Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

KnightofChrist
Posted

Looks shopped, I can tell because of the pixels.

 

Posted

I'm curious about thoughts on the quote....

 

Posted

Well clearly it's an incomplete quote - that what the ellipsis dots indicate. What's the full quote? "May St. John the Baptist protect Islam from false leaders? from fringe elements within its own ranks? 

I've just done a quick search for the full quote on Google and I can't find it. The only links that come up are from "The V-II Church is NOT the Catholic Church" and groups like that. 

Does anyone in the Pham have a book of John Paul II quotes that can complete the quotation? Until I see the full quotation, and know the context in which it was spoken or written, then No, I don't have any thoughts.

KnightofChrist
Posted

Well the complete sentence is...

"May Saint John Baptist protect Islam and all the people of Jordan, and all who participated in this celebration, a memorable celebration. I’m very grateful to all of you." Source

By "Islam" the Pope could have meant the individual persons who are of Islam, or he could have meant the religion of Islam. Nothing wrong with asking a Saint to protect individuals. But Islam is false, and Saint John the Baptist cannot protect it.

Posted
40 minutes ago, KnightofChrist said:

Well the complete sentence is...

"May Saint John Baptist protect Islam and all the people of Jordan, and all who participated in this celebration, a memorable celebration. I’m very grateful to all of you." Source

By "Islam" the Pope could have meant the individual persons who are of Islam, or he could have meant the religion of Islam. Nothing wrong with asking a Saint to protect individuals. But Islam is false, and Saint John the Baptist cannot protect it.

Perhaps you can pray for religion X (not Catholic) if people would otherwise fall to religion Y  (worse than X) instead. 

And perhaps we can pray for certain things to be upheld because, although false, they serve as a path or temporary stop along the way to the truth. Should we pray for the downfall of the Southern Baptists and Anglicans? I was once Protestant before I became Catholic. I wouldn't necessarily exclude my Protestant days from God's providence.

And I would not necessarily conclude that God does not have a use for other religions. I don't  know one way or the other. But if He does, I don't see why the saints cannot protect them. I think that the Church has made it clear that God acts through non-Catholic Christian communities of faith, but I am not sure if that would extend to other groups as well. Certainly there are great truths that can be found in most religions.

KnightofChrist
Posted
1 hour ago, Peace said:

Perhaps you can pray for religion X (not Catholic) if people would otherwise fall to religion Y  (worse than X) instead. 

We cannot do evil so good may come from it. Can we praise birthday cake X (10% Sodium fluoride) if people would otherwise eat birthday cake Y (15% Sodium fluoride)?

1 hour ago, Peace said:

And perhaps we can pray for certain things to be upheld because, although false, they serve as a path or temporary stop along the way to the truth. Should we pray for the downfall of the Southern Baptists and Anglicans? I was once Protestant before I became Catholic. I wouldn't necessarily exclude my Protestant days from God's providence.

I think we can appreciate the elements of truths found in false religions, because those truths are truth despite the false religion, but we can't pray for or honor false religions. Because all false religions endanger souls, no matter the truths found in them. To continue the metaphor we can also appreciate the none deadly ingredients of a poisoned cake, we just can't appreciate the poisoned cake. Because cake that is poisoned endangers peoples lives, no matter the tasty and good ingredients in it.

The Church calls us to unite our will with God the Father, who wills to call the whole of humanity together into his Son's Church. So if we obey that and pray for it, it would effectively be a praying to end all other religions, just not as hyperbolic. 

1 hour ago, Peace said:

And I would not necessarily conclude that God does not have a use for other religions. I don't  know one way or the other. But if He does, I don't see why the saints cannot protect them. I think that the Church has made it clear that God acts through non-Catholic Christian communities of faith, but I am not sure if that would extend to other groups as well. Certainly there are great truths that can be found in most religions.

God does not use false religions. Revealed truth teaches us that the gods of false religions are devils and that false worship of the true God is offensive to or does not please God. Asking a Saint to protect a false religion would be like asking a baker to praise a poisoned cake. I believe Pope John Paul II was talking about the people, individuals who belong to Islam, and not talking about Islam as a religion.

But again we can appreciate truths where ever they are found.

