Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The Pope decrees that not only men may be chosen for the washing of the feet in the Liturgy of Holy Thursday


Recommended Posts

Posted

Vatican City, 21 January 2016 (VIS) – The Holy Father has written a letter, dated 20 December and published today, to Cardinal Robert Sarah, prefect of the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments, in which he decrees that from now on, the people chosen for the washing of the feet in the liturgy of Holy Thursday may be selected from all the People of God, and not only men and boys.

The Pope writes to the cardinal that he has for some time reflected on the "rite of the washing of the feet contained in the Liturgy of the Mass in Coena Domini, with the intention of improving the way in which it is performed so that it might express more fully the meaning of Jesus' gesture in the Cenacle, His giving of Himself unto the end for the salvation of the world, His limitless charity".

"After careful consideration", he continues, "I have decided to make a change to the Roman Missal. I therefore decree that the section according to which those persons chosen for the Washing of the feet must be men or boys, so that from now on the Pastors of the Church may choose the participants in the rite from among all the members of the People of God. I also recommend that an adequate explanation of the rite itself be provided to those who are chosen".

The Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments has today published a decree on the aforementioned rite, dated 6 January 2016, the full text of which is published below:

"The reform of the Holy Week, by the decree Maxima Redemptionis nostrae mysteria of November 1955, provides the faculty, where counselled by pastoral motives, to perform the washing of the feet of twelve men during the Mass of the Lord's Supper, after the reading of the Gospel according to John, as if almost to represent Christ's humility and love for His disciples.

In the Roman liturgy this rite was handed down with the name of the Mandatum of the Lord on brotherly charity in accordance with Jesus' words, sung in the Antiphon during the celebration.

In performing this rite, bishops and priests are invited to conform intimately to Christ who 'came not to be served but to serve' and, driven by a love 'to the end', to give His life for the salvation of all humankind.

To manifest the full meaning of the rite to those who participate in it, the Holy Father Francis has seen fit to change the rule by in the Roman Missal (p.300, No. 11) according to which the chosen men are accompanied by the ministers, which must therefore be modified as follows: 'Those chosen from among the People of God are accompanied by the ministers' (and consequently in the Caeremoniale Episcoporum No. 301 and No. 299 b referring to the seats for the chosen men, so that pastors may choose a group of faithful representing the variety and unity of every part of the People of God. This group may consist of men and women, and ideally of the young and the old, healthy and sick, clerics, consecrated persons and laypeople.

This Congregation for Divine Worship and the Disipline of the Sacraments, by means of the faculties granted by the Supreme Pontiff, introduces this innovation in the liturgical books of the Roman Rite, recalling pastors of their duty to instruct adequately both the chosen faithful and others, so that they may participate in the rite consciously, actively and fruitfully".

Posted

So it goes. We do not have to like or favour it.

Posted

Yes, I have never really seen the need to include the ceremony in my Holy Thursday Mass. It's optional anyway: from the Roman Missal for Holy Thursday: " After the homily, where pastoral reason suggests it, the washing of the feet follows."

Posted

At least now when the Holy Father continues to do as he wishes, those who follow his example are not thereby breaking Liturgical law.

Posted
1 hour ago, Nihil Obstat said:

At least now when the Holy Father continues to do as he wishes, those who follow his example are not thereby breaking Liturgical law.

It says 'pastors of the Church may choose the participants in the rite from among all the members of the People of God'. I guess that includes non Catholics and Christians too, if the Popes actions are anything to go by.

I think it better to omit the washing completely so as to not confuse everyone more than already happens with the endless list of modifications or liturgical tinkering.

Posted

Yes.  Better to not perform the washing of the feet to demonstrate that the Church Clergy is to serve humanity if risking muddling up some arcane theological point that is unknown and irrelevant to the vast majority of the observers. 

Posted
9 minutes ago, Benedictus said:

It says 'pastors of the Church may choose the participants in the rite from among all the members of the People of God'. I guess that includes non Catholics and Christians too, if the Popes actions are anything to go by.

I think it better to omit the washing completely so as to not confuse everyone more than already happens with the endless list of modifications or liturgical tinkering.

Yes, going exclusively by past actions, one would be justified in thinking that Pope Francis intends to include all sorts of non-Catholics and non-Christians. But, regardless of how the law is worded, he probably intends to continue doing whatever he wishes to do.

Posted
10 minutes ago, Anomaly said:

Yes.  Better to not perform the washing of the feet to demonstrate that the Church Clergy is to serve humanity if risking muddling up some arcane theological point that is unknown and irrelevant to the vast majority of the observers. 

Off base. You're outside the ball park.

