Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Dubia Submitted to the Holy Father


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

http://chiesa.espresso.repubblica.it/articolo/1351414?eng=y&refresh_ce  "In its Declaration of June 24, 2000, the Pontifical Council for Legislative Texts seeks to clarify Canon 915 of the Code of Canon Law, which states that those who “obstinately persist in manifest grave sin, are not to be admitted to Holy Communion.” The Pontifical Council’s Declaration argues that this canon is applicable also to faithful who are divorced and civilly remarried. It spells out that “grave sin” has to be understood objectively, given that the minister of the Eucharist has no means of judging another person’s subjective imputability.

Thus, for the Declaration, the question of the admission to the sacraments is about judging a person’s objective life situation and not about judging that this person is in a state of mortal sin. Indeed subjectively he or she may not be fully imputable or not be imputable at all."

Some time back Nihil corrected me re Canon 915 and was correct in doing so:like2:.  Thanks Nihil - I was wrong. 

However, I cannot for the life of me understand how a person not in the state of mortal sin can be denied Holy Communion and possibly declared by implication to be cut off from The Church and a relationship with God.  That sentence is horrendous to say the very least and commonly a sentence reserved for those guilty of mortal sin alone.

Canon 915 seems to me possibly to be a step to prevent Catholic teaching (not sure if it is a doctrine) from scandal i.e. those known to be in a situation of grave matter being permitted Holy Communion.  Where the former is concerned (preventing The Church from scandal), there just might be another scandal inherent in the Canon i.e. that The Church can protect Herself from possible scandal by dreadful severe sentences for those who might be outside of Catholic Teaching (or doctrine, whatever) in a public type of manner and although possibly not guilty of mortal sin.  The Church does have the right to do so "Whatever you shall bind upon earth, it is bound also in Heaven".  But can The Church do so on an anything at all type of basis including to protect Herself?

Non comprehendo.

_________

 

Edited by BarbaraTherese
Posted

Public sins call for a public response. If one lives, publicly, in a state which objectively contradicts Church teaching, then such a person should be publicly corrected through our sacramental discipline.

In addition the restriction from Communion is meant to be corrective.

Posted (edited)

A good portions of Catholics are completely ignorant of Scripture. St Paul explicitly says receiving Communion without examining your conscience brings judgement on yourself. He goes on to say that's why certain people even have illnesses and problems. There's a reason why we are only required to take Communion once a year. It's so we can make 100% sure we are in a state of grace when we go up to receive. Not saying you should only receive once a year but you should be completely sure you have no unconfessed grave sins when you do receive. 

Just now, Josh said:

A good portions 

*portion 

Preventing someone from receiving who is known to have unrepented grave/mortal sins is doing them a huge favor. I remember when I first joined here in 03 that point got drilled in my head. I remember Dust saying he would tackle someone going up to receive who hadn't repented of grave/mortal sins.

Edited by Guest
Posted (edited)
1 hour ago, Josh said:

St Paul explicitly says receiving Communion without examining your conscience brings judgement on yourself. He goes on to say that's why certain people even have illnesses and problems.

"Certain people" might have illnesses and problems for the reasons you state.  St Paul in the quotation to which you refer I am presuming uses "some" people - both imply that there is no universal generalization that illnesses and problems are always connected directly/solely to sin, although some or even many might be for sure.  "If you say you are without sin you are deceiving yourself.......(and) you make God a liar and His Word is not in you " 1 John Ch8

Illnesses and problems, sufferings, have positive meanings in our lives.  One only has to contemplate a crucifix.

Many of our great saints suffered illness.  Some who come to mind are St Teresa of Avila, St Therese of Lisieux, St Bernadette, St Pope John Paul II to mention a few.  This is not to state that the latter were all sinless and impossible - but it does indicate that those who suffer illnesses and/or problems could become great saints.  St Augustine, for example was thought to have perhaps suffered depression and we know for sure that he had committed terrible sins.  He repented, turned his life around, and became a great saint indeed.  Hence even those of us who have committed mortal sins need not despair, rather repent and turn life around.

I would never contest and always uphold in every way that those in the state of mortal sin cannot receive The Blessed Eucharist.  It is to receive The Body and Blood of The Lord unworthily and is the mortal sin of sacrilege as well as the original mortal sin i.e. two mortal sins.

Edited by BarbaraTherese
Posted
18 minutes ago, BarbaraTherese said:

Illnesses and problems, sufferings, have positive meanings in our lives. ...Many of our great saints suffered illness. 

+Sheen would remark while walking past a hospital, "Look at all the wasted suffering!"

