Anomaly Posted September 13, 2016 Posted September 13, 2016 (edited) I believe we are physical creatures of varying ability and a member of society. Either it is only the strong dominating the weak, or society struggles for all to coexist peacefully. It's illogical to sanction the death of an individual weaker than I when there are others stronger than myself. Empathy does not require Divine instruction. Edited September 13, 2016 by Anomaly
Amppax Posted September 13, 2016 Posted September 13, 2016 43 minutes ago, dominicansoul said: I would give you props if I wasn't out. I think most Catholics in this country are Democrats and I find it OUTRAGEOUS that they are. Instead of bellyaching about how horrible our candidates are this year, we should have been a powerful influence on our culture, be an endless champion for the unborn and force our politicians to put abortion front and center. Instead we bury our heads in the Democrat Donkey's behind and pretend we're doing it out of "social justice" concerns. How can anyone believe that anything good can come from a party who's sole objective is to get abortion on demand without excuses? This back and forth has been going on on phatmass for years, where I see "catholics" voting for democrats and trying to justify it with very weak arguments, then chide others for calling them out... Its no wonder we are where we are at as a country! Our Church is supposed to be out there fighting for the most vulnerable and poor. Yet, we think of them as an after thought and "not really the issue to base an entire vote on." Say what? What the hell is more important out there than the fact that every hour thousands of babies are being mercilessly slaughtered and their parts sold to the highest bidder? Why.aren't.we.outraged????? I'll tell you why, because most Catholics agree that abortion is necessary. Just ask my parish. 99 percent of them all voting Democrat, and conduct massive polling operations on behalf of the Democrat party. When knocking on doors in my neighborhood, they are called out for the stance on abortion, and I cringe when I hear them say, "We don't judge women for having abortions. We are Catholics. Abortion isn't an issue." Hyperbole much? Abortion is not the left's only concern. That's just nonsense. I have quite a few friends on that side of the political aisle, and the issue is rarely discussed, in my experience. Sure, it's part of the typical liberal agenda, but it's only one part. Also, there aren't thousands of babies aborted every hour in this country. That there are any aborted is an unspeakable horror, but there's only so much we can do about this politically, and most of that is done on the state level. You would be much better served to focus your efforts on that level of politics to make a difference, rather than lambast people who come to different conclusions about the presidential election.
ruso Posted September 13, 2016 Posted September 13, 2016 No vote, since I am not a US citizen. In Europe do nothing but criticize Trump, who we are outside the major parties, we think of Trump as the best candidate.
KnightofChrist Posted September 14, 2016 Posted September 14, 2016 (edited) 2 hours ago, Amppax said: Hyperbole much? Abortion is not the left's only concern. That's just nonsense. I have quite a few friends on that side of the political aisle, and the issue is rarely discussed, in my experience. Sure, it's part of the typical liberal agenda, but it's only one part. Also, there aren't thousands of babies aborted every hour in this country. That there are any aborted is an unspeakable horror, but there's only so much we can do about this politically, and most of that is done on the state level. You would be much better served to focus your efforts on that level of politics to make a difference, rather than lambast people who come to different conclusions about the presidential election. There is one element of Abortion that I believe allows for its continued acceptance in society. An element that allows people to rationalize voting for parties who treat it as a fundamental right. An element that allows or at least makes it easier for you to criticize Ds and myself for hyperboles and lambasting people. The element is the veil of Abortion, it's hidden away from our senses. If children were being murdered in the streets, out in the open where ever we would go, it would change everything. Having to wake up and go through the day seeing thousands of children being killed, having to hear their screams, and walk around or drive around the countless bodies, to see the pain on their faces, to smell their decomposing bodies, that would change