Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

A Facebook "friend" I work with posted this. I see a lot of people posting similar things. What do you find wrong with this? If you agree with it do you find people who don't agree with it hateful? I don't consider myself an ally. Should I be? As a Catholic is it even possible to be an ally for equal rights for gays? A Catholic can never support "gay marriage" correct?

FB_IMG_1466344648650.jpg

Edited by Guest
Posted

People don't understand what equal rights really means. The way a lot of people use it is asinine. Does equal rights mean I'm entitled to enter the Boston Marathon?  I'm a cripple who uses a walker and I'm self identifying as a runner therefore I'm entitled to be allowed to enter. 

Anyone who has more than one kid understands that you treat your kids fairly, but you can't treat them all equally because each kid is different and has different needs. 

Posted
31 minutes ago, Josh said:

Another post 

FB_IMG_1466351714027.jpg

This is the problem with American culture: Disagree, and you're banished from my circle of friends.

We need to grow the fugg up.

Posted (edited)
Just now, Gabriela said:

This is the problem with American culture: Disagree, and you're banished from my circle of friends.

We need to grow the fugg up.

I agree. I think the poster is saying that his religious Facebook "friends" will delete him and he's somehow being brave. I didn't delete him. I don't think that's the case (him going against everyone and risking "friendships") since it seems now a days almost everyone agrees with "gay marriage" and supports it. Even Catholics and Christians. I just saw a picture of a Catholic Church the other day covered by the pride rainbow colors.

 

FB_IMG_1466354329108.jpg

This was posted by a really good friend that I haven't seen in about 5 years since I moved states. I replied to it and he didn't write back.

Edited by Guest
Posted
1 minute ago, Josh said:

I agree. I think the poster is saying that the religious friends will delete him and he's somehow being brave. I didn't delete him. I don't think that's the case since it seems now a days almost everyone agrees with "gay marriage". Even Catholics and Christians. I just saw a picture of a Catholic Church the other day covered by the pride rainbow colors.

Cuz Catholics are afraid to disagree too. We just want everybody to like us. :| 

Posted
41 minutes ago, Josh said:

Even Catholics and Christians. I just saw a picture of a Catholic Church the other day covered by the pride rainbow colors.

Here is today's bulletin from a parish not too far from downtown Boystown in Chicago:

https://content.parishesonline.com/bulletins/01/0544/20160619B.pdf

On page 9, the pastor wishes the LGBTQ community "Happy Pride".

Posted

Happy Pride. So pretty much saying homosexual acts are no longer a sin let alone one that cries out to God for vengeance and justice.

Spem in alium
Posted

I have friends who are gay. I have a cousin who is gay, who has been with one partner for around eight years and wants to be married. I love them, and I want the best for them. But what is the best for them? I'm not convinced that it's marriage.

Re. expressions of gay pride, etc., I do understand why people are coming out with this. When you are victimised and discriminated against unfairly, as many members of the LGBTQ community have been and continue to be, it seems natural that you want to speak out. I completely understand the displays of solidarity and camaraderie, and I'm not wholeheartedly against them. But at the same time, I'm not about to depart from my opinions or my values. Gabriela is right, it seems that Catholics have typically kept silent on issues like this because they want to be liked or don't want to "rock the boat". This is very, very unfortunate, and it needs to change.

The purpose of life isn't to be liked or held in high regard. It is - at least in my view - recognising God's love for us and revealing God's love to others. Sometimes that does mean disagreeing, or expressing an opinion which is contradictory or very unpopular, but it always means showing respect and value for the other and for the dignity they possess by virtue of the fact that God dwells in them, even if they don't recognise it.

