Guest Posted January 2, 2016 Posted January 2, 2016 You seem to confrontational to me. I'm not looking for an argument.
Spinozist Posted January 2, 2016 Posted January 2, 2016 (edited) Well, if you decide change your mind, you're welcome to ask me anything. If not, it took very little effort to make this account, so not using it wouldn't be so terrible. Edited January 2, 2016 by Spinozist
Spinozist Posted January 2, 2016 Posted January 2, 2016 Just now, Josh said: I hope you stick around either way. Take care. And you as well. Happy New Year. I'll keep an eye on this forum for a few days, and maybe contribute some of my thoughts about ways Catholics and atheists can work together in the public square. Points of common interest and the like. I might also set up a discussion about Aquinas and Spinoza.
Guest Posted January 2, 2016 Posted January 2, 2016 (edited) As long as I'm convinced you are an actual atheist poster and not someone trying to mess with me I will respond. Might not be tonight but within the next day or two. Phatmass can't compare to Catholic Answers and the discussions they get over there. Although this is a cool site with good people. Happy New Year and I hope it's a great one for you and yours. Edited January 2, 2016 by Guest
HisChildForever Posted January 2, 2016 Posted January 2, 2016 Josh, it could be more helpful to simply create a testimonials thread. Share your faith experiences and encourage others to do the same. Any non-Catholics and non-Christians would be able to read through at their leisure without feeling uncomfortable or confrontational. I mean, at the end of the day, your story is your story. People can't really argue because it's not meant to be a debate. 2 minutes ago, Josh said: As long as I'm convinced you are an actual atheist poster and not someone trying to mess with me I will respond. Might not be tonight but within the next day or two. Phatmass can't compare to Catholic Answers and the discussions they get over there. Although this is a cool site with good people. Happy New Year and I hope it's a great one for you and yours. Eh I believe him because I've heard plenty of complaints about how quick CA is to ban people who don't meet their status quo. I think it's a neat forum to browse and learn, but too overwhelming to join.
Spinozist Posted January 2, 2016 Posted January 2, 2016 (edited) Josh, that's fine. Take your time. Anyone here is welcome to ask questions if they like. I think I'll start a discussion on Aquinas and Spinoza in the Debates section of the forum in the meantime. Edited January 2, 2016 by Spinozist
Guest Posted January 2, 2016 Posted January 2, 2016 (edited) 37 minutes ago, HisChildForever said: Eh I believe him because I've heard plenty of complaints about how quick CA is to ban people who don't meet their status quo. I think it's a neat forum to browse and learn, but too overwhelming to join. Really? I've been browsing a lot there lately and thinking of joining. Some of the threads I read were really good and they let the discussion flow. One was dealing with Hitler and had tons of pics of him posing with Catholic Clergy that I had never seen before. None of it was edited or taken down. Also they just have so many discussions and sub forums. I really enjoy what I've seen so far. I guess I will have to join and find out how it is. Will always love Phatmass either way. Edited January 2, 2016 by Guest
Anomaly Posted January 3, 2016 Posted January 3, 2016 Josh, i like and respect you too much to want to get into an argument about paranormal "experiences", if they are real, and what they may mean. It's still a long way to go to conclude there is a God paying attention to every nano/second of everyone's inner thoughts for all their earthly existence and judging them worthy of worshipping Him for eternity.
xSilverPhinx Posted January 3, 2016 Posted January 3, 2016 On 12/31/2015, 4:31:52, Josh said: Any here who deny all things supernatural/paranormal? I think that if the supernatural exists, it is beyond the reach of humans.
xSilverPhinx Posted January 3, 2016 Posted January 3, 2016 On 1/1/2016, 8:06:19, Josh said: I've have more than one experience but the particular one I want to present first is dealing with a ouija board. This was over 12 years ago and I would never touch one now because I believe it to be demonic. At the time I didn't view it that way although I was skeptical. I got talked into participating. Anyway I think my experience (and countless others) leads to the conclusion spirts/souls exist and therefore an atheist purely materialistic view on reality is wrong. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ideomotor_phenomenon This is the phenomenon that explains how the Ouija board works. You subconsciously move the pieces yourself. It would be impressive if they moved on their own, though, and probably be a stronger reason to believe in the paranormal/supernatural, provided no natural force is acting upon them.
