Seven77 Posted July 7, 2016 Posted July 7, 2016 (edited) It all comes down to the fact that it must be a grave matter if it can be considered to be a mortal sin… sure, in the hypothetical situation it is a sin… but it's not mortal a grave matter is a grave matter whether you know it or not… likewise, something not grave is not grave whether you know it or not. Edited July 7, 2016 by Seven77
Peace Posted July 7, 2016 Author Posted July 7, 2016 33 minutes ago, Gabriela said: The problem is, we are all constantly putting ourselves before God. Constantly. Not a single one of us loves God with all our heart, soul, and strength. Speak for yourself! Didn't you hear about my recent canonization? Quote So his failing is a very human one. Yes, he did something he thought was against God's commands, and he did it intentionally. That's bad. But what he did—the actual consumption of the pork—was not really a sin, so all he did was what every one of us does every day: Put his satisfaction before God's. If that's mortal, God help us all. But putting something before God is a sin. One might consider it the PRIMARY sin in a sense. It is basically a form of idolatry I think. 27 minutes ago, Seven77 said: It all comes down to the fact that it must be a grave matter if it can be considered to be a mortal sin… sure, in the hypothetical situation it is a sin… but it's not mortal a grave matter is a grave matter whether you know it or not… likewise, something not grave is not grave whether you know it or not. I think it can be grave. Could it be a form of idolatry? Consider the following for example: Philippians 3:18-20English Standard Version (ESV) 18 For many, of whom I have often told you and now tell you even with tears, walk as enemies of the cross of Christ. 19 Their end is destruction, their god is their belly, and they glory in their shame, with minds set on earthly things. 20 But our citizenship is in heaven, and from it we await a Savior, the Lord Jesus Christ, The guy in my hypo seems to have bowed down to the altar of ribs, if you will . . .
Papist Posted July 7, 2016 Posted July 7, 2016 (edited) 1 hour ago, Gabriela said: The problem is, we are all constantly putting ourselves before God. Constantly. Not a single one of us loves God with all our heart, soul, and strength. We're miserable like that. So his failing is a very human one. Yes, he did something he thought was against God's commands, and he did it intentionally. That's bad. But what he did—the actual consumption of the pork—was not really a sin, so all he did was what every one of us does every day: Put his satisfaction before God's. If that's mortal, God help us all. It is not mortal. The sin is not a grave matter. Edited July 7, 2016 by Papist
Seven77 Posted July 7, 2016 Posted July 7, 2016 25 minutes ago, Peace said: Speak for yourself! Didn't you hear about my recent canonization? I thought you were a Blessed? I keep hearing about Blessed Peace. 25 minutes ago, Peace said: But putting something before God is a sin. One might consider it the PRIMARY sin in a sense. It is basically a form of idolatry I think. I think it can be grave. Could it be a form of idolatry? Consider the following for example: Philippians 3:18-20English Standard Version (ESV) 18 For many, of whom I have often told you and now tell you even with tears, walk as enemies of the cross of Christ. 19 Their end is destruction, their god is their belly, and they glory in their shame, with minds set on earthly things. 20 But our citizenship is in heaven, and from it we await a Savior, the Lord Jesus Christ, The guy in my hypo seems to have bowed down to the altar of ribs, if you will . . . If the guy in your scenario eats the share of the man who is literally starving… I guess the thing can become grave… or if he tries to commit suicide by eating 3 packs of bacon.
Anomaly Posted July 7, 2016 Posted July 7, 2016 (edited) 25 minutes ago, Papist said: It is not mortal. The sin is not a grave matter. I know it's hypothetical and may be hyberbolic, but in the scenario the guy believes it's a grave matter and is clear about it being wrong, but eats pork any way without any qualifications. With full knowledge and consent of will, he is purposely putting eating ribs before obeying in what he believes is a grave matter. Kinda like you get graded on a curve if you are invincibly ignorant, but in reverse. 1862 One commits venial sin when, in a less serious matter, he does not observe the standard prescribed by the moral law, or when he disobeys the moral law in a grave matter, but without full knowledge or without complete consent. Edited July 7, 2016 by Anomaly
Peace Posted July 7, 2016 Author Posted July 7, 2016 29 minutes ago, Seven77 said: I thought you were a Blessed? I keep hearing about Blessed Peace. If the guy in your scenario eats the share of the man who is literally starving… I guess the thing can become grave… or if he tries to commit suicide by eating 3 packs of bacon. Nope. Sorry. I am not saying that he is guilty of theft. In my hypo there are plenty of ribs going around for everyone. If there were this many ribs in the book of Genesis Adam would have had 7 or 8 wives. We are talking about a lot of ribs. I am saying that he may have violated the 1st commandment.