everything. If that one element changed would society accept the mass murder of children? Would people rationalize voting for parties that treated the mass murder of children as a fundamental right? Would you so easily criticize Ds for 'thousands an hour' when technically she should have said per day? Would you so easily criticize Ds for 'lambasting' those that would still vote for a presidential candidate that would openly support and advocate the mass murder of children? I don't believe you would, not after seeing, hearing and smelling unveiled abortion, out in the open. I'm sorry to say it but I think many of us, myself included, would treat abortion as a far greater threat than we do now, and more as the threat that it is, it's just so hard to see its true wickedness because it is hidden away from our senses. Edited September 14, 2016 by KnightofChrist
dominicansoul Posted September 14, 2016 Posted September 14, 2016 1 hour ago, Amppax said: Hyperbole much? Abortion is not the left's only concern. That's just nonsense. I have quite a few friends on that side of the political aisle, and the issue is rarely discussed, in my experience. Sure, it's part of the typical liberal agenda, but it's only one part. Also, there aren't thousands of babies aborted every hour in this country. That there are any aborted is an unspeakable horror, but there's only so much we can do about this politically, and most of that is done on the state level. You would be much better served to focus your efforts on that level of politics to make a difference, rather than lambast people who come to different conclusions about the presidential election. For Planned Parenthood, elections are all about abortion. For Planned Parenthood, it's all about that one single issue. Seeing that this billion dollar industry is well taken care of and protected by the Democrat Party is proof enough that its the major part of their platform. The Democrat Party politicians and Planned Parenthood make lots and lots of $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ slaughtering babies. I don't agree that we can't do anything about abortion in a presidential election. Obama vetoed defunding Planned Parenthood. Abortion is a main staple of his "health care" mandate. I can't possibly understand why so many Catholics can't recognize this. I do agree that working to end abortion is more successful in the state's level, we pro-lifers have been very blessed in Texas. Planned Parenthood was struck down pretty hard and will have a great deal of time rebuilding itself up in our state. But they got help from their Democrat friends on the Supreme Court. Which is another reason why voting against Hilary is more important now than in any election. She will stack the court with democrats. As far as the thousands of babies aborted....I'm not speaking only of our country. The USA under a Democrat Party administration also helps other nations kill their unborn every hour... I'm not lambasting anybody, I'm bewailing the sad fact that Catholics push abortion aside and make like it's not the biggest issue out there. We need to make it our main issue. How can we sit by and allow this to continue and sit on our hands and say, "we can't do anything about this politically in a presidential election?" In my example, I pointed out the truth of my local parish. Sadly, they worked hard to try and help Wendy Davis get elected governor of our State. Do you know what Wendy Davis was known for? She fillibustered for 11 hours to keep the killing of 20 week old unborn babies legal in our state. Her nickname was "Abortion Barbie." And for this woman, Catholics in my state worked hard to try and get her elected. Thankfully, Governor Abbot won instead. (Ironically, he's our first Catholic governor in Texas' history.) Can you imagine if we Catholics were of all one mind against abortion and rallied behind this one issue, how fast our politicians would change their minds on it? If all Catholic voters demanded a truly prolife candidate, I am sure we would see more of them. A truly prolife Republican ticket where they actually do some damage to Planned Parenthood's stronghold on our policies would be a dream come true. Trump has a man running with him who is unapologetically prolife. I hope he can be the prolife voice in a Trump administration... Hilary's vice president pushes abortion to the side..."meh" to that issue, like most catholics do... I know that there are many issues that need to be addressed...but I think these are waaaaaaay secondary to abortion. Let's stop the bloody unborn baby sacrifices first, then we can truly find solutions to all our country's problems...
