Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Phamilton?  

9 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

LittleWaySoul
Posted (edited)

Phamilton pls

image.jpeg

Edited by LittleWaySoul
PhuturePriest
Posted

Meh. I'm not a fan of rap and hip hop, so it's not really my thing.

I am, however, a big fan of Alexander Hamilton and the Federalist Party.

Posted
On 6/23/2016 at 1:32 AM, PhuturePriest said:

Meh. I'm not a fan of rap and hip hop, so it's not really my thing.

I am, however, a big fan of Alexander Hamilton and the Federalist Party.

 So… doesn't that mean that you should see it even though the method of delivery isn't your thing?

 I haven't seen it… but I would definitely like to. I didn't see an option for that!

LittleWaySoul
Posted
On 23 giugno 2016 at 1:32 AM, PhuturePriest said:

Meh. I'm not a fan of rap and hip hop, so it's not really my thing.

I am, however, a big fan of Alexander Hamilton and the Federalist Party.

 

7 hours ago, Seven77 said:

 So… doesn't that mean that you should see it even though the method of delivery isn't your thing?

 I haven't seen it… but I would definitely like to. I didn't see an option for that!

Well, unfortunately right now tickets are near impossible to come by unless you're exorbitantly wealthy, so I really didn't expect anyone to have seen it yet, haha. Once it goes on tour it'll be a LOT easier to see. It's still only on Broadway though. (It won 11 Tonys, yo!)

And FP, I wasn't a huge hip hop person either, but Hamilton transcends individual dislikes of genre, be they hip hop or Broadway. I've yet to meet someone who hasn't liked it (my mom and more traditional Catholics included!). It's even easier to like if you already like history and musicals bc thousands of people have liked none of the three (hip hop, history, musicals) and still love Hamilton. I'd recommend opening the Wikipedia synopsis and reading along as you listen to the soundtrack (it's on Spotify).

I do warn you, however, that there's some swearing on some tracks, so be cautious about how you listen the first time around. Headphones are a good idea. 

This thread needs more Hamilpics. 

image.jpeg

LittleWaySoul
Posted (edited)

A personal fave

 

image.jpeg

Edited by LittleWaySoul
LittleWaySoul
Posted

I'm never letting go of this thread. I will go down with this ship. 

image.jpeg

Posted

I know not this Hamilton.  

Posted

Me neither. What in the world is this?

LittleWaySoul
Posted
12 hours ago, PhuturePriest said:

Hahaha throwing shade, FP?

3 hours ago, Papist said:

tumblr_m1vknqkfDX1qeyt27o1_500.gif

I thought the same until I read the story & heard the music. 

It was nominated for a record 16 Tony Awards and won 11. It's at the top of the rap, soundtrack, AND overall charts. It's become an international phenomenon for its originality, ingenuity, and wisespread acclaim. It feels so massively popular that I'm always a bit shocked when I meet people who haven't heard of it. But now ya know. :)

Posted

Reading the Wikipedia page on it, it sounded like it got so much critical acclaim because it used a bunch of non-white actors and musical genres. Which I don't consider creative these days. I consider it pretty brainwashed.

But I'll withhold judgment on the actual quality of the show until I've seen it. My point is: Just because it wins awards doesn't mean it's any good. It might just be a bandwagon phenomenon.

Posted

It be a musical. That is enough for me to judge. 

LittleWaySoul
Posted (edited)
50 minutes ago, Gabriela said:

Reading the Wikipedia page on it, it sounded like it got so much critical acclaim because it used a bunch of non-white actors and musical genres. Which I don't consider creative these days. I consider it pretty brainwashed.

But I'll withhold judgment on the actual quality of the show until I've seen it. My point is: Just because it wins awards doesn't mean it's any good. It might just be a bandwagon phenomenon.

There's critical acclaim for the non-traditional casting, for sure. But the biggest reason it's so widely popular and acclaimed is because it's a *really* well-crafted work, drawing on the traditions of musical theater and hip hop alike (when I first listened to it, I was struck by how much it reminded me of Les Miserables, both in scope and in score [repeating motifs and melding of key tunes; I love it!]-- you can tell that the writer knows his musical theater!!). It doesn't necessarily take skill to cast a show. It *does* take skill to combine such improbable source material with such unlikely music genres and have the result be an emotionally compelling and well-written piece (not to mention widely appealing to fans of any kind of music-- it's like Wicked in that way). To put history to rap music can all too easily become schoolhouse rock-ish or seem forced, but to make it into a groundbreaking and compelling work of art is a feat indeed.

For it to be a bandwagon phenomenon would require it to be something that's not *actually* that good, but that people say that they like to look "enlightened" or "with it." My first-hand experience of this music tells me this is not the case for Hamilton, despite my own initial skepticism. I have experience with music myself and I'm a huge musical theater buff; I'm telling you, this isn't just a pretentious fad on a global scale.

(Oh and by the way, you don't need to wait to see it; you can listen to the music on Spotify) :like2:

37 minutes ago, Papist said:

It be a musical. That is enough for me to judge. 

Ah. It's your prerogative to dislike musicals, but I really love them! :) 

Edited by LittleWaySoul
Posted
20 minutes ago, LittleWaySoul said:

Ah. It's your prerogative to dislike musicals, but I really love them! :) 

:pirate2:

Posted (edited)
51 minutes ago, LittleWaySoul said:

this isn't just a pretentious fad on a global scale.

There's also critical acclaim for the outrageous pricing of the tickets, which seems appallingly hypocritical when you're casting a bunch of minorities, presumably to make a statement about social justice and equality and whatnot, yet the large majority of non-whites could never afford tickets to see it.

