Socrates Posted June 3, 2016 Posted June 3, 2016 This is all very sad. First of all, people are conceived in plenty of less than ideal circumstances, and the child should not be blamed. And I have no doubt that Lee does in fact love her son. What's in the past can't be undone, and I'm not sure much can be done now, other than pray that things work out best for everyone and that the kid finds a good father-figure in his life. However, that does not make the actions involved with the boy's conception and the "family" he's born with right and good, and I don't think we all need to just sit there and pretend this is all fine and good and wonderful. Especially not on a website devoted to preaching Catholic truth. The OP posted on a Catholic board something that she probably knows is blatantly at odds with the Church's moral teaching, so she should be able to handle it if Catholics on said board challenge her with such teaching. She's an adult. God willed that children should be conceived by an act of love between a man and a woman committed to one another. Children should not be consumer products impersonally produced to be sold and bought. And having a child is not a right owed to whoever wants one, but a gift of God. The reality is that every child has a father and a mother. At some point the kid's going to find out that the stork didn't actually bring him to his "two mommies," but he will learn that Daddy was some guy who never even met, much less loved, his mother, masturbating into a cup at some clinic somewhere, probably while looking at porn, in order to make some extra bucks. And his conception was the result of a business transaction his mother made with people she probably never knew personally. It may be harsh and impolite to say that, and I'm sure this won't make me more popular on here, but one can only imagine how harsh it will be for the boy. Just some things to think about. And, no, one cannot be a "good Catholic" while willfully disregarding the Church's moral teachings. Sorry, but that's honesty.
franciscanheart Posted June 3, 2016 Posted June 3, 2016 44 minutes ago, Socrates said: This is all very sad. First of all, people are conceived in plenty of less than ideal circumstances, and the child should not be blamed. And I have no doubt that Lee does in fact love her son. What's in the past can't be undone, and I'm not sure much can be done now, other than pray that things work out best for everyone and that the kid finds a good father-figure in his life. However, that does not make the actions involved with the boy's conception and the "family" he's born with right and good, and I don't think we all need to just sit there and pretend this is all fine and good and wonderful. Especially not on a website devoted to preaching Catholic truth. The OP posted on a Catholic board something that she probably knows is blatantly at odds with the Church's moral teaching, so she should be able to handle it if Catholics on said board challenge her with such teaching. She's an adult. God willed that children should be conceived by an act of love between a man and a woman committed to one another. Children should not be consumer products impersonally produced to be sold and bought. And having a child is not a right owed to whoever wants one, but a gift of God. The reality is that every child has a father and a mother. At some point the kid's going to find out that the stork didn't actually bring him to his "two mommies," but he will learn that Daddy was some guy who never even met, much less loved, his mother, masturbating into a cup at some clinic somewhere, probably while looking at porn, in order to make some extra bucks. And his conception was the result of a business transaction his mother made with people she probably never knew personally. It may be harsh and impolite to say that, and I'm sure this won't make me more popular on here, but one can only imagine how harsh it will be for the boy. Just some things to think about. And, no, one cannot be a "good Catholic" while willfully disregarding the Church's moral teachings. Sorry, but that's honesty. Perhaps not a good Catholic, but not a person who doesn't love her son. That's what I took issue with. For the record, I spoke privately with @beatitude to address the confusion from our exchange, and to apologize for any harm done. At the end of the day, we may disagree with the approach of others here, but I do understand that the OP opened herself up to some pretty forthright criticism by sharing such intimate details of her life. I also realize that making the decision once and then sharing about it is less likely to garner the same outcry as sharing excitement over the prospect of doing it again. Responding to conscience, others here are likely to take issue and to denounce the practice before it happens again.
dUSt Posted June 3, 2016 Posted June 3, 2016 "Of all the rocks upon which we build our lives, we are reminded today that family is the most important. And we are called to recognize and honor how critical every father is to that foundation. They are teachers and coaches. They are mentors and role models. They are examples of success and the men who constantly push us toward it. But if we are honest with ourselves, we’ll admit that what too many fathers also are is missing — missing from too many lives and too many homes... And the foundations of our families are weaker because of it." - Barack Obama
Anomaly Posted June 3, 2016 Posted June 3, 2016 Some sadness, but certainly not all. There is no less valuable humanity whether you have three dads, a prostitute mother, or rapist priest father. People have abortions to avoid the shame, criticisms, and opinion the child can't avoid misery in a less than ideal family. The issue I have is the thought that sharing DNA is going to make you a better parent, or more legitimate family, or that not knowing your DNA donors is some horrific violation that can't ever be overcome. Those are some significant reasons I believe this sanctimonious society unintentionally causes so many abortions and leaves children in orphanages, foster homes, or with unfit parents. They're very similar arguments I remember from the 60's and 70's decrying interracial marriages.
dUSt Posted June 3, 2016 Posted June 3, 2016 My opinion on all of this is super complicated and confusing. I may have to write a book about it.
CatherineM Posted June 3, 2016 Posted June 3, 2016 Just to clarify, I never said that She didn't love her son with all her heart. I said it was a shame she didn't love him enough to give him a father. The reality is that being broken humans, we aren't capable of giving our kids everything they need. Most parents do the best they can.