Posted (edited)
56 minutes ago, KnightofChrist said:

We cannot do evil so good may come from it.

Thank you for the clarification. Now the only thing you need to do is demonstrate that praying for religion X is evil.

Quote

Can we praise birthday cake X (10% Sodium fluoride) if people would otherwise eat birthday cake Y (15% Sodium fluoride)?

Yes. For the reason that cake X gives the person a better chance of survival than cake Y. Of course, cake Z (0% Sodium fluoride) would be more praiseworthy than both.

Quote

I think we can appreciate the elements of truths found in false religions, because those truths are truth despite the false religion,

This strikes me as kind of a "all or none" mentality.  You can praise Islam for being a monotheistic religion, can you not? You can praise Islam for being recognizing the God of Abraham, can you not?

Quote

but we can't pray for or honor false religions.

Why? There are parts to them that are honorable, are there not?  Are we to only to honor things that are perfect?

Quote

Because all false religions endanger souls, no matter the truths found in them.

 They might all endanger souls in comparison to the Catholic faith, but again, we are not dealing with an either/or situation here.  Let's say I have a friend from an Asian or Middle Eastern country who has never  heard the gospel.  Can I pray "God I hope that my friend will come to enter the Catholic Church, but if that does not happen, I hope that my friend may come to know you through another Christian community of faith?" Do you deny that God works through non-Catholic communities of faith?

Quote

To continue the metaphor we can also appreciate the none deadly ingredients of a poisoned cake, we just can't appreciate the poisoned cake. Because cake that is poisoned endangers peoples lives, no matter the tasty and good ingredients in it.

I think that we have already discussed this.

Quote

God does not use false religions.

According to who? How do you know what God uses and what God does not use? How do you know that it was not God's will that I became a protestant on my way to becoming Catholic? Do you have some unique access to the divine will that I am not aware of?

Quote

Revealed truth teaches us that the gods of false religions are devils and that false worship of the true God is offensive to or does not please God.

So then is it safe to assume that you believe that our Jewish brothers and sisters worship a devil?

Quote

Asking a Saint to protect a false religion would be like asking a baker to praise a poisoned cake. I believe Pope John Paul II was talking about the people, individuals who belong to Islam, and not talking about Islam as a religion.

Well. Either that or you are wrong.

Edited by Peace
Posted

 

19 minutes ago, Peace said:

I do not even know if the quote is true, by the way.

.........Good comment!

I could not find the quote either on the more reputable sites.  I did however find the quote on http://www.novusordowatch.org/pope-saint-john-paul-ii.htm *** the site said the quote could be found on the Vatican website.  I couldn't find it there because the link they give links only to The Holy See - a website which I find confusing - someone else might be able to find the quote there.

____________________________

*** About Norvus Ordo Watch site: HERE The primary mission and purpose of Novus Ordo Watch is to educate. We wish to compare and contrast the Catholic Church and the Catholic Faith with the new religion (“Novus Ordo” —  see below) instituted after the supposed election of Cardinal Angelo Roncalli as "Pope" John XXIII in 1958 and his disastrous Second Vatican Council (aka "Vatican II" - 1962-65). We are confident that our web site provides sufficient documentation, esp. at our continually-updated Novus Ordo Wire blog, to prove that since the death of the last known Pope, Pius XII (1939-58), the apparent Catholic establishment in the Vatican has been run by anti-Catholic infiltrators who have done everything in their power to destroy the Catholic Faith and cause scandal and impiety among the faithful, all under the guise of a "Great Renewal" of the Faith and ad nauseam references to a supposed "New Springtime" of Catholicism. The truth, however, is quite the opposite. This web site is dedicated to pointing out that truth.

 

4 hours ago, Josh said:

FB_IMG_1469561259689-1.jpg

 

Josh, could you give the actual source you have used for the above quote?

My bad, I see that @KnightofChrist gave a source for the quotation linking to the Vatican website.

KnightofChrist
Posted
5 minutes ago, BarbaraTherese said:

Josh, could you give the actual source you have used for the above quote?


I gave the original source earlier, it comes from a speech during a visit by Pope John Paul II to Wadi Al-Kharrar.

