Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Speaking of mental illness, moral choices can be quite screwed up. BarbaraTherese


Recommended Posts

IgnatiusofLoyola
Posted
49 minutes ago, CatherineM said:

The first time we presented to seminarians several years ago, their formation director had spent time at the large mental health hospital as a chaplain. We played an auditory recreation of what the voices sound like for schizophrenics. He looked shocked and then went white. First realization of what they were going through. A couple of Filipino seminarians looked like they were going to pass out. 

I continue to be impressed by the work you do!

I wish there was a way to teach people what major depression feels like or what a panic attack feels like. I think that afterwards there would be no question in their minds that this was something physical, not a character defect.

Posted

Thank you again, Catherine - and for all you are doing.  I agree with IgnatiusOL - that we need to find the language to communicate the suffering of MI and MI right across the board.  If sufferers of any kind of MI were not so fearful of stigma (including attitudes of "character defect")and talked openly about their condition, things might improve.  Although I do think there is more willingness to communicate than before, but it seems to me to be mainly only where depression is concerned, which is a valid MI.  Again, it can be a case of the 'right' words are becoming known and accepted, while in the day to day sufferers can still experience rejection and stigma.

We do know that the biggest hurdle a sufferer is going to have to cope with is stigma.  From stigma flows more major problems: rejection, isolation and loneliness.  From that, of course, can come a sense of meaningless, lack of self esteem and confidence, hopelessness.

It is horrific what people who suffer schizophrenia go through and many of them most of 24x7........ and this includes rejection and abandonment on the human level.  It is a difficult, even impossible, frame of mind for those who have never experienced it - and education is the answer even shock value if it helps - and I think if one is going to be educated about the facts of MI, there will be shock.  I do think that in the minds of many it is fear that triggers rejection and/or abandonment.

In my previous suburb I knew quite a few sufferers/visitors with serious schizophrenia.  I never had problems with any of them due to violence or the likelihood of violence - whereas, I had teenagers also visit (not suffering MI) and sometimes I needed to ask someone(s) to leave.  That is not to state that sufferers of schizophrenia do not commit violence.

 Because of media, you will read headlines similar to: "Schizophrenic stabs and murders..............." but never headlines that state similar to "Completely normal person stabs and murders........"   Hence, fear of sufferers of MI is generated and affirmed, confirmed as valid.

It is not to state that those who suffer schizophrenia are incapable of violence - they are just as capable as any other person; however, their reasons for the violence/non social behaviour is at times totally non understandable, or unreal - disconnected from reality. An indication on another level of how in psychotic states, moral choices might be all screwed up.  Not unusual for fellow human beings to refuse to accept this - but The Lord certainly does.

In psychotic states, there can be the ordinary everyday type of reality whereas the sufferer can be living a totally different reality - TOTALLY, nothing to do with ordinary everyday reality.  Totally different.  The same can apply with depression, I think.  The sufferer experiences reality in a totally different way to a non sufferer.  To the sufferer, the whole of reality is screwed up compared to the most common or 'normal' experience of the same reality.  However in the depressed state, what is experienced as the reality - is experienced as very real.

I once had a psychiatrist say to me "You know it is not real".  Bit of silly thing to say.  To me (psychotic state) it was very real - it was he that had the problem and out of step with what was real. 

Panic attacks are terrible things.  Mine expressed themselves as similar to a heart attack - so much so that the ambulance people told me that I must call them because it just could be a heart attack rather than panic.  Mine had no rhyme or reason to them at times, just suddenly struck out the blue ...........could be during a conversation, in the shops, or while reading a book, having a shower - i.e. at any time.

I am saying things as best I am able - I am hoping others might correct me wherever necessary.