Anomaly Posted September 14, 2016 Posted September 14, 2016 I repeatedly here abortion referred to as "a women's right to chose". If society really wants to coexist and protect rights, then we must first protect the rights of the most vulnerable, the most voiceless. Before women in a male dominated society, before dark skinned in a light colored society, before foreigners escaping their homeland, are infants. They are the most silent, the weakest, the poorest, the least like us grown adults. We can afford to not give them any rights. They aren't human yet like the sick, infirm, and old aren't human anymore. Saying there are too many of them, they aren't mentioned, they aren't seen or discussed, they don't vote, they can't contribute to society, they can't beg, bully, wheedle or whine is frightening. They are a burden, unwelcome interlopers, inconvenient, not really human, destined for misery. Could that not be us in old age, suffering an illness or accident, the bad luck of a few proteins in our DNA? A spider could never be me or you. A zygote could. We all can be aged and/or infirm. An atheist can rationally identify with and have empathy for the unborn without divine decree instructing them to. I empahize with a large dose of selfishness. I hope for a pleasant 80-90 years and then I exist no more. To obtain that while I'm not dominating and strongest, I want a society that protects everyone. I'm okay with giving to get. You Catholics know you must first do for the least. Your Supreme Being God demands it if you or suffer eternal torture for failure. Who is the least this God of yours means? The least that can thank you? The least that you can't ignore? It is the Democrat Party that makes abortion protection a priority and a protectected "women's right" a Plank of their political platform. The masses are bamboozled and go along with it so now, it's politically inconvenient for everyone, even Republicans. How stupid to point at the failures of Republicans who don't have the political power to change or effectively contest Democrats, and then give MORE power to pro-abortion political party. What do you think will happen? Trump smells of elderberries a lot! At least he owes something to the political party that is not pro-abortion. At least he can have a running mate that is somewhat anti-abortion. Pay attention to your local state and federal politicians, senators, congressmen. Support ones that aren't pro-abortion. It isn't all about the Presidential race, but the Presidential race is important too.
Peace Posted September 14, 2016 Author Posted September 14, 2016 1 hour ago, KnightofChrist said: There is one element of Abortion that I believe allows for its continued acceptance in society. An element that allows people to rationalize voting for parties who treat it as a fundamental right. An element that allows or at least makes it easier for you to criticize Ds and myself for hyperboles and lambasting people. The element is the veil of Abortion, it's hidden away from our senses. If children were being murdered in the streets, out in the open where ever we would go, it would change everything. Having to wake up and go through the day seeing thousands of children being killed, having to hear their screams, and walk around or drive around the countless bodies, to see the pain on their faces, to smell their decomposing bodies, that would change everything. If that one element changed would society accept the mass murder of children? Would people rationalize voting for parties that treated the mass murder of children as a fundamental right? Would you so easily criticize Ds for 'thousands an hour' when technically she should have said per day? Would you so easily criticize Ds for 'lambasting' those that would still vote for a presidential candidate that would openly support and advocate the mass murder of children? I don't believe you would, not after seeing, hearing and smelling unveiled abortion, out in the open. I'm sorry to say it but I think many of us, myself included, would treat abortion as a far greater threat than we do now, and more as the threat that it is, it's just so hard to see its true wickedness because it is hidden away from our senses. The lecture continues. Trump advocates torture. If you saw men being tortured in the streets would that prevent you from voting for Trump? Apparently not. Therefore you have rationalized voting for torture. And that is vile and despicable.
Peace Posted September 14, 2016 Author Posted September 14, 2016 46 minutes ago, Anomaly said: A spider could never be me or you. A zygote could. We all can be aged and/or infirm. An atheist can rationally identify with and have empathy for the unborn without divine decree instructing them to. I empahize with a large dose of selfishness. I hope for a pleasant 80-90 years and then I exist no more. To obtain that while I'm not dominating and strongest, I want a society that protects everyone. I'm okay with giving to get. OK. But so what? What makes your, mine, or any human life any more valuable than a spider? Because humans are created in the image and likeness of God, and because humans are especially loved by God, while spiders are not, perhaps? And why should you empathize with anyone? Other animals do not empathize, and from a strictly atheistic standpoint humans are simply another animal. And why should a society protect everyone? Where does that idea come from? You, as an atheist, do not have any logical reasons for asserting that those things should be done, do you? And who cares whether you get 80-90 years of a pleasant life, and cease to exist, or get 6 months of a torturous life, and cease to exist? The outcome is exactly the same in either case. That is, in either case your life is objectively meaningless, if atheism is true. So why should you, me, or anyone else care about whether your life is pleasant or not? 46 minutes ago, Anomaly said: You Catholics know you must first do for the least. Your Supreme Being God demands it if you or suffer eternal torture for failure. Who is the least this God of yours means? The least that can thank you? The least that you can't ignore? He is your God as well. And He exists. You know that as well, but you just refuse to acknowledge it. You know very well that your inner sense of morality comes from your Creator in Heaven. Hopefully your denial of this will not be to your peril, but I would advise you to think about your decision to refuse to acknowledge your Creator yet again. As far as the rest of what you wrote, yes, I agree. We should try our best to end abortion.