 

 

 

Posted (edited)

Thank you KoC.  I did eventually wake up that you had given a sound source for the quote.  I missed that post initially.

Seems to me in the words "may God protect Islam" common sense tells me that God would not protect evil and certainly there is much good in some versions of Islam to be protected and upheld.  I am sure Pope John Paul II knew this too.  It is not Islam that is the evil, it is Isis who claim Islam falsely.

We have different versions of Christianity too admittedly none of them that I know of are violent in our day anyway, except maybe the KKK who apparently do claim some sort of Christian beliefs and not Christian at all.  I have heard too but only on the grapevine (word of mouth) as it were that neo-Nazism claims too some sort of Christian beliefs and not Christian at all.

Edited by BarbaraTherese
KnightofChrist
Posted
32 minutes ago, Peace said:

Thank you for the clarification. Now the only thing you need to do is demonstrate that praying for religion X is evil.

When did something that is false, corrupt, or a lie become good?

32 minutes ago, Peace said:

Yes. For the reason that cake X gives the person a better chance of survival than cake Y. Of course, cake Z (0% Sodium fluoride) would be more praiseworthy than both.

The only moral and sane suggestion would be the cake without poison. Suggesting the other two for whatever reason would be immoral.

32 minutes ago, Peace said:

This strikes me as kind of a "all or none" mentality.  You can praise Islam for being a monotheistic religion, can you not? You can praise Islam for being recognizing the God of Abraham, can you not? Why? There are parts to them that are honorable, are there not?  Are we to only to honor things that are perfect?

Monotheism is true, so Monotheism can be praised, that the true God is the God of Abraham is true so that can be praised. But Islam is truth mixed with lies, it rejects the God of Israel for example. We cannot adopt a sort of dualism, believing we can praise something that is both true and false, good and evil. The Devil believes in monotheism, the devil believes God is the God of Abraham. The devil holds elements of truth, but should we praise the devil because he holds to elements of truth? No. But using your position for praising false religions, we can also praise the devil. Because the devil has elements of truth. 

32 minutes ago, Peace said:

They might all endanger souls in comparison to the Catholic faith, but again, we are not dealing with an either/or situation here.  Let's say I have a friend from an Asian or Middle Eastern country who has never  heard the gospel.  Can I pray "God I hope that my friend will come to enter the Catholic Church, but if that does not happen, I hope that my friend may come to know you through another Christian community of faith?" Do you deny that God works through non-Catholic communities of faith?

They might endanger souls but, they might endanger souls but... I don't see how you can say that yet continue on with your position or questions.

Again, this is just like praying "Lord please guide my friend to eat the cake without poison, but if he will not eat that cake have him eat the cake that will make him violently ill or kill him dead so he will not go hungry."

32 minutes ago, Peace said:

According to who? How do you know what God uses and what God does not use? How do you know that it was not God's will that I became a protestant on my way to becoming Catholic? Do you have some unique access to the divine will that I am not aware of?

Amos 5:21-24 gives a clear picture of how God feels about false worship of Him. Psalm 96:5 gives us a clear picture of how God feels about worship of false gods.

32 minutes ago, Peace said:

So then is it safe to assume that you believe that our Jewish brothers and sisters worship a devil?

No. As I stated before false religions are of two kinds, worship of false gods, or the false worship of the true God. Judaism rejects the true nature of God, due to it's rejection of Christ as God. So they give false worship to the one true God. The only Church that gives God true worship is the Catholic Church.

32 minutes ago, Peace said:

Well. Either that or you are wrong.

I am not.

Posted (edited)

@Peace I don't see the comparison in Islam and Protestant Churches. Protestants accept Christ as God. Islam doesn't. That is the spirit of the Antichrist is it not?

1 John 2:22 ►

Who is the liar? It is whoever denies that Jesus is the Christ. Such a person is the antichrist--denying the Father and the Son.

 

Edited by Guest
Posted

MATTHEW CH13 (Vatican Translation) 

"The kingdom of heaven may be likened to a man who sowed good seed in his field. While everyone was asleep his enemy came and sowed weeds 10 all through the wheat, and then went off. When the crop grew and bore fruit, the weeds appeared as well.