 

Posted (edited)

I genuinely think that a majority of Catholics and Christians truly support "gay marriage". As well as a ton of Priests and Bishops. Maybe I'm wrong on this but it seems to be the case. I know very kind loving Catholics/Christians who believe gay people should be able to marry. With this tragic Orlando massacre I think even more are going to be swayed over to Satan's side. I trust the Church will never give in on this and I'm thankful to hear Pope Francis say things like this 

FB_IMG_1435469365205.jpg

Edited by Guest
Posted
13 hours ago, Gabriela said:

Cuz Catholics are afraid to disagree too. We just want everybody to like us. :| 

I think there is some truth in the above. I think that we probably have a sense of very deep shame and rightly so - and are trying to move on and in the trying might make every effort possible to get others to "like us".  Not perhaps so much because one wants to be liked - but rather to witness to the fact that Catholics can be quite likeable people.  The very real mistake can be to cave in and adhere to popular secular opinions in order to attempt to show the face of Catholicism as likeable.  We are not called to be likeable people, we are called to be loving people.........and that begs the question "What is the difference between liking and loving?" and another subject.

"Well, I try my best
To be just like I am
But everybody wants you
To be just like them"  (Bob Dylan "Maggie's Farm")

Posted

Why was the picture removed on the post where I said "Sorry I'm not an ally." How was that inappropriate? 

polskieserce
Posted (edited)

There are a lot of things wrong with that banner.  The first problem is that the homosexual movement is not campaigning for equal rights.  It is campaigning for rights which previously did not exist.  Prior to the US Supreme Court’s decision to redefine marriage, homosexuals had the right to get married to people of the opposite sex.  That’s the first major flaw.

As a true Catholic, you should not get yourself entangled in the homosexual movement and you are correct in assuming that you can’t be a Catholic and support these kinds of things simultaneously.  People who try to have it both ways are Catholic in Name Only.  If some people view you as “hateful” for sticking to God’s definition of marriage, then you don’t need them in your life.

The second problem is that Catholics are trying too hard to please people (and not only on the issue of homosexuality).  If a Catholic stands up and says that he/she is against abortion under all circumstances or that he/she refuses to marry someone who is not a virgin, then that Catholic will also get plenty of dirty looks and criticism.  Too many Catholics don’t want to be “bigoted”.  It's time that Catholics took a stand against this judgment free nonsense.

Edited by polskieserce
Line Spacing, Added another thought
Posted (edited)
Just now, Josh said:

Why was the picture removed on the post where I said "Sorry I'm not an ally." How was that inappropriate? 

Here was the picture. Maybe it was a glitch and got removed. I think the picture needs to be seen. Look at the little kids in in the background. This is what Catholics and Christians are an ally for? Satan rejoices when you are an ally for this satanic cause.

FB_IMG_1466371326837.jpg

6 hours ago, BarbaraTherese said:

I think there is some truth in the above. I think that we probably have a sense of very deep shame and rightly so - and are trying to move on and in the trying might make every effort possible to get others to "like us".  Not perhaps so much because one wants to be liked - but rather to witness to the fact that Catholics can be quite likeable people.  The very real mistake can be to cave in and adhere to popular secular opinions in order to attempt to show the face of Catholicism as likeable.  We are not called to be likeable people, we are called to be loving people.........and that begs the question "What is the difference between liking and loving?" and another subject.

"Well, I try my best
To be just like I am
But everybody wants you
To be just like them"  (Bob Dylan "Maggie's Farm")

 

FB_IMG_1466380181780.jpg

Edited by Guest
NadaTeTurbe
Posted

I reported this image because it's innapropriate in a forum where there is minor (and frankly, it's inappropriate for adult too). I understand your anger, but we need to keep this place safe. 

IgnatiusofLoyola
Posted (edited)
2 hours ago, polskieserce said:

 

The second problem is that Catholics are trying too hard to please people (and not only on the issue of homosexuality).  If a Catholic stands up and says that he/she is against abortion under all circumstances or that he/she refuses to marry someone who is not a virgin, then that Catholic will also get plenty of dirty looks and criticism.  Too many Catholics don’t want to be “bigoted”.  It's time that Catholics took a stand against this judgment free nonsense.