LittleWaySoul Posted September 14, 2016 Posted September 14, 2016 18 minutes ago, Peace said: OK. But so what? What makes your, mine, or any human life any more valuable than a spider? Because humans are created in the image and likeness of God, and because humans are especially loved by God, while spiders are not, perhaps? And why should you empathize with anyone? Other animals do not empathize, and from a strictly atheistic standpoint humans are simply another animal. And why should a society protect everyone? Where does that idea come from? You, as an atheist, do not have any logical reasons for asserting that those things should be done, do you? And who cares whether you get 80-90 years of a pleasant life, and cease to exist, or get 6 months of a torturous life, and cease to exist? The outcome is exactly the same in either case. That is, in either case your life is objectively meaningless, if atheism is true. So why should you, me, or anyone else care about whether your life is pleasant or not? He is your God as well. And He exists. You know that as well, but you just refuse to acknowledge it. You know very well that your inner sense of morality comes from your Creator in Heaven. Hopefully your denial of this will not be to your peril, but I would advise you to think about your decision to refuse to acknowledge your Creator yet again. All due respect, but let's try to keep the conversation political. Ending abortion, from what I know of our political and cultural system, is a complex issue that needs to be addressed at all levels of society. While republicans tend to be pro life in the sense that they are against abortion, often they forget all of the surrounding issues which also support higher abortion rates. They forget that this is not just about changing laws, but changing hearts. Much work has to be done on the grassroots level. That's not to say that voting for someone blatantly pro-choice is a good idea, but I think that republicans often have extreme tunnel vision when it comes to this issue. There are so many things that would decrease the rate of abortions that I think both parties could/should get behind. But there needs to be a balance. Normally I would unquestionably vote for the most pro-life person for reasons expressed above. This time, however, I believe we are in a desperate situation which makes me extremely unsure of what I will do come November. There are lives on the line here, and not only if Clinton wins. Being pro-life means having a consistent pro life ethic, and I sometimes think that Trump's statements and ideas on the whole are much more reflective of the culture of death than Clinton's are. That doesn't mean I'm not authentically pro life. That doesn't mean I haven't considered whether or not my thoughts would be different if abortion were a more visible and prominent reality. I assure you, I and others here have likely given this a LOT of thought. I for one say none of this lightly or flippantly. I am genuinely and sincerely conflicted, pro-life and all. As Pope Benedict said: "When a Catholic does not share a candidate’s stand in favor of abortion and/or euthanasia, but votes for that candidate for other reasons, it is considered remote material cooperation, which can be permitted in the presence of proportionate reasons." I am seriously considering the possibility that preventing a Trump presidency could be a proportionate reason to vote Clinton. However, once again, I am extremely conflicted here.
Peace Posted September 14, 2016 Author Posted September 14, 2016 1 minute ago, LittleWaySoul said: All due respect, but let's try to keep the conversation political. You must not be familiar with Unofficial Phatmass Rule #367, Subsection 5: The person who creates a thread may derail it as he pleases.
LittleWaySoul Posted September 14, 2016 Posted September 14, 2016 7 minutes ago, Peace said: You must not be familiar with Unofficial Phatmass Rule #367, Subsection 5: The person who creates a thread may derail it as he pleases. Ha! Then I ask you, o thread-creator, to keep it political for my sake, just so this doesn't get complex and confusing with multiple debates going on at once.
Anomaly Posted September 14, 2016 Posted September 14, 2016 Only I can try to make my life special or meaningful to me. Or not. Whether you believe your God threatens you with eternal as motivation, or I rationalize it. We both have the same challenge. To try to do what we think is best as an individual and a member of a society.
