Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

the empire strikes back


Recommended Posts

Posted

WASHINGTON ― The Obama administration has proposed a new rule that would prevent states from defunding Planned Parenthood or any other family planning provider for political reasons. 

The new rule, which the Department of Health and Human Services proposed last week, says that states cannot withhold Title X federal family planning money from certain recipients for any reason other than the provider’s “ability to deliver services to program beneficiaries in an effective manner.” That means states can no longer vote to defund Planned Parenthood because some of its clinics offer abortion services. 

“This will make a real difference in so many people’s lives,” said Cecile Richards, president of Planned Parenthood. “Thanks to the Obama administration, women will still be able to access the birth control they need to plan their families, and the cancer screenings they need to stay healthy.”

 

image_zps7de4a1ys.jpeg

 

Posted

They don't do cancer screenings. 

Posted

New president. New agency head. Change the rule.

Posted (edited)

Trump train has come to Washington...  maybe things will change?  Who knows....

 

Choo - choo...

Edited by Didacus
Posted

And people wonder why pro-lifers and conservatives despise his presidency so much . . . ("Must be because he's black!")

 

On 12/15/2016 at 5:51 PM, Peace said:

New president. New agency head. Change the rule.

We can hope.  But the president and his underlings have absolutely no power whatever under the Constitution to make and impose such rules on the states.  The states should refuse to comply.

Posted
3 hours ago, Socrates said:

And people wonder why pro-lifers and conservatives despise his presidency so much . . . ("Must be because he's black!")

 

We can hope.  But the president and his underlings have absolutely no power whatever under the Constitution to make and impose such rules on the states.  The states should refuse to comply.

I am pretty sure those restrictions are constitutional. It is Federal money. You can't force states to take it, but you can condition acceptance on compliance with how the money is distributed.

If you are suggesting that the states turn down the money altogether I think that works.

Posted
13 hours ago, Peace said:

I am pretty sure those restrictions are constitutional. It is Federal taxpayer's money. You can't force states to take it, but you can condition acceptance on compliance with how the money is distributed.

If you are suggesting that the states turn down the money altogether I think that works.

Fixed.

Posted
1 hour ago, Papist said:

Fixed.

If it is yours why don't you walk down to Uncle Sam and ask for it back? See how that goes.

It was taxpayer's money. It is now Federal money because the government took it from you.

dominicansoul
Posted

his legacy will take him to hell if he doesn't repent of his actions

Posted
45 minutes ago, Peace said:

If it is yours why don't you walk down to Uncle Sam and ask for it back? See how that goes.

It was taxpayer's money. It is now Federal money because the government took it from you.

Glad to see you recognizing it is stealing. 

Posted
3 hours ago, Papist said:

Glad to see you recognizing it is stealing. 

I recognize that you don't understand the Church's teaching on theft.

Posted
28 minutes ago, Peace said:

I recognize that you don't understand the Church's teaching on theft.

Please enlighten me on the Church's teaching on theft?

Posted
23 hours ago, Peace said:

I am pretty sure those restrictions are constitutional. It is Federal money. You can't force states to take it, but you can condition acceptance on compliance with how the money is distributed.

If you are suggesting that the states turn down the money altogether I think that works.

It's certainly not among the enumerated powers granted the president by the constitution.  This would amount to an act of legislation, which belongs to the legislative branch (Congress), not the executive.  And the power of the purse belongs to Congress constitutionally, not the president.

And no, I can't "condition acceptance on compliance on how the money is distributed," and neither can your Dear Leader, lawfully.

But yes, I realize he has lots of precedent of presidential lawlessness to build his godless tyranny on.

Posted
1 hour ago, Socrates said:

It's certainly not among the enumerated powers granted the president by the constitution.  This would amount to an act of legislation, which belongs to the legislative branch (Congress), not the executive.  And the power of the purse belongs to Congress constitutionally, not the president.

And no, I can't "condition acceptance on compliance on how the money is distributed," and neither can your Dear Leader, lawfully.

But yes, I realize he has lots of precedent of presidential lawlessness to build his godless tyranny on.

How is your Dear Leader Trump doing? Still "grabbing women by the p****" and doing the other things that led you to vote for him?

The rule is not in the form of an executive order, it is an agency rule. Congress allocates the money to the agency. The statute likely grants the agency a certain scope to make rules. I don't have time to pull up the title and analyze whether the rule in is within the scope authorized by the statute, but assuming that it is then the rule is constitutional. 

Have any of the people who do most of your thinking for you over at the conservative review asserted that the rule violates the constitution? I would be interested in hearing from someone who actually knows what he is talking about.

Posted

 

Abortion is legal in the US

Slavery was legal at one time in the US

THE DIFFERENCE IS THAT SLAVERY WAS NOT FUNDED BY EXECUTIVE ORDER OR CONGRESS

do you get my gist, sweetheart 

Posted (edited)
2 hours ago, little2add said:

Abortion is legal in the US

Slavery was legal at one time in the US

THE DIFFERENCE IS THAT SLAVERY WAS NOT FUNDED BY EXECUTIVE ORDER OR CONGRESS

Sure it was. The Fugitive Slave Act is one obvious example.

And the Constitution itself had a Fugitive Slave clause.

Quote

do you get my gist, sweetheart 

Not really. If the Federal Government wants to use money to fund abortion or any other type of "health care" (sarcasm) I don't think anyone believes that it would violate the constitution. The constitution allows for the government to take action that we consider immoral, unfortunately.

Edited by Peace
Posted

Some people might argue that the tenth amendment applies to the regulation of abortion

X - Rights of the States under Constitution

The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.

peace :sam:

Posted (edited)
6 hours ago, Peace said:

Sure it was. The Fugitive Slave Act is one obvious example.

And the Constitution itself had a Fugitive Slave clause.

The Fugitive Slave Act was more like a (bad) fine

not really the same, the Federal Government did not: pay for, promote, condone, encourage or provide slave labor like it does for abortion service industry.

 

Edited by little2add

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...