Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

How can we help our priests to smell like the sheep?


Recommended Posts

Ash Wednesday
Posted

Sheep actually really stink. Ever smell one that needs to be washed? :P

I could be wrong, but it seems to me that priests did have more involvement with families and the congregation in the past. Clergy in my experience have often been a little detached, very busy, and I was often a little intimidated by them. But I can imagine life can get lonely for them.

Sadly, I think the abuse scandals have also broken a lot of trust people may have ever had for clergy, and the shortage is a problem as well because what priests we have often are very busy.

Praying for more good priests.

Posted

Let them have wives. Straight up.

MarysLittleFlower
Posted

I think its good that priests in the Latin rite don't marry.

Our priests do interact with the families quite a bit... Theres a Christian family group that meets, they get invited to peoples homes and also do blessings and Sacred Heart enthronements. 

I think the lay people in the parish can help priests get to know the families just by inviting them over or suggesting apostolates like the enthronement 

Posted
3 hours ago, Peace said:

Let them have wives. Straight up.

But a priest already has a wife; she is called The Church.

Posted
Just now, bardegaulois said:

But a priest already has a wife; she is called The Church.

Let them marry human beings of the female sex.

MarysLittleFlower
Posted
Just now, Peace said:

Let them marry human beings of the female sex.

Why?

Posted
23 minutes ago, MarysLittleFlower said:

I think its good that priests in the Latin rite don't marry.

Our priests do interact with the families quite a bit... Theres a Christian family group that meets, they get invited to peoples homes and also do blessings and Sacred Heart enthronements. 

I think the lay people in the parish can help priests get to know the families just by inviting them over or suggesting apostolates like the enthronement 

I think it is cool for those who desire to take a vow of celibacy. I am not knocking it.

It seems like there could be plenty of people who could be good priests and at the same time married, too though. I think there is something to be said if the priest is in the same family position as many of his parishioners. I think you can relate to someone who is married if you have been married yourself, more so than if you have never been married . . .

Plus, when you go to a party or to someone's house - you always feel more comfortable going there with a friend right? Would probably be the same for a priest. I bet they would be a lot more comfortable hanging out with families, if they could bring their family along too. . .

MarysLittleFlower
Posted

I like the symbolism of them not having a wife except the Church... But anyway the reason I asked is because I though your reason was parish related. (Which it seems to be). Maybe Eastern priests can relate in that way.. But I don't know I guess just in my parish I see the two priests are so friendly with the families and really liked. I think if they were married they'd actually have less time to do parish work? Eastern rite priests don't have daily Mass. Our parish has two Masses every weekdays, Confession before all Masses, plus the priests do spiritual direction and tons of other things. The parish is not territorial (its FSSP) so when they visit people they often have to travel a while. There's just a lot to do and having a family is very time consuming as well. 

Posted
3 minutes ago, MarysLittleFlower said:

I like the symbolism of them not having a wife except the Church... But anyway the reason I asked is because I though your reason was parish related. (Which it seems to be). Maybe Eastern priests can relate in that way.. But I don't know I guess just in my parish I see the two priests are so friendly with the families and really liked. I think if they were married they'd actually have less time to do parish work? Eastern rite priests don't have daily Mass. Our parish has two Masses every weekdays, Confession before all Masses, plus the priests do spiritual direction and tons of other things. The parish is not territorial (its FSSP) so when they visit people they often have to travel a while. There's just a lot to do and having a family is very time consuming as well. 

Yeah - the family life would take away from their time (as it should). Maybe it might be balanced by the uptick in vocations that would probably result though?

I guess it really depends on the individual priests though. I guess my experience has been that Catholic priests are much more distant than at the previous churches I was at before I became Catholic. But maybe that is more perception than reality.

I invited one priest at my parish out for a drink one time. He was like "I don't drink". LOL. End of conversation. I tried.

veritasluxmea
Posted

Huh, was just reading tonight something Fulton Sheen wrote about how like the first pope all priests have a Simon and Peter nature- Simon representing their human nature, Peter their vocational nature of being calling out of the body of Christ to intercede with Christ in a way no one else is. That does separate them from "other" humans in a unique way (for our benefit to continue Christ's work) but at the same time they still remain fully human- as they are still fully human. Sort of like the mystery of Christ being fully human and divine. 

Posted
23 minutes ago, Peace said:

Yeah - the family life would take away from their time (as it should). Maybe it might be balanced by the uptick in vocations that would probably result though?

