Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I don't have a gun but am ready to get one. Any suggestions? I'm thinking something smaller. Will only be used in an emergency for self defense.

Posted

Edc or home defense? Edc, Glock 19. Or smaller if you are so inclined. The 26 I think is the 9mm subcompact. Home defense, Remington 870, Mossberg 500, or a carbine length AR15.

Posted (edited)

Thanks for the recommendations. Will research a little and go with one of these. Only for home defense now because of laws where I'm at. Although would prefer to Edc and will when I can by law.

Edited by Guest
Posted

I should pick up a Glock 30S this weekend. Thanks for the suggestion.

Posted
37 minutes ago, Josh said:

Thanks for the recommendations. Will research a little and go with one of these. Only for home defense now because of laws where I'm at. Although would prefer to Edc and will when I can by law.

Most people say 12ga shotgun for home defense. Remington 870 is easily modifiable and I believe there should be several shorter barrelled variants, down to whatever is the minimum allowed wherever you are. You could put a light on it, stuff like that. I would recommend against a pistol grip with no stock, because if there is no stock you will probably smack yourself in the face. :)

I.E. set it up more like this:

maxresdefault.jpg

And less like this:

a59e1fc7e521ff129a52796d13c93ea4.jpg

 

 

There is debate on whether or not a rifle is ideal for home defense. Lot of variables there, and I am not really qualified to give you a meaningful opinion. I would be willing to argue that a large part of it comes down to how comfortable you are using it. A shotgun is a bit simpler than an AR15. You also have to consider the possibility of overpenetration with a rifle, so carefully consider your environment.

Posted (edited)

This

fusil_oa.jpgImage from Clay Smith Guns

Fusil de Chasse (Tulle replica)

You can load it with shot or ball. And if you need to you can use it at a club.

 

 

 

I'm only half kidding

 

Edited by Maximilianus
Natty Bummpo
Posted
1 hour ago, Nihil Obstat said:

There is debate on whether or not a rifle is ideal for home defense. Lot of variables there, and I am not really qualified to give you a meaningful opinion. I would be willing to argue that a large part of it comes down to how comfortable you are using it. A shotgun is a bit simpler than an AR15. You also have to consider the possibility of overpenetration with a rifle, so carefully consider your environment.

Good points.

There is the school of thought that a carbine AR is better than a handgun for home defense because of the abilty to have more control and accuracy, especially in high stress situation. Shotguns are also thought of a better option for the same reason.

I personally feel more secure using a long gun than a pistol, but it all comes down to training, practice and what you are comfortable shooting. 

 

Posted
24 minutes ago, Maximilianus said:

Good points.

There is the school of thought that a carbine AR is better than a handgun for home defense because of the abilty to have more control and accuracy, especially in high stress situation. Shotguns are also thought of a better option for the same reason.

I personally feel more secure using a long gun than a pistol, but it all comes down to training, practice and what you are comfortable shooting. 

 

Just on a personal level, I love rifles. :) In the next few years I hope to have the disposable income to build an AR.

Posted
1 hour ago, Nihil Obstat said:

Most people say 12ga shotgun for home defense. Remington 870 is easily modifiable and I believe there should be several shorter barrelled variants, down to whatever is the minimum allowed wherever you are. You could put a light on it, stuff like that. I would recommend against a pistol grip with no stock, because if there is no stock you will probably smack yourself in the face. :)

I.E. set it up more like this:

maxresdefault.jpg

And less like this:

a59e1fc7e521ff129a52796d13c93ea4.jpg

 

 

There is debate on whether or not a rifle is ideal for home defense. Lot of variables there, and I am not really qualified to give you a meaningful opinion. I would be willing to argue that a large part of it comes down to how comfortable you are using it. A shotgun is a bit simpler than an AR15. You also have to consider the possibility of overpenetration with a rifle, so carefully consider your environment.

There are a lot of things I don't know about you Nihil.

Posted
6 minutes ago, Peace said:

There are a lot of things I don't know about you Nihil.

No kidding. I bet there are at least three or four more things too!

Posted
5 hours ago, Josh said:

I don't have a gun but am ready to get one. Any suggestions? I'm thinking something smaller. Will only be used in an emergency for self defense.

You need a gun that doesn't make any noise 

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=9rDJvGSFY-c 

 

Posted

I'd get a biggun (<not a typo; say it out loud) if I weren't afraid that, when I get mad, I'd start going postal on people.

