Peace Posted November 19, 2015 Posted November 19, 2015 (edited) Yup. That's right folks. I have converted back to being a Protestant. And with that my very first act shall be to ask you "If you were to die today, do you know if you would be going to Heaven or Hell?" Just kidding of course. I was hoping to get some other people's opinions about this. I have been thinking a lot lately about my own spiritual development and my own motivations. Especially around the time of my conversion, I guess you could have called me a bit of a child. My mindset was kind of like "Well - I have to do XYZ or I cannot do ABC because if I do not comply I will be cast into the hot flames of hell". Now - there is nothing wrong with that. Fear of the Lord is a good thing. Not wanting to go to hell is a good thing too. If that fear motivates a person to keep from sinning and it works then I don't think that is a problem. But this mindset is not really one that is sustainable in the long run, I think. You have to have some deeper reason or motivation to refrain from sin, to do good works, etc. So I have been trying to get to this other place. The reason why I titled this topic "Are you saved?" is because I think the question itself kind of indicates that type of juvenile mindset. People tend to put this idea of going to heaven (or conversely staying out of hell) on some kind of pedestal, as if it is the ultimate end to be achieved in itself. But I don't think that is right. It seems to me that "Are you saved?" is not really a question that we should be asking, either to ourselves, or to other people. A much more relevant question to me seems to be "Do I love God? Do I want to see Him? Am I willing to die for Him the way that He died for me?" Whether one can answer these questions in the affirmative seems to be a lot more important than answering the "Are you saved?" question. I had mentioned it in another thread - but recently I saw a movie about St. Thomas More called "A man for all seasons." At the end of the movie just before he is about to be executed he says "God would not refuse one who is so blithe to go to Him." To me - I kind of think this is what it is about. Are we blithe to see God? Do we do our good works and refrain from sin because we do not want to be punished, or do we do those things because we love God and we want to please Him? So I guess for me I am still trying to develop. I am trying to have that same desire to see God or to please God that the saints have. Just some more random thoughts I guess . . . Edited November 19, 2015 by Peace
KnightofChrist Posted November 19, 2015 Posted November 19, 2015 The way I normally answer this question is to say I am saved, I am being saved, and I will be saved. I am saved from original sin by my baptism, I am being saved by going to confession, and I will be saved if I remain in Christ from the fires of hell. And since most people who ask me that question are Bible only Christians I also try to point this out. To be saved, you must believe in the Lord Jesus Christ (Acts 16:31), but the Sacred Scriptures show other things you must also do to be saved. * You must endure to the end. Matthew 10:22, Matthew 24:13, Mark 13:13.* You must accept the Cross (suffering). Matthew 10:38, Matthew 16:24-25, Mark 8:34, Luke 9:23, Luke 14:27.* You must be baptized with water. Mark 16:16, John 3:3-5 Titus 3:5, I Peter 3:20-21.* You must be a member in God's true church. Acts 2:47.* You must confess your sins. James 5:16, I John 1:9* You must keep the Commandments of God. Matthew 5:19-20, Matthew 7:21* You must heed the words of St. Peter, the first Pope. Acts 11:13-14, Acts 15:7.* You must eat the flesh and drink the blood of Jesus Christ. John 6:51-58, I Corinthians 10:16, I Corinthians 11:23-29
Peace Posted November 19, 2015 Author Posted November 19, 2015 The way I normally answer this question is to say I am saved, I am being saved, and I will be saved. I am saved from original sin by my baptism, I am being saved by going to confession, and I will be saved if I remain in Christ from the fires of hell. And since most people who ask me that question are Bible only Christians I also try to point this out. To be saved, you must believe in the Lord Jesus Christ (Acts 16:31), but the Sacred Scriptures show other things you must also do to be saved. * You must endure to the end. Matthew 10:22, Matthew 24:13, Mark 13:13.* You must accept the Cross (suffering). Matthew 10:38, Matthew 16:24-25, Mark 8:34, Luke 9:23, Luke 14:27.* You must be baptized with water. Mark 16:16, John 3:3-5 Titus 3:5, I Peter 3:20-21.* You must be a member in God's true church. Acts 2:47.* You must confess your sins. James 5:16, I John 1:9* You must keep the Commandments of God. Matthew 5:19-20, Matthew 7:21* You must heed the words of St. Peter, the first Pope. Acts 11:13-14, Acts 15:7.* You must eat the flesh and drink the blood of Jesus Christ. John 6:51-58, I Corinthians 10:16, I Corinthians 11:23-29 Thank you for the information. I am wondering - did you actually read my entire post?