The slaves of the householder came to him and said, 'Master, did you not sow good seed in your field? Where have the weeds come from?' He answered, 'An enemy has done this.' His slaves said to him, 'Do you want us to go and pull them up?'

He replied, 'No, if you pull up the weeds you might uproot the wheat along with them.

Let them grow together until harvest; 11 then at harvest time I will say to the harvesters, "First collect the weeds and tie them in bundles for burning; but gather the wheat into my barn."'"

Posted (edited)

Knight,

I will try to get back to you later when I have time.

Best,
Peace

Edited by Peace
Posted

Popes and saints say all kinds of things. Wrong things, stupid things, or verbal mistakes they didn't mean to make. It would only bother me if this was being said ex cathedra. I mean he's not even pope any more. Never been into the "Saint quote" stuff. 

The picture is definitely photoshop though. I have the original (of the pope giving his blessing, no Koran in sight!) 

i think there does exist a black and white photo of the pope holding a Koran, it was a gift from somebody he was meeting, I think. Or a gift TO them. Anyway, not this photo. 

image_zpsqeteq3op.jpegJohn Paul kisses the Koran (you can see the official he was meeting with... He was trying to be polite I think)

Original prior to Photoshopping 

image_zpskqddtaaq.jpeg

dominicansoul
Posted

I took the prayer as a prayer for their conversion.  It was not taken that way by the majority of people, but I'm pretty sure St. John the Baptist knows what to do...

Posted

Knight,

Just to clarify a few things, I have no intention of praying for Islam. It is not on my bucket list of things to do. Nor am I specifically advocating that anyone else here do the same. But if St. John Paul II or anyone else decides to do so, I do not feel that I am in a position to assert that they are wrong. I would not be as quick as you are to condemn the statement he made because I do not think the issue is as black and white as you do. And I think that anyone who wants to make an assertion that other people’s actions constitute sin or are wrong carries the burden of proving that he is correct.

I will try to respond to your post the best that I can.

20 hours ago, KnightofChrist said:

When did something that is false, corrupt, or a lie become good?

Things that contain falsehoods, corruption, or lies can be considered good (and praiseworthy) because the common definition of “good” includes things that are not perfect.

You seem to equate the word “good” and the word “perfect”. I asked you whether this was the case in my previous post and you did not answer the question, so I can only assume that the answer is yes.  If your answer is not yes please let me know.

Based on your view of things, it would seem that if your young son scored a 99% on a math test, you would not think it right to say to him “Good job Johnny! You did an amesome job on the test”.  Seemingly under your logic because the test contains flaws, you could only say to your son “Johnny, you got one question wrong on the test. Therefore you smell of elderberries and your performance on the test smells of elderberries. If you want me to say that you did a good job, study harder next time and get 100% of the questions right.”

Is that what you would say to your son, or would you agree that things can be good even though they are not perfect? Or is there some other alternative that I have overlooked?

20 hours ago, KnightofChrist said:

The only moral and sane suggestion would be the cake without poison. Suggesting the other two for whatever reason would be immoral.

What you wrote may be true, but you have not presented any authoritative or logical reasons in support of your opinion. I think that I have already established here on the forum that I am not inclined to assent to things “just because Knight says it is so.” If you present any authoritative or logical reasons in support of your opinion, I will be happy to consider them.

Now, concerning the matter of birthday cakes, it just so happens that my birthday was a few months ago, and my girlfriend made me a birthday cake. It was quite delicious.

If you do a brief search online you will notice that drinking water contains trace amounts of Sodium Fluoride (NaF). Because some drinking water was used to make my birthday cake, I think that it reasonable to conclude that my birthday cake contained some trace amount of NaF.  Let’s say, for the sake of argument, that the birthday cake was 0.001% NaF.

On my birthday I said to my girlfriend “Thanks baby! What an amesome and delicious cake you made! Good job! I really appreciate it. I hope that I am lucky enough to have you make me a cake like this every year.”  Or something similar to that.

Now, if I hire a bunch of scientists and pay one million dollars, I am pretty sure that I can get them to make me a birthday cake with 0% NaF.  That is, they can bake me a perfect, NaF free birthday cake.