Posted (edited)

What I do think about and at times share with other sufferers of MI specifically, is that Jesus indeed was like us in all things, except sin.  Mental Illness is not sinful (as with any illness) and Jesus never had a mental illness and from what we know, any other serious illness either.  The fact about mental illness is that it does have a strong element of social disgrace unlike other serious illnesses. That does place sufferers of MI in an intimately reflective place, an intimate relationship of unity, with the Sufferings of Jesus.  It is a place at once of dignity and of social disgrace.  This ties in with what Cardinal Javier Lozano Barragán (Adelaide - World Day of The Sick) had to state in my post here (scroll down post to "The Mentally Ill, A Faithful Image of God"

Quote

 

Isaiah 53:2 http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG0839/__PP0.HTM

There was in him no stately bearing to make us look at him, nor appearance that would attract us to him. He was spurned and avoided by men, a man of suffering, accustomed to infirmity, One of those from whom men hide their faces, spurned, and we held him in no esteem.

.................................we thought of him as stricken, as one smitten by God and afflicted. ................Oppressed and condemned, he was taken away, and who would have thought any more of his destiny? When he was cut off from the land of the living,

(I have edited the quotation above from Isaiah 53)

 

 Those who might criticize sufferers of MI for going off medication might have some compassion and understanding, less condemning, if they took the medication themselves.  The side-effects are cruel and a sufferer is on these meds 24x7.  What happens in fact is that one nasty condition can be corrected as it creates another nasty condition.  However, the second nasty condition is the more socially acceptable, since the socially acceptable do not have to suffer it.

Should a sufferer go off medication unless with psychiatric guidance.  Absolutely not!  However, I know from experience why some do so. It is not wise nor recommended in any way whatsoever - it can be a terrible mistake, but I know too how difficult life can be with the meds - and written off by the socially acceptable as 'character defects'. 

Flash of anger there...........c'est la vie. As long as I am still not angry at Night Prayer and preparing for going to sleep, I can live with it.

 

 

 

 

Edited by BarbaraTherese
<3 PopeFrancis
Posted
12 hours ago, BarbaraTherese said:

We do know that the biggest hurdle a sufferer is going to have to cope with is stigma.  From stigma flows more major problems: rejection, isolation and loneliness.  From that, of course, can come a sense of meaningless, lack of self esteem and confidence, hopelessness.

This sounds like a vicious cycle and needs more sympathy from society.

Posted

Thank you for your comment, 3PF and very real kindness :like2:- I do wonder if it is so much sympathy as understanding, compassion and recognition, which would hopefully preclude rejection.  It is not only rejection re personal relationships, but rejection too on an institutional type level.  Hopefully such dispositions might gift the other with awareness, eyes and mind open, to recognise the gifts that sufferers can have and a willingness to help them develop and serve with those gifts........to become contributing members of society and The Church.  This would be an absolutely major step for sufferers and for the community too.  Wherever it just might have been put into practise, the results speak loudly, while it just might be a rocky and precarious type of journey for all involved to the results "speaking loudly".  It becomes a willingness and openness to journey with the sufferer - i.e. the parable of The Good Samaritan.

Most common side effects of Seroquel (also known as Quetiapine) follows.  I have used Seroquel as an example as it is a medication with which I am familiar.  I experience most all the side effects below to some degree or other, including under the heading: "Other side effects include".  Some of my side effects are severe - while others might be less so.  My psychiatrist is aware of my side effects.  It all has to be weighed up by my doctor: harm caused by side effects versus likely harm if medication is changed or ceased.  We have tried a change of medication, that did not work successfully either.

So I journey the 'devil' :) ...(Seroquel)
 

Quote

 

https://www.drugs.com/sfx/seroquel-side-effects.html

Common side effects of Seroquel include: dizziness, headache, weakness, drowsiness, constipation, increased serum triglycerides, increased serum cholesterol, increased thyroid stimulating hormone level, and xerostomia. Other side effects include: increased serum alanine aminotransferase, dyspepsia, weight gain, orthostatic hypotension, pharyngitis, abdominal pain, and tachycardia. See below for a comprehensive list of adverse effects.

 

 I will stress again that a sufferer of MI should never cease medication without doctor's advice and support.  With my doctor's support, we tried my coming off Seroquel.  The side effects I experienced as Seroquel was reduced became severe (including interruption to sleep resulting in extreme tiredness next day = inability to function and cope during the day) and it became a case of:  "I prefer the devil I know (Seroquel), to the one I do not know."