:( 

Better that I remain unarmed, really.

Posted

I'm a fan of the Ruger 10/22. Good target rifle because ammo is cheaper and you can defend your home with less chance of actually killing an intruder. 

Posted (edited)
7 hours ago, Gabriela said:

I'd get a biggun (<not a typo; say it out loud) if I weren't afraid that, when I get mad, I'd start going postal on people.

:( 

Better that I remain unarmed, really.

Yeah that's definitely something I worry about. Hopefully my mental health doesn't deteriorate to that point. As crazy as the world is/is getting I think I'm a fool not to be armed. I don't trust people anymore.

Edited by Guest
Posted
1 hour ago, Josh said:

Yeah that's definitely something I worry about. Hopefully my mental health doesn't deteriorate to that point. As crazy as the world is/is getting I think I'm a fool not to be armed. I don't trust people anymore.

Make sure there is someone you trust who can take them from you for a while if your mental health becomes compromised.

Posted

That's why I had to leave my rifle in Florida. Himself was afraid he'd use it if he had breakthrough symptoms. 

Posted

First, happy feast day of St. Gabriel Possenti, the unofficial patron saint of handun owners.

Second, Josh, what experience with firearms do you have?  If little to none, I suggest that you take a training course.  The NRA and most gun shops/ranges offer it.  It may just take up one Saturday of your time.

Another point is to go to a range and rent some handguns (or go with a friend who has the type of gun you are interested in) to find which ones you are comfortable with and can handle well.  Remember, since your purpose is for "emergency defense", you will most likely be nervous and full of adrenaline if you find yourself suddenly hurrying to defend yourself in the middle of the night against an intruder.  You will also want to consider how to store it so you can access it quickly yet have it safely locked away when you are not present.  If your "emergency defense" means when you are away from home, you will also want to get your concealed carry permit.

Also, please factor in what type of dwelling you are in, because bullets can and will travel through walls, which is partially why many recommend a shotgun for home defense.

 

Posted
1 hour ago, Norseman82 said:

First, happy feast day of St. Gabriel Possenti, the unofficial patron saint of handun owners.

Second, Josh, what experience with firearms do you have?  If little to none, I suggest that you take a training course.  The NRA and most gun shops/ranges offer it.  It may just take up one Saturday of your time.

Another point is to go to a range and rent some handguns (or go with a friend who has the type of gun you are interested in) to find which ones you are comfortable with and can handle well.  Remember, since your purpose is for "emergency defense", you will most likely be nervous and full of adrenaline if you find yourself suddenly hurrying to defend yourself in the middle of the night against an intruder.  You will also want to consider how to store it so you can access it quickly yet have it safely locked away when you are not present.  If your "emergency defense" means when you are away from home, you will also want to get your concealed carry permit.

Also, please factor in what type of dwelling you are in, because bullets can and will travel through walls, which is partially why many recommend a shotgun for home defense.

 

Do shotguns not fire through walls?

Credo in Deum
Posted
On 2/26/2016, 3:39:42, Nihil Obstat said:

Most people say 12ga shotgun for home defense. Remington 870 is easily modifiable and I believe there should be several shorter barrelled variants, down to whatever is the minimum allowed wherever you are. You could put a light on it, stuff like that. I would recommend against a pistol grip with no stock, because if there is no stock you will probably smack yourself in the face. :)

I.E. set it up more like this:

maxresdefault.jpg

And less like this:

a59e1fc7e521ff129a52796d13c93ea4.jpg

 

 

There is debate on whether or not a rifle is ideal for home defense. Lot of variables there, and I am not really qualified to give you a meaningful opinion. I would be willing to argue that a large part of it comes down to how comfortable you are using it. A shotgun is a bit simpler than an AR15. You also have to consider the possibility of overpenetration with a rifle, so carefully consider your environment.

There is always the AR Pistol. 

maxresdefault.jpg

Posted
19 hours ago, Gabriela said:

 

2 hours ago, Gabriela said:

Do shotguns not fire through walls?

Not nearly to the same extent. Rifles shoot bullets at an incredibly high velocity. Generally well over the speed of sound. Other things being equal, these will penetrate quite a lot. Shotguns fire heavy projectiles at much slower speeds. It will penetrate walls, yes, but like two or three walls, not two or three houses like some rifles will.

26 minutes ago, Credo in Deum said:

There is always the AR Pistol. 

maxresdefault.jpg

Lol. Yes, yes there is.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...