You've opened up a couple of "Pandora's Boxes" here. I'll  address your second comment first. To refrain from judging others is not nonsense. Here are the Pope's remarks from this morning's Mass (Monday the 20th) about leaving judgement to God. http://www.news.va/en/news/pope-francis-look-in-the-mirror-before-judging-oth  As I understand it, Catholics are called upon to support the Pope. Certainly here on Phatmass, posters who call themselves Catholic are called upon to be respectful of the Pope in their remarks. Although my opinions likely mean nothing to you since I am not Catholic, I thought the Pope's remarks were "spot on." I felt as if the Pope had been reading Phatmass the past few days and was sending us a personal message.

Second, where did you get this idea that a good Catholic should refuse to marry someone who is not a virgin? In the same sentence, you gave as an example that a good Catholic should be against abortion in all circumstances, This is an accepted Catholic teaching as far as I know--please correct me if I'm wrong. But, I've never heard of the idea that a Catholic should refuse to marry someone who is not a virgin. 

Yes, the Catholic Church calls upon unmarried couples to refrain from sex until marriage. But, while this means that both members of a Catholic couple who follow this teaching are likely to be virgins at marriage, I don't know of anywhere where it is taught that a Catholic should discriminate against a partner who is not a virgin. Perhaps the partner is a widow or widower. Perhaps the partner is a convert to Catholicism, who has remained celibate after his/her conversion, but was not celibate before. Why should the partner's actions before conversion be held against them (assuming they have gone to confession, etc.)? Heck, Jesus forgave St. Paul for killing Christians before St. Paul's conversion. Are we asked to be less forgiving? I won't even get into circumstances where a person was sexually abused as a child so may no longer be a virgin. We had a "virgin" thread not that long ago about the definition of "virgin" and it's a very complex subject. One subject that came up is that there are MANY non-sexual circumstances under which a woman might no longer have a hymen, but she has never engaged in sexual intercourse. Personally, I would say that that woman is still a virgin, but others might disagree.

Edited by IgnatiusofLoyola
polskieserce
Posted
1 hour ago, IgnatiusofLoyola said:

You've opened up a couple of "Pandora's Boxes" here. I'll  address your second comment first. To refrain from judging others is not nonsense. Here are the Pope's remarks from this morning's Mass (Monday the 20th) about leaving judgement to God. http://www.news.va/en/news/pope-francis-look-in-the-mirror-before-judging-oth  As I understand it, Catholics are called upon to support the Pope. Certainly here on Phatmass, posters who call themselves Catholic are called upon to be respectful of the Pope in their remarks. Although my opinions likely mean nothing to you since I am not Catholic, I thought the Pope's remarks were "spot on." I felt as if the Pope had been reading Phatmass the past few days and was sending us a personal message.

Second, where did you get this idea that a good Catholic should refuse to marry someone who is not a virgin? In the same sentence, you gave as an example that a good Catholic should be against abortion in all circumstances, This is an accepted Catholic teaching as far as I know--please correct me if I'm wrong. But, I've never heard of the idea that a Catholic should refuse to marry someone who is not a virgin. 

Yes, the Catholic Church calls upon unmarried couples to refrain from sex until marriage. But, while this means that both members of a Catholic couple who follow this teaching are likely to be virgins at marriage, I don't know of anywhere where it is taught that a Catholic should discriminate against a partner who is not a virgin. Perhaps the partner is a widow or widower. Perhaps the partner is a convert to Catholicism, who has remained celibate after his/her conversion, but was not celibate before. Why should the partner's actions before conversion be held against them (assuming they have gone to confession, etc.)? Heck, Jesus forgave St. Paul for killing Christians before St. Paul's conversion. Are we asked to be less forgiving? I won't even get into circumstances where a person was sexually abused as a child so may no longer be a virgin. We had a "virgin" thread not that long ago about the definition of "virgin" and it's a very complex subject. One subject that came up is that there are MANY non-sexual circumstances under which a woman might no longer have a hymen, but she has never engaged in sexual intercourse. Personally, I would say that that woman is still a virgin, but others might disagree.