Every sufferer's reaction to taking prescribed medication, and coming off it with medical support, will probably be different.  It needs to be noted too that the content of a psychotic episode can be far more serious than any side effect of medication - and that the content of a psychotic episode might vary too from risk of harm to the sufferer to risk of harm to the community.  Psychotic episodes and their content are quite complex matters it seems to me, while cruel general stereotypes and stigma do persist in the community in the day to day.

The side effects of psychiatric medication can be quite severe in many sufferers.  This might be a reason the patient stops medication; however, while it might be the reason, it is certainly not a just excuse to do so.  In fact, one would have to lack common sense, prudence and wisdom to do so with any accurate education at all re mental illness and related medication.  This is not always due to risk to the community, rather the risks to the sufferer - including that without medication, the symptoms of mental illness become overt and obvious.  What then follows is that the environment/community reacts in a totally negative manner (based on fear, stereotypical concepts re MI) and rejection of the sufferer. This in turn has a negative reaction in the sufferer (isolation, loneliness, lack of meaning in life, hopelessness .... and etc.);  hence, it just might be that medication could be protecting the sufferer from the community just as much - or more than - any sort of vv.

I have very deliberately used sound resource material below:

Quote

 

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2686644/

Excerpt: " Violence may be more of an issue in patients diagnosed with personality disorders and substance dependence. The overall impact of mental illness as a factor in the violence that occurs in society as a whole appears to be overemphasized, possibly intensifying the stigma already surrounding psychiatric disorders. Violence and mental illness are not without connection, however, as they share many biologic and psychosocial aspects."

https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2016/06/160606200849.htm

Date:
June 6, 2016
Source:
Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health
Summary:
Nearly four in 10 news stories about mental illness analyzed by researchers connect mental illness with violent behavior toward others, even though less than five percent of violence in the United States is directly related to mental illness.
 
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4921198/ Excerpt "News media coverage of mental illness changed very little during 1995–2014. Coverage has continued to emphasize interpersonal violence in a way that is highly disproportionate to actual rates of such violence among the US population with mental illness. Initiatives to educate reporters and the opinion leaders they use as sources regarding the relationship between mental illness and interpersonal violence are needed, as are efforts to increase news media depictions of successful treatment for and recovery from mental illness, which have the potential to reduce harmful social stigma toward this population."

 

 

 

 

<3 PopeFrancis
Posted

 

On 10/2/2016 at 10:53 PM, CatherineM said:

The first time we presented to seminarians several years ago, their formation director had spent time at the large mental health hospital as a chaplain. We played an auditory recreation of what the voices sound like for schizophrenics. He looked shocked and then went white. First realization of what they were going through. A couple of Filipino seminarians looked like they were going to pass out. 

Why are foreign priests and seminarians particularly affected?

Posted
8 hours ago, <3 PopeFrancis said:

 

Why are foreign priests and seminarians particularly affected?

I think it's because the idea of true possession is more of a cultural norm for them. They hear those voices and became really afraid. 

<3 PopeFrancis
Posted
1 hour ago, CatherineM said:

I think it's because the idea of true possession is more of a cultural norm for them. They hear those voices and became really afraid. 

Thank you.  That is interesting.  This is amazing technololgy.

I hear there is similar technology for autism and migraine headaches.

This awareness is wonderful breakthrough for the Mental Health community particularly as @BarbaraTherese mentioned for purposes of stigma.

 

Posted (edited)

I think this thread is probably coming to a natural conclusion.   The subject of this thread was moral responsibility and mental illness.  It is a quite complex area and why I used "can be screwed up" rather than "are screwed up".  Just a few quotations below to round off the thread.

http://catholicmoraltheology.com/st-augustine-catholics-and-mental-illness/         .........."What a wondrous thing it is that we have been given the ability to know our world, our selves, and even, with the help of grace, our God!  In the midst of this beautiful, celebratory passage, however, he interrupts himself to say this:St Augustine "City of God" ............."Crazy people say and do many incongruous things, things for the most part alien to their intentions and their characters, certainly contrary to their good intentions and characters; and when we think about their words and actions, or see them with our eyes, we can scarcely — or possibly we cannot at all — restrain our tears, if we consider their situation as it deserves to be considered........"...........

