Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Philosophy Discussions for Nerds


Recommended Posts

Posted
On 3/25/2016, 6:57:56, Nihil Obstat said:

If you like complex discussions of simple ideas... Gottlob Frege's discussion of the concepts of zero and one in The Foundations Of Arithmetic.

Frege hated Catholics.

On 3/25/2016, 6:04:06, PhuturePriest said:

So I'm currently doing a course in philosophy at my community college. It's just an intro class, so it arches across the entire history of philosophy and speaks about the most influential philosophers/philosophical thoughts. I find it incredibly enjoyable, and I think philosophy is perhaps on par with theology, which is my favorite subject.

I think I enjoyed it most when we were on Greek philosophers, particularly Socrates and Plato. We just got done with Descartes (who was certainly interesting, in his own respect), and now we're onto Hobbes and Rousseau, and their theories of social contract and man in a state of nature. Oh my word. Rousseau is wonderful, but I sincerely think Hobbes was never hugged by his parents and his high school crush did something unspeakably horrible and shattered his heart. The only other possible explanation was that he was a legitimate sociopath. His belief in man's absolute fundamental depravity is only rivaled by that of Luther.

Just remember, kids: the only reason we don't murder each other is for our own safety's sake.

Anyone have any interesting philosophers or philosophies they want to discuss/nerd out about?

You should go read Frege, Wittgenstein, Russell, Alasdair McIntyre, Nietzsche and that's about it. 

Nihil Obstat
Posted
7 minutes ago, Hasan said:

Frege hated Catholics.

I know. Makes me sad. He was an interesting guy. Heidegger was something of a Nazi, and I rather enjoyed studying him as well.

Posted
Just now, Nihil Obstat said:

I know. Makes me sad. He was an interesting guy. Heidegger was something of a Nazi, and I rather enjoyed studying him as well.

Have you ever read Michael Dummett?

 

Nihil Obstat
Posted
9 minutes ago, Hasan said:

Have you ever read Michael Dummett?

 

No, but based on the bit I just read about him I think I definitely should.

Posted
On 3/25/2016, 7:01:34, PhuturePriest said:

One particularly interesting philosopher who is incredibly undervalued (and was sadly skipped in our class) is Marcus Aurelius. I once read a passage in his Meditations about how, just as it would be unnatural and against its nature for a bee to not do what is proper to a bee, it is unnatural and against man's nature to do nothing. He wrote something to the effect of "If a man lies around doing nothing, he is going against the very nature of man itself."

I like Marcus Aurelius, but also the Taoists Lao Tzu and Chang Tzu who would see it differently...to do anything is to do nothing, all there is actionless action. Man is breath...the maintenance of breath is not to burn it up in effort, but simply to maintain its balance and harmony.

I'm also partial to the anarchists, particularly the Russian Mikhail Bakunin.

Posted
1 minute ago, Era Might said:

I like Marcus Aurelius, but also the Taoists Lao Tzu and Chang Tzu who would see it differently...to do anything is to do nothing, all there is actionless action. Man is breath...the maintenance of breath is not to burn it up in effort, but simply to maintain its balance and harmony.

I'm also partial to the anarchists, particularly the Russian Mikhail Bakunin.

get out of here!!

Posted
On 3/26/2016, 7:25:05, enitharmon said:

If you like classical philosophy, I recommend you read Pierre Hadot's "Philosophy as a Way of Life" or "What is Ancient Philosophy?" (particularly the later sections of this book). He demonstrates that ancient philosophy was about spiritual exercises and a way of life, that became incorporated into early monasticism, and he shows how this notion of philosophy is still there to some degree in Descartes. His works made me rethink both the role of philosophy in classical Greece and Rome, the purpose of monastic spiritual exercises, and the relationship between theology and philosophy.


 

I listened to a lecture a while back vehemently rejecting this spiritualization of the Greeks. The lecturer argued that Greek philosophy was a life of reason, and that the philosopher's only goal was to live by reason...which is not the goal of Christianity or monadticism, because an illiterate peasant can have a spiritual life, it is not a life of reason. In the lecturer's view, to turn ancient philosophy into spirituality is to divorce the philosopher from reason, which was the Supreme law...nothing else mattered except reason, and the philosopher was to question everything.

Posted
4 hours ago, Era Might said:

I listened to a lecture a while back vehemently rejecting this spiritualization of the Greeks. The lecturer argued that Greek philosophy was a life of reason, and that the philosopher's only goal was to live by reason...which is not the goal of Christianity or monadticism, because an illiterate peasant can have a spiritual life, it is not a life of reason. In the lecturer's view, to turn ancient philosophy into spirituality is to divorce the philosopher from reason, which was the Supreme law...nothing else mattered except reason, and the philosopher was to question everything.

I don't know if that lecturer responded to Hadot specifically, but if he did, he grossly misrepresented Hadot's views. Hadot is not "spiritualising" Greek and Roman philosophy, but merely showing that for them the work of reason was not an end in itself, but rather part of a way of life. The goal was not knowledge per se, but to become a better person. Reason had a huge role to play in this. I recommend you read his work--he is intimately familiar with classical philosophy and makes a strong case.
 

Posted
5 hours ago, enitharmon said:

I don't know if that lecturer responded to Hadot specifically, but if he did, he grossly misrepresented Hadot's views. Hadot is not "spiritualising" Greek and Roman philosophy, but merely showing that for them the work of reason was not an end in itself, but rather part of a way of life. The goal was not knowledge per se, but to become a better person. Reason had a huge role to play in this. I recommend you read his work--he is intimately familiar with classical philosophy and makes a strong case.
 

Not sure if he was responding to him. I think his point was not that knowledge was the end, but that for the Greeks spirituality would be redundant, because to reason was not a handmaid to the spiritual, but rather reasoning and acting were the same thing. Reason was their way of being, whereas in Christianity reason is a handmaid to contemplation, but the believer acts in obedience, not as a process of reasoning. The Christian monks had a different agenda than the philosophers, even if they did try to spiritualize philosophy.

PhuturePriest
Posted
10 hours ago, Hasan said:

Frege hated Catholics.

You should go read Frege, Wittgenstein, Russell, Alasdair McIntyre, Nietzsche and that's about it. 

I take the advice of a man who publicly expresses love for Sophists and dislike for Socrates with very little weight, even if that man is my sultan. :|

Posted

Tried searching my YouTube history, I think this is the video I was talking about, if not still worth a watch:

 

PhuturePriest
Posted

John Locke smells of elderberries. Anyone who can't explain what they mean simply is not worth reading. Alas, this is required.

Can anyone help me to understand primary and secondary characteristics, as well as his thing on sensation, ideas, and quality? The book tries explaining it, but it's not doing it very well.

Posted

If you wanna read something nobody understands, read Wittgenstein. There's a general consensus about what he said, but nobody really knows for sure what he actually intended. As far as the general consensus goes, I like it.

I also liked all the natural language philosophers, and Peirce. Quine's translation theory was also good.

But my heart... My heart belongs to Habermas. :love:

Oh, and my favorite field of philosophy is epistemology. Hands down.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...