KnightofChrist Posted November 19, 2015 Posted November 19, 2015 (edited) Thank you for the information. I am wondering - did you actually read my entire post? Yes, I thought it went well with your post, well as I understood it anyway. Being saved isn't a one and done event, that is a bit simple minded. But "being saved" is important to Catholics and we can use that language in the right way with the rightly ordered understanding. It is a life time of events, something must we strive for every day for our love of God. Being saved is first and foremost about loving God, we should not fear hell for the sake of the pain there, but fear it because it is disappointing God and is not loving God. We should endure, accept our Cross, be baptized, be Catholic, confess our sins, keep the Commandments, be obedient to the Holy Father, and receive the Body and Blood of Christ because we love God and he loves us. But I am a bit tired, maybe I missed some of your points. Edited November 19, 2015 by KnightofChrist
Peace Posted November 19, 2015 Author Posted November 19, 2015 (edited) Yes, I thought it went well with your post, well as I understood it anyway. Being saved isn't a one and done event, that is a bit simple minded. But "being saved" is important to Catholics and we can use that language in the right way with the rightly ordered understanding. It is a life time of events, something must we strive for every day for our love of God. Being saved is first and foremost about loving God, we should not fear hell for the sake of the pain there, but fear it because it is disappointing God and is not loving God. We should endure, accept our Cross, be baptized, be Catholic, confess our sins, keep the Commandments, be obedient to the Holy Father, and receive the Body and Blood of Christ because we love God and he loves us. But I am a bit tired, maybe I missed some of your points. Thanks for the further explanation. I suppose I am wondering if "being saved" is something that should be a direct concern of us at all. Is it something that should be important to us - in and of itself? You seem to suggest that your answer to that is "no" - that "being saved" is not the key component, but rather, having the love of God that puts us on the path to salvation. Let me pose to you a hypothetical question (and it is a true hypothetical as we believe that God desires all to be saved): If it were the will of God that you should be eternally separated from Him, in other words, if it pleased God that you should spend the rest of your existence in Hell, should you desire to go to Hell and please God by doing so, or should you desire to go to Heaven and displease God by doing so? It is a crazy hypothetical of course (although from what I understand some Calvinists believe something similar to that) - but I would think that the answer to it would be "I desire to please God, I desire that God's will be carried out, therefore I also desire to spend the rest of eternity in Hell." Again - luckily we are not faced with that choice, but the point of the hypothetical, I think, is to show that "going to heaven" or "going to hell" is not the thing that we should be striving for. In our minds we should be striving to please God because we love Him, regardless of what that might entail. Edited November 19, 2015 by Peace
Era Might Posted November 19, 2015 Posted November 19, 2015 A good salesman asks for the sale, he doesn't beat around the bush. Catholics love beating around the bush...you play bingo? Well come on down!
KnightofChrist Posted November 19, 2015 Posted November 19, 2015 Oh yes being saved should and must be a concern to us. Being saved is staying the in state of grace rather than falling into sin, one never knows when being saved in the confessional will become being saved from hell. I hate what if's because what if's are never what is. If it pleased God to send every soul to hell and it was his will for us to go to hell I'm not sure what good it would do for us to have a desire or hope for heaven. Hope is only possible if what we hope for has the possibility of coming true. We can't rightly desire the opposite of what God desires and hope to get what we want. This what if God would not be God, not our God anyway. It would turn God's nature on its head, real life God desires all men in each age to be saved because he loves us, he loves us because part of him is within us and we love him in return because he is in us. But in this what if world that what if God would desire all men to be damned, so would he love the part of him in us or would he hate the part of himself in us and if he hates us wouldn't we in return hate him?
