Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

CatherineM
Posted

I'm finishing up my Masters thesis on the Pastoral Care of People with Schizophrenia.  I'm seriously considering including a section from the book, "Star Trek and Philosophy:  The Wrath of Kant."  It's a compilation of writings by professional philosophers on the issues raised by Star Trek.  I wanted to use a discussion of forcing a person who has been assimilated by the Borg into reverting to their natural biological state against their will.  It raises the same issue involved in medicating those with schizophrenia against their will. 

Do I dare, or is it a bridge too far?

Posted

I would do it, but I think academia is stuffy and academics are full of themselves. If you frame it as a thought experiment that illustrates the important principles needing consideration in the pastoral care of schizophrenics, they might go with it. And if they don't, then the worst thing that happens is your advisor tells you to take it out. So you do, and you defend it, and you pass, and then you put it right back into the book version, cuz hey, it's already written.

;) 

CatherineM
Posted

She let me keep it in my annotated bibliography, so I'm hoping it's okay.  I agree it's stuffy in the ivory tower.  Besides, it's just the kind of irreverent thing I'd do.  I once cited myself in a paper.  It was a bar journal article I wrote years ago, so in my maiden name.  Had fun laughing about it with the professor later.

Posted
29 minutes ago, CatherineM said:

She let me keep it in my annotated bibliography, so I'm hoping it's okay.  I agree it's stuffy in the ivory tower.  Besides, it's just the kind of irreverent thing I'd do.  I once cited myself in a paper.  It was a bar journal article I wrote years ago, so in my maiden name.  Had fun laughing about it with the professor later.

I cite myself all the time. :| 

What else are you gonna do when you're the only person who's said what you need to quote?

truthfinder
Posted

Go for it. You've got a reasonable explanation that you can give to your thesis committee.  And it's standard practice to cite yourself - less you be accused of plagiarizing yourself (yeah, that one always struck me as strange).

Archaeology cat
Posted

Can we discuss Seven of Nine now?

Posted

Go for it! 

Yes, the idea of self-plagiarizing is strange...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...