Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Can we please somehow get this guy elected president?


Recommended Posts

LittleWaySoul
Posted
53 minutes ago, Maggyie said:

The funny thing is he is an ex-Catholic. 

Really? Huh, didn't know that. Regardless, he's done pretty well in Ohio and he's moderate enough that I think he'd be good at both swaying centric/left centric voters to his side and at engaging Congress in a productive way. Alas...

Posted

Crisis averted. The American Solidarity Party doesn't oppose the sale of alcohol, simply the participation of the state in "legal vice" such as gambling, alcohol, or drugs. I suppose I could get behind that. 

Well, now I have a little political cardboard box to call home. Better than nothing. 

Posted
11 hours ago, Maggyie said:

I'm trying to find a third party candidate but so far they all seem like cranks. This Joe person has been running for prez forever on various tickets including the Green Party. The ASP platform is against selling alcohol. At this point I'm going to write in a name, probably my governor, John Kasich, who isn't perfect but who angers the right people on both the left and right. 

Kasich . . . I'd as soon vote for a pile of dog doo.

Quote

The ASP platform is against selling alcohol.

If true, they've lost me right there.

Posted
12 hours ago, Socrates said:

Kasich . . . I'd as soon vote for a pile of dog doo.

If true, they've lost me right there.

In their platform it says:

"We oppose the participation of public agencies in legal vices, such as gambling and the sake of recreational drugs and alcohol." So, reading closer, apparently they just don't want the government involved in that "vice."

Ash Wednesday
Posted

I've voted for Joe in the past. I'm in a solid blue state and especially being left with the Don and Hill, I'm definitely not "with her" and I don't trust Trump at all so I may find a 3rd party again.

 

This election got me like:

tumblr_nk99fhuymq1qhnoouo1_400.gif

 

Posted
On August 1, 2016 at 4:58 PM, Amppax said:

Crisis averted. The American Solidarity Party doesn't oppose the sale of alcohol, simply the participation of the state in "legal vice" such as gambling, alcohol, or drugs. I suppose I could get behind that. 

Well, now I have a little political cardboard box to call home. Better than nothing. 

You beat me to it :blush:

Posted

You know, I don't understand American elections. I know this is a huge generalisation, but the impression given is that Catholics will support anyone who opposes abortion, regardless of their other policies. If you care so much about human life get rid of the guns and provide free health care to those who can't afford it on their own.

Posted (edited)
2 hours ago, Anselm said:

You know, I don't understand American elections. I know this is a huge generalisation, but the impression given is that Catholics will support anyone who opposes abortion, regardless of their other policies. If you care so much about human life get rid of the guns and provide free health care to those who can't afford it on their own.

The "get rid of the guns" thing is not so simple (and I say this as someone who supports a certain amount of gun control). In the first place, the right to bear arms is a constitutional right here, and the way it's been interpreted in our law has been to allow for largely unregulated ownership of firearms. Firearms are a big part of our culture, for better or worse. To "get rid of guns" would most likely involve a constitutional amendment, and I doubt that could ever happen. Firearms are not intrinsically evil, and have plenty of legitimate uses (hunting, sports, legitimate self-defense). It is nowhere near as important a moral issue as abortion. 

Health care is a different debate, and one which I don't necessarily have enough knowledge of to get into. However, there's a big difference trying to do nationalized health care in a nation of 300 million+ and a smaller nation (such as Great Britain). I believe that our society could certainly do a better job in regards providing for those who are unable to provide these things for themselves. 

Edited by Amppax
Nihil Obstat
Posted

Healthcare is a massively complex issue, and 'universal health care' is not a magical be all end all solution. That is too shallow and simplistic. A true, substantive solution to the systemic problems in the American system would be/will be the work of multiple generations, in all likelihood.

PhuturePriest
Posted

Vote me and I will solve all of these problems. I have the solutions, and unlike these petty politicians, I will get them done without congress' help or consent.

Just send three easy payments of $1,000,0000 into my account beginning tomorrow and ending this weekend (PM me for account details) and I will be your political savior. As proof of my greatness, I will even negotiate with those who can't afford that amount in such a short time frame and instead opt for twelve easy payments of $500,000 over a period of two weeks.

Posted

I'm afraid that on this side of the Atlantic it just seems senseless to protect a right to carry lethal weapons when that results in huge numbers of deaths. So what if it's an American tradition? Thirty-odd people a day are shot in the U.S.; that's almost inconceivable to any other country in the world. The police in the U.S. shot and killed more people in the first 24 days of 2015 than the British police did in the preceding 24 YEARS. Three people were shot and killed by the police in Stockton, CA, in the first five months of that year. One person was shot and killed by the police in Iceland (which has a similar sized population) in the preceding 71 YEARS. that's just shootings by the police, not to mention those by actual criminals!

of course 'firearms aren't intrinsically evil', but take them away and the people who are can't use them. It's quite simple.