Era Might Posted June 3, 2016 Posted June 3, 2016 (edited) Family and parenthood are overrated. Many people would have turned out much better without their father in the home. I say "their father" and not "a father" because family is not an abstraction or an ideal, it's a reflection of our societies. Parents are condemned to give up the hard way of honesty to be what they have to be in society, because that's what family is for the most part, a socialization of children into society. The less a person has in common with their society, the harder it will be to have a family. No doubt, this is unavoidable in our civilizing evolution, but we raise family to a divine level because we are selfish and lazy, and want our children to follow in our footsteps as members of this society. Anyway, family has its good and its bad aspects, but ultimately parents and their kids have to learn that they're both just clueless travellers in life. Here's some advice from Kurt Vonnegut, who created his own broken family but tried to maintain a friendship with his kids, not as wise old turtle to young turtles, but as one human being talking to another. Our kids are people...they are born into a society just as their parents were. Such is life. If we take this artificial ideal too seriously we can rail against anything....fathers working outside the home instead of in the field, mothers working at all, etc. We have such families because we have such a society. If we had to restrict family to an ideal, nobody would have kids...imagine slaves bringing human beings into this world, or people in war daring to procreate. Shame on them for not waiting till the ideal was realized. Quote We are all experiencing more or less the same lifetime now. What is it the slightly older people want from the slightly younger people? They want credit for having survived so long, and often imaginatively, under difficult conditions. Slightly younger people are intolerably stingy about giving them credit for that. What is it the slightly younger people want from the slightly older people? More than anything, I think, they want acknowledgement, and without further ado, that they are without question women and men now. Slightly older people are intolerably stingy about making any such acknowledgement. ... We are so lonely because we don’t have enough friends and relatives. Human beings are supposed to live in stable, like-minded, extended families of fifty people or more. Your class spokesperson mourned the collapse of the institution of marriage in this country. Marriage is collapsing because our families are too small. A man cannot be a whole society to a woman, and a woman cannot be a whole society to a man. We try, but it is scarcely surprising that so many of us go to pieces. Edited June 3, 2016 by Era Might
Era Might Posted June 3, 2016 Posted June 3, 2016 (edited) 3 hours ago, Anomaly said: Some sadness, but certainly not all. There is no less valuable humanity whether you have three dads, a prostitute mother, or rapist priest father. There's a beautiful story in the John Steinbeck novel East of Eden. One of the characters is the son of Chinese immigrants to California. His mother and father came as indentured servants, but she came disguised as a man, because they didn't allow women to join their husbands, it made the men less subservient. Once the men laborers found out she was really a woman, they all savagely raped her...they were men starved of family and worked like slaves. But once the baby was born, they all raised him tenderly as their own. We underestimate the social and economic factors that creates our families. Conservatives like to point to some unique collapse of the black family, as if it were some monstrosity unique to blacks, and not a consequence of the economic life of this country (e.g., the collapse of industrial jobs in the 70s that deprived black men of the chance to be middle class, and helped create a social context where their only realistic option was gangs and drugs). Edited June 3, 2016 by Era Might
Norseman82 Posted June 4, 2016 Posted June 4, 2016 50 minutes ago, Era Might said: Family and parenthood are overrated. Many people would have turned out much better without their father in the home. I say "their father" and not "a father" because family is not an abstraction or an ideal, it's a reflection of our societies. Parents are condemned to give up the hard way of honesty to be what they have to be in society, because that's what family is for the most part, a socialization of children into society. The less a person has in common with their society, the harder it will be to have a family. No doubt, this is unavoidable in our civilizing evolution, but we raise family to a divine level because we are selfish and lazy, and want our children to follow in our footsteps as members of this society. Anyway, family has its good and its bad aspects, but ultimately parents and their kids have to learn that they're both just clueless travellers in life. Here's some advice from Kurt Vonnegut, who created his own broken family but tried to maintain a friendship with his kids, not as wise old turtle to young turtles, but as one human being talking to another. Our kids are people...they are born into a society just as their parents were. Such is life. If we take this artificial ideal too seriously we can rail against anything....fathers working outside the home instead of in the field, mothers working at all, etc. We have such families because we have such a society. If we had to restrict family to an ideal, nobody would have kids...imagine slaves bringing human beings into this world, or people in war daring to procreate. Shame on them for not waiting till the ideal was realized.
Socrates Posted June 4, 2016 Posted June 4, 2016 1 hour ago, Norseman82 said: Pretty much my reaction to most of his posts these days. . .
Era Might Posted June 4, 2016 Posted June 4, 2016 8 minutes ago, Socrates said: Pretty much my reaction to most of his posts these days. . . You must have gotten high marks in college, the sure mark of a mediocre mind. I'm drunk, sorry, lemme get out of here.
Socrates Posted June 4, 2016 Posted June 4, 2016 12 minutes ago, Era Might said: You must have gotten high marks in college, the sure mark of a mediocre mind. I'm drunk, sorry, lemme get out of here. Go easy on the sauce, man.
Amor vincit omnia Posted June 4, 2016 Author Posted June 4, 2016 I just want to say that I have read each and every post and I am grateful for the insight and thoughts in each and everyone one of them! I decided to post this for the simple reason that I wanted to be truthful to myself and to those who I have met here from the years that I have spent on the Phorum. As much as everyone wants to label me "broken" for not having a father in my life I am going to say that I had an amazing mother who did everything when the father I had wanted no part of raising his daughters. I had some really great family around to nurture and support us along the way and let me tell ya my mama raised some amesome girls! Me not growing up without a father has absolutely nothing to do with who I ended up falling in love with and it absolutely had nothing to do with bringing my son into the world. My son has an amazing support system in his life and since some have asked yes that include some really great male role models!! At the end of it all I am not perfect and I have never claimed to be but the only certain thing I know is Gods love for me, my child and my family. -Lee Avo❣
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now