God was the one who determined that living a homosexual lifestyle is evil.  When Catholics voice disapproval for the homosexual movement and distance themselves from it, they are simply repeating God's stance.  The homosexual movement, as well as secular society in general, would like you to believe that simply making a distinction between right and wrong is going against God's will.

I never said a Catholic is obligated to dump/reject someone who isn't a virgin.  I simply said that if a Catholic does that, then he/she will get plenty of negative responses for it.  The only reason I made that comparison to opposing abortion under every circumstance is that both of those issues will cause sparks to fly.  When I first joined this forum 3 years ago, I started a thread on this exact topic because it meant a lot to me.  Finding other Catholic Virgins  I got a lot of criticism over having those kinds of views but 3 years later I feel the same way.  The issues you bring up have already been covered in that thread.  Let's not hijack OPs thread and just leave it there.

IgnatiusofLoyola
Posted
3 hours ago, Josh said:

Here was the picture. Maybe it was a glitch and got removed. I think the picture needs to be seen. Look at the little kids in in the background. This is what Catholics and Christians are an ally for? Satan rejoices when you are an ally for this satanic cause.

Josh--I agree with Nada De Turbe that the picture you posted is not appropriate for a Web site visited by minors, and even for adults. To me, at least, it doesn't fit with the guidelines of Phatmass--but that is the decision of dUSt and the Mediators of Meh. Also, the picture was not necessary.

You could simply have described the actions of the people in the picture in scientific terms--that is, "sadomasochism" or "dominance/submission." Similar terms to what would be used in a textbook. I'm still not sure that that discussion belongs here in Open Mic or in the Adult Forum. Unfortunately, I've read posts from minors saying that they check the Adult forum just to see what is going on, so putting a post in the Adult forum may not prevent a minor from reading it. If readers don't understand the "scientific" terms, they can look up their meaning--although I'd be VERY wary of doing that on the Internet. I strongly suspect that the search results would not be "scientific" explanations, but could easily be porno sites.This may be a situation where an "old-fashioned" paper dictionary would serve the purpose better.

I understand the point you were making, but this was probably not the best example to use, since these practices are not limited to homosexuals, but also are practiced by heterosexuals.

I'm not sure that a practicing Catholic can be an "ally" for many of the causes of the homosexual community. However, this does not mean that Catholics should treat homosexuals as less than human, or that Catholic homosexuals are not deserving of sympathy, because to be both a practicing Catholic and a homosexual means practicing celibacy, which is a difficult path. Also, even if a practicing Catholic feels that homosexuality is a sin, that doesn't mean that homosexuals should be gunned down as they were in Orlando, or systematically executed, as they are by ISIS. 

37 minutes ago, polskieserce said:

God was the one who determined that living a homosexual lifestyle is evil.  When Catholics voice disapproval for the homosexual movement and distance themselves from it, they are simply repeating God's stance.  The homosexual movement, as well as secular society in general, would like you to believe that simply making a distinction between right and wrong is going against God's will.

I never said a Catholic is obligated to dump/reject someone who isn't a virgin.  I simply said that if a Catholic does that, then he/she will get plenty of negative responses for it.  The only reason I made that comparison to opposing abortion under every circumstance is that both of those issues will cause sparks to fly.  When I first joined this forum 3 years ago, I started a thread on this exact topic because it meant a lot to me.  Finding other Catholic Virgins  I got a lot of criticism over having those kinds of views but 3 years later I feel the same way.  The issues you bring up have already been covered in that thread.  Let's not hijack OPs thread and just leave it there.

If you personally want to reject non-virgins as marriage partners, that's your decision. Just don't pretend that that is official Church teaching.

Similarly, it is one thing to repeat the Church teaching that living a homosexual lifestyle is a sin, but the Pope has been teaching a lot recently about how Catholics are to find the difficult balance between not supporting sin and yet following Jesus' example of mercy toward sinners.

 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...