Peace Posted November 19, 2015 Author Posted November 19, 2015 (edited) Oh yes being saved should and must be a concern to us. Being saved is staying the in state of grace rather than falling into sin, one never knows when being saved in the confessional will become being saved from hell. Well. Don't get me wrong. It is a concern of mine on some level. I'm not exactly walking the streets like "I could care less whether I go to Heaven or Hell!" Far from it. I think that when Protestants say "being saved" they do not mean "staying in a state of grace". That is more of a Catholic concept that they don't quite get or accept for the most part. I think that when they say "being saved" they refer to it in a sense that is closer to what we would call the "particular judgment". The exact moment at which your fate is sealed for all eternity. Being in a state of grace (at least before your death) is something that can change from second to second according to our actions (sinning or going to confession). But anyway - is it really a valid question for a Catholic to ask? Should we ask whether we are "saved" or "in a state of grace" as though we can know the answer with certainty? I do not think that we have assurance of salvation in the way that Protestants believe they do. We know in an academic sense that one who dies in a state of grace goes to Heaven, but whether or not we are actually in a state of grace is not something that we can know with 100% certainty - is it? I just went to confession yesterday and have not committed any grave sins since then. I have confidence that I would go to Heaven if I die today, but for me to ask "Will I go to Heaven now if I died today?" seems to be somewhat of a pointless question as we cannot know for certain. It seems that a much more relevant question for me to ask today is "Do I love God? Is there anything in my life that I would be unwilling to part with if God asked me?" I mean - we make prudential judgements about whether or not we are in a state of grace in order to determine whether we should receive communion, etc. but I don't think that our Church allows us to say that we "know" we are in a state of grace or would go to Heaven, unless we have been given a private revelation by God on the matter. So spending time on a question that we cannot know the answer to with certainty does not seem very productive (I realize that I am giving a different reason for my conclusion this time). I hate what if's because what if's are never what is. I think it has been sufficiently demonstrated by many philosophers and moral theologians that hypothetical questions have value. If it pleased God to send every soul to hell and it was his will for us to go to hell I'm not sure what good it would do for us to have a desire or hope for heaven. Hope is only possible if what we hope for has the possibility of coming true. We can't rightly desire the opposite of what God desires and hope to get what we want. Fair enough. Then it would seem that you would answer the hypothetical in the same way that I would. Is that correct? This what if God would not be God, not our God anyway. It would turn God's nature on its head, real life God desires all men in each age to be saved because he loves us, he loves us because part of him is within us and we love him in return because he is in us. LOL. I already agreed that the hypothetical is inconsistent with what we believe about God. Although I might add that some Calvinists seem to believe that God hates the reprobate and actually damned them to hell before the world was even created. But in this what if world that what if God would desire all men to be damned, so would he love the part of him in us or would he hate the part of himself in us and if he hates us wouldn't we in return hate him? Just to clarify, I did not mean "all men". I just meant you in particular, as opposed to all of mankind. Under the hypothetical it would presumably please God that person X goes to Heaven and that person Y goes to Hell (I think this is what Calvinists actually believe). I don't think I can answer your question though. I think your question proves why the hypothetical cannot be true. But again - I already conceded that. It is a hypothetical that I posed in order to explore an idea. I think that we can imagine abstract situations an analyze them (I do realize that some folks are not naturally disposed to doing that, however, if that is not your cup of tea). Edited November 19, 2015 by Peace
John Paul Posted November 19, 2015 Posted November 19, 2015 The way I normally answer this question is to say I am saved, I am being saved, and I will be saved. I am saved from original sin by my baptism, I am being saved by going to confession, and I will be saved if I remain in Christ from the fires of hell. And since most people who ask me that question are Bible only Christians I also try to point this out. To be saved, you must believe in the Lord Jesus Christ (Acts 16:31), but the Sacred Scriptures show other things you must also do to be saved. * You must endure to the end. Matthew 10:22, Matthew 24:13, Mark 13:13.* You must accept the Cross (suffering). Matthew 10:38, Matthew 16:24-25, Mark 8:34, Luke 9:23, Luke 14:27.* You must be baptized with water. Mark 16:16, John 3:3-5 Titus 3:5, I Peter 3:20-21.* You must be a member in God's true church. Acts 2:47.* You must confess your sins. James 5:16, I John 1:9* You must keep the Commandments of God. Matthew 5:19-20, Matthew 7:21* You must heed the words of St. Peter, the first Pope. Acts 11:13-14, Acts 15:7.* You must eat the flesh and drink the blood of Jesus Christ. John 6:51-58, I Corinthians 10:16, I Corinthians 11:23-29 AMEN!
