LittleWaySoul Posted July 27, 2016 Posted July 27, 2016 4 hours ago, Nihil Obstat said: It seems that lately the violence has been spilling over into the developed world much more than in recent memory. That's a good way of putting it.
little2add Posted July 27, 2016 Posted July 27, 2016 It seems that lately the moral decay has been Flourishing in the developed world much more than in recent memory too.
Nihil Obstat Posted July 27, 2016 Posted July 27, 2016 8 minutes ago, little2add said: It seems that lately the moral decay has been Flourishing in the developed world much more than in recent memory too. I think it has been on an accelerating decline since the Enlightenment. Would not be much surprised if that is part of your recent memory though.
NadaTeTurbe Posted July 28, 2016 Posted July 28, 2016 the French organization who lead all of the muslims organizations called for muslims to go to mass sunday, by "compassion and solidarity" for catholics, and also because Father Jacques Hamel was involved in inter-religious dialogue. I hope this is followed widely, and I'll pray it will touch them. One of my friend told me he'll be here.
PhuturePriest Posted July 28, 2016 Posted July 28, 2016 (edited) That's a very nice and touching gesture, but the reality of possibly dozens of Muslims attending a parish at once would realistically make it easier for a terrorist to slip in unnoticed. More realistically, I fear such a thing would put many parishioners on edge and they would leave Mass out of caution, particularly if they have small children. It would certainly cross my mind to do so were I at Mass with my sister and nephews. I'm not trying to berate or denigrate the idea, mind you. I'm simply thinking out loud the pluses and benefits of the situation. It would be a more powerful gesture if Catholics themselves had done it, as now it feels like Muslims are foisting themselves upon parishes and making people more afraid of terrorist attacks. If all goes well (as I hope and expect it to,) it will hopefully do the opposite, of course. Edited July 28, 2016 by PhuturePriest
Ice_nine Posted July 29, 2016 Posted July 29, 2016 10 minutes ago, PhuturePriest said: That's a very nice and touching gesture, but the reality of possibly dozens of Muslims attending a parish at once would realistically make it easier for a terrorist to slip in unnoticed. More realistically, I fear such a thing would put many parishioners on edge and they would leave Mass out of caution, particularly if they have small children. It would certainly cross my mind to do so were I at Mass with my sister and nephews. I'm not trying to berate or denigrate the idea, mind you. I'm simply thinking out loud the pluses and benefits of the situation. It would be a more powerful gesture if Catholics themselves had done it, as now it feels like Muslims are foisting themselves upon parishes and making people more afraid of terrorist attacks. If all goes well (as I hope and expect it to,) it will hopefully do the opposite, of course. I think it may benefit you to take a break from your contrarianism streak. Islam is a religion and Muslims come in many stripes, some fairly westernized in dress, some very traditional. Some Christians may be Middle Eastern or "look" Arab/Muslim (again the two are not synonymous). Also a terrorist is probably good at "slipping in unnoticed" without a crowd of "Muslim-looking" people. That's usually their M.O. Unless you are to be suspect of any brown guy who might be Muslim or any woman with a head-covering. It's a good thing to have Muslims attend Holy Mass. I don't expect sweeping conversions but maybe a few souls will be touched. Who knows?
PhuturePriest Posted July 29, 2016 Posted July 29, 2016 10 minutes ago, Ice_nine said: I think it may benefit you to take a break from your contrarianism streak. Islam is a religion and Muslims come in many stripes, some fairly westernized in dress, some very traditional. Some Christians may be Middle Eastern or "look" Arab/Muslim (again the two are not synonymous). Also a terrorist is probably good at "slipping in unnoticed" without a crowd of "Muslim-looking" people. That's usually their M.O. Unless you are to be suspect of any brown guy who might be Muslim or any woman with a head-covering. It's a good thing to have Muslims attend Holy Mass. I don't expect sweeping conversions but maybe a few souls will be touched. Who knows? I'm not being contrary for the sake of being contrary. I'm saying it's potentially imprudent for tons of Muslims to invite themselves to Mass even though many Catholics in France are scared. In my opinion, it would have been a much better idea for this organization to host an event for Catholics and Muslims to stand in solidarity. This way it's completely optional and those who go are doing so on their own accord and having weighed the risks for them and their family. Catholics are *required* to go to Mass, and the French Catholics who do go are being forced into a situation they may not feel is safe. We can't fault people for fearing the safety of their families at Mass in this situation, especially considering this week two men slit the throat of a priest and held parishioners hostage.
