Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

How school harms introverted teachers and students (The Atlantic)


Recommended Posts

Posted

I agree completely. It's typical for educators to get carried away by pedagogy fads. Right now, group learning is the fad. There's very little critical thinking about it, as is practically always the case with bandwagon thinking. Shameful for educators, though...

Have you seen this, Nada?

 

Clare~Therese
Posted

I agree with them. I never liked group work and would have preferred to work quietly and/or alone. 

MarysLittleFlower
Posted

I don't like group work too and there's often the student that does half the work for the group. 

homeschoolmom
Posted

I agree as well.

Posted

Thing will get better when the department of education is done away with. along with common core.

 

MarysLittleFlower
Posted (edited)

I'm a teacher... I read the teacher article. I totally agree that quieter teachers have a harder time. I'm one of those teachers. I usually come home completely exhausted. Even the staff room is often loud social time. No escape :)

 I don't really use the term introvert / extrovert because there are so many definitions of this related to various psychological theories.. I never know how people are using the term... And I'm not a fan of Carl Jung in general and aspects in his ideology seem at odds with the faith (not sure what he said on this topic in detail)

The article seems to just talk about people who like some quiet time. I agree that people who have quieter personalities get overwhelmed with modern classrooms. It used to be different I think. I think the modern style of teaching is very active social and loud "cooperative group work " etc

Edited by MarysLittleFlower
Oremus Pro Invicem
Posted

What can we expect from a society that is filled with constant distractions? Society views being alone and being in silence as unhealthy. You're called "anti-social" or "not being a team player" if you do not want to be 100% all the time working in a group.  You just want to do an Ecclesiastes style rant "A time for group work and a time for individual work. A time for social banter and a time for sweet silence."

I think teachers are just going to have to go against the fad and do what's right for their students and themselves.

Posted

I remember the feelings of horror and dread when we needed to "pair up" or "get into groups of x." I still hate when those situations arise as an adult. Hate.

Posted

For me, it's also another symptom of a world who refuse the idea of the Truth... Maybe I'm extrapolating... But in a world where there's not ONE Truh, but where everybody can build its own "truth", well, the idea of someone speaking, passing down one knowledge who is true, while other people just listen and accept it, this idea is "bad". Better let people building their own things. I don't know if I'm clear. 

Also, group work can be horrible for people with learning disability. I'm a good student, so my teacher never think about my disability (Elhers Danlos Syndrom and severe dyspraxia https://www.dyspraxiafoundation.org.uk/about-dyspraxia/ ). For me, the best way to learn is to listen, write something, and having only one sheet of papers, with simple page setting. I struggled a lot in high school when we have to "buit by ourselves" and we had one billion of papers with numerous colours, etc... Impossible to focus on it. 

I'm studying history right now, and it's perfect, because you can't really do group work in history. We just sit, listen to our teachers (who are very good orators), write, ask questions, and learn. And only then, when we know something, we can train to critical thinking. 

Mary, you're a teacher ? Can I ask in wich level ? I'd like to be a teacher later :) 

Posted (edited)
12 hours ago, NadaTeTurbe said:

For me, it's also another symptom of a world who refuse the idea of the Truth... Maybe I'm extrapolating... But in a world where there's not ONE Truh, but where everybody can build its own "truth", well, the idea of someone speaking, passing down one knowledge who is true, while other people just listen and accept it, this idea is "bad". Better let people building their own things. I don't know if I'm clear. 

This is very insightful. I agree 100%: The trend toward group work is related to the intellectual decline toward relativism and the "social construction of reality". I think ("Ecclesiastically", I guess ;)) that there is a time when it's important to let people discover Truth for themselves (alone or in groups), and there are also a great many times when we ought to humbly acknowledge our own ignorance, shut up, and listen to people who do know. Society's rejection of objective Truth implies that "nobody really 'knows'" because it implies there is no such thing as "knowing". Everyone just has "opinions". In that climate, "experts" are worthless and we might as well all just sit around talking in groups, because our opinions are as good as the "experts'". This makes us feel good, because it means we're not stupider than the "experts". Yay, self-esteem.

It's the beginning of the end. :| 

Edited by Gabriela
Posted
On 27/01/2016, 16:09:07, NadaTeTurbe said:

http://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2016/01/why-introverted-teachers-are-burning-out/425151/

http://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2015/09/introverts-at-school-overlook/407467/

I hate group work, and my vision of an ideal class is a teacher speaking while students are writing (with some questions at the end), so I liked these articles. Your thoughts ? 

I personally noticed differences in how various schools handled things. I've been to private and public schools in three or four countries. Private schools tended to nurture independent learning, academic competitiveness and critical thinking skills etc. You'd have more direct tutoring and time focused on personal projects and hobbies etc. Group work in academic matters wasn't so important because 'team work' skills were met in aspects of living together, sports, holidays etc.