Spinozist Posted January 3, 2016 Posted January 3, 2016 3 hours ago, xSilverPhinx said: I think that if the supernatural exists, it is beyond the reach of humans. Why do you think that the supernatural exists? What does it mean for it to be beyond the reach of humans?
Not A Real Name Posted January 3, 2016 Posted January 3, 2016 11 minutes ago, Spinozist said: Why do you think that the supernatural exists? What does it mean for it to be beyond the reach of humans? He's an athiest so he doesnt believe the supernatual exists. He said "if", and he is right the supernatural would be beyond humans, however, this does conclude that the supernatural could not be revealed to human beings by God.
Spinozist Posted January 3, 2016 Posted January 3, 2016 1 minute ago, Not A Real Name said: He's an athiest so he doesnt believe the supernatual exists. He said "if", and he is right the supernatural would be beyond humans, however, this does conclude that the supernatural could not be revealed to human beings by God. Thanks for pointing that out. I missed the key 'if'. I'm still curious, how would we know whether they were beyond us vs didn't exist? And to you, how would revelation solve the problem? God reveals through some naturalistic means, presumably (a book, the sound of a voice, a dream, etc.), how could those naturalistic means by themselves provide sufficient reason to believe that the supernatural exists? Or do you think some sort of interior revelation, a motion within the individual spirit by God, is also necessary?
Not A Real Name Posted January 3, 2016 Posted January 3, 2016 3 minutes ago, Spinozist said: Thanks for pointing that out. I missed the key 'if'. I'm still curious, how would we know whether they were beyond us vs didn't exist? And to you, how would revelation solve the problem? God reveals through some naturalistic means, presumably (a book, the sound of a voice, a dream, etc.), how could those naturalistic means by themselves provide sufficient reason to believe that the supernatural exists? Or do you think some sort of interior revelation, a motion within the individual spirit by God, is also necessary? I believe both means would be necessary, but I will comment on the necessity of naturalistic means. For example we will take books/scriptures. If a scripture(s), as well as other writtings throughout the world, preannounced the coming of God, how he would be born, where he would be born, how he would live, the works he would do, and etc, then we could test the truth of these revelations and the claimants themselves once they arrived. In fact preannouncment is so necessary that without it there could be no proper way we could ever test an individuals claim to either be God or a messenger from God.
Spinozist Posted January 3, 2016 Posted January 3, 2016 (edited) 27 minutes ago, Not A Real Name said: For example we will take books/scriptures. If a scripture(s), as well as other writtings throughout the world, preannounced the coming of God, how he would be born, where he would be born, how he would live, the works he would do, and etc, then we could test the truth of these revelations and the claimants themselves once they arrived. In fact preannouncment is so necessary that without it there could be no proper way we could ever test an individuals claim to either be God or a messenger from God. I think that is a great point. Prediction would be a good way to indicate the truth of supernatural claims, although it would be open to alternative interpretations, these interpretations would be similarly outlandish (time-travel, advanced alien interference to complete predictions, etc.). So predictions is a good way to go. My struggle is that the predictions, as far as I've seen them, are fairly vague. For the example of Jesus, comparing the prophesies to the life of Jesus didn't convince most of the Jews at the time (and don't convince very many of them today), but they did convince some of them, and those Jews have gone into quite a bit of analysis about how Jesus completed the prophesies. There have been other great Rabbis, more recently Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson, who some Lubavitch Hasids believe was the Messiah, and they have written quite a bit arguing how his life fits the prophesies. What would be nice is if the prophesies were very specific, such as, "The Messiah would be born during a time a people called the Romans ruled, when the ruler's names was Augustus, 25 years into his rule. His parents will be named Mary and Joseph, and he will have a birthmark the shape of Greece on his right forearm." Or something like this. It would also be helpful