Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

crusader1234
Posted

Do you think this is evil?

My friend took a pointer (wooden school pointer thing) and broke it over a girls head (that means he hit her really hard) for saying "The Body of Christ tastes like [expletive deleted]".

He doesn't think it is evil and I do. We want to know what you think.

Posted (edited)

Ouch...that's hard. :huh: But then again what she said was pretty rude. But two wrongs don't make a right.

Edited by azaelia
Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

Yes, it is evil. On evil does not excuse another.

crusader1234
Posted

And I mean, thats sort of hypocritical, hitting someone for being unchristian and rude :wacko:

daugher-of-Mary
Posted

Woah. Somebody around here has "diss me and I'll get over it, diss the Eucharist and I take up my sword" in their sig. That might be an appropriate motto for your friend!

Posted

I can understand why he'd be upset, as dissing the Body of Christ is beyond wrong. On the other hand, I don't think your friend was right in acting out violently against that girl. Violence done not out of self-defense is wrong. Plus, I don't think your friend, a guy, should be hitting girls. That's just wrong.

God bless,

Jen

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

Crusader, you and I agree for once. Take it as a sign.

The kid who was so irreverent committed a terrible sin, but it is not the right of a person to seek vengeance, even for God. That is why the Church only approves of the death penalty for the purposes of keeping the public safe.

If we seek vengeance on the sinner, then we seek vengeance on ourselves.

Posted

I dunno i was present at the situation and it was not like it was a hard pointer thing it was really like one that pulls out of a pen....and she wasnt hurt by it. So its a tuff call although i do agree that perhaps it was not the best course of action.

crusader1234
Posted (edited)
<_< I don't think its a tough call... I think it was "Jim" doing something evil to "Sally" for doing something evil to "John". Thats revenge, which is evil. Edited by crusader1234
Posted

[quote name='Raphael' date='Jun 23 2004, 12:28 AM'] If we seek vengeance on the sinner, then we seek vengeance on ourselves. [/quote]
So true, Raph.

God bless,

Jen

Posted

wats wrong with saying it taste's bad... its not about the taste of the Eucharist thats important, its about the miracle there!

Posted

Yes but when one mentions the "Body of Christ".....its not techinically referring to the wafer anymore.

Posted

It would tick me off. And I would probly tackle her and hurt her. LOL! So I am just glad I wasn't there.

crusader1234
Posted

You dont need to use expletives to express taste - the Body of Christ probably does taste bad in some cases like where it became the cross section of the heart and the physical blood - however again it doesnt justify violence.

WWJD? definately not that

Posted

It was wrong for him to hit the girl. Calling it evil is something else. Evil implies intent for evil, which means that the guy intended to do wrong. I really don't think that was his intent, but it doesn't make it right.

Wrong yes. Evil no.

Posted

yeah, with my temper I'd have :ph34r:

Kinda glad I wasn't there....

But two wrongs dont make a right.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote]Evil implies intent for evil, which means that the guy intended to do wrong. I really don't think that was his intent, but it doesn't make it right.
[/quote]

No, evil is any bad thing. Sin implies intent for evil. We can't judge whether it was sin or not, but we can certainly call it evil.

Posted

I beg to differ, Raph. I am refering to the common understanding of people. To say that some one acted evil, pretty much is saying they intended to do something bad.

We can sin without intending to do bad. Our intentions will only absolve some of the guilt.

Posted

Just to simplify things it was me that did this. For which i am truly sorry and have sent a response. My rage and looking for vengeance got ahead of my rational. However, with that being said lets turn this into a more proactive thread what would be some good respeonse in case i am in this situation again (which i am sure i might be).

Posted

Ask why they would say that and what do they mean.

Many people will have negative opinions about stuff without really thinking too much about it. When you simply ask them to explain, and ask the questions, you get them to think about it. They usually don't change their mind right then, but it gets their mind working and thinking about ti and often they change their minds later on.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...