PhuturePriest Posted July 29, 2016 Posted July 29, 2016 For the record, I'm not saying Muslims should be disallowed from Mass. In fact, anyone who knows me knows I love the Middle East. I find its history and culture to be endlessly fascinating, and I want to visit Arabia and Egypt someday. I always get really excited whenever I speak to Muslims regardless of their ethnic heritage, and if a parish near me invited Muslims to attend in the name of dialogue and better relations, I would go out of my way to attend. Then again, my parish priest's throat wasn't slit in front of me and I wasn't held hostage several days ago. If that did happen to me, I would potentially feel very unsafe and scared if the next time I were at Mass lots of Muslims came. I'm not coming at this from a point of prejudice or distrust, but concern for the people this happened to. I think it was imprudent for this organization to invite themselves to a Mass that might include the victims of this crime, who may choose not to go because of that fear. An independent event held by the organization would have been in better taste.
NadaTeTurbe Posted July 29, 2016 Posted July 29, 2016 If a french catholic is afraid of a muslim at mass, he is stupid. It's not the US here where there is 2% of muslims I read, you know, we live with them. They're 10% of the population. If you're afraid of a muslim at mass, it means you're afraid of a muslim in the bus, in the streets, etc... In wich case, you just have to never leave your house. Because if you're afraid of a muslims in a place where there was a terrorist attack, it means that : you're afraid of muslims on the streets you're afraid of muslims in a stadium (so you can't watch football since the team is made of a lot of muslims) you're afraid of muslims in a bar French are not as coward as americans believe... And this idea comes from... the parish of Saint Etienne du Rouvray ! i.e the people who were attacked. The idea was that the parishioner of Saint Etienne du Rouvray will go to prayers on friday at the mosquée, and then the muslims will go to mass sunday, because Father Jacques was involved in inter-religious dialogue. btw, the sisters who witnessed the execution of Father Jacques, a few hours after, she was back in her home in a muslims neighbourhood, and she wasn't afraid, and she had reasons to be ! Also = ton of muslims ? With a little luck, one or two will come. They don't obey blindly to the CFCM, it's an institution created less than 10 years ago. http://www.lemonde.fr/societe/portfolio/2016/07/29/en-images-l-hommage-au-pretre-jacques-hamel-assassine_4976035_3224.html
PhuturePriest Posted July 29, 2016 Posted July 29, 2016 (edited) 8 hours ago, NadaTeTurbe said: If a french catholic is afraid of a muslim at mass, he is stupid. It's not the US here where there is 2% of muslims I read, you know, we live with them. They're 10% of the population. If you're afraid of a muslim at mass, it means you're afraid of a muslim in the bus, in the streets, etc... In wich case, you just have to never leave your house. Because if you're afraid of a muslims in a place where there was a terrorist attack, it means that : you're afraid of muslims on the streets you're afraid of muslims in a stadium (so you can't watch football since the team is made of a lot of muslims) you're afraid of muslims in a bar French are not as coward as americans believe... And this idea comes from... the parish of Saint Etienne du Rouvray ! i.e the people who were attacked. The idea was that the parishioner of Saint Etienne du Rouvray will go to prayers on friday at the mosquée, and then the muslims will go to mass sunday, because Father Jacques was involved in inter-religious dialogue. btw, the sisters who witnessed the execution of Father Jacques, a few hours after, she was back in her home in a muslims neighbourhood, and she wasn't afraid, and she had reasons to be ! Also = ton of muslims ? With a little luck, one or two will come. They don't obey blindly to the CFCM, it's an institution created less than 10 years ago. http://www.lemonde.fr/societe/portfolio/2016/07/29/en-images-l-hommage-au-pretre-jacques-hamel-assassine_4976035_3224.html From what you wrote before, it sounded like the organization itself had come up with the idea, not the parish, so it was my fault for not looking at that closely enough. I was also picking up on fears you yourself had expressed ("I don't want to live in this country anymore.") as potential indicators that people might be afraid in such a situation. Obviously, I am very far removed from it and cannot guess it accurately. I can only come at this from the perspective of what would most likely happen in the area of the world I live in, which would unfortunately be a lot of social backlash towards Muslims (Heck, they get it simply from coming into this country, sadly.) I'm glad to hear this has not caused a lot of fear in everyone and I'm sorry if I came across too harshly. I wasn't in a very good mood yesterday and I spoke too rashly without carefully thinking over the issue. Edited July 29, 2016 by PhuturePriest
Gabriela Posted July 30, 2016 Posted July 30, 2016 (edited) I think the Muslim organization did a very honorable thing encouraging Muslims to go to Mass this Sunday. I also think what PhuturePriest says makes a great deal of sense. It's not Muslims that Catholic Mass-goers would be afraid of, but Islamist terrorists using Muslims to slip in unnoticed. It may lead to more fear. Though, hopefully, not to more violence. Edited July 30, 2016 by Gabriela