However, public state schools tended to have bigger classes, less real engaged time and less of a personal focus. Teachers seemed to use group activity as a management class strategy (those who worked did and anyone else didn't have to sit silent or bored) and to divert the focus away from themselves. They'd have their time taken up with marking, dealing with problems, sorting out books or paperwork throughout the class etc.

Group work is often used as a time plug when a class lacks structure. I hated assessed projects in this context as lazy, flaky or less interested people placed more burden on the other group members. It's OK in a couple of classes but if it's a repeat cycle then a good student wastes a lot of time managing the fallout of those slackers. That time could have been spent advancing in a subject, getting a better grade or doing something else they enjoy.

Posted

The articles bring up some great points. In college, I enjoy class discussions led by the professor, and I'm usually eager to contribute my thoughts. At the same time, I really dislike splitting into groups of students to discuss topics or work through assignments. I don't like the forced interaction, and I often encounter an imbalance of interest and aptitude that hinders the group work. I am definitely an independent learner and worker.

17 hours ago, Gabriela said:

This is very insightful. I agree 100%: The trend toward group work is related to the intellectual decline toward relativism and the "social construction of reality". I think ("Ecclesiastically", I guess ;)) that there is a time when it's important to let people discover Truth for themselves (alone or in groups), and there are also a great many times when we ought to humbly acknowledge our own ignorance, shut up, and listen to people who do know. Society's rejection of objective Truth implies that "nobody really 'knows'" because it implies there is no such thing as "knowing". Everyone just has "opinions". In that climate, "experts" are worthless and we might as well all just sit around talking in groups, because our opinions are as good as the "experts'". This makes us feel good, because it means we're not stupider than the "experts". Yay, self-esteem.

It's the beginning of the end. :| 

Well said. I think people consider the humanities not useful partly because the study of humanities (at least in secular institutions) is no longer connected to finding objective Truth. Without a mooring in Truth, studying humanities can seem very unfocused and just a sharing of "opinions."

Posted
21 hours ago, HopefulHeart said:

Well said. I think people consider the humanities not useful partly because the study of humanities (at least in secular institutions) is no longer connected to finding objective Truth. Without a mooring in Truth, studying humanities can seem very unfocused and just a sharing of "opinions."

I agree again 100%. You really have a very clear view of the cultural landscape and its philosophical/theological assumptions, Nada! You will make a wonderful teacher. :) 

Posted
5 hours ago, Gabriela said:

I agree again 100%. You really have a very clear view of the cultural landscape and its philosophical/theological assumptions, Nada! You will make a wonderful teacher. :) 

This is kind, but all the merit goes to HopefulHeart that you just quoted ! 

I think that all of us should open a school. 

Posted
1 minute ago, NadaTeTurbe said:

This is kind, but all the merit goes to HopefulHeart that you just quoted ! 

I think that all of us should open a school. 

:oops: !

LOL!

MarysLittleFlower
Posted
On ‎30‎/‎01‎/‎2016‎ ‎6‎:‎25‎:‎57‎, NadaTeTurbe said:

For me, it's also another symptom of a world who refuse the idea of the Truth... Maybe I'm extrapolating... But in a world where there's not ONE Truh, but where everybody can build its own "truth", well, the idea of someone speaking, passing down one knowledge who is true, while other people just listen and accept it, this idea is "bad". Better let people building their own things. I don't know if I'm clear. 

Also, group work can be horrible for people with learning disability. I'm a good student, so my teacher never think about my disability (Elhers Danlos Syndrom and severe dyspraxia https://www.dyspraxiafoundation.org.uk/about-dyspraxia/ ). For me, the best way to learn is to listen, write something, and having only one sheet of papers, with simple page setting. I struggled a lot in high school when we have to "buit by ourselves" and we had one billion of papers with numerous colours, etc... Impossible to focus on it. 

I'm studying history right now, and it's perfect, because you can't really do group work in history. We just sit, listen to our teachers (who are very good orators), write, ask questions, and learn. And only then, when we know something, we can train to critical thinking. 

Mary, you're a teacher ? Can I ask in wich level ? I'd like to be a teacher later :) 

I agree with you Nada about the idea of Truth not being accepted and how that can affect the educational system. In many ways the current educational system in schools is based on the idea that "students construct their own truth" and "their own learning". That's where all this might actually be coming from, and I heard this same view one time in an article that compared schools in the past to today. Students used to memorize poetry etc and learn about culture because it was assumed we have something to learn from the past.. now it's all about constructing your own reality and being creative, and it's ignored that to be creative in a topic you first have to really know it. Anyway that's something I noticed in my teachers college education (which I didn't always agree with). I teach kindergarten to grade 6 :) I teach in 'public' Catholic schools but they're not as Catholic as they can be.. and these modern ideas are very popular in them too. I try to just tell the kids the truth and teach them the faith, and integrate simple old fashioned learning. I find with all the technology everywhere perhaps, the attention spans are much shorter than when I was in grade 1.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...