MarysLittleFlower Posted November 19, 2015 Posted November 19, 2015 I believe that we should care about salvation because that is God's Will for us and if we are not saved we would not be able to be with God who we want to spend eternity with. However at the same time, the motivation for this becomes more love rather than fear over time, and in the end its not an anxious sort of thing but just a way to love God. However we still care about salvation then too I think... Just with a different motive and more trust maybe we do end up thinking more of loving God, but of course going to Heaven is still important because we want to be closer to Him. There's also more trust that He will help us get there Of course regarding "being saved" I mean the Catholic position
chrysostom Posted November 20, 2015 Posted November 20, 2015 Ite ad Thomam. Go to Thomas. I'm thinking that a lot of the theological clarity you are looking for is dealt with in St. Thomas' writings. You live in Arlington, VA, right? Why not make a trip up to the Dominican House of Studies in DC and ask to have a chat with a friar? There are lots of Dominicans at St. Dominic's parish DC, too, which is quite a bit closer to Arlington. Either way, I think you would really enjoy something like that. Seriously though, you should try it out. My own perspective as a Protestant convert myself: I find the question "are you saved" to most often have the Protestant implication of "have you made a one-time decision for Christ/are you a snow-covered dung heap/etc". On the other side of the spectrum, I don't want the idea of the "fundamental option" to be brought into play when we're talking about "are you saved". Either way, I would respond like KnightOfChrist did since that is the Catholic thing to do. I have been saved, I am being saved, and I hope to be saved. As for your concerns about the motivation for living the Catholic life, I understand that you ultimately want to love God entirely for His own sake. I want that too. But the lesser motivations - avoiding Hell, amongst other things - are all COMPLETELY legitimate. It isn't disingenuous to be motivated by these things. They are the stepping stones to higher things and they will be subsumed into a more perfect love of God as we learn detachment through suffering, or, as one could put it, the Dark Night of the Senses and the Dark Night of the Soul. The question about the Will of God is something I'm sure Aquinas has written on before. A question for your Dominican. About assurance of salvation: interestingly enough, my experience becoming Catholic is that I have more assurance of my salvation than I did before. But I can't explain it very well. I highly highly recommend this article: http://www.calledtocommunion.com/2009/08/st-thomas-aquinas-on-assurance-of-salvation which explains St. Thomas on the very pertinent theological virtue of hope.
Guest Posted November 22, 2015 Posted November 22, 2015 (edited) I accept the these teaching on mortal sin but it's depressing. Hearing @Peace say He just got out of Confession but doesn't know for sure if he would end up in hell if he died right now. What is that? God loves us. We're supposed to trust in Him. The Bible says that we can know with confidence that we are saved. In you're hypothetical if you came out of Confession in a state of grace and then died why would there be a chance you would go to hell to grind your teeth and be tortured in outer darkness for all of eternity? You should know absolutely that you'll get at least Purgatory. God loves you. We're cherished by Him. If that isn't true and we're really not cherished but just specs of useless filthy dust in a universe so big and old its hard to even logically think about then maybe the idea of you ending up in hell even though you just came out of Confession is valid and something to consider. The Old Testament does say we're dust and to dust we return. Although I think Christ changed that and we become much more at our Baptism. God to me and the way I understand Him is ultimately through Jesus on the cross telling the Father to forgive the people murdering Him. And before that asking for the Cross to pass Him and even asking the Father why He had forsaken Him at His death. If Jesus is fully God He gets what He wants and the people who murdered Him are forgiven if that really is Jesus's will. After a likely extended stay in Purgatory of course. Unconditional love, forgiveness and mercy seem like a big part of His message and his actions while here on earth. Even to people who appear to not even be asking for it or seeking it out. So while it may sound Pious and what not contemplating if you'll somehow wind up in hell if you die stepping fresh out of Confession I don't think it shows much confidence in God's unconditional love for us. I for one know how quick one can slip into mortal sin when just getting out of Confession. So I can see how the question can be asked in a way. But not in a way that's saying I'm fresh