Socrates Posted September 14, 2016 Posted September 14, 2016 (edited) PM, Peace said: Yes. Okay . . . Alrighty then . . . To summarize: Clinton packing the courts with leftist rubber-stampers: pretty much certain. Trump launching a nuclear holocaust: Extremely unlikely. It seems you've concocted a fantastical "phantom menace" to justify defending the indefensible. (And I'm the one who's "paranoid"? Jeez.) Quote Perhaps you are correct. Or you could just be another paranoid conservative who says the same thing anytime any Democrat is elected. Time will tell. It's not paranoia. It's realism and basic math. Just to clarify, I don't think Hillary's nominations to the Supreme and federal courts would be significantly worse than Obama's or those of any similar leftist statist Democrat, but the fact is that there are now more leftists and fewer constitutionalists on these courts now than when Obama first took office, or even four years ago. On the SCOTUS, there are now only two solid constitutionalist conservatives, Thomas and Alito; one fairly liberal Republican nominee, Kennedy; another highly unreliable "conservative," Roberts; and the remaining four are all left-wing Dem nominees who vote as block. One more Obama or Hillary nominated justice would tip the court's balance solidly leftist. And the SCOTUS has already recently made a number of horrible rulings, including on Obamacare's contraceptive mandate, the enforcement of same-sex "marriage" on the states, and striking down Texas's regulations on abortion mills. Things will only get much worse with a Dem-nominated majority on the Court. (I know you support at least some of those, and I see no need to rehash the arguments. I also know you and your ilk will probably approve of whatever unjust and unconstitutional decisions the SCOTUS makes in the future, and deride conservative criticism as crazy and paranoid.) About 40% of federal judges are now Obama appointees, and this percentage could rise to as much as 80% with eight years of Hillary. Quote Do you mean besides gutting the public option from his health care bill, refusing to even hold a vote on Garland, and shutting down the government just for the hell of it? Oooh, that awful, awful "government shut-down"! How'd we ever survive? But you know darn well your Dear Leader got essentially everything he wanted. Edited September 14, 2016 by Socrates
Peace Posted September 14, 2016 Author Posted September 14, 2016 21 minutes ago, Anomaly said: Only I can try to make my life special or meaningful to me. Or not. Whether you believe your God threatens you with eternal as motivation, or I rationalize it. We both have the same challenge. To try to do what we think is best as an individual and a member of a society. It kind of saddens me that you view Catholicism as a religion that threatens people with eternal damnation as motivation to do good. That is not really what it is about, but you seem to have gotten that impression by whomever it was that exposed you to the faith. 17 minutes ago, Socrates said: Okay . . . Alrighty then . . . To summarize: Clinton packing the courts with leftist rubber-stampers: pretty much certain. Trump launching a nuclear holocaust: Extremely unlikely. Please. Trump will not be any better than Clinton when it comes to appointing conservative justices. He is not a conservative and both you and I know it. If you think that he is putting anyone on that list, which he has never even looked at, on the Supreme Court, I have some snow to sell you this winter. 17 minutes ago, Socrates said: It seems you've concocted a fantastical "phantom menace" to justify defending the indefensible. Please. You know very well that my comments were not limited to a "nuclear holocaust". He has openly come out and said that he advocates torture, and the killing of innocent people. Nor does he have any demonstrated knowledge of military or foreign affairs whatsoever. Go ahead and vote for him if that pleases you. I have no intention of voting for either of them, which I already indicated at the top of page of this thread. 