To me, that screams "liberal white-people feel-good bull$hite".

Edited by Gabriela
Posted

I LOVE HAMILTON.

My best friend, who can't stand rap/hip-hop, loves Hamilton. 

I don't know anyone IRL who doesn't like Hamilton. 

LittleWaySoul
Posted
On 7/2/2016 at 2:17 PM, Gabriela said:

There's also critical acclaim for the outrageous pricing of the tickets, which seems appallingly hypocritical when you're casting a bunch of minorities, presumably to make a statement about social justice and equality and whatnot, yet the large majority of non-whites could never afford tickets to see it.

To me, that screams "liberal white-people feel-good bull$hite".

I'm not trying to force you to like it or anything, of course. I'd just like to respond to your impression of it as hypocritical. I don't think it is (or its creators are). First, one doesn't need to actually see the show to resonate with its story or music. A vast majority of fans have probably only listened to the album (and, if they're like me, watched every legal clip of the show released thus far). The value of the music isn't something that necessitates the stage performance to be appreciated. It's also loved by people across the political spectrum. Further, have you ever heard about ticket bots? I hadn't before Hamilton, actually. A huge reason the tickets are so expensive is because second-hand ticket sellers have software ("bots") they use to buy tickets instantly when they come on sale and re-sell them at a much higher price (article written by Hamilton creator Lin Manuel Miranda). The creators of Hamilton have actually been instrumental in advocating for anti-ticket bot legislation. Not only that, but through initiatives like Ham4Ham (outdoor performances prior to the show), the lottery (a lottery you can enter to win front row seat tickets to the show for a mere "Hamilton," or $10 [this isn't new to Hamilton, but they're continuing it to help people get a chance at seeing the show]), and most importantly, EduHam, an initiative where New York City public school students are given the opportunity not only to see the show for $10, but also to perform their own original historical songs/poems/and covers for the cast! Yes, the regular ticket price is outrageous, but the creators, cast, and crew of the show are making huge strides to make Hamilton (and Broadway as a whole) more accessible to those who cannot afford such high prices. 

It's also heading to other places besides NYC soon, and then on tour, and thus will become more and more accessible to those who wish to go. :) I can't wait until I can see it!

On 7/2/2016 at 4:13 PM, Amppax said:

I LOVE HAMILTON.

My best friend, who can't stand rap/hip-hop, loves Hamilton. 

I don't know anyone IRL who doesn't like Hamilton. 

Same, actually. I don't personally know anyone who has listened to it and doesn't love it. @Gabriela, if you'd like to be the first, I'd be interested in hearing a critical opinion of it. There are flaws in the show, sure, but none that I see as coming close to overpowering how good it is overall.

Token Ham image of the post:

ham.jpg

Posted
42 minutes ago, LittleWaySoul said:

I'm not trying to force you to like it or anything, of course. I'd just like to respond to your impression of it as hypocritical. I don't think it is (or its creators are). First, one doesn't need to actually see the show to resonate with its story or music. A vast majority of fans have probably only listened to the album (and, if they're like me, watched every legal clip of the show released thus far). The value of the music isn't something that necessitates the stage performance to be appreciated. It's also loved by people across the political spectrum. Further, have you ever heard about ticket bots? I hadn't before Hamilton, actually. A huge reason the tickets are so expensive is because second-hand ticket sellers have software ("bots") they use to buy tickets instantly when they come on sale and re-sell them at a much higher price (article written by Hamilton creator Lin Manuel Miranda). The creators of Hamilton have actually been instrumental in advocating for anti-ticket bot legislation. Not only that, but through initiatives like Ham4Ham (outdoor performances prior to the show), the lottery (a lottery you can enter to win front row seat tickets to the show for a mere "Hamilton," or $10 [this isn't new to Hamilton, but they're continuing it to help people get a chance at seeing the show]), and most importantly, EduHam, an initiative where New York City public school students are given the opportunity not only to see the show for $10, but also to perform their own original historical songs/poems/and covers for the cast! Yes, the regular ticket price is outrageous, but the creators, cast, and crew of the show are making huge strides to make Hamilton (and Broadway as a whole) more accessible to those who cannot afford such high prices. 

It's also heading to other places besides NYC soon, and then on tour, and thus will become more and more accessible to those who wish to go. :) I can't wait until I can see it!

Same, actually. I don't personally know anyone who has listened to it and doesn't love it. @Gabriela, if you'd like to be the first, I'd be interested in hearing a critical opinion of it. There are flaws in the show, sure, but none that I see as coming close to overpowering how good it is overall.

Token Ham image of the post:

ham.jpg

I don't mean to hijack your thread with negativity, either. I'm just always skeptical of the popular, especially when it's so mainstream PC like this and costs so much only the rich can enjoy it. In any case, I will look into it, and I won't make any judgment of the artistic quality of the production until then, because that would be terribly unfair to do without having actually seen or heard it.

I'm glad you enjoy it so much, and I hope that you get to see it live when it goes on tour! :) 

veritasluxmea
Posted

I have on friend on social media who posts almost daily about it, so that's the only reason I know it exists. Took me a while to catch on she was posting about a Broadway play, I thought it was a movie at first. No one else I know seems interested- this is the the only other place I've seen it mentioned. 

I thought les Mis was good, so I'd probably enjoy watching Hamilton as well. I saw Mary Poppins on Broadway a while back and loved it. Amazing how they told an old story in a completely fresh form. Broadway plays are something else, really great art. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...