Credo in Deum Posted July 7, 2016 Posted July 7, 2016 6 hours ago, Peace said: Your hypothetical is a bit difficult to answer because you are seemingly bringing another factor into it (mental illness) that was not presented in my hypothetical. In other words, your hypothetical is difficult because it does not seem very likely for a person to draw the conclusion that eating dog poo is necessary unless the person were suffering from mental illness. This is not true with my hypothetical. As you can see from the Bible passage that I quoted above, apparently some of the early Christians (former Jews) had concluded that they were still forbidden to eat certain things. That does not make them idiots or mentally ill. But it does mean that their consciousness were misinformed. But to answer your question the best that I can, if a person who was not mentally ill somehow came to the conclusion that God required him to eat dog poo, then I think he would be bound by it. I think he would commit sin by not eating the dog poo. I think that the sin would be venial because of the significant duress involved in eating dog poo. Doing such a thing is obviously terrible for one's health and biologically repulsive to us. . . Given the mans internal dialogue with himself in your OP, I'm convinced he's mentally ill.
Peace Posted July 7, 2016 Author Posted July 7, 2016 3 minutes ago, Credo in Deum said: Given the mans internal dialogue with himself in your OP, I'm convinced he's mentally ill. Heh. Either that, or they were some AWFULLY tasty looking ribs!
Nihil Obstat Posted July 7, 2016 Posted July 7, 2016 Mortal sin requires grave matter, full knowledge, deliberate consent. This situation does not seem to involve grave matter, so it seems not to meet the criteria.
Peace Posted July 7, 2016 Author Posted July 7, 2016 1 minute ago, Nihil Obstat said: Mortal sin requires grave matter, full knowledge, deliberate consent. This situation does not seem to involve grave matter, so it seems not to meet the criteria. I think that is the question. Are grave matters limited to an enumerated list of actions "murder, rape, adultery" etc., or can a person's intention turn an otherwise benign action into a grave matter? I do not see why not. For example, you point a gun at someone and pull the trigger, fully intending to kill the person. That is pretty bad right? I think you should do some serious jail time, even if unbeknown to you the gun was empty and the action of you pulling the trigger itself turned out to be completely harmless. Should the person not have to go to jail only because he did not succeed in his desire to kill someone?
Gabriela Posted July 8, 2016 Posted July 8, 2016 4 hours ago, NadaTeTurbe said: This is the most jesuit thing I've read today. 3 hours ago, Seven77 said: or if he tries to commit suicide by eating 3 packs of bacon. What a (glorious) way to go. 19 minutes ago, Peace said: I think that is the question. Are grave matters limited to an enumerated list of actions "murder, rape, adultery" etc., or can a person's intention turn an otherwise benign action into a grave matter? I do not see why not. For example, you point a gun at someone and pull the trigger, fully intending to kill the person. That is pretty bad right? I think you should do some serious jail time, even if unbeknown to you the gun was empty and the action of you pulling the trigger itself turned out to be completely harmless. Should the person not have to go to jail only because he did not succeed in his desire to kill someone? There's no parallel. The law, unfortunately, considers the consequences of acts, not just the intent. The Church is not consequentialist; She cares about intent. The problem you're bringing up with the 1st Commandment is one I noticed after like my 3rd confession as a Catholic: There's the individual stoopid things I do that are enumerable sins, and then there's just me, this wretched sinful being, all of me miserable and out of control and hopelessly selfish and desperate to love God more than myself but so finking stuck on myself that I just can't Can't CAN'T actually love Him more than I do my worthless self. That's what we mean by "born in sin" and "sinful nature". It's not the number of times I gossiped, which I can count on one hand (or both hands and both feet, if I'm lucky). It's me being me. Me being human—there's just stuff about me, knitted into who I am, that is sinful and I can't make it stop. The sin you're naming for your hypothetical guy is a sin that just being human makes unavoidable. He's going to love himself more than God. We can't help it. So no, it's not mortal, because it's always there, in your genes, in your constitution, in your very essence. If you call that mortal, then you're saying that, by merely being fallen, we're all always, forever, perpetually in a state of mortal sin. And that means we're all damned to hell forever. So no, your guy is not in mortal sin. He's just human, putting himself before God, and he should confess it, but he'll have to figure out how first. If he does, please tell him to let me know, cuz I've been trying to figure out how to confess the non-numerable sins of my just being fallen ever since that 3rd confession some 5 years ago.
