Socrates Posted September 19, 2016 Posted September 19, 2016 What's wrong with being happy? I'm confused.
dominicansoul Posted September 19, 2016 Posted September 19, 2016 11 hours ago, Socrates said: What's wrong with being happy? I'm confused. I'm almost positive the Church wants us all to be gay. Especially in times of trials and sufferings...
Ice_nine Posted September 19, 2016 Posted September 19, 2016 On 9/17/2016 at 5:58 PM, Hasan said: Some people think it is 'ok' to 'be gay' but others disagree. How does the Church come down (no pun intended) on this issue? your mom is gay
Peace Posted September 19, 2016 Posted September 19, 2016 On 9/18/2016 at 11:18 AM, IgnatiusofLoyola said: Hasan may not be Catholic, but he knows a heck of a lot about Catholic theology--possibly even more than you. I'm not calling you uneducated, I'm just saying that because Hasan is older than you are, he has had more years to learn Catholic theology--you'll catch up. I've got my money on Jack4.
Selah Posted September 19, 2016 Posted September 19, 2016 (edited) On 9/18/2016 at 10:48 AM, Jack4 said: I agree with the last sentence; yet I hold on to what I said. The following are from a theologian friend (who is faithful to the Church): This is not the teaching of the Church. What your friend espouses is more in line with reformed christianity, such as calvinism which is rejected by the church. In the nicest way possible, your friend is misinformed. Especially in Eastern Churches, hell is understood as being hell because of the person's rejection of God. Fire refines, or it burns. To the saved, it refines, but to the damned it burns. The fire stays fire. It's the condition of the person that makes it heaven or hell. Fire is God's love, and it is wonderful to the saved and terrible to the lost. God will love all people for eternity, but not everyone enjoys it. On the other hand, reformed Christianity teaches that the fire is the wrath of God. John Calvin especially taught this, but his entire system of theology was rejected by the Church. Everything you have posted from your friend, down to "the elect" is Calvinism and not in line with church teaching. We are not called to hate anyone, not even the damned. Edited September 19, 2016 by Selah
Norseman82 Posted September 20, 2016 Posted September 20, 2016 (edited) 23 hours ago, Socrates said: What's wrong with being happy? I'm confused. Because somebody had to post it: Edited September 20, 2016 by Norseman82
Amppax Posted September 20, 2016 Posted September 20, 2016 4 hours ago, Selah said: This is not the teaching of the Church. What your friend espouses is more in line with reformed christianity, such as calvinism which is rejected by the church. In the nicest way possible, your friend is misinformed. Especially in Eastern Churches, hell is understood as being hell because of the person's rejection of God. Fire refines, or it burns. To the saved, it refines, but to the damned it burns. The fire stays fire. It's the condition of the person that makes it heaven or hell. Fire is God's love, and it is wonderful to the saved and terrible to the lost. God will love all people for eternity, but not everyone enjoys it. On the other hand, reformed Christianity teaches that the fire is the wrath of God. John Calvin especially taught this, but his entire system of theology was rejected by the Church. Everything you have posted from your friend, down to "the elect" is Calvinism and not in line with church teaching. We are not called to hate anyone, not even the damned. Though I largely agree with what you have here, there is quite a bit in what Jack4 had (the part from his "friend") which is, in certain respects, in line with a possible reading of Augustinian and Thomistic theological traditions. I would argue that it isn't either authentically Augustinian or Thomistic, but that's a different debate. That being said, what is there is, from an Eastern Catholic perspective, totally off. I'm not as familiar with the rites from India as the Byzantine rites, but it sounds far too western to be in line with Eastern theology.
Jack4 Posted September 20, 2016 Posted September 20, 2016 That friend is a Latin Church Catholic. He is a Thomist, and has some formal degree. I don't believe he would knowingly reject the teaching of the Church. Is there anything you want to tell him?
Guest Posted September 20, 2016 Posted September 20, 2016 Does God have human emotions? This is what a poster had to state over at CA (Thread Title: "Does God Hate?") (Scroll down to #2 - it gave me a smile as well here ) Actually, New Advent had some interesting things to say : (Anthropomorphism) http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/01558c.htm Excerpt only: "The Scriptures themselves amply warn us against the mistake of interpreting their figurative language in too literal a sense. They teach that God is spiritual, omniscient, invisible, omnipresent, ineffable. Insistence upon the literal interpretation of the metaphorical led to the error of the Anthropomorphites." __________________________ PRIVATE VOWS http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/topic/132845-home-mass-private-vows/ Vocation of The Laity – An Office of The Church HERE
Jack4 Posted September 20, 2016 Posted September 20, 2016 Barb., Selah and others, we would be wasting our time without first having answers to two questions. Define love. Define hate.
