Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

America is a two party system. Voting third party is futile.


Recommended Posts

Posted

It is of my opinion that one should live responsibly in reality. The United States is a two party system. We must choose the best candidate in that system or not vote at all. I choose not to vote at all.

Discuss.

HisChildForever
Posted

I thought this way during last election. I also was convinced at that time that a vote for third party was a vote for Obama. But now, with the next election looming, if Trump gets the nod I can't in good conscience vote for him. So that either has me voting third party or not voting at all. And I would much rather vote.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

If you don't vote, that sends the message you don't care about politics. If you vote third party, is says you care about politics but you're dissatisfied with the two parties. 

If you want to complain about anything political in this country, you have an obligation to participate in the process. 

PhuturePriest
Posted

What do you mean you're not voting at all when you have such great choices as Pedro?

77325796.jpg

Posted
2 hours ago, dUSt said:

It is of my opinion that one should live responsibly in reality. The United States is a two party system. We must choose the best candidate in that system or not vote at all. I choose not to vote at all.

Discuss.

Have your opinions changed since the last election cycle?

LittleWaySoul
Posted

It seems to me that not voting at all does the same thing as voting third party: hands the vote to the candidate you like least. Perhaps that's my misunderstanding of the system, though. Feel free to correct me here. 

Ive always been under the belief that if I want my vote to count for something, the only option is voting for one of the two partisan candidates. Voting 3rd party and not voting at all seem to me like they'd both do a disservice to my actual views/desires. 

Though with this election I'm not quite as secure in this above belief as I once was. I'm interested in hearing other people's thoughts on this topic. 

Posted
3 hours ago, dUSt said:

It is of my opinion that one should live responsibly in reality. The United States is a two party system. We must choose the best candidate in that system or not vote at all. I choose not to vote at all.

Discuss.

I disagree. My state always goes solid blue in every election cycle. Thus, whenever I'm not pleased with either of the main party's presidential candidates, I will vote for the candidate of one of the minor parties. The reason for this is that any party scoring at least 5% is automatically on the ballot next time around. So I decide that I'll put my vote where it actually does matter by voting for a more diverse ballot.

Moreover, most local elections in my area are non-partisan, and many of them are three-ways as well. New England really isn't a two-party area insofar as local elections are concerned.

HisChildForever
Posted
23 minutes ago, LittleWaySoul said:

It seems to me that not voting at all does the same thing as voting third party: hands the vote to the candidate you like least. Perhaps that's my misunderstanding of the system, though. Feel free to correct me here. 

Ive always been under the belief that if I want my vote to count for something, the only option is voting for one of the two partisan candidates. Voting 3rd party and not voting at all seem to me like they'd both do a disservice to my actual views/desires. 

Though with this election I'm not quite as secure in this above belief as I once was. I'm interested in hearing other people's thoughts on this topic. 

These are my exact feelings too. I now understand those last election who said they weren't comfortable voting for the GOP runner. But I enjoy presidential elections and being part of the discussion, even just reading and listening to others' thoughts. If Trump isn't the GOP candidate then I'll be voting for whoever is.

This is my third presidential election so it's still fresh (and exciting) to me. 

PhuturePriest
Posted
42 minutes ago, HisChildForever said:

These are my exact feelings too. I now understand those last election who said they weren't comfortable voting for the GOP runner. But I enjoy presidential elections and being part of the discussion, even just reading and listening to others' thoughts. If Trump isn't the GOP candidate then I'll be voting for whoever is.

This is my third presidential election so it's still fresh (and exciting) to me. 

This is my first presidential election I can participate in, and that Trump is the likely candidate makes me wholly unexcited. :|

PhuturePriest
Posted

I mean, really. It's like going into your first election and your options are Incompetent Hitler or Less Genocidal Stalin.

If Rubio or some other competent person doesn't get the nomination I'm honestly not sure who I'm voting for. 

KnightofChrist
Posted

 

I gave up long ago on the two party only thought system. We only have two parties because people think we can only have two parties. That helps the two parties keep it a two party system.

The Trump effect, for me at least, is certainly interesting. The other week or so when Trump visited my state I saw a church-van load of grandmas (of various ethic backgrounds, white, black, spanish) taking a pit stop at a McDonalds, every single one of them decked out in Trump gear. Also I live in a very heavily populated black/spanish neighborhood and I've seen a number of houses cars with Trump signs and bumper stickers. Despite all the brew-ha-ha about him being a destroyer of worlds he should get support from groups we're told would never support him. Also, I really doubt he'd be any better or worse than any other sellout, fake and typical politician.

 

16 minutes ago, PhuturePriest said:

I mean, really. It's like going into your first election and your options are Incompetent Hitler or Less Genocidal Stalin.

If Rubio or some other competent person doesn't get the nomination I'm honestly not sure who I'm voting for. 

He's another corporate owned phony, when it came to voting for actual funding of Planned Parenthood he didn't show up.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

When you vote third party, at least you're counted as someone who is interested in participating in the political process. When you don't vote at all you can be written off as someone who just isn't interested, so there's no point for people to really campaign for your issues. If third party candidates start getting more votes, it can force mainline candidates to swing toward them. 

The practical result is basically the same - your candidate won't get elected. But it's better than not voting at all. If you don't vote because you feel like all voting for any of the candidates would violate your conscience, that's different. 

No, wait, still vote. Write someone in. 

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)
17 minutes ago, Basilisa Marie said:

When you vote third party, at least you're counted as someone who is interested in participating in the political process. When you don't vote at all you can be written off as someone who just isn't interested, so there's no point for people to really campaign for your issues. If third party candidates start getting more votes, it can force mainline candidates to swing toward them. 

