Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

In anticipation of the exhortation...this seems helpful


Recommended Posts

Posted

264 pages, yeah I dont have time to read that before work!

Nihil Obstat
Posted
1 minute ago, Peace said:

Nihil "I have an opinion, but I ain't telling you what it is" Obstat.

I like to play my cards close to my chest. I think it allows me to be more precise and more clear when I do express my opinions.

Posted
6 minutes ago, Nihil Obstat said:

2f471961b5038a9da6f29855bedcd79e.jpg

 If the CIA fails then the Vatican will obviously sort things out. It might cost me a bit more though :smile4:

Posted
7 hours ago, PhuturePriest said:

I think Pat Archbold's interpretation is wholly unfair and inappropriate, given that the Exhortation hadn't even been published. Here are two articles I've read written in response to actually having read it which say the Holy Father unequivocally affirms Church teaching:

http://www.wordonfire.org/resources/article/first-thoughts-on-amoris-laetitia/5134/

http://www.patheos.com/blogs/davearmstrong/2016/04/amoris-laetitia-pope-francis-1968-moment.html

But I don't think it's free from issue. There are indeed certain ambiguities which can and likely will be abused by dissenters who hear what they want. But whether these are a special Da Vinci-like code, a secret "marching order" by the Holy Father to his legions of Satanic, truth-hating liberals who foam at the mouth and spit acid when approached with writings containing Latin and hymns written before 1972, is something far past bordering the ridiculous and melodramatic.

 

I agree with this. It's uncharitable to judge the document before it's even been released.

Of course, now it is released, and there's no way I'm reading 246 pages. I can't imagine many other people will, either. That in and of itself is a problem. I think the Vatican needs to remember that people have jobs.

“Hence it can no longer simply be said that all those in any ‘irregular’ situation are living in a state of mortal sin and are deprived of sanctifying grace” (301).

If mortal sin assumes (1) grave matter, (2) full knowledge, and (3) deliberate consent, then which of these is Pope Francis saying is compromised in cases of civil re-marriage/cohabitation?

Nihil Obstat
Posted
31 minutes ago, Gabriela said:

I agree with this. It's uncharitable to judge the document before it's even been released.

 

Well let us get things straight here. Mr. Archbold was not judging anything. That would be ridiculous. He was quite clear that he was making a prediction as to how the document would turn out when it was released.

Posted
1 minute ago, Nihil Obstat said:

Well let us get things straight here. Mr. Archbold was not judging anything. That would be ridiculous. He was quite clear that he was making a prediction as to how the document would turn out when it was released.

Okay, but it was an uncharitable prediction. While I can see how one might be given to expect the worst from Pope Francis after some of the "unfortunate" things he has let slip, we have a duty as Christians—and as his flock—to give him the benefit of the doubt. And not 7 times, but 70 times 7 times. I know patience is wearing thin in some Catholic crowds, but we must remember that Pope Francis is our shepherd and we owe him charity just as much, if not more, than anybody else.

I read both the articles that PhuturePriest posted and the document looks pretty alright to me. But there is some concerning language in places, like that I highlighted. Is it possible to make a charitable, orthodox interpretation of this? That's what I'd like to know.

Nihil Obstat
Posted
6 minutes ago, Gabriela said:

Okay, but it was an uncharitable prediction. While I can see how one might be given to expect the worst from Pope Francis after some of the "unfortunate" things he has let slip, we have a duty as Christians—and as his flock—to give him the benefit of the doubt. And not 7 times, but 70 times 7 times. I know patience is wearing thin in some Catholic crowds, but we must remember that Pope Francis is our shepherd and we owe him charity just as much, if not more, than anybody else.

I read both the articles that PhuturePriest posted and the document looks pretty alright to me. But there is some concerning language in places, like that I highlighted. Is it possible to make a charitable, orthodox interpretation of this? That's what I'd like to know.

"If it turns out I am wrong, I will be the first to admit it and praise God for my foolishness."

I do not think it was uncharitable. Just concerned more than anything about protecting the Truth, doing whatever that entails. Whatever one's opinion is of Pope Francis, witnessing the Truth of Catholic teaching cannot be in any way opposed to exercising true charity towards the Holy Father.

In the interest of completeness, Mr. Archbold himself believes his initial predictions were proven true.

Posted

I could have predicted that the ultra conservatives would hate it because they don't care for much of what Pope Francis says. 

Nihil Obstat
Posted
22 minutes ago, CatherineM said:

I could have predicted that the ultra conservatives would hate it because they don't care for much of what Pope Francis says. 