Quote

 

http://catholicmoraltheology.com/st-augustine-catholics-and-mental-illness/ "At our very best, we know that mental illness is a tragedy, one that afflicts those who did not choose it, and we serve and care for those so afflicted as we would care for Christ.  But the range of mental illnesses and the variety of behavioural symptoms often make it hard for many of us not to judge those with mental illness as moral and/or spiritual failures.  The stigma of that judgment, for many, ends up being as big an additional burden as the illness itself.  Educating ourselves about mental illness is a great place to start.  Being courageous enough to talk about it is another.....".............

............."........... When someone is approaching mania, they often feel energetic and creative and productive. They are often at their best in sort of a hypomanic phase. In both cases, when you are dealing with someone who is genuinely ill, medication and other treatment is really essential, so that they don’t swing further out of control. Many, many people complain that they are not themselves on their meds. This is true both because of the side effects of psychophamaceuticals (horrid) and because of their *intended* effects. The fact of the matter is that these illnesses and their solutions both touch on personality in such a deep way that it is very difficult to parse.........

.................. I think sticking to the language of illness is a starting point. But I think one of the things that churches may be poised to do more about than other organizations: people with severe, persistent mental illnesses need their communities to realize that all medicine has any hope of ever doing for them is to stabalize them. They need communities that value and welcome them, and that work with them to create ways for them to make real contributions.  .........

.............. I did hear other chaplains deride or dismiss treatment altogether and was appalled! Though I did see the occasional flashes of brilliance and insight from the patients, which I felt were unduly romanticized by some of my peers, I was more often struck by the grinding loneliness that the patients and their families experienced. Also, as you said, patients who are manic or delusional often have religious aspects to their experience, but because it is linekd to illness, we have no way of really being able to morally justify confirming that they are experiencing something divine. For every person I saw break and recover enough to be released, I saw many more whose illnesses refused to bend to either therapy or medications............."..............

 

  Further reading http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/11542b.htm#IV

Edited by BarbaraTherese
<3 PopeFrancis
Posted

Thank you for sharing your thoughts and knowledge from the physical to spiritual trials (Crosses) faced by MI sufferers. The stigma they suffer from society is one of the worse barriers to healing from it.  I believe there can be healing because of tech innovations and growing awareness.    

Posted

Auditory hallucinations (hearing voices) - some offensive language.  The video (a similarity only) is an example, while the variety of personal experience is probably considerable.   Not only those suffering schizophrenia can hear an hallucinatory voice or voices in a psychotic state. 

I can't get the video to insert as it should.  Google: "You Tube - auditory hallucinations" and it should come up.  I watched/heard the first one only.

 

<3 PopeFrancis
Posted

The article from New Advent was an excellent perspective from the Catholic ie. moral point of view for what is accountable and responsible for not only the mentally ill but those around them and who deal with them at a professional level. Thank you so much for your insight and resources -especially @BarbaraTherese, @CatherineM and others.  

I confess I haven't watched the videos of the simulated experience on the spectrum ie. mental illness/schizophrenia, autism, etc. because I am not yet prepared to.  I have expectant hope to do so.

@BarbaraTherese and anyone ever wants  or needs to chat please feel free to contact me on a personal level.  :)

Posted

In most cases, I feel, those with MI aren't violent. They are victims of violence. 

Posted

When you say "mental illness", that's the same as saying "illness". You're talking about a wide range of conditions that vary dramatically and no two peoples experiences will be exactly the same, even if they have the same condition. It's important not to assume that all people with mental illness are the same.  

Even though my degree is in psychology, I've always stubbornly refused to think of myself as having a mental illness because I don't want the connotations and assumptions that come with that as a label. I was a self-harmer, so it's hard for me to hide that I have problems because I have very obvious scars across my arms. I wear a lot of long or 3/4-length sleeves so that I don't have to answer questions - even though it's fairly obvious what they are I still get people quizzing me. One summer at my old job I wore short sleeves and when a colleague asked me I just said "they're old now" and she tutted at me.