17 minutes ago, Socrates said: (And I'm the one who's "paranoid"? Jeez.) I do not know whether you are paranoid. But if it walks like a duck, talks like a duck, and quacks like a duck, it is likely a duck. 17 minutes ago, Socrates said: It's not paranoia. It's realism and basic math. Just to clarify, I don't think Hillary's nominations to the Supreme and federal courts would be significantly worse than Obama's or those of any similar leftist statist Democrat, but the fact is that there are now more leftists and fewer constitutionalists on these courts now than when Obama first took office, or even four years ago. On the SCOTUS, there are now only two solid constitutionalist conservatives, Thomas and Alito; one fairly liberal Republican nominee, Kennedy; another highly unreliable "conservative," Roberts; and the remaining four are all left-wing Dem nominees who vote as block. One more Obama or Hillary nominated justice would tip the court's balance solidly leftist. Correction: One more Obama, Hillary, or Trump nominated justice would tip the court's balance solidly leftist. Please check your math. 17 minutes ago, Socrates said: And the SCOTUS has already recently made a number of horrible rulings, including on Obamacare's contraceptive mandate, the enforcement of same-sex "marriage" on the states, and striking down Texas's regulations on abortion mills. Things will only get much worse with a Dem-nominated majority on the Court. (I know you support at least some of those, and I see no need to rehash the arguments. I am not sure what you mean. I do not support a contraceptive mandate, the enforcement of same-sex marriage on the state, or striking down the regulations on the abortion mills. But you should know that by now. Perhaps by support you meant, "I do not agree with those decisions"? 17 minutes ago, Socrates said: I also know you and your ilk will probably approve of whatever unjust and unconstitutional decisions the SCOTUS makes in the future, and deride conservative criticism as crazy and paranoid.) Who are me and my ilk? You seem to think Marc Rubio is a bleeding heart liberal. I doubt that you would even vote for Ronald Reagan if he were running today. As for approving "whatever unjust decisions", I have no idea what you are talking about. I do not support any of the things you mention above. And I think that Thomas is probably the best justice on the court, and has been for many years now. As for you being crazy and paranoid, please refer to my duck comment above. You seem to be living in some kind of a conservative fantasy-land where everyone who does not agree with you lock and step on every issue must be in line with Bernie Sanders. Well, just to clarify, here in this place that we like to refer to as "the Earth", otherwise known as "reality", people need not be limited to one of two extremes. People can in fact and do exist in the middle. Please make note of it for future reference. 17 minutes ago, Socrates said: Oooh, that awful, awful "government shut-down"! How'd we ever survive? But you know darn well your Dear Leader got essentially everything he wanted. He did not get the public option, the key aspect of his Health-Care bill. Nor did he hardly get through any other major legislation during his 8 years in office. He did get some financial reform legislation through, and a stimulus package at the beginning of his term that basically built off of what Bush proposed, from what I recall. What exactly is this "everything he wanted"?
Ice_nine Posted September 14, 2016 Posted September 14, 2016 I find it really irritating that people keep going on about how horrible abortion is. WE PRETTY MUCH ALL AGREE THERE. I mean unless Hassan or SilverPhinx walks in here . . . And actually, I take that back. That's not what I find irritating. What I find irritating is the insinuation that just because someone doesn't agree that Trump might be worse than Hillary, must NOT realize what an epic travesty abortion is. It is one of the most important issues I consider when voting. But it is among other human rights issues. The suffering of post-born people matter to me too. I guess that makes me a horrible Christian. I am genuinely concerned about what Trump would do to people. I honestly don't think it's out of the realm of possibility that Trump would resort to nuclear warfare if given the opportunity. He has been on the record as saying we should kill the families of terrorists. It makes me think he doesn't really give a you know what about slaughtering innocents outside of the country, whether some of they are out of the womb or still in it. I think nuclear war is worse than abortion. You're all welcome to disagree, but I don't think it's an entirely unreasonable or unchristian thing to say. You're also welcome to say that you don't think there is a considerably higher risk that Trump will push the big red button, but since none of us are clairvoyant, our opinions on that are not verifiable. We don't hear the cries of the unborn, but often I don't think we hear the cries of people who live thousands of miles away. They can feel pain too. And lots of them don't deserve to be blown up. God have mercy.
Peace Posted September 14, 2016 Author Posted September 14, 2016 5 hours ago, Ice_nine said: I think nuclear war is worse than abortion. Aha! You support abortion, you vile and sick human being. . .