I guess it really depends on the individual priests though. I guess my experience has been that Catholic priests are much more distant than at the previous churches I was at before I became Catholic. But maybe that is more perception than reality.

I invited one priest at my parish out for a drink one time. He was like "I don't drink". LOL. End of conversation. I tried.

To be frank, I have to say I admire that distance about which you speak. I'm far more inclined to trust a priest who bears about him a sort of dignified otherworldliness than I am a gladhander.

IgnatiusofLoyola
Posted

I have talked with Catholics who are having their first experience with married priests because they attend a formerly Anglican congregation that converted to Catholicism. At first, they aren't used to it, do they call the wife "Mrs. Priest?" But once they are used to it, they like it.

Growing up as an Episcopalian, I was used to priests being married, so it doesn't seem strange. My parents were active in the church and were social friends with priests (and even a bishop). Four or five families, including the rector's family, used to go camping together every summer.

If there is a theological or traditional argument for priests to stay celibate, I can understand that, even if I don't necessarily agree. But, then I read about people saying things like, "What if the priest was having sex before Mass?" First, most married people not only wash their hands but take a shower before dressing for the day. I would hope that even a celibate priest would wash his hands before Mass. Second, there is nothing sinful or "dirty" about sex between a married couple.

I know of Episcopal congregations with multiple Masses per day, and the priest is married. At least where I live, Episcopal congregations tend to have more priests than Catholic congregations. Even small Episcopal congregations often have two or three priests, and large congregations, even more. (Then again, I live about 5 miles from an Episcopal seminary, so I imagine that affects the number of available priests.)

The priests I feel bad for are the ones who are the only priest in a parish. It must be a very lonely life. I've read one recommendation that priests who serve congregations near each other live in Community with each other, rather than live alone, so they have "family" life.

dominicansoul
Posted

If we want our priests to "smell like the sheep" spend more time with the sheep...in the confessional!

KnightofChrist
Posted
15 hours ago, Peace said:

Let them have wives. Straight up.

When there are troubles in a relationship many people have the idea that getting married and/or having a baby will fix things. Rarely to mostly never is that so. Married priests won't really solve the sex abuse plague, if I remember correctly a high number of men who sexually abuse young teens and children are married. There's even a high number of protestant pastors who can marry but still sexually abuse teens and children. 

I am also not at all convinced that it would solve the priest shortage problem. The shortage problem goes beyond the issue of men would be priest if they could marry. There is in many regards a great falling away, Church attendance continues to shrink in many places.

Also, I don't like dropping traditions of the Church, we've done quite enough of that lately, and done so in the name of bringing more people to Mass or in the Church and it hasn't really been effective.

PhuturePriest
Posted

My question: What shortage? Vocations are booming. There's literally a page on Facebook dedicated to that very fact. Studies have been made, and vocations are way, way up, and the trend is getting more and more positive. Many seminaries around the world have so many applicants that they have to turn men down because they don't have enough room for all of them.

It seems too many people are stuck in 1985. The shortage we're experiencing now will be fixed in ten years when the aforementioned seminarians are ordained. The end of the shortage is nigh. Not for all dioceses, of course. Some of them are still hurting. But that's due to catechesis and what the dioceses themselves focus on, not because men simply aren't willing to go without a physical bride.

Men won't give up something unless you can convince them what they're taking up is just as valuable and will even make them happier if it is their true vocation. Some dioceses (like mine) do an amesome job at that, and they're seeing the fruits of it. Others (like my former diocese) are not, and they are seeing the fruits of that.

Overall, the trend has been incredibly positive. I'll use a paragraph from Jason Evert for my closing statement, and keep in mind this was made many years ago before the better numbers we have now:

"But is there a crisis at all? In so many words, the Vatican has declared that the vocations crisis is over. Figures from the Church's Statistic Yearbook for 1997 were given in a June 4, 2000 Zenit News Agency report, which stated, "In 1978 there were 63,882 seminarians; at present there are 108,517, an increase of 69.87 percent. The increase in Africa and Asia, in fact, is incredible. Over the last twenty years, these two continents have seen an increase of 238.50 percent and 124.01 percent, respectively." Over the past twenty years, vocations have increased in every continent around the globe. In America, the number of seminarians has increased from 22,011 to 35,000 in the last two decades."

Posted

Having converted from Anglicanism, I'd definitely say that the Roman priesthood is in a much better state- even with the celibacy.