out of Confession in a state of grace and die but maybe I'm still in mortal sin or God thinks I'm still a piece of c r a p or whatever else....... If a person truly understands mortal sin then you know for sure when you're out of it. At least I do. It's trickier knowing when you're in it since there are 3 conditions to make a grave sin mortal and habits and other things determine if a grave sin becomes mortal. As I previously said I choose to view God primarily through Jesus. I love the Father with all my whole heart but He's tougher to wrap my mind around. Jesus warned of hell frequently so it shows its real and you can end up there. But He also showed tons of mercy and forgiveness and if you're actively cooperating with His grace and love Him you should have confidence that He's going to save you. That He will never forsake you and nothing will separate you from His love as Saint Paul tells us. You can't really genuinely love somebody if you think there just going to dispose of you at any second for reasons you might not even be aware of. Edited November 22, 2015 by Guest
Peace Posted November 22, 2015 Author Posted November 22, 2015 (edited) I accept the these teaching on mortal sin but it's depressing. Hearing @Peace say He just got out of Confession but doesn't know for sure if he would end up in hell if he died right now. What is that? God loves us. We're supposed to trust in Him. The Bible says that we can know with confidence that we are saved. In you're hypothetical if you came out of Confession in a state of grace and then died why would there be a chance you would go to hell to grind your teeth and be tortured in outer darkness for all of eternity? You should know absolutely that you'll get at least Purgatory. God loves you. We're cherished by Him. If that isn't true and we're really not cherished but just specs of useless filthy dust in a universe so big and old its hard to even logically think about then maybe the idea of you ending up in hell even though you just came out of Confession is valid and something to consider. The Old Testament does say we're dust and to dust we return. Although I think Christ changed that and we become much more at our Baptism. God to me and the way I understand Him is ultimately through Jesus on the cross telling the Father to forgive the people murdering Him. And before that asking for the Cross to pass Him and even asking the Father why He had forsaken Him at His death. If Jesus is fully God He gets what He wants and the people who murdered Him are forgiven if that really is Jesus's will. After a likely extended stay in Purgatory of course. Unconditional love, forgiveness and mercy seem like a big part of His message and his actions while here on earth. Even to people who appear to not even be asking for it or seeking it out. So while it may sound Pious and what not contemplating if you'll somehow wind up in hell if you die stepping fresh out of Confession I don't think it shows much confidence in God's unconditional love for us. I for one know how quick one can slip into mortal sin when just getting out of Confession. So I can see how the question can be asked in a way. But not in a way that's saying I'm fresh out of Confession in a state of grace and die but maybe I'm still in mortal sin or God thinks I'm still a piece of c r a p or whatever else....... If a person truly understands mortal sin then you know for sure when you're out of it. At least I do. It's trickier knowing when you're in it since there are 3 conditions to make a grave sin mortal and habits and other things determine if a grave sin becomes mortal. As I previously said I choose to view God primarily through Jesus. I love the Father with all my whole heart but He's tougher to wrap my mind around. Jesus warned of hell frequently so it shows its real and you can end up there. But He also showed tons of mercy and forgiveness and if you're actively cooperating with His grace and love Him you should have confidence that He's going to save you. That He will never forsake you and nothing will separate you from His love as Saint Paul tells us. You can't really genuinely love somebody if you think there just going to dispose of you at any second for reasons you might not even be aware of. I think that we can be very confident, and I am. Can we declare with absolute 100% certainty that we are going to Heaven when we leave the confessional? I don't know if we are allowed to go that far. I have a sense that there is a Church document out there that prohibits that, but I can't recall it offhand. Can anyone? Edited November 22, 2015 by Peace
Guest Posted November 22, 2015 Posted November 22, 2015 (edited) The Hypothetical was if you died right then. Not talking 8 hours from then when you could fall into grave sin. Or even 2 hours from then. Talking right at that moment like you proposed. This is why I love the debates on you tube about this. Protestants make some very strong arguments. There argument even makes more sense when Purgatory is understood. As a Catholic though i agree with what the Church teaches about mortal sin. And it makes sense to me at the end of the day. Edited November 22, 2015 by Guest