Apparently, according to your logic, what I should have said to my girlfriend was “what tha fonze is this baby? Are you trying to poison me with this 0.001% NaF birthday cake? This cake is no good babe. You have NaF mixed in with the chocolate filling and the vanilla icing so so the whole cake is a disaster. Come back with the perfect and true 0% NaF cake and then I will show you some love for your efforts.”

You would find that to be an unreasonable and ridiculous way to respond to my girlfriend, would you not?

But the only difference between my hypothetical and your hypothetical is that we are dealing with different numbers.  You say “you cannot call the 10% NaF cake good, because even though it is better than the 15% NaF cake, it is not perfect.”  I said “you cannot call the 0.001% NaF cake good because, even though it is better than the 10% NaF cake, it is not perfect.”  The principle and logic here is exactly the same.  The only thing that is different is the numbers.

So if you would find it ridiculous if I had told my girlfriend that the cake she made for me was not good, can you please explain why your statement concerning the cake should not also be considered ridiculous?

20 hours ago, KnightofChrist said:

Monotheism is true, so Monotheism can be praised, that the true God is the God of Abraham is true so that can be praised. But Islam is truth mixed with lies, it rejects the God of Israel for example. We cannot adopt a sort of dualism, believing we can praise something that is both true and false, good and evil. The Devil believes in monotheism, the devil believes God is the God of Abraham. The devil holds elements of truth, but should we praise the devil because he holds to elements of truth? No. But using your position for praising false religions, we can also praise the devil. Because the devil has elements of truth. 

My position is not that we should praise the devil, should anyone reading this be wondering if that is the case.  My position is also not that one should praise a thing (be it the devil, Islam, or otherwise) merely because it holds elements of truth or goodness.  Let’s say, for example, that Johnny comes home and shows me his math test, which has 10% and a big fat “F” written on the front in red.   I would certainly not say “Good job on the test Johnny my boy! Even though you got 90% wrong, you got 10 questions right. Let’s go out for ice cream”.  I would say “What a horrible test. Go up to your room, you are on punishment.” I do not know where the devil would score on our hypothetical measure of goodness, but I am guessing that his score would be a lot less than 10%.

Now, as for where Hinduism, Judaism, Southern Baptists, Eastern Orthodoxy, etc. fall on the scale, I have no strong opinions about. But I would tend to say that some of these religions are “good”, although imperfect. Many people have come to know the Lord through Orthodoxy, Southern Baptist beliefs, etc.

20 hours ago, KnightofChrist said:

Amos 5:21-24 gives a clear picture of how God feels about false worship of Him. Psalm 96:5 gives us a clear picture of how God feels about worship of false gods.

That may very well be true. But neither of those Bible verses specifically addresses or answers the questions that I asked you, and which you did not answer. I will ask them again (1) who says that God does not use false regions?  (2) How do you know that it was not God’s will that I became a protestant on my way to becoming Catholic?

Now, I also asked you whether you deny that God acts through non-Catholic communities of faith.  You also did not answer the question. I can only assume that your answer to this question is “no”, but if this is not the case please let me know.  As for me, I do not know for certain whether and the extent to which God uses non-Catholic religions and communities of faith. But I do not have any reason to rule out the possibility, nor have you provided any. 

And there are Church documents that indicate that God does.  For example:

http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_20000806_dominus-iesus_en.html
 

Quote

 

On the other hand, the ecclesial communities which have not preserved the valid Episcopate and the genuine and integral substance of the Eucharistic mystery,61 are not Churches in the proper sense; however, those who are baptized in these communities are, by Baptism, incorporated in Christ and thus are in a certain communion, albeit imperfect, with the Church.62 Baptism in fact tends per se toward the full development of life in Christ, through the integral profession of faith, the Eucharist, and full communion in the Church.63

“The Christian faithful are therefore not permitted to imagine that the Church of Christ is nothing more than a collection — divided, yet in some way one — of Churches and ecclesial communities; nor are they free to hold that today the Church of Christ nowhere really exists, and must be considered only as a goal which all Churches and ecclesial communities must strive to reach”.64 In fact, “the elements of this already-given Church exist, joined together in their fullness in the Catholic Church and, without this fullness, in the other communities”.65 “Therefore, these separated Churches and communities as such, though we believe they suffer from defects, have by no means been deprived of significance and importance in the mystery of salvation. For the spirit of Christ has not refrained from using them as means of salvation which derive their efficacy from the very fullness of grace and truth entrusted to the Catholic Church”.66

 

The document states right there that spirit of Christ uses non-Catholic communities of faith as a means for salvation. What do you have to say about it? Does that not indicate that God works through non-Catholic communities of faith? Is that an unreasonable conclusion to make?