Anomaly Posted September 14, 2016 Posted September 14, 2016 "Please. Trump will not be any better than Clinton when it comes to appointing conservative justices. He is not a conservative and both you and I know it. If you think that he is putting anyone on that list, which he has never even looked at, on the Supreme Court, I have some snow to sell you this winter." Trump and Hillary can't help but cooperate with their Party's political machine. There are some checks to what they can do. Yes, Trump can (and may have to) have to nominate relatively more conservative persons for the SC to appease the voter base. Hillary cannot afford to (and ostensibly not want to) do anything that restricts a "women's right" to expell a cyst. And yes, living in Florida, I'd be happy to purchase snow if delivered in good snow condition at a reasonable rate. 7 hours ago, Ice_nine said: I find it really irritating that people keep going on about how horrible abortion is. WE PRETTY MUCH ALL AGREE THERE. I mean unless Hassan or SilverPhinx walks in here . . . And actually, I take that back. That's not what I find irritating. What I find irritating is the insinuation that just because someone doesn't agree that Trump might be worse than Hillary, must NOT realize what an epic travesty abortion is. It is one of the most important issues I consider when voting. But it is among other human rights issues. The suffering of post-born people matter to me too. I guess that makes me a horrible Christian. I am genuinely concerned about what Trump would do to people. I honestly don't think it's out of the realm of possibility that Trump would resort to nuclear warfare if given the opportunity. He has been on the record as saying we should kill the families of terrorists. It makes me think he doesn't really give a you know what about slaughtering innocents outside of the country, whether some of they are out of the womb or still in it. I think nuclear war is worse than abortion. You're all welcome to disagree, but I don't think it's an entirely unreasonable or unchristian thing to say. You're also welcome to say that you don't think there is a considerably higher risk that Trump will push the big red button, but since none of us are clairvoyant, our opinions on that are not verifiable. We don't hear the cries of the unborn, but often I don't think we hear the cries of people who live thousands of miles away. They can feel pain too. And lots of them don't deserve to be blown up. God have mercy. I disagree that killing less people is worse than killing more infants. I'm certainly not judging your quality of Catholicism as much as I'm judging your quality of rationalism.
MIKolbe Posted September 14, 2016 Posted September 14, 2016 29 minutes ago, Anomaly said: And yes, living in Florida, I'd be happy to purchase snow if delivered in good snow condition at a reasonable rate. We need to talk.
Peace Posted September 14, 2016 Author Posted September 14, 2016 (edited) 36 minutes ago, Anomaly said: "Please. Trump will not be any better than Clinton when it comes to appointing conservative justices. He is not a conservative and both you and I know it. If you think that he is putting anyone on that list, which he has never even looked at, on the Supreme Court, I have some snow to sell you this winter." Trump and Hillary can't help but cooperate with their Party's political machine. There are some checks to what they can do. Yes, Trump can (and may have to) have to nominate relatively more conservative persons for the SC to appease the voter base. Hillary cannot afford to (and ostensibly not want to) do anything that restricts a "women's right" to expell a cyst. That's fine. You put more faith in Mr. Trump than I do. I will concede you, for the sake of argument, that there is a 2% better chance that Supreme Court justices appointed under Trump will be better than Clinton. None of you folks can say with any confidence that Trump will put good justices on the Supreme Court, or do anything positive to limit abortion. The best that you folks have said is "Well hey. I know that he is terrible, but at least there is some slight possibility that he might do something good." This is really what would lead you to vote for one person over another? The point, which I have made before, is that that although Trump may be slightly better than Clinton on abortion, one need not vote based on the issue of abortion ONLY because both candidates are terrible on the issue (which everyone here concedes). Because they are both terrible on that issue, it is acceptable for a voter to take into account Trump's various forms of racism, xenophobia, advocacy of torture, violence and killing of innocent people, blatant sexism, making fun of people with disabilities, complete lack of experience or knowledge of anything relating to foreign policy or military affairs, constantly changing opinions, etc., when deciding who to vote for. I do not see what is so difficult to understand about this. If someone concludes that overall Trump is the lesser of two evils because of the things mentioned above, it does not mean that the person desires the mass murder of thousands of babies. Just like if you conclude that Trump is the lesser of two evils because he (in your opinion) is better concerning abortion, does not mean that you are a racist xenophobe that advocates torture. That is the point. Edited September 14, 2016 by Peace
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now