Nihil Obstat Posted July 8, 2016 Posted July 8, 2016 34 minutes ago, Peace said: I think that is the question. Are grave matters limited to an enumerated list of actions "murder, rape, adultery" etc., or can a person's intention turn an otherwise benign action into a grave matter? I do not see why not. For example, you point a gun at someone and pull the trigger, fully intending to kill the person. That is pretty bad right? I think you should do some serious jail time, even if unbeknown to you the gun was empty and the action of you pulling the trigger itself turned out to be completely harmless. Should the person not have to go to jail only because he did not succeed in his desire to kill someone? Intent is a different criterion. We will confuse the issue if we try to blend object and intent.
Peace Posted July 8, 2016 Author Posted July 8, 2016 2 hours ago, Gabriela said: The problem you're bringing up with the 1st Commandment is one I noticed after like my 3rd confession as a Catholic: There's the individual stoopid things I do that are enumerable sins, and then there's just me, this wretched sinful being, all of me miserable and out of control and hopelessly selfish and desperate to love God more than myself but so finking stuck on myself that I just can't Can't CAN'T actually love Him more than I do my worthless self. Yes, you can. You can love God more than yourself. You can love God more than your own life. Plenty of saints have willingly given up their own lives for the love of God. So can you and I. Is that easy? No. But it is possible I think. Were it not possible, I would think that everyone would need to spend time in purgatory. But at least from what I have been taught it is possible for some people who are sufficiently detached to avoid purgatory altogether. Quote That's what we mean by "born in sin" and "sinful nature". It's not the number of times I gossiped, which I can count on one hand (or both hands and both feet, if I'm lucky). It's me being me. Me being human—there's just stuff about me, knitted into who I am, that is sinful and I can't make it stop. Not by ourselves we cannot. But with God's help it is possible, I think. Quote The sin you're naming for your hypothetical guy is a sin that just being human makes unavoidable. He's going to love himself more than God. We can't help it. So no, it's not mortal, because it's always there, in your genes, in your constitution, in your very essence. If you call that mortal, then you're saying that, by merely being fallen, we're all always, forever, perpetually in a state of mortal sin. And that means we're all damned to hell forever. So no, your guy is not in mortal sin. He's just human, putting himself before God, and he should confess it, but he'll have to figure out how first. If he does, please tell him to let me know, cuz I've been trying to figure out how to confess the non-numerable sins of my just being fallen ever since that 3rd confession some 5 years ago. I think I agree with your conclusion that it would not be a mortal sin. But maybe for reasons that you have alluded to rather than stated explicitly. If eating ribs were mortal, then seemingly every sin would be mortal, since every sin is a rejection of God, to a certain extent. With every sin to a certain extent we say "God I do not care that you forbid this".
Gabriela Posted July 8, 2016 Posted July 8, 2016 14 minutes ago, Peace said: Yes, you can. You can love God more than yourself. You can love God more than your own life. Plenty of saints have willingly given up their own lives for the love of God. So can you and I. Is that easy? No. But it is possible I think. Were it not possible, I would think that everyone would need to spend time in purgatory. But at least from what I have been taught it is possible for some people who are sufficiently detached to avoid purgatory altogether. Not by ourselves we cannot. But with God's help it is possible, I think. I think I agree with your conclusion that it would not be a mortal sin. But maybe for reasons that you have alluded to rather than stated explicitly. If eating ribs were mortal, then seemingly every sin would be mortal, since every sin is a rejection of God, to a certain extent. With every sin to a certain extent we say "God I do not care that you forbid this". I agree with everything you say. But it doesn't change the fact that we're all still fallen and most of us do not attain perfect love of God or total selflessness or sainthood in this life, even with all God's mercy and grace and generous help. So while in theory you are correct, in practice I am. Or maybe more appropriately:
Peace Posted July 8, 2016 Author Posted July 8, 2016 8 minutes ago, Gabriela said: I agree with everything you say. But it doesn't change the fact that we're all still fallen and most of us do not attain perfect love of God or total selflessness or sainthood in this life, even with all God's mercy and grace and generous help. So while in theory you are correct, in practice I am. Or maybe more appropriately: I ain't anywhere close to being there either. Heck, most of the folks on this forum are probably way closer than me. At the same time though, I think that we have to accept that God gives each of us sufficient grace to become a saint. The fact that we make a choice not to cooperate with that grace (or put another way, not to allow the holy spirit to work within us) has more to do with our free will and choice to do evil than it does with any lack of grace or defect in the way that we are made. How about this? Let's both you and I choose to love God more than we love ourselves? I think that we can do it. Peace
Papist Posted July 8, 2016 Posted July 8, 2016 15 hours ago, Anomaly said: I know it's hypothetical and may be hyberbolic, but in the scenario the guy believes it's a grave matter and is clear about it being wrong, but eats pork any way without any qualifications. With full knowledge and consent of will, he is purposely putting eating ribs before obeying in what he believes is a grave matter. Kinda like you get graded on a curve if you are invincibly ignorant, but in reverse. 1862 One commits venial sin when, in a less serious matter, he does not observe the standard prescribed by the moral law, or when he disobeys the moral law in a grave matter, but without full knowledge or without complete consent. I do not believe that simply believing it is grave matter makes it a grave matter. If so, one could argue the reverse.