NadaTeTurbe Posted July 30, 2016 Posted July 30, 2016 17 hours ago, PhuturePriest said: From what you wrote before, it sounded like the organization itself had come up with the idea, not the parish, so it was my fault for not looking at that closely enough. I was also picking up on fears you yourself had expressed ("I don't want to live in this country anymore.") as potential indicators that people might be afraid in such a situation. Obviously, I am very far removed from it and cannot guess it accurately. I can only come at this from the perspective of what would most likely happen in the area of the world I live in, which would unfortunately be a lot of social backlash towards Muslims (Heck, they get it simply from coming into this country, sadly.) I'm glad to hear this has not caused a lot of fear in everyone and I'm sorry if I came across too harshly. I wasn't in a very good mood yesterday and I spoke too rashly without carefully thinking over the issue. I was tired too, so it makes two of us who spoke too rashly. I don't want to live in this country anymore not only because of the attacks, but also because of the politics that was have. At least we don't have Trump and Hillary, but our government doesn't know what to do, their opponents just want more voices. Yes, people are afraid, but you can't live here if you're afraid of muslims. And muslims are afraid, because if you're not a member of ISIS, you're one of their ennemies. Mohammed Merah who killed jewish children in 2012 began by killing muslims soldiers. I think people are afraid because the answers that they received from politics are useless, aimed at having more voices, or out of touch with reality.
Benedictus Posted July 30, 2016 Posted July 30, 2016 14 hours ago, Gabriela said: I think the Muslim organization did a very honorable thing encouraging Muslims to go to Mass this Sunday. I also think what PhuturePriest says makes a great deal of sense. It's not Muslims that Catholic Mass-goers would be afraid of, but Islamist terrorists using Muslims to slip in unnoticed. It may lead to more fear. Though, hopefully, not to more violence. Possibly. But they can enter at anytime, regardless. It's not like you can easily tell who's a terrorist in most situations. These attackers choose not to commit their crimes during the peak of Sunday Mass. They did it during the week when they knew less people would be there to stop them. They were opportunistic cowards who killed an elderly priest for the media attention so that it would accelerate their cause of spreading fear and hate. I do think Churches need to increase security in the same way Synagogues have had to do for many decades. Many people will know many Synagogues have good security procedures and you won't just breeze in. Synagogues have been fairly good at blocking disruptions and attacks for this reason. Catholic Churches pose different challenges but it seems something pertinent to think about more and more.
Gabriela Posted July 30, 2016 Posted July 30, 2016 I was an Orthodox Jew in Germany so I know all about synagogue access, as well as the theological and spiritual assumptions that communities make when considering access to their places of worship. It would be patently unchristian to guard churches in the way that Jews guard synagogues. It's just not the same religion, and it doesn't allow for the same kinds of security measures. Most Catholics feel terrible that they have to lock their churches at night. To guard them in the way that Jews guard their synagogues, screening people who want to come in, would be utterly unthinkable to us.
NadaTeTurbe Posted July 31, 2016 Posted July 31, 2016 It would be impossible in France to protect church like synagogue : there's more than 50 000 churches. But we can do better : only 128 of them have a protection ! My muslim friend liked mass, he thought it was great that you could understand what was going on. I wanted to give him a Bible or a gospel but I didn't have one, so I gave him the Imitation of Jesus Christ
Guest Posted July 31, 2016 Posted July 31, 2016 "And it is here that the language of sacrifice is especially tricky. I have no time for the idea that Jesus is sacrificed on the cross to appease an angry God. If that’s true, then God becomes the enemy of humankind and I am against him. No, Jesus absorbs the violence that comes from us, not from God. He receives our blows, our punishments, our disdain. And, despite his innocence – or, rather, precisely because of it – he refuses to answer back in kind. No more an eye for an eye. In other words, the sacrifice of the cross is the non-violent absorption of human violence. The offer of love in return for hate, even to the point of death. This is the horrendous price that peace is sometimes asked to pay. This is what makes the Eucharistic sacrifice life-giving and not some historical death cult. And this is the sacrifice that Father Jacques was celebrating as he died. He died as a priest, doing what priests do. May he rest in peace and rise in glory." https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/belief/2016/jul/28/father-jacques-hamel-died-as-a-priest-doing-what-priests-do?CMP=share_btn_fb
PhuturePriest Posted July 31, 2016 Posted July 31, 2016 Good news: I was right in that Muslims came in droves: http://aleteia.org/blogs/deacon-greg-kandra/muslims-attend-catholic-mass-in-france-as-show-of-solidarity/?ru=31274c1dd0b3e3c08686c0b863611051 Glad everything went well. I'm sure all those who attended were very touched.
