic-secular-kids-study Thoughts?
NadaTeTurbe Posted November 8, 2015 Posted November 8, 2015 They should have made a different study according to the religion and the country. Islam and Christianism have very differents way to see sharing and charity. There's MAJOR differences in the state of mind between China, USA, Turkey and South Africa ! "Muslim children judged “interpersonal harm as more mean” than children from Christian families, with non-religious children the least judgmental. Muslim children demanded harsher punishment than those from Christian or non-religious homes" It doesn't surprise me. Again, it's coherent with how muslim countries work. The emphasis is on justice and punishment, not on mercy.
Gabriela Posted November 8, 2015 Posted November 8, 2015 (edited) There's also a major difference between how Muslims and Christians see in-group versus out-group harm. To Christians, your group status doesn't matter. To Muslims it matters a great deal. Also: Almost 24% were Christian, 43% Muslim, and 27.6% non-religious. That number of Muslims is really going to skew the results towards the Muslim view. Children from religious households “frequently appear to be more judgmental of others’ actions”, it said. Muslim children judged “interpersonal harm as more mean” than children from Christian families, with non-religious children the least judgmental. Muslim children demanded harsher punishment than those from Christian or non-religious homes. What this actually says is this: When Mary is mean to Sarah, the religious children think that's worse than the non-religious children, and demand more punishment. Meanness should be punished harshly according to religious kids, but not to secular kids. That makes the religious kids "judgmental" and "punitive". The report was “a welcome antidote to the presumption that religion is a prerequisite of morality”, said Keith Porteus Wood of the UK National Secular Society. Well, sheesh. Look at the source. Key consideration: How one defines "morality" in such a study matters. Doing science requires the operationalization of abstracts constructs like "meanness" and "judgmentalness" and "punitiveness". If you define them in a secular rather than a religious way, of course the religious kids are going to come out looking bad. Finally, you have to ask yourself: What motivates a person to conduct such a study? Hmmm. Let me think about that. :rollingeyes: Edited November 8, 2015 by Gabriela
xSilverPhinx Posted November 8, 2015 Posted November 8, 2015 Here's the paper: http://www.cell.com/current-biology/pdf/S0960-9822(15)01167-7.pdf
Era Might Posted November 9, 2015 Posted November 9, 2015 "While it is generally accepted that religion contours people’s moral judgments and pro-social behaviour, the relation between religion and morality is a contentious one," it said. The report was "a welcome antidote to the presumption that religion is a prerequisite of morality", said Keith Porteus Wood of the UK National Secular Society. They could have just read the Gospels to figure that one out. It was the religious people who wanted to stone the woman taken in adultery, and the pharisees and scribes (the scientists of the day) who wanted to make precise arguments that completely missed the obvious. It's kind of like saying intellectual people are more argumentative than non-intellectuals, therefore intellect is not a prerequisite of argument. Non-intellectual people still have ways of reasoning that do not depend on intellectual disposition, and non-intellectual reasoning may actually be more practical in the real world, but that doesn't really tell us anything about intelligence or reason. It just tells us that they aren't the special domain of people who claim to specialize in them. When it comes to religion, that's more or less the message of Jesus: Jesus said to her, "Woman, believe me, the hour is coming when neither on this mountain nor in Jerusalem will you worship the Father. You worship what you do not know; we worship what we know, for salvation is from the Jews. But the hour is coming, and now is, when the true worshipers will worship the Father in spirit and truth, for such the Father seeks to worship him. God is spirit, and those who worship him must worship in spirit and truth." --John 4:21-24
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now