Anomaly Posted July 8, 2016 Posted July 8, 2016 27 minutes ago, Papist said: I do not believe that simply believing it is grave matter makes it a grave matter. If so, one could argue the reverse. Exactly! If you don't know it is a grave matter, then it isn't. A mortal sin requires full knowledge that it's a grave matter. In this hypo, the guy fully believes it's a grave matter. There is no habit, social pressure, undue outside pressure, or influence telling him that maybe it isn't a grave matter in this particular circumstance. He coldly and clearly chose ribs over God. He didn't forget, got distracted, was pressured by the cook, etc.
Papist Posted July 8, 2016 Posted July 8, 2016 19 minutes ago, Anomaly said: Exactly! If you don't know it is a grave matter, then it isn't. A mortal sin requires full knowledge that it's a grave matter. In this hypo, the guy fully believes it's a grave matter. There is no habit, social pressure, undue outside pressure, or influence telling him that maybe it isn't a grave matter in this particular circumstance. He coldly and clearly chose ribs over God. He didn't forget, got distracted, was pressured by the cook, etc. put simply, I believe he sinned, but sin not mortal. But then again. I am not a moral theologian.
AveMariaPurissima Posted July 8, 2016 Posted July 8, 2016 On 7/6/2016 at 8:29 PM, Peace said: Let's say a Catholic is poorly catechized, reads parts of the Bible in his spare time, and incorrectly comes to the firm conclusion that it is a grave sin and contrary to a direct commandment of God for a Catholic to eat pork. Otherwise known as swine to our Canadian friends. Then at a July 4th BBQ party the same Catholic sees the perfect rack of ribs on the grill. He says to himself "Well. If eating pork is wrong then I don't want to be right!" He then says "God. I love you, but these ribs. These ribs man! They are too tasty. Sorry to disobey. It is what it is." He eats the ribs fully believing that to do so is a sin against God. Does the Catholic sin? If so, what commandment is violated? Mortal or venial? Or does he not sin because in actuality he is not forbidden to eat pork? I tend to think that he sins, but I am not quite sure what sin he is guilty of. Thoughts? On 7/6/2016 at 9:27 PM, KnightofChrist said: In other words, is it possible to sin against a malformed conscience? I did some research in my old high school religion textbook, Catholic Morality by Fr. John Laux, and I came up with this: Quote "If our conscience, whether it speaks the truth or not, speaks with assurance, without a suspicion of error, and its voice carries with conviction, we are said to have a certain conscience....We are always bound to follow a certain conscience, even if it is false or erroneous...The reason is clear. We are judged by God according as we do good or evil. Our merit or demerit is dependent on our responsibility. We are responsible only for the good or evil we know we do. But knowledge and certainty come from a certain conscience. Therefore, if we disobey a certain conscience, we make ourselves responsible. A Protestant who is fully convinced that it is a sin to hear Mass or to speak to a priest would undoubtedly commit a sin by so doing." (pg. 19) Quote "In the case of an erroneous conscience, the morality of an action, as we have seen above, does not depend on the object as it is in itself, but as it is represented in the mind." (pg. 25) Based on these quotes, here are my thoughts on the hypothetical situation presented above: Eating pork is certainly not sinful in itself, but the person in the example has "incorrectly come to the firm conclusion" that doing so "is a grave sin." So in this matter the person has an erroneous conscience (since the action is not, in fact, sinful), but his erroneous conscience is also a certain conscience. Going by Fr. Laux, he is therefore obliged to obey his conscience. My understanding is that if a person incorrectly but sincerely believes that action X is a mortal sin and does it anyway, it is, for him at that moment, a mortal sin. Even though the action wasn't grave, his actions showed that he was willing to do something he sincerely believed was a grave offense to God. Conversely, if a person sincerely but incorrectly believes that action Y is not sinful (or at least not mortally sinful), when said action is in fact a grave sin, then for him in that moment, it is not a mortal sin, even though for someone properly catechized who committed the same action, it would be a sin. Of course, we are under an obligation to form our conscience properly, but this is an ongoing process. I am open to correction on this, but this is what I was taught, and it seems reasonable to me.
Nihil Obstat Posted July 8, 2016 Posted July 8, 2016 That does seem reasonable. Perhaps I have assessed the incorrect moral object in my response.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now