Benedictus Posted July 31, 2016 Posted July 31, 2016 8 hours ago, NadaTeTurbe said: It would be impossible in France to protect church like synagogue : there's more than 50 000 churches. But we can do better : only 128 of them have a protection ! My muslim friend liked mass, he thought it was great that you could understand what was going on. I wanted to give him a Bible or a gospel but I didn't have one, so I gave him the Imitation of Jesus Christ I agree. Policy and protocols are weak. It's something that needs attention and I suspect will be hopefully discussed between civil and Church authorities. This is a new challenge and people should feel the Church is taking reasonable steps to ensure there's a degree of safeguarding in place and an emergency plan that can be put into action locally. The Church has a degree of responsibility for those on its property. 19 hours ago, Gabriela said: I was an Orthodox Jew in Germany so I know all about synagogue access, as well as the theological and spiritual assumptions that communities make when considering access to their places of worship. It would be patently unchristian to guard churches in the way that Jews guard synagogues. It's just not the same religion, and it doesn't allow for the same kinds of security measures. Most Catholics feel terrible that they have to lock their churches at night. To guard them in the way that Jews guard their synagogues, screening people who want to come in, would be utterly unthinkable to us. There would be a lot to unpack here. I accept elements of what you're saying, although I've seen the practices employed at liberal and reform congregations too. It's driven by pragmatic need and not anything else, especially not theology. They manage this with fairly big communities too. They don't turn people away and always try to be welcoming. It's not a one size fits all approach but it's very considered and professional. I know less about Orthodox communities, minus a few Modern Orthodox congregations, but it's not uncommon to hear criticisms, even from Orthodox adherents, regarding exclusive and restrictive behaviour practised by some. The issue is unthinkable for Catholics, especially ones living safe environments, because they've never had to really think about it. Things change and if risks increase I doubt they'll keep shrugging it off. Churches in persecuted countries do think about security and don't accept that somehow they have to ignore it to be considered Christian.
NadaTeTurbe Posted July 31, 2016 Posted July 31, 2016 I was so moved by the testimony of the sisters in the newspaper "La Vie", i wanted to translate most of it for Phatmass. There's mistakes I'm sure, and some useless things, I did not translate it, but the main accoung is here. http://www.lavie.fr/actualite/france/face-a-face-avec-les-terroristes-de-saint-etienne-du-rouvray-le-temoignage-des-religieuses-29-07-2016-75263_4.php Troubled youngs people who squat stars and promise to watch over their cars. Teachers in professional high school, nurses, these three sisters of Saint Vincent de Paul have already seen this kind of youngs during their missions in Normandy, Brittany, North and Paris. To be in the heart of difficult neighbourhoods and close to the marginalized is the DNA of their order since more than 150 years. But terrorists ? These 3 womens with white hairs never thought they could meet some of them. And not in St Etienne du Rouvray, a communist suburbia next to Rouen, where they live with another sister. Friendship between muslims and catholics is lived during every day life : the parish Sainte Thérèse gave some ground to the next door mosque. On feast days, the paris welcome muslims on its ground, who give them pastries. (…) We never felt hate in our discussion with the sisters. Sitting in their dinning room, these three “sisters courage” don’t leave each other, surronded by white flowers given by friends. On the wall, a crucifix. On the table, a call to national prayer and a picture of father Hamel with a white alb. Sisters Danielle Delafosse, who have a strong character, is shaked : “I would like to be able to place this image with the image that I have of Jacques in church.” At 9 :30 am, this Tuesday, father Jacques Hamel is saying mass with three religious and a couple of elderly : « The portuguese moms were on holidays ! ». During the mass, a man comes : “with his blue shirt, I thought he was a student. He wanted to know when the church was open. I told him to come again in 10 minutes, after the mass” says Sister Huguette, calmly. The young man comes back later, but with a friend and dressed in black. “They were dressed like terrorist on TV. One of them had a black cap on its head, and