Posted
55 minutes ago, Nihil Obstat said:

Yes, going exclusively by past actions, one would be justified in thinking that Pope Francis intends to include all sorts of non-Catholics and non-Christians. But, regardless of how the law is worded, he probably intends to continue doing whatever he wishes to do.

Better be careful, you might end up like me where every post is moderated, your mailbox shrunk to nothing and get the scarlet letter of "fishy."

MarysLittleFlower
Posted

Are priests free to still choose altar boys for this ceremony if they want? Especially in the TLM where they just stick to the 1962 way of doing things. I'm a bit confused what the washing of the feet means. From what I read it was an example but also a way Jesus purified the Apostles before the Communion. Is this so? Also this recent change, is it under infallibility or just pastoral? If the latter, does it mean priests can choose the older way too?

Basilisa Marie
Posted

All this does is open it up so that pastors can choose what he wants to emphasize with the Holy Thursday footwashing. Some people like having a bunch of men there because it sends a better image of the institution of the priesthood. But having different kinds of people there emphasizes how Jesus took on the role of the servant of all, and how we're meant to be servants to one another in imitation of him. Neither is inherently better than the other, we just have to be clear what we're trying to teach people. 

And honestly most changes in the liturgy that have ever happened in the history of the Church came from the bottom up, not from decrees from the Pope. So this change is actually pretty typical of the process. There's no reason to get our knickers in a bunch. 

1 hour ago, Nihil Obstat said:

Yes, going exclusively by past actions, one would be justified in thinking that Pope Francis intends to include all sorts of non-Catholics and non-Christians. But, regardless of how the law is worded, he probably intends to continue doing whatever he wishes to do.

Yeah, because he's the pope, honey, he IS the law. ;) 

Posted

This is the utter idiocy that society sees , to wash only a mans foot or not. But if we are going to follow this stupidity then the topic has to include well if we are only going to wash the feet of men, should those men only be seminarians , who have a good GPA , or only deacons, or only men between the ages of 21 and 65, or how about only white men, or only Hebrew men, how about only circumcised men should have their feet washed ?  This is beyond stupid to even be written an published about. Let alone even be considered an argument. Pedophile priests run free, bishops and cardinals who covered it up get only a slap on the wrist, everyone turns a blind eye to it and just goes oh well that is humanity for ya. An this is what the church wants us as catholics to notice  as a worthy topic of interest ? Because watching who gets their feet washed is really a life changing moment in the Church. Forget the entire message Christ was trying to emphasis to his disciples at that moment; what Christ would really be p.offd about today is how dare women or the unholy get their feet washed on this day. Wait now the argument should be, are only religious women allowed to have their feet washed !

So raise the stupidity flag proud and high and make sure to keep it going.

An then everyone goes wait a minute why are people leaving the church ? I have my church militant badged polished, I make sure to politely inform everyone I know of their mistakes while pointing out I am no holier than they because I tell them I am a sinner too so that way they can not possibly pin me as being a fat hypocrite... I just have no idea why anyone would want to leave the church.

An what is sadder, is that the Pope had to waste his time to clarify the matter when he could have been doing something more important than having to wipe the noses of those people sniveling about the entire thing.

Posted (edited)
56 minutes ago, StMichael said:

 

34 minutes ago, Basilisa Marie said:

 

Yeah, because he's the pope, honey, he IS the law. ;) 

I thought that was obvious. He is the pope, and liturgically he does as he wishes. And in this case too, we are obligated neither to like nor favour what he wishes.

Edited by Nihil Obstat
Posted
20 minutes ago, Nihil Obstat said:

I thought that was obvious. He is the pope, and liturgically he does as he wishes. And in this case too, we are obligated neither to like nor favour what he wishes.

Whoops. Weird implicature there. "We are not obligated to like, neither are we obligated to favour what he wishes."

MarysLittleFlower
Posted
4 hours ago, superblue said:

This is the utter idiocy that society sees , to wash only a mans foot or not. But if we are going to follow this stupidity then the topic has to include well if we are only going to wash the feet of men, should those men only be seminarians , who have a good GPA , or only deacons, or only men between the ages of 21 and 65, or how about only white men, or only Hebrew men, how about only circumcised men should have their feet washed ?  This is beyond stupid to even be written an published about. Let alone even be considered an argument. Pedophile priests run free, bishops and cardinals who covered it up get only a slap on the wrist, everyone turns a blind eye to it and just goes oh well that is humanity for ya. An this is what the church wants us as catholics to notice  as a worthy topic of interest ? Because watching who gets their feet washed is really a life changing moment in the Church. Forget the entire message Christ was trying to emphasis to his disciples at that moment; what Christ would really be p.offd about today is how dare women or the unholy get their feet washed on this day. Wait now the argument should be, are only religious women allowed to have their feet washed !