As for healthcare, yes it would be much more complex in a country with a much larger population but a) that's no reason not to try, and b) that's not the reason used by most people in the U.S. who object.

Ash Wednesday
Posted (edited)

Sorry Pham, I started to make this off topic. Please continue.

Edited by Ash Wednesday
Bad bad bad Meh!
LittleWaySoul
Posted
5 hours ago, PhuturePriest said:

Vote me and I will solve all of these problems. I have the solutions, and unlike these petty politicians, I will get them done without congress' help or consent.

Just send three easy payments of $1,000,0000 into my account beginning tomorrow and ending this weekend (PM me for account details) and I will be your political savior. As proof of my greatness, I will even negotiate with those who can't afford that amount in such a short time frame and instead opt for twelve easy payments of $500,000 over a period of two weeks.

:hehe: 

3 hours ago, Anselm said:

I'm afraid that on this side of the Atlantic it just seems senseless to protect a right to carry lethal weapons when that results in huge numbers of deaths. So what if it's an American tradition? Thirty-odd people a day are shot in the U.S.; that's almost inconceivable to any other country in the world. The police in the U.S. shot and killed more people in the first 24 days of 2015 than the British police did in the preceding 24 YEARS. Three people were shot and killed by the police in Stockton, CA, in the first five months of that year. One person was shot and killed by the police in Iceland (which has a similar sized population) in the preceding 71 YEARS. that's just shootings by the police, not to mention those by actual criminals!

of course 'firearms aren't intrinsically evil', but take them away and the people who are can't use them. It's quite simple.

While I tend to agree with most of this, and think we would be better off with less guns here, @Amppax makes a good point. A Constitutional right is nowhere near the same thing as an American tradition. It's part of our law and Bill of Rights, right up there with freedom of speech, religion, assembly, etc. Whether or not it should be there is a valid question, but the very fact that it is there makes it extremely unlikely that it will be changed or that guns will be taken away any time soon. Legally, it is considered a fundamental right of US citizens to own firearms. As Amp said, this won't change in the near future.

Other methods of restricting access to guns, on the other hand, are a different story. I personally hope the gun control discussion continues and we find ways to standardize regulation on the sale of guns across state borders and at both stores and gun shows. 

Posted

But the right itself is enshrined in an amendment; written constitutions can be and are changed. It is a human construction not a divinely ordained document, so if it does not serve the people it should be changed. The numbers of people killed by guns in the U.S. is horrific, it's scandalous and it is surely a Christian duty to work to reduce it by any morally justifiable means.

PhuturePriest
Posted
15 hours ago, Anselm said:

But the right itself is enshrined in an amendment; written constitutions can be and are changed. It is a human construction not a divinely ordained document, so if it does not serve the people it should be changed. The numbers of people killed by guns in the U.S. is horrific, it's scandalous and it is surely a Christian duty to work to reduce it by any morally justifiable means.

Sadly, no doubt due to Americanism and American protestantism whose identity was born from America and whose theology is inextricably linked with America, many protestants view the Constitution as divinely inspired. Glenn Beck said verbatim that the Declaration and the Constitution are divinely inspired by God. Ergo, guns are a God-given right, and restricting them for any means is hindering God's divine mandate to have all the guns you want.

KnightofChrist
Posted
15 hours ago, PhuturePriest said:

Sadly, no doubt due to Americanism and American protestantism whose identity was born from America and whose theology is inextricably linked with America, many protestants view the Constitution as divinely inspired. Glenn Beck said verbatim that the Declaration and the Constitution are divinely inspired by God. Ergo, guns are a God-given right, and restricting them for any means is hindering God's divine mandate to have all the guns you want.

 

16 minutes ago, Anselm said:

Urgh.

Not that you two would care, but there's a pretty strong historical case that the right to bear arms is profoundly Catholic.

http://www.davekopel.com/Religion/Catholic-Second-Amendment.pdf

Posted
33 minutes ago, KnightofChrist said:

 

Not that you two would care, but there's a pretty strong historical case that the right to bear arms is profoundly Catholic.

http://www.davekopel.com/Religion/Catholic-Second-Amendment.pdf

Huh. The thesis of that seems quite a bit like John Courtney Murray's thought regarding the US and Catholicism. Which is interesting, because he doesn't cite Murray at all. 

I'll take a look at it later, thanks Knight. 

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Posting here to remind myself to read that when not at work.

Posted
On 8/2/2016 at 11:22 AM, Maggyie said:

In their platform it says:

"We oppose the participation of public agencies in legal vices, such as gambling and the sake of recreational drugs and alcohol." So, reading closer, apparently they just don't want the government involved in that "vice."

I don't want the federal government involved in most things.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...