Guest Posted November 23, 2015 Posted November 23, 2015 15 hours ago, Josh said: If a person truly understands mortal sin then you know for sure when you're out of it. At least I do. It's trickier knowing when you're in it since there are 3 conditions to make a grave sin mortal and habits and other things determine if a grave sin becomes mortal. I meant to say it's trickier to know *when you fall into it.*
Guest Posted November 23, 2015 Posted November 23, 2015 (edited) To the original question I think it's very important to know where you're going. If you take the idea of an eternity (I can't even comprehend eternity) of being TORTURED and without hope for FOREVER and EVER how can you not want to know where you will be? We didn't ask to be here as far as I know. From my understanding of theology I didn't tell God to create me or ask Him to. I'm thankful for life and it's beautiful. I would rather be created then uncreated and I love God and want to be with Him for eternity. The idea is thrilling and I pray this is all real and God exist. I honestly believe He does. Although this world can be a very scary place. I think it's important for a persons sanity to know the promises we have of God's love and our salvation. I really believe consciousness is fundamental in the universe. Because of consciousness there is matter and quantum physics. Consciousness and the law written on humans hearts point towards a Creator. Along with the fine tuned laws that allow planets and stars to form and the universe to expand. For life to evolve and be able to comprehend these ideas and observe reality and question it and wonder the reason for it all. So the idea of a soul and heaven, purgatory and hell doesn't seem far fetched to me. I think one should meditate everyday on where they are going to be for eternity. And whenever possible know and trust in God's promise He will never forsake us. Especially when you're fresh out of Confession and it was valid. Edited November 23, 2015 by Guest
Guest Posted November 23, 2015 Posted November 23, 2015 (edited) 22 minutes ago, Josh said: To the original question I think it's very important to know where you'. If you take the idea of an eternity (I can't even comprehend eternity) of being TORTURED and without hope for FOREVER and EVER how can you not want to know where you will be? I forgot to add if you take the idea of hell SERIOULY and ACTUALLY BELIEVE it then you have no choice but to worder where you're going to be. It's not like hell is being uncreated and just going out of existence. No it's literally being conscious with a body and being TORTURED FOR ETERNITY WITHOUT IT EVER ENDING. I comfort sooooooo soooooo much in the truth that I'm saved by GRACE THROUGH MY FAITH IN JESUS WHO WAS PERFECT AND DESIRES TO LOVE AND FORGIVE a person like me. And that He will never forsake and I will always call on His name and pray to His Holy Mother. Amen. Edited November 23, 2015 by Guest
Guest Posted November 23, 2015 Posted November 23, 2015 And Pray I never hear these words....“Not every one that saith unto me, Lord, Lord, shall enter into the kingdom of heaven; but he that doeth the will of my Father which is in heaven.” “Many will say to me in that day, Lord, Lord, have we not prophesied in thy name? and in thy name have cast out devils? and in thy name done many wonderful works? And then will I profess unto them, I never knew you: depart from me, ye that work iniquity.”
Peace Posted November 23, 2015 Author Posted November 23, 2015 On 11/22/2015, 10:51:43, Josh said: The Hypothetical was if you died right then. Not talking 8 hours from then when you could fall into grave sin. Or even 2 hours from then. Talking right at that moment like you proposed. This is why I love the debates on you tube about this. Protestants make some very strong arguments. There argument even makes more sense when Purgatory is understood. As a Catholic though i agree with what the Church teaches about mortal sin. And it makes sense to me at the end of the day. OK. You mean the very instant you open the door of the confessional you get hit with a sniper's shot? Your chances of going to Heaven are pretty good in that scenario. I will concede you that. 6 hours ago, Josh said: To the original question I think it's very important to know where you're going. If you take the idea of an eternity (I can't even comprehend eternity) of being TORTURED and without hope for FOREVER and EVER how can you not want to know where you will be? I don't know. I certainly like to think that I am going Heaven as opposed to Hell. That does motivate my actions. But as I mentioned earlier in this thread - I think that there better things to worry about, or to spend one's time thinking about, than that.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now