Posted

"Much suffering in hospitals is wasted." 
Archbishop Fulton Sheen 

We always find that those who walked closest to Christ were those who had to bear the greatest trials.
Saint Teresa of Ávila

Sufferings gladly borne for others convert more people than sermons.
Saint Thérèse of Lisieux

Don’t waste your suffering.
Saint John Paul the Great

You can’t do God’s work without suffering.
Blessed Mother Teresa

 Link to Quotations

You Tube "Bishop Fulton Sheen on Suffering"

Posted

1 Corinthians 11:29–30

For he who eats and drinks in an unworthy manner eats and drinks judgment to himself, not discerning the Lord’s body. For this reason many are weak and sick among you, and many sleep.

Posted
4 hours ago, BarbaraTherese said:

"Much suffering in hospitals is wasted." 
Archbishop Fulton Sheen 

We always find that those who walked closest to Christ were those who had to bear the greatest trials.
Saint Teresa of Ávila

Sufferings gladly borne for others convert more people than sermons.
Saint Thérèse of Lisieux

Don’t waste your suffering.
Saint John Paul the Great

You can’t do God’s work without suffering.
Blessed Mother Teresa

 Link to Quotations

You Tube "Bishop Fulton Sheen on Suffering"

https://w2.vatican.va/content/john-paul-ii/en/apost_letters/1984/documents/hf_jp-ii_apl_11021984_salvifici-doloris.html 

You might find this an interesting read.

On 11/16/2016 at 11:30 AM, Peace said:

But seriously, who even knew what a dubia was? We are all using the word like we didn't just learn it for the first time two days ago.

http://www.catholicherald.co.uk/commentandblogs/2016/11/24/submitting-dubia-is-a-standard-part-of-church-life-its-not-unreasonable-to-expect-a-clear-answer/

Posted

Thank you for the link to Salvifici Doloris, Jack.  I read it when it first came out and retain a copy of it.  Beautiful document.

Posted

Catholic World News Headlines http://www.catholicculture.org/news/

17hrs ago: San Diego’s Bishop McElroy strongly encourages Communion for divorced/remarried

Bishop Robert McElroy of San Diego, California, has asked his priests to encourage Catholics who are divorced and remarried to consider whether “God is calling them to return to the Eucharist.”...

 

14hrs ago: Four cardinals could be stripped of status for questioning papal document, says Vatican archbishop

The dean of the Roman Rota has said that Pope Francis, if he wanted, could remove four prelates from the College of Cardinals as punishment for submitting and publicizing their dubia about Amoris Laetitia....

 

14hrs agoCardinal Pell defends four cardinals for asking ‘significant’ questions

Cardinal George Pell has come to the support of the four cardinals who have submitted dubia about the interpretation of Amoris Laetitia....

 

14hrs agoCardinals’ questions about Amoris Laetitia already answered: Father Spadaro

The questions submitted by four cardinals about the interpretation of Amoris Laetitia have already been answered, according to Father Antonio Spadaro....

Posted

Thank you PP and Amppax for the links.

I'm just a gal out in the pews and I have questions, which well might be well below the standard of the (thankfully) educated, but then I am (as are all individuals) representative of a "we" - and we count too (this is not stating that anywhere at all it is felt that we do not count) - I cannot even understand at times commentaries on canon law etc. and the situation re AL.   I'll keep trying to understand but probably will need to wait until the whole issue of the four cardinals and AL is past tense and decided by The Church in a quite formal manner and I am taking it that that will be Pope Francis's decision?

I have read that what Pope Francis wrote in AL was a confirmation of what the bishops decided in the Synod?. 

My other question is: I have read that Canon 915 is a disciplinary law of The Church?  Disciplinary laws and canon law can change if necessary i.e. not beyond Church Law that they can change?  It seems to me to be a question re subject under discussion, in part, of definition what St Paul meant by "unworthy" (reception of The Blessed Eucharist)? The current definition of course is mortal sin and/or living in a manifestly grave situation.

Quote

"But until he [Pope Francis] speaks, the hypothesis is open."  New York Times (article quoted by Amppax)

I think Pope Francis has opened a can of worms...........and then the Pandora's box inside the can of worms.  The current furore and uproar, predictions of doom and gloom, the end is coming etc., very much reminds me of the situation immediately post V2 and still ongoing light spot fires.  I have read too that every Council in The Church has been followed by the same.

The nun who taught me said as long as there was one Catholic on earth, The Church existed on earth.  I don't think we are there - nor that we ever might get there.  But there is something in it nevertheless.

________________

Off topic and smiling :   I wonder if perhaps, just perhaps, media might have learn something from the surprise election of Donald Trump? .........