a big beard. I understood immediately.” Remembers sister Hélène, the trio’s nurse. « They were very angry. They pronounced a kind of slogan in arab, and in french, they reproached us for the fact that “us christian, we don’t support arabs” Then, the horror. The agressors throw everything that is on the altar to put their bags on it, and ask the prist to kneel. They put a camera in the hand of Mr C. “Jacques screamed : “Stop, what are you doing ?” At this moment, one of them gave the frist blow to his throat. I left” remembers Danielle, who still can’t explain her survival reflex. Outside, she calls herself. Before being put in safety, she stopped a blue car, and asked the man inside to call the police. Inside the church, the tragedy is still going on. The two murderers are following their plan. They put their knife another time in the throat of father Jacques, who died soon after. After wounding Mr C., they check if he did not move the camera, that the macabre scene have been well recorded. “I saw on the screen the white alb of Jacques with a red stain.” Says Huguette, who was behing the “cameraman”. While father Jacques and mr C. are lying down on the ground, the “leader” tell the three women that he is keeping them as hostage. “They hold us by the shoulders. One of them had a gun, but I soon thought it was a fake, and I was true. The one who hold me had blood on its hand and a knife that he sharpened against I don’t know what” says Hélène, traumatized to the point that she can’t see a knife without shivering. The change in attitude of the two terrorist is obvious. They are no longer angry or aggressive. “The second one smiled to me. Not a triumphant smile, but a sweet smile, the smile of someone happy”, says Huguette, still surprised two days after the tragedy. Sister Hélène, 83 ans, and Mme C., more than 80 years old, ask to sit down. A killer says “yes”. Between the torturer and the captives women, begins a surrealist dialogue with pseudo-theological accents. Did the killers try to convert the sisters to Islam ? We could believe it. They ask sister Hélène if she know the Qu’ran. “Yes, I respect it like I respect the Bible, I already read some sura. And what striked me, it’s the part about peace.” Touched, the man answers : “We want peace ! When you will be on TV, you will say to your rulers that there will be attacks as long as there is bombing in Syria.” Under threats, Hélène says yes. After her liberation, she will say it to François Hollande. “Are you afraid to die ?” ask the killer with cruelty, or maybe curiosity. “No” answers the sister. “Why ?” “I believe in God and I know that I’ll be happy” Hélène doesn’t want to weaken, so she prays the Virgin Mary, and think about Christian de Chergé, the prior of the monastery of Tibhirine. “I always answered calmly, never more than necessary. Never against my thought, but not too much.” With sister Huguette, the conversation is about Jesus and the debate between muslims and christians. “esus can’t be man and God? You’re wrong” says the 19 years old terrorist. “Maybe, and so what ?” answers the sister. “I did not want to provoke him, and I did not want to renounce to my convictions. Thinking that I was going to die, internally, I offered my life to God.” While the police is coming, the two murderers begins to hit the bench, to push the candles around the tabernacle, shouting “Allah Akbar !” “They were waiting for the police.” Before the police enters the church, they try to leave with the three women as human shield. “But they were not really behind us. They wanted to die. I moved my bag, there was a noise. The same one that smiled to me said : “Don’t move. Stay here.” The police who entered by the sacristy door shoots. The terrorist dies. Mr and Mme C, and the two sisters leave free but traumatized. Two days after the tragedy, they see reflections of this nightmare, and memories of Jacques, who often ate at their home and gave to them “La Vie”. “He was a welcoming man, who had a strong character, and liked music and beautiful eucharistic celebrations. He wanted order on the altar, and the carpet had to be at the perfect place.” Danielle – who did not have the time to think to celebrate her jubilee – sigh “It going to be difficult, and we will go back to church and work in his presbitery.” She is angry “inside” “It’s us, but it’s also others who were targets. We can’t accept this violence. They are not real muslims.” “I don’t know if they had awareness of their acts. We must not try to understand.” Says sister Hélène. The tragedy ? “It will pass.” She hopes. With a soft voice, sister Huguette remind us that “2016 is the year of mercy.”
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now