20 hours ago, KnightofChrist said:

No. As I stated before false religions are of two kinds, worship of false gods, or the false worship of the true God. Judaism rejects the true nature of God, due to it's rejection of Christ as God. So they give false worship to the one true God. The only Church that gives God true worship is the Catholic Church.

The Eastern Orthodox Church gives God true worship. Are their Masses not valid? Is Christ not present in their Mass? Are we not allowed to attend their Mass under certain circumstances?

So it seems fairly clear to me that your statement that “the only Church that gives God true worship is the Catholic Church” is wrong. Please feel free to correct your statement.

If you go to any evangelical Church you might hear them sing a song that goes “Our God is an amesome God! He reigns from heaven above with wisdom, power and love! Our God is an amesome God!”  Now what about this, exactly, does not constitute true worship in your opinion? What about it is defective?

Lastly, concerning Islam specifically, you know exactly what the Catechism has to say on the matter, but I will repeat it here again for your reading enjoyment:

Quote

841 The Church's relationship with the Muslims. "The plan of salvation also includes those who acknowledge the Creator, in the first place amongst whom are the Muslims; these profess to hold the faith of Abraham, and together with us they adore the one, merciful God, mankind's judge on the last day."330

The Catechism plainly states that Muslims “with us” adore the one, merciful God.  So how exactly does this adoration, that the Muslims do “with us”, constitute worship of a false god or false worship of the true God?

21 hours ago, Josh said:

@Peace I don't see the comparison in Islam and Protestant Churches. Protestants accept Christ as God. Islam doesn't. That is the spirit of the Antichrist is it not?

1 John 2:22 ►

Who is the liar? It is whoever denies that Jesus is the Christ. Such a person is the antichrist--denying the Father and the Son.

 

Josh, I will try to get to this when I have time. I had a bit to chew on with Knight's post.

KnightofChrist
Posted

I attempted to reply point for point but my computer's wifi is not working. I will not even bother trying to do so on my phone. I will attempt to do so tomorrow.

However,  I will quote two authoritative sources Christ and Pope Pius XI (later if I am able I will provide other like sources)

 @Peace, Christ teaches us that " Whoever does not honor the Son does not honor the Father who sent him",  and "whoever rejects me rejects the one who sent me."

So how can someone truely accept and adore God the Father if they reject Christ as God or do not honor Christ as God? Christ, to me, clearly states it is not possible to truely honor or accept (truely worship) God the Father if they reject or do not honor God the Son. So, to me, it is clear that anyone who professes to believe in the God of Abraham yet rejects and does not honor Christ as God gives God the Father false worship.

As for finding false religons praiseworthy, Pope Pius XI in Mortalium Animos made it clear that is both dangerous and erroneous. 

"Certainly such attempts can nowise be approved by Catholics, founded
as they are on that false opinion which considers all religions to be more or less good and praiseworthy, since they all in
different ways manifest and signify that sense which is inborn in us all, and by which we are led to God and to the
obedient acknowledgment of His rule. Not only are those who hold this opinion in error and deceived, but also in
distorting the idea of true religion they reject it, and little by little, turn aside to naturalism and atheism, as it is called; from which it clearly follows that one who supports those who hold these theories and attempt to realize them, is altogether abandoning the divinely revealed religion."

source: http://w2.vatican.va/content/pius-xi/en/encyclicals/documents/hf_p-xi_enc_19280106_mortalium-animos.html

KnightofChrist
Posted

Also from Pope Pius XI in Mortalium Animos 

"The Catholic Church is alone in keeping the true worship. This is the fount of truth, this the house of Faith, this the temple of God: if any man enter not here, or if any man go forth from it, he is a stranger to the hope of life and salvation. "

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...