My old Anglican priest refers to the priesthood as his "job" and has very clearly defined times of when it is acceptable for the congregation to ring him or knock on the door- the old joke was "never die on a Monday!" The R.C priests I've encountered since I swam the Tiber (even though I only did so officially on Sunday) have been so full of warmth and the Holy Spirit whilst also being able to have a joke and connect with the individual in front of them- my college chaplain is an absolute scream! ;) 

If you ask me, the priests smell enough like the sheep already!

veritasluxmea
Posted (edited)

Iggy, way back in the early church there was a rule/practice that priests who had sex the night before would abstain from saying mass the next morning. When Anglicans allowed married priests this tradition didn't carry over. That's what people are referencing when they talk about the priest abstaining, not him being physically dirty.

I like Fr. Longnecker's approach. He converted from Anglicanism and is a married Catholic priest, and he makes a good point. Why should Catholics change our approach to celibacy? It won't solve anything. 

"As a married former Anglican priest who is now a Catholic I sometimes hear Catholics say things like, “Excellent, and it’s about time too! I hope all our priests could marry. That would solve a lot of the problems.” What they mean is that relaxing the celibacy rule will solve the priest shortage, solve the problems of pedophile priests, solve the problem of loneliness and ‘difficult’ celibate priests.

I can tell you from being in a church with married clergy that you would only exchange one set of problems for another. Here’s a story from England about a married priest who ran off with his female assistant. I am not relishing the problems outlined in this article, nor am I tut tutting and pointing the finger at the Anglicans. I’m simply pointing out that having married clergy would not necessarily solve any problems.

Marriage has problems too. It was all best summed up by an old Irish priest I met in England. “What do you think Father,” I said, “About all of us married men becoming Catholic priests?”

“Well,” he said with a twinkle in his eye, “I expect sometimes we’ll be jealous of you…and then again, I expect sometimes you’ll be jealous of us.” " (Unfortunately I can't figure out how to get the quote feature to work). http://www.patheos.com/blogs/standingonmyhead/2009/01/married-priests-2.html 

Edited by veritasluxmea
Posted
14 hours ago, Peace said:

Let them marry human beings of the female sex.

Ukrainian Catholic priests can do such a thing, Its one of the valid rites that is part of the Catholic Church, so yes Catholic priests can marry its just a different liturgy.   

KnightofChrist
Posted
14 minutes ago, PhuturePriest said:

My question: What shortage? Vocations are booming. There's literally a page on Facebook dedicated to that very fact. Studies have been made, and vocations are way, way up, and the trend is getting more and more positive. Many seminaries around the world have so many applicants that they have to turn men down because they don't have enough room for all of them.

It seems too many people are stuck in 1985. The shortage we're experiencing now will be fixed in ten years when the aforementioned seminarians are ordained. The end of the shortage is nigh. Not for all dioceses, of course. Some of them are still hurting. But that's due to catechesis and what the dioceses themselves focus on, not because men simply aren't willing to go without a physical bride.

Men won't give up something unless you can convince them what they're taking up is just as valuable and will even make them happier if it is their true vocation. Some dioceses (like mine) do an amesome job at that, and they're seeing the fruits of it. Others (like my former diocese) are not, and they are seeing the fruits of that.

Overall, the trend has been incredibly positive. I'll use a paragraph from Jason Evert for my closing statement, and keep in mind this was made many years ago before the better numbers we have now:

"But is there a crisis at all? In so many words, the Vatican has declared that the vocations crisis is over. Figures from the Church's Statistic Yearbook for 1997 were given in a June 4, 2000 Zenit News Agency report, which stated, "In 1978 there were 63,882 seminarians; at present there are 108,517, an increase of 69.87 percent. The increase in Africa and Asia, in fact, is incredible. Over the last twenty years, these two continents have seen an increase of 238.50 percent and 124.01 percent, respectively." Over the past twenty years, vocations have increased in every continent around the globe. In America, the number of seminarians has increased from 22,011 to 35,000 in the last two decades."

I guess it depends on how one views the data. According to George Town University, in 1970 the number of priests worldwide was 419,728, in 2014 the number of priests worldwide was 414,313. A drop of only 5,415 and you would think that would hardly be a shortage crisis. However in 1970 the worldwide Catholic population was 653.6 million, with 39,431 parishes without a resident priest, in 2014 the worldwide Catholic population was 1.229 billion, with 49,153 parishes without a resident priest, 9,722 more parishes without a resident priest than in 1970.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...