So raise the stupidity flag proud and high and make sure to keep it going.

An then everyone goes wait a minute why are people leaving the church ? I have my church militant badged polished, I make sure to politely inform everyone I know of their mistakes while pointing out I am no holier than they because I tell them I am a sinner too so that way they can not possibly pin me as being a fat hypocrite... I just have no idea why anyone would want to leave the church.

An what is sadder, is that the Pope had to waste his time to clarify the matter when he could have been doing something more important than having to wipe the noses of those people sniveling about the entire thing.

The liturgy is very important which is why these topics are discussed. Its not just a human thing, its divine worship and sharing in the worship of Heaven. If we saw the spiritual reality of it we would see Calvary, Our Lady and countless Angels. 

I personally don't think its unimportant to discuss aspects of the liturgy 

Posted
5 hours ago, MarysLittleFlower said:

Are priests free to still choose altar boys for this ceremony if they want? Especially in the TLM where they just stick to the 1962 way of doing things. I'm a bit confused what the washing of the feet means. From what I read it was an example but also a way Jesus purified the Apostles before the Communion. Is this so? Also this recent change, is it under infallibility or just pastoral? If the latter, does it mean priests can choose the older way too?

For those who use the 1962 missal, the rubrics of 1962 remain in place. This only affects the Novus Ordo. Moreover, a priest celebrating the Novus Ordo "may," not "must," choose women for the mandatum. If a priest wishes to choose only men, he may as well. If he wishes to omit the entire ceremony altogether, it being optional, he may also do that.

Posted
11 minutes ago, MarysLittleFlower said:

The liturgy is very important which is why these topics are discussed. Its not just a human thing, its divine worship and sharing in the worship of Heaven. If we saw the spiritual reality of it we would see Calvary, Our Lady and countless Angels. 

I personally don't think its unimportant to discuss aspects of the liturgy 

this has nothing to do with divine worship, Christ never said, and please make sure to re create this symbolic gesture of what I want you to do. This is a humanly created addition to the mass to be demonstrated only once during Holy week and nothing more, and it became blown out of proportion when Pope Francis decided to do something different to include women. An then when all the self righteous started crying about oh no not this ! PLEASE LORD NOT THIS ATROCITY !   Taking out this washing of the feet, having only men or women being washed, means nothing to the sacrifice at the altar.  I am not disagree with discussing aspects of liturgy, I am disagreeing that the washing of the feet should even be considered important to the mass. It is nothing more than a distraction. An is just sad all the way across the board that it only became an issue once the pope decided to have women for a change, as if it was some giant in your face move of holiness, my diocese has had varying priests do just that before the pope ever did, and it never made the news let alone was considered an issue, probably because thankfully I do not completely live in an area of complete morons.

You know what the next idiotic topic should be, is what is the proper sign of peace, should it be a kiss, a hug, a nod, a handshake, and which hand if you shake hands, how about a fist bump, or better yet, how about a high 5 followed by a hug. Then lets dissect who should give the sign to whom, should men only give the sign of peace to men and women to women, but in turn children should sit down with their hands folded.

The Pope has bigger fish to fry and hopefully he doesn't get bogged down with having to be accountable to the public eye on issues that they create to be a problem because they have their own stupid agenda attached to it.  Someone should do an actual study to see if people in the congregation when this takes place during holy week, even knows why it is done in the first place, and what the viewer is meant to take away from the act. Half the congregation would not even know what day it was, and the remainder would vary.

Just like I am not going to change anyones mind here on the non importance of this issue, no one here will be able to convince me that it is important and why, because in the end it is just left up to this idea of mystical spirituality that some how connects us to a made up idea of whatever that is just more nonsense.

 

1 minute ago, bardegaulois said:

For those who use the 1962 missal, the rubrics of 1962 remain in place. This only affects the Novus Ordo. Moreover, a priest celebrating the Novus Ordo "may," not "must," choose women for the mandatum. If a priest wishes to choose only men, he may as well. If he wishes to omit the entire ceremony altogether, it being optional, he may also do that.

YES A THREAD DERAILING TOPIC ! and really it should be altar boys vs altar girls. Adults are sparse as altar servers usually due to lack of children in a community. But yes a very  serious topic in deed ,lol, should ONLY males or females be allowed as an altar server while the priest is conducting liturgical abuses.   

MarysLittleFlower
Posted

I guess I just disagree Superblue. Its not self righteous to care about more detailed parts of the liturgy because this has nothing to do with the self. The Mass is the whole liturgy not only the canon. Anyway I've said all I wanted to say, I'll just leave it. 

Posted

Good news :) 

KnightofChrist
Posted

I'm afraid this will encourage those who are disobedient and abuse rites and the liturgy. If they do it long enough they are rewarded.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...