Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

abstinence tomorrow?


Recommended Posts

MarysLittleFlower
Posted

Tomorrow is the day of obligation feast of Mary Mother of God (here in Canada). Its also a Friday. So do we eat meat or not? (I follow the no meat on Friday traditional practice instead of substituting penances). 

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

The Church has proclaimed that we can fast on anything we so choose or do some other form of penance or works of Charity. Though Saint Paul does state in Holy Scripture that fasting off meat and alcohol is the best kind of fast and Abel fasted off meat, just so you know not that you did or didnt already. :) luv yah. Hope that helps.

GodblesS

Not The Philosopher
Posted

It's a solemnity so I assume that the penitential character of Friday is lifted.

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted (edited)
5 minutes ago, Not The Philosopher said:

It's a solemnity so I assume that the penitential character of Friday is lifted.

Are we exempt from fasting on a solemnity? I don't even know what is meant by solemnity, please illuminate me. :) Catholic with L plates on even after 13 years practicing 'The way' though 7 years of that have been trapped in a sluggish dark night of the soul where the growth of this branch of the vine has been agonisingly slow.

Edited by Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Not The Philosopher
Posted
21 minutes ago, Tab'le De'Bah-Rye said:

Are we exempt from fasting on a solemnity? I don't even know what is meant by solemnity, please illuminate me. :) Catholic with L plates on even after 13 years practicing 'The way' though 7 years of that have been trapped in a sluggish dark night of the soul where the growth of this branch of the vine has been agonisingly slow.

A solemnity is the highest kind of feast day. Christmas is a solemnity, as is Easter and others. Because they are times for rejoicing, Solemnities cancel Friday penances when they fall on them.

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted (edited)

Oh okay. A missionary brother once rebuked me for fasting on a sunday. Is it the same for sundays? And what if one wants to do a 40 day fast, if your not under holy orders surely your conscience and Gods assumed will dictates whether you can or can't fast on particular days.

Edited by Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

We are in the octave of Christmas which is an eight day solemnity, plus Jan 1st the solemnity of Mary Mother of God.  Its been party time this whole time no fasting or abstinance required!  Fasting or abstaining on a solemnity is like fasting or abstaining on Easter Sunday!  Christmas and Easter being the two greatest solemnities in the liturgical calendar. 

MarysLittleFlower
Posted

Thank you for the replies! So if I understand we *don't* fast or abstain tomorrow? 

1 hour ago, Tab'le De'Bah-Rye said:

Oh okay. A missionary brother once rebuked me for fasting on a sunday. Is it the same for sundays? And what if one wants to do a 40 day fast, if your not under holy orders surely your conscience and Gods assumed will dictates whether you can or can't fast on particular days.

Yes its the same as Sundays. I was told the Church actually forbids us to fast on Sunday so we are under obedience to the Church in this :) if you fast for 40 days just leave out Sundays or major solemnities like days of obligation. That's what we do in Lent :)

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

ok thanks mary's little flower i will take this into consideration and ask for further clarification from a few different priests. Are you sure that the forbondance is not only for those under holy orders, sometimes we make the mistake of discerning some church documents as pertaining to the layity when it is strictly for holy orders.

Happy new year all. Good night and GodblesS.

MarysLittleFlower
Posted
18 minutes ago, Tab'le De'Bah-Rye said:

ok thanks mary's little flower i will take this into consideration and ask for further clarification from a few different priests. Are you sure that the forbondance is not only for those under holy orders, sometimes we make the mistake of discerning some church documents as pertaining to the layity when it is strictly for holy orders.

Happy new year all. Good night and GodblesS.

No I was told its for all. No one fasts on Sundays

Posted
17 hours ago, MarysLittleFlower said:

Thank you for the replies! So if I understand we *don't* fast or abstain tomorrow? 

Yes its the same as Sundays. I was told the Church actually forbids us to fast on Sunday so we are under obedience to the Church in this :) if you fast for 40 days just leave out Sundays or major solemnities like days of obligation. That's what we do in Lent :)

But is it okay to not eat meat on sundays because you just don't want to ?

Posted

You can eat the bacon double cheeseburger without hesitation. 

bardegaulois
Posted
8 hours ago, NadaTeTurbe said:

But is it okay to not eat meat on sundays because you just don't want to ?

That's like asking if one should eat meat every day. On certain days I don't eat meat, but not out of any intention. Rather, it's because other dishes seemed more appealing to me. Should I consider that day a day of penitential character? No, because I didn't have the intention not to eat meat; it's just how the day turned out. So if you're invited to a vegetarian relation's house for Sunday dinner and thus dine on a meatless dish, it's not really an act of abstinence because there was no intention to abstain and thus do penance. Likewise, if you're tired on a Sunday evening and just make a bowl of pasta because it is easy, then it can't really be abstinence either because you didn't form the intention.

It was once explained to me that in generally morally neutral acts, like what one eats for the day, it's not the act itself but the intention behind the act that really makes the difference. So abstaining as an act of penance and in deference to a precept of the Church is rather different than abstaining because you haven't been grocery shopping in a while. I hope that helps.

Not A Real Name
Posted
8 hours ago, Papist said:

You can eat the bacon double cheeseburger without hesitation. 

Add extra bacon. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...