I could have predicted that you would say that. Where does that leave us?

Posted
14 minutes ago, Nihil Obstat said:

I could have predicted that you would say that. Where does that leave us?

Hopefully able to have an adult conversation about the document. Also, to continue to be faithful Catholics called to obedience. I didn't like some things that Benedict did, but I never questioned his authority to do them. Francis is trying to teach us all the importance of mercy and not being judgemental. I think those are good things for us to learn. 

Nihil Obstat
Posted
2 minutes ago, CatherineM said:

Hopefully able to have an adult conversation about the document. Also, to continue to be faithful Catholics called to obedience. I didn't like some things that Benedict did, but I never questioned his authority to do them. Francis is trying to teach us all the importance of mercy and not being judgemental. I think those are good things for us to learn. 

If we want an adult conversation, perhaps we would be better off if you do not characterize "ultra-conservative" Catholics as not liking the exhortation simply because they do not like Pope Francis. It is a caricature and does not contribute to discussion.

Posted
Just now, Nihil Obstat said:

If we want an adult conversation, perhaps we would be better off if you do not characterize "ultra-conservative" Catholics as not liking the exhortation simply because they do not like Pope Francis. It is a caricature and does not contribute to discussion.

But Nihil, to what else could one ascribe a negative prediction about the exhortation before it's even published?

It's possible to protect the Truth without snark and hasty judgments. And there was judgment in that post: judgment that the exhortation would break with Church teaching. Why would the poster say that unless he already expects the worst from Pope Francis?

You know I love you, Nihil, and I have deep respect for your views because I know you're very educated in the Faith—much more than most of us—and I don't want you to feel ganged up on. But in this case I think your own position is blinding you to the unnecessary negative language in that post (the one you linked to, not your own!).

Posted

What I don't like is the idea that we may become as polarized as American politics. I didn't invent the titles of liberals and conservatives. We're not called by Christ to disunity. 

 

Posted (edited)

So will the annulment process be simplified and promoted or will it be undermined at parish/Bishop Conference level by pastoral responses influenced by this document? Hopefully this won't make things even more of a confusing mess in practice.

Edited by Benedictus
Nihil Obstat
Posted
50 minutes ago, Gabriela said:

But Nihil, to what else could one ascribe a negative prediction about the exhortation before it's even published?

It's possible to protect the Truth without snark and hasty judgments. And there was judgment in that post: judgment that the exhortation would break with Church teaching. Why would the poster say that unless he already expects the worst from Pope Francis?

You know I love you, Nihil, and I have deep respect for your views because I know you're very educated in the Faith—much more than most of us—and I don't want you to feel ganged up on. But in this case I think your own position is blinding you to the unnecessary negative language in that post (the one you linked to, not your own!).

Well first off I think it was a reasonable prediction that he made. He read the writing on the wall, so to speak. It is not like his assessment came out of nowhere. We had the documents of both synods first of all, plus Pope Francis' many, many comments on the subject, and the positions of those with whom Pope Francis consulted and wrote the exhortation itself. Knowing all these facts, he drew conclusions which I think he is relatively qualified to offer.

Secondly, and he explains why aptly, he considers the preliminary warning to have been justified and vindicated. He offers his own evidence. If we agree with him, or at least assume good faith on his part, it seems that he made a predictive warning which seemed to be justified, requiring at this point further defense of the truth.

I understand that many people do not agree with the so-called traditionalist interpretation of these facts, but if we are at the very least willing to assume good faith on the part of people like Pat Archbold, even Cardinal Burke (in his own way), etc., then it should at least be concluded that they are acting in ways which they consider to be necessary, which are reasonable based on that necessity, and which even in their disagreement, even in their deep disagreement with Pope Francis, remain charitable.

39 minutes ago, Benedictus said:

So will the annulment process be simplified and promoted or will it be undermined at parish/Bishop Conference level by pastoral responses influenced by this document? Hopefully this won't make things even more of a confusing mess in practice.

I believe that simplification has already been enacted, according to the framework that was published a couple months ago.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Raymond Arroyo, for instance (about as mainstream a Catholic as you can find) sees some cause for concern.

In reference to footnote 351, Arroyo said: "This is the smoking footnote of #AmorisLaetitia, 351. Is this the embrace of the Kasper doctrine?"

truthfinder
Posted
13 minutes ago, Nihil Obstat said:

Raymond Arroyo, for instance (about as mainstream a Catholic as you can find) sees some cause for concern.

In reference to footnote 351, Arroyo said: "This is the smoking footnote of #AmorisLaetitia, 351. Is this the embrace of the Kasper doctrine?"