if the verification could somehow perpetuate to today, without having to rely on one set of fairly well established (but I believe embellished, at least as far as the miracles) historical documents, comparing to not as well established and somewhat vague prophesies. Reality is somewhere in between. The prophesies are not maximally vague, and Jesus is a compelling candidate, more compelling probably than Rabbi Menachem. But it would have been nice, and certainly more convincing to me personally, if the prophesies had been more specific, and had some sort of direct verifiability to this day. All this to say that it's a good reason, convincing for some people, but not as good as it could have been (and I wonder why this would be the case). And even if the predictions were very specific and very accurate, it might not be compelling evidence for the supernatural, since there are still other explanations. For example, some writers who were nominally affiliated with the Russian Orthodox Church in the 1800's thought that Jesus might have been a time-travelling Russian. Edited January 3, 2016 by Spinozist
Not A Real Name Posted January 3, 2016 Posted January 3, 2016 30 minutes ago, Spinozist said: I think that is a great point. Prediction would be a good way to indicate the truth of supernatural claims, although it would be open to alternative interpretations, these interpretations would be similarly outlandish (time-travel, advanced alien interference to complete predictions, etc.). So predictions is a good way to go. My struggle is that the predictions, as far as I've seen them, are fairly vague. For the example of Jesus, comparing the prophesies to the life of Jesus didn't convince most of the Jews at the time (and don't convince very many of them today), but they did convince some of them, and those Jews have gone into quite a bit of analysis about how Jesus completed the prophesies. There have been other great Rabbis, more recently Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson, who some Lubavitch Hasids believe was the Messiah, and they have written quite a bit arguing how his life fits the prophesies. What would be nice is if the prophesies were very specific, such as, "The Messiah would be born during a time a people called the Romans ruled, when the ruler's names was Augustus, 25 years into his rule. His parents will be named Mary and Joseph, and he will have a birthmark the shape of Greece on his right forearm." Or something like this. It would also be helpful if the verification could somehow perpetuate to today, without having to rely on one set of fairly well established (but I believe embellished, at least as far as the miracles) historical documents, comparing to not as well established and somewhat vague prophesies. Reality is somewhere in between. The prophesies are not maximally vague, and Jesus is a compelling candidate, more compelling probably than Rabbi Menachem. But it would have been nice, and certainly more convincing to me personally, if the prophesies had been more specific, and had some sort of direct verifiability to this day. All this to say that it's a good reason, convincing for some people, but not as good as it could have been (and I wonder why this would be the case). And even if the predictions were very specific and very accurate, it might not be compelling evidence for the supernatural, since there are still other explanations. For example, some writers who were nominally affiliated with the Russian Orthodox Church in the 1800's thought that Jesus might have been a time-travelling Russian. You make great points, however, there are things other than the scriptures which point to Christ as the fullfilment of the OT prophecies. As Arch Bishop Fulton J Sheen mentions in his book "Life of Christ", other factors to be considered are: the ceasing of all prophieses as well as sacrifices in Judaism after Christ, and that Christ's very life has split time in two. Our history as human beings revolve around His life.
xSilverPhinx Posted January 3, 2016 Posted January 3, 2016 3 hours ago, Not A Real Name said: He's an athiest so he doesnt believe the supernatual exists. He said "if", and he is right the supernatural would be beyond humans, however, this does conclude that the supernatural could not be revealed to human beings by God. Actually I'm a "she"
Not A Real Name Posted January 3, 2016 Posted January 3, 2016 7 minutes ago, xSilverPhinx said: Actually I'm a "she" My apologies.
xSilverPhinx Posted January 3, 2016 Posted January 3, 2016 2 minutes ago, Not A Real Name said: My apologies. No worries.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now