Stigma is a big issue, and mentally ill people generally are far more vulnerable to harm from others than they are to harming others.

 

Posted
On ‎6‎/‎10‎/‎2016 at 4:18 AM, EmilyAnn said:

Stigma is a big issue, and mentally ill people generally are far more vulnerable to harm from others than they are to harming others

 

On ‎6‎/‎10‎/‎2016 at 2:38 AM, Jack4 said:

In most cases, I feel, those with MI aren't violent. They are victims of violence.

Well said. Statistics support the above http://www.mindframe-media.info/for-mental-health-and-suicide-prevention/talking-to-media-about-mental-illness/facts-and-stats . 

Harm or violence is not only physical, it also includes the psychological from stigma (false stereotyping) which can be severe and have severe repercussions.  Gossip spreading, exacerbation of MI symptoms in sufferer , isolation, loneliness, lack of meaning in life, hopelessness, severe depression, self harm.........sometimes suicide. 

<3 PopeFrancis
Posted

Stigma hinders healing from mental illness.  If it were not for the stigma, people could be healing completely.

People are developing technologies beyond and despite the stigma.  

Posted

It is who is suffering right now that is my concern.....and all any now's and sufferers down the line as technology develops striving to outpace the major problem sufferers of MI face.  If it can outpace stigma or any other problem related to mental illness and if it is going to help sufferers, it has my vote absolutely....as long as we don't sit on our hands waiting for a 'silver bullet' in the meantime.

 

Posted (edited)

To round off this thread on 'screwed up moral choices', here are extracts from a paper which appeared in the United States National Library of Medicine "Free Will and Mental Disorder - Exploring The Relationship".

 

Quote

 

Free Will and Mental Disorder - Exploring The Relationship". https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2975916/

There are several reasons for the importance of a “first person” perspective on this matter. The first reason is that it is about psychopathological mental states. Such mental states are not easily accessible to everybody. Therefore, those who have had experiential access to these states or conditions should not be excluded from, but welcomed into, discussions on the relation between mental disorder, free will (in whatever sense), and responsibility. Notably, there are a huge variety of mental disorders, so being familiar with one of them is certainly not enough.

Conclusion

In this paper the link between mental disorder and free will was explored as it is present in two domains: philosophy of free will and forensic psychiatry. As it turns out, philosophers working on free will often view mental disorders as compromising free will and, hence, as threatening or reducing responsibility. In forensic psychiatry, mental disorders are also viewed as compromising the agent’s free will and legal responsibility. Meanwhile, in philosophy, free will turns out to be hard to define. However, three central elements or senses of free will are present in the philosophical debate. Consequently, the sentence “mental disorders are able to compromise free will” can have at least three different meanings. In order to explore the link between mental disorder and free will, we tentatively related each of these three senses to mental disorder. Based on our preliminary considerations, understanding the sentence in terms of the mental disorder preventing the person from being the actual source of the action could make sense both from a forensic and a philosophical perspective. Mental disorder, then, would affect the element of origination.

Returning to the “important loss of freedom” phrase in the introduction of the DSM-IV, which motivated this article, I conclude that freedom in the sense of free will could indeed be a meaningful understanding of this phrase. Both the philosophical debate on free will and forensic psychiatry suggest that mental disorders may affect free will. Yet, the sense of free will that may be affected by mental disorder in general and by specific disorders in particular remains to be elucidated. It is, therefore, important to further study this link, especially because of the value attached to free action and free decision-making in the lives of individual people and because of the impact of (not) ascribing praise and blame to an agent. It is noteworthy that the mental states associated with mental disorders are not immediately accessible to everybody. Therefore, further research should not only be conceptual in nature but also involve first person and firsthand accounts of people who actually suffered or suffer from mental disorder. Their experiences should inform the discussion on free will and mental disorder.

I wanted to highlight what appears below in my post at the conclusion of the paper - however, highlight would not work for me:

Quote

"Therefore, further research should not only be conceptual in nature but also involve first person and firsthand accounts of people who actually suffered or suffer from mental disorder. Their experiences should inform the discussion on free will and mental disorder."

 

Edited by BarbaraTherese
format

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...