That footnote is so broad you can run a truck through it.  It can be interpreted either way - although honestly if interpreted in continuity with tradition, it shouldn't be seen as an adoption of the Kasperian principle.  When I read things like this from the Holy Father, I have to wonder if he had a mean confessor/novice master who liked to yell at him.  There's seems to be a frequent feeling that priests can be mean (and some of them are) and putting barriers where there shouldn't be. 

I'm probably not going to read through this whole document, mostly because the style of writing is just incredibly difficult/annoying. 

Nihil Obstat
Posted
12 minutes ago, truthfinder said:

That footnote is so broad you can run a truck through it.  It can be interpreted either way - although honestly if interpreted in continuity with tradition, it shouldn't be seen as an adoption of the Kasperian principle.  When I read things like this from the Holy Father, I have to wonder if he had a mean confessor/novice master who liked to yell at him.  There's seems to be a frequent feeling that priests can be mean (and some of them are) and putting barriers where there shouldn't be. 

I'm probably not going to read through this whole document, mostly because the style of writing is just incredibly difficult/annoying. 

I think that is the fundamental problem, is the ambivalence of interpretation. Yes you can interpret it in a relatively benign manner. If you are inclined to do so. But those people who were already in the 'Kasper camp' will find more than enough to do exactly as they had already planned on doing, using this footnote as an equally valid defense.

And yes, I thought that the reference to the confessional as a torture chamber was rather odd. Certainly does not line up with my own experience, anyway.

Posted (edited)
1 hour ago, Nihil Obstat said:

Well first off I think it was a reasonable prediction that he made. He read the writing on the wall, so to speak. It is not like his assessment came out of nowhere. We had the documents of both synods first of all, plus Pope Francis' many, many comments on the subject, and the positions of those with whom Pope Francis consulted and wrote the exhortation itself. Knowing all these facts, he drew conclusions which I think he is relatively qualified to offer.

Secondly, and he explains why aptly, he considers the preliminary warning to have been justified and vindicated. He offers his own evidence. If we agree with him, or at least assume good faith on his part, it seems that he made a predictive warning which seemed to be justified, requiring at this point further defense of the truth.

I understand that many people do not agree with the so-called traditionalist interpretation of these facts, but if we are at the very least willing to assume good faith on the part of people like Pat Archbold, even Cardinal Burke (in his own way), etc., then it should at least be concluded that they are acting in ways which they consider to be necessary, which are reasonable based on that necessity, and which even in their disagreement, even in their deep disagreement with Pope Francis, remain charitable.

I do see where you're coming from. But I think that "reading the writing on the wall" when it comes to breaking with Church tradition always needs an extra dose of charity. It seems to me that making any negative prediction before the document is published shows a lack of faith and hope. One may have ten thousand good reasons to believe that something bad will come, but wouldn't it be better for a Christian to say, "The signs are not looking good on this one. But I'm going to pray, and I'm going to hope that God will bring us something good"?

Plus, no matter how you look at it, language like this:
This will provide all the cover necessary for the "everything is amesome" toadies to crow about how beautiful and orthodox it is. "I mean, did you read the second paragraph on page 98, that almost sounds like Pope Pius X. All is well." It will be a load of croutons, but there will be those who just eat it up and call it ice cream.
97% Jesuitical blather and pious sounding non-sequiturs.
And then 1% will be where all the action and all the danger will be. Buried deep within the text will be the cryptic marching orders.

This stuff is the reason trads have a serious PR problem. You'd think it's not possible to speak the Truth kindly and gently, that you have to be sarcastic and put somebody down while you do it, and say it in the tone of an arrogant know-it-all. Who the hell wants that kind of Truth? If you can say the Truth, but say it in a way that's loving—which we owe to the Holy Father, at the very least—then why not do that?

I know some people think this is a "stylistic choice", but my point is it's an unchristian one. Sure, it's dramatic and gets attention because it's bombastic, but ultimately, it's ugly and angry and hateful and drives people away from the Truth. One can speak the Truth just as directly without all the sarcasm and put-downs. In fact, in my opinion, it would be more true that way!

I know you're not likely to stop reading such websites just because I say ^all this^, but really Nihil, ask yourself: Does reading this stuff make you more angry? Does it make you more hateful? Does it make you bitter about the state of the Church? Because I can't see how it wouldn't, and I don't think that's good for you or anyone. It would be better to find commentary that speaks the Truth in a way that isn't so spiteful.

Edited by Gabriela

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...