Guest Posted September 20, 2016 Posted September 20, 2016 Jimmy Akin "Does God Hate Sinners?" HERE Excerpt only: "This has led Christians to recognize that when Scripture talks about things as if God is suffering that it is not meant to be taken literally. That we have a truth being expressed, but it is not to be understood as if God were experiencing these things the way we do. As if He experienced anger, sadness, sorrow, frustration, impatience, or other negative emotions that occasionally ascribed to God in the language of the Bible in particularly of the Old Testament. These are expressions of truths but they’re accommodated to our human understanding of things. To use a fancy term, they’re anthropomorphic expressions. They make God sound as if He were human, when in fact He’s not. "............ ............."That’s the fundamental thing we need to keep in mind in analyzing all of these passages. We to recognize that when Scripture talks about God hating things, it’s expressing a profound truth about the reality of sin and the fact that we need to avoid it. It’s not expressing the idea that God ‘has it out for sinners’ and that He’s just looking to punish them. On the contrary, He’s looking to save them. He’s so willing to save them that He gave His own Son for all of us while we were yet sinners."
Jack4 Posted September 20, 2016 Posted September 20, 2016 5 hours ago, BarbaraTherese said: LOVE HATE Can you quote from the relevant sections in these articles articles where a clear definition is given? 5 hours ago, BarbaraTherese said: Jimmy Akin "Does God Hate Sinners?" HERE Excerpt only: "This has led Christians to recognize that when Scripture talks about things as if God is suffering that it is not meant to be taken literally. That we have a truth being expressed, but it is not to be understood as if God were experiencing these things the way we do. As if He experienced anger, sadness, sorrow, frustration, impatience, or other negative emotions that occasionally ascribed to God in the language of the Bible in particularly of the Old Testament. These are expressions of truths but they’re accommodated to our human understanding of things. To use a fancy term, they’re anthropomorphic expressions. They make God sound as if He were human, when in fact He’s not. "............ ............."That’s the fundamental thing we need to keep in mind in analyzing all of these passages. We to recognize that when Scripture talks about God hating things, it’s expressing a profound truth about the reality of sin and the fact that we need to avoid it. It’s not expressing the idea that God ‘has it out for sinners’ and that He’s just looking to punish them. On the contrary, He’s looking to save them. He’s so willing to save them that He gave His own Son for all of us while we were yet sinners." Jimmy Akin seems to speak about living sinners, wayfarers. My friend had the damned in mind.
Peace Posted September 20, 2016 Posted September 20, 2016 4 hours ago, Jack4 said: Can you quote from the relevant sections in these articles articles where a clear definition is given? Jimmy Akin seems to speak about living sinners, wayfarers. My friend had the damned in mind. Hmm. In you and your friend's seemingly speculative theology, does God also hate those who will be damned before their final judgement (in other words, while they are still wayfarers)? If what you assume is true I don't see why God would not also hate them from the moment of their conception, since He knows their ultimate fate even before they are born. If that is the case, that is, if God hates these folks from the beginning, why would He send Jesus to die for them? You would seemingly end up with Calivinistic limited atonement, which I think the Church rejects. I don't understand these issues very well, but how does your theology not lead to Calvinism?
Guest Posted September 21, 2016 Posted September 21, 2016 (edited) 10 hours ago, Jack4 said: Jimmy Akin seems to speak about living sinners, wayfarers. My friend had the damned in mind Jack, what JA addresses first in his quotation is anthropormorphism which, with reflection, responds to your friend's comments about God having hatred for anything at any time, or at any point - either living or dead including those in hell. I do not have means of researching your source (your friend), however Jimmy Akin is easily researched and is regarded as a reliable and sound Catholic apologist. He is a senior apologist on Catholic Answers. Re your request for short summary of "Love" and "Hate" :- Likewise, the same quotation from JA, with reflection on his comments on anthropormorphism, means that love and hate are human experiences only in our context and, as such, are complex. The articles I quoted go into that complexity; hence to understand love and hate as human experiences, you need to read the articles. The article on "Hate" is quite short, the one on "Love" is longer but worth the read as it does go into the complexity of human love - that type of love we can experience and the type of love (agape) to which we aspire. Edited September 21, 2016 by BarbaraTherese
Guest Posted September 21, 2016 Posted September 21, 2016 Since Scripture tells us "God is Love" (1 John 1:8), the article I posted on "Love" does go into agape, which is not a feeling but an act of the will. Does God Love the Souls in Hell? Then Why Do They Suffer? This blog comes from The Archdiocese of Washington as source. It is lengthy, but it goes into all questions related to God's Love and the souls in Hell - I thought so anyway.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now