Quote

 

New York Times article quoted by Amppax: "The logic of “Rome has spoken, the case is closed” is too deeply embedded in the structures of Catholicism to allow for anything but a temporary doctrinal decentralization. So long as the pope remains the pope, any major controversy will inevitably rise back up to the Vatican.

Francis must know this. For now, he seems to be choosing the lesser crisis of feuding bishops and confused teaching over the greater crisis that might come (although who can say for certain?)"

 

 

Posted

Sitting outside under the pergola with coffee - can anyone else see some parallel in all this with the arrest and trial of Jesus?

__________

@dUSt I wonder if we might need one of those definition underscores for AL?  I think it just might be a long discussion over an extended period.  Up to you, Oh Fearless Leader :lust:

Posted

Canon law is an interesting mix of purely legal norms and customs, which can be changed according to the dictates of prudence, and the moral law, which is irreformable. I think it is safe to say that canons 915 and 916 are based very strongly in moral law first. It is not a merely legal administrative precept that can be tossed aside.

Posted
6 minutes ago, Nihil Obstat said:

Canon law is an interesting mix of purely legal norms and customs, which can be changed according to the dictates of prudence, and the moral law, which is irreformable. I think it is safe to say that canons 915 and 916 are based very strongly in moral law first. It is not a merely legal administrative precept that can be tossed aside.

Well that is the question of the hour isn't it? 

I would think that the moral law would prohibit someone in a state of mortal sin from partaking in communion.

If we can't say certainly that one is in a state of mortal sin, then denial in the case of objective grave sin seems to be more of a prudential measure. In our day and age I wouldn't necessarily think that allowing the divorced and remarried to communion would lead to scandal, or be a hindrance to the couple correcting their actions. Could their participation in the sacraments be used as a means of bringing them back into the life of the church and as an aid to their ultimate correction? I have no idea, but if the powers that be reach that conclusion I am not convinced that it would be wrong. 

I had meant to follow up on your last Q but haven't had a chance to give it the time it would take.

Posted

To me it is perfectly obvious that living in a state which is objectively contradictory to the moral law means that one is barred under normal circumstances from participating fully in the Church's sacramental life. To be honest, with no condescending whatsoever, I have trouble understanding why this is not obvious to everyone.

Posted
3 minutes ago, Nihil Obstat said:

To me it is perfectly obvious that living in a state which is objectively contradictory to the moral law means that one is barred under normal circumstances from participating fully in the Church's sacramental life. To be honest, with no condescending whatsoever, I have trouble understanding why this is not obvious to everyone.

Well most of us live in a state that is objectively contradictory to the moral law. You don't? It seems to me that most people who are allowed to participate in the sacraments are in that state. The difference is the extent (mortal or venial).

We owe God our complete love, devotion and obedience, but very few of us achieve that, or are truly committed to even attempting it when we examine our lives. And that is a violation of the greatest commandment, right?

You would seemingly have to exclude everyone except for the St. Theresa types living among us.

What is your rationale for reaching your conclusion, by the way? It seems obvious to me that this is what the Church has done, but I am not sure why it must always be so.

I know little of formal sacramental theology so perhaps that is the reason for the difference.

Posted (edited)
1 hour ago, Nihil Obstat said:

Canon law is an interesting mix of purely legal norms and customs, which can be changed according to the dictates of prudence, and the moral law, which is irreformable. I think it is safe to say that canons 915 and 916 are based very strongly in moral law first. It is not a merely legal administrative precept that can be tossed aside.

Thanks Nihil -

Nihil, is Pope Francis in AL confirming the majority conclusions of the Synod?  Or is his [Pope Francis] challenge to 915 coming right out the blue and not connected to formal discussions and conclusions in the Synod?

I didn't mean to cast aside the spirit of what they are stating - rather to redefine what constitutes forbidden to attend Holy Communion as in Canon 915.

Canon 916 - Does it mean and still apply that a person in mortal sin cannot even attend Mass?  Have I read rightly?

It seems to me that The Church (Jesus) is totally pushing away grave sinners, rather than fully embracing them:  "I have come for sinners, the righteous have no need of Me".  

It seems to me in practise as if Jesus (The Church) has come only for the righteous or moderately sinful (whatever that is) - unless the seriously sinful convert to the moderately sinful. It seems to me too that this attitude is what Pope Francis is challenging.

I rejoice truly that this debate is at last right out into the open and most everywhere not only on pham - also in the Universal Church and hierarchy.   It is now a public and serious issue in The Church and in secular media and current affairs.  The Church is again under scrutiny.

Faith seeking understanding.

What Peace has to state makes sense to me.

 

Edited by BarbaraTherese

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...