Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Have you ever thought about committing murder?


Recommended Posts

Posted

No necessarily to the point of making real plans, but ever had the passing thought?  If so, who, why, and how (if you thought that far). 

I'll go first. A former roommate, to put us both out of our misery, and I toyed with the idea of a push in front of a bus. I obviously came to my senses. Ironically about a month later she jumped in front of a bus and survived. I wasn't in the vicinity, so don't go there. My confessor gave me such a loud sigh. I think he was really glad to see me leave the country. 

Posted

I think that people who have been badly hurt, but more when someone you love has been badly hurt, thoughts can turn murderous.  The thought of someone hurting any one of my young "nieces" and "nephews" or my actual nieces...or really any child...that's be the end of that person.  Figuratively of course, unless I had to intervene right away.

However, when my friend's son at age 3 was literally shaken (like those horrible shaken baby videos) by his grandmother because he tried to stand on a stadium chair to see. (she wouldn't let him on her lap) I told my friend (who wasn't there) that if she didn't address it I'd call CPS and get a lawyer to protect the little boy from anyone--even her letting her MIL around her son.  It didn't come to that, but it worries me still some days.

dominicansoul
Posted

Honestly never.  I do pray for mean people to drop dead before they can hurt other people though.  

MarysLittleFlower
Posted (edited)

I don't know if this is good to discuss?. I mean the enemy can tempt to all kinds of weird things but IMO its best to just ignore them. Just think of God :)

Edited by MarysLittleFlower
HisChildForever
Posted

I can honestly say no, never. 

Posted

Before I was a Christian, yeah, all the time. I got hurt a lot, and I'd plan out an assassination James Bond-style. I think it helped me cope with the hurt.

Posted

The passing thought? Absolutely, and a number of times: a man who had hurt a lady-friend of mine, a disrespectful boss, myself even. However, the thing about thoughts like this is that they pass if they are not entertained. Thought they may enter the mind, if they are not given attention and ignored, they will leave as rapidly as they entered, and we are then back to clarity. It takes some mental discipline, but it is an excellent armor against sin.

Posted
3 minutes ago, bardegaulois said:

The passing thought? Absolutely, and a number of times: a man who had hurt a lady-friend of mine, a disrespectful boss, myself even. However, the thing about thoughts like this is that they pass if they are not entertained. Thought they may enter the mind, if they are not given attention and ignored, they will leave as rapidly as they entered, and we are then back to clarity. It takes some mental discipline, but it is an excellent armor against sin.

I once heard an Amish person say, "You can't help it if a bird lands on your head. But you can help it if he builds a nest there."

Posted

You guys caught on really quick. I was doing some spiritual counselling with someone who has sexual sin issues, and they were having trouble with the idea that having random thoughts isn't a sin, but acting on them is. Once I framed it as thinking about wanting to hurt or kill someone, they understood 

Credo in Deum
Posted

I have many a time wanted to murder a cheeseburger and I must confess I have done it.  I try to be clean but sometimes it gets a little messy and sauce gets splattered everywhere.   The horror!  The horror!

Posted

I have had some rather unpleasant thoughts about the pit bull and its owner that hurt my basset hound. 

Posted
3 minutes ago, CatherineM said:

I have had some rather unpleasant thoughts about the pit bull and its owner that hurt my basset hound. 

:sad2:It's always toughest with kids and pets.  It's a natural feeling.  We can't act upon it, and even in the moment where I'd of said "For sure I'd of kicked a woman shaking a toddler down a set of stadium seats" we may not because of prudence or because it's just impractical.  We have tools to put that anger to good use.

In the case of sexual feelings...they are natural too...and we can choose to use those passions in more healthy ways.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

Not seriously entertained, no.

 

But when my mother passed away because of a doctor's carelessness, I was filled with so much anger, I did understand why some people do become enraged enough to commit violence or want to kill.

Posted

When my Dad died, it was my mom and God I was angry at. 6 months before they had recommended that he get a bypass operation. She said no, he's to old. He was 71. His heart muscle slowly died from lack of oxygen. I don't remember wanting to kill my mom, all I remember is the anger and grief. 

In the end, I reconciled with her because I knew my Dad would have wanted me to forgive her. 

Posted

I don't think I've felt the 'passionate' side of wanting to kill someone. As in 'crime of passion'... But I have thought about how I'd do it, if I did. Especially since we have such amazing technology to trace and track things, it's amazing to me that anyone still can get away with murder. So yes I've thought about it in that sense! :rolleyes:

Posted
16 hours ago, CatherineM said:

I have had some rather unpleasant thoughts about the pit bull and its owner that hurt my basset hound. 

Totally understandable.

Be nice to yourself, Catherine! :buddies:

Posted

Once.  I teach my students that murder is often a crime of passion; and only once have I truly experienced that passion.  My mother had just had surgery for colon cancer, my father and I had been forced to rely on one another all week, and I thought we had finally healed our shattered relationship.  I came home from work, and while I poured a glass of water in the kitchen, next to the steak knives, he said, "Son, it's about your mom, they..." and his voice cracked.  I started to cry and then he started laughing and said "Got you" and told me they'd gotten the cancer.  As he kept making fun of me for thinking my mother was dying, every single piece of verbal and emotional abuse over the years was going through my head and it took every last ounce of my willpower not to pick up a steak knife.

I've never felt that way before, or since.  And I pray that I never do again.

PhuturePriest
Posted

I can honestly answer no. I've sometimes been so angry that I fantasized telling the person off, but never so far as murder.

Posted
3 hours ago, PhuturePriest said:

I can honestly answer no. I've sometimes been so angry that I fantasized telling the person off, but never so far as murder.

You will always be a sweet, precious, innocent child to me :heart::heart::heart: 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...