The practical result is basically the same - your candidate won't get elected. But it's better than not voting at all. If you don't vote because you feel like all voting for any of the candidates would violate your conscience, that's different. 

No, wait, still vote. Write someone in. 

Clearly, the answer is obvious.

Vermin_Supreme_glitterbombs_Randall_Terr

I'm seriously writing in Vermin Supreme if it comes down to Trump or Hillary. At least with Supreme we would all get ponies. Plus, look at the joy the guy brings. Even his opponents love him.

Edited by PhuturePriest
Posted
12 minutes ago, PhuturePriest said:

Clearly, the answer is obvious.

Vermin_Supreme_glitterbombs_Randall_Terr

I'm seriously writing in Vermin Supreme if it comes down to Trump or Hillary. At least with Supreme we would all get ponies. Plus, look at the joy the guy brings. Even his opponents love him.

I would be incredibly mad if someone threw that much glitter on my suit.

PhuturePriest
Posted
1 hour ago, Nihil Obstat said:

I would be incredibly mad if someone threw that much glitter on my suit.

Jesus told him to turn Randall Terry gay, so he sprinkled the glitter on him to magically transform his sexuality. It had to be done.

Unless of course you don't want people to obey direct commands from God. :|

Posted

As practicing Catholics it is our moral duty to vote.  Not voting is not an option unless you willfully intend to do a transgression against the Church.

https://www.ewtn.com/vote/voting_faq.htm

Our Duty to Vote

With the development of popular government comes the duty of citizens to participate in their own government for the sake of the common good. Not to do so is to abandon the political process to those who do not have the common good in mind. Given the nature of democracies this inevitably leads to unjust laws and an unjust society. These may come about anyway, but they should not come about through the negligence of Christians, who would then share in the guilt.

This duty is chiefly exercised by voting, through which citizens elect their representatives and even determine by referendum the laws which will govern them. The Catechism of the Catholic Church states:

2239 It is the duty of citizens to contribute along with the civil authorities to the good of society in a spirit of truth, justice, solidarity, and freedom. The love and service of one's country follow from the duty of gratitude and belong to the order of charity. Submission to legitimate authorities and service of the common good require citizens to fulfill their roles in the life of the political community.

2240 Submission to authority and co-responsibility for the common good make it morally obligatory to pay taxes, to exercise the right to vote, and to defend one's country [Rom 13:7]:

Pay to all of them their dues, taxes to whom taxes are due, revenue to whom revenue is due, respect to whom respect is due, honor to whom honor is due. [Christians] reside in their own nations, but as resident aliens. They participate in all things as citizens and endure all things as foreigners.... They obey the established laws and their way of life surpasses the laws.... So noble is the position to which God has assigned them that they are not allowed to desert it. [Ad Diognetum 5: 5, 10]

The Apostle exhorts us to offer prayers and thanksgiving for kings and all who exercise authority, "that we may lead a quiet and peaceable life, godly and respectful in every way." [1 Tim 2:2]

 

Credo in Deum
Posted (edited)

Duty. Hero's duty.

Edited by Credo in Deum
Posted
11 hours ago, dUSt said:

It is of my opinion that one should live responsibly in reality. The United States is a two party system. We must choose the best candidate in that system or not vote at all. I choose not to vote at all.

Discuss.

I would like to think that voting no longer matters because of a two party system, but then I ask myself, if that is true, why do candidates spend so much money to win votes ? Why go through the trouble of cheating and having people use the deceased as voters, to bring in illegal immigrants and use them as well for their votes.  Not voting only guarantees that the basic what ever in our nation you want to see, won't happen, or that the politician you hope will win, does not have your vote.  Not voting is probably the worse thing anyone can do and is what causes the nation to suffer more often than not. It does not have to be a two party system, the problem is getting enough people to want to leave the two party system in the wind, not destroying the two party system; they are doing good on their own at proving how worthless they are as respectable leaders. A third party can work, but it will take those forming it , to be able to persevere, have enough funding, and to not expose themselves until they are strong enough to be able to throw the political blows that will come from both the democrats and republicans working together to stop said third party and even infiltrate that party. The tea party, their big mistake was the name, It was meant to be a grass roots org  for demonstrating against corruption in our government, and instead the name killed them and forced them into a corner which they easily lost. I do not think we will ever have a good government in any sense of the word, but we should at the very least have a government that fears the voter. An fears repercussions  from breaking any law. It is a crying shame when anyone of us can get a ticket for going over the speed limit, or running a red light, but a politician who is voted in, blatantly flaunts and abuses laws, and not only does the person not face jail time or fines, but gets re elected ! An education is needed on our constitution and bill of rights, because too often the same leader that breaks these laws and gets re elected, is telling the public that not only are they not breaking any law, but that they are the law and can interpret the law at their discretion to fit their agenda and that we as the voting public must believe them because after all they are the ones who are in power.

 I was thinking about not voting, but really it is my last choice before joining a militia and waiting for things to get to a point of no return.

The Constitution and Bill of Rights are on our side, to protect us from things already happening, the problem is we have weak boned leaders from the ground up who refuse to educate themselves on these laws, and use them properly.

 

Credo in Deum
Posted (edited)

Voting no longer matters because of corporations.  The puppet who is going to win this presidential race is the one that works best for the corporate  puppeteers.  

This doesn't mean I won't vote though.  No, I will vote since that is me doing my part. 

Edited by Credo in Deum

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...