Graciela Posted January 24, 2017 Posted January 24, 2017 I marched in Chicago and feel compelled to point out that abortion rights were not the only things for which marchers advocated. I object SO much to one issue folks who get upset about abortion but apparently are unconcerned about ANY and ALL of the following issues which were part of the Women's March too: justice and compassion for immigrants, racism and police violence against people of color, sexual assault ( and of men like Trump who brag about getting away with it), vilification of Muslims, wage inequality, unfair funding of public education, nuclear threats, AND concern for the health of this planet. Crowds far exceeded expected turn out and yet the atmosphere was peaceful, happy, and cordial, with many families, and people of all ages participating.
little2add Posted January 24, 2017 Posted January 24, 2017 Will you be marching on 01/27/17 for RTF? http://marchforlife.org/mfl-2017/ As with your march the < Crowds (will) far exceeded expected turn out and yet the atmosphere (will be) peaceful, happy, and cordial, with many families, and people of all ages participating>
KnightofChrist Posted January 24, 2017 Posted January 24, 2017 53 minutes ago, Graciela said: I marched in Chicago and feel compelled to point out that abortion rights were not the only things for which marchers advocated. I object SO much to one issue folks who get upset about abortion but apparently are unconcerned about ANY and ALL of the following issues which were part of the Women's March too: justice and compassion for immigrants, racism and police violence against people of color, sexual assault ( and of men like Trump who brag about getting away with it), vilification of Muslims, wage inequality, unfair funding of public education, nuclear threats, AND concern for the health of this planet. Crowds far exceeded expected turn out and yet the atmosphere was peaceful, happy, and cordial, with many families, and people of all ages participating. But how do you feel about pro-life women's groups being banned unless they crashed the party? The one issue of course that a person believes they have the right to say someone else is not a person and can be exterminated. Some of us have trouble seeing pass that. I don't see protest groups being as successful if it officially only allowed groups that thought immigrants or Muslims are not persons and can be exterminated. Do you?
Peace Posted January 24, 2017 Posted January 24, 2017 On 1/22/2017 at 5:22 PM, McM RSCJ said: demands that I work for Social justice, Peace, and the integrity of . . . OK. But I can only pay you minimum wage . . . On 1/22/2017 at 5:22 PM, McM RSCJ said: Not quite sure why responses to my description of the amazing, God-filled Spirit of the day are focusing on abortion. Maybe a misunderstanding of the march? Certainly a misunderstanding of the purpose of this marcher and of many other marchers. You got hit with the abortion block. It is a Phatmass rite of passage. It goes something like this: I would like to start a thread to discuss police violence against African Americans. Oh really? More African Americans are aborted every year than killed by police, so why don't you stop whining about police violence against African Americans and talk about the number of African American abortions instead? Don't you even care about abortion? I would like to start a thread to discuss the use of the Confederate Flag in South Carolina, which many people view as racist. Oh really? And why should we spend any time talking about that when 1 million children were aborted last year? Why don't you stop whining about the Flag and talk about the 1 million children that were aborted last year instead? Don't you even care about abortion? I would like to start a thread to discuss US immigration policy. Oh really? And why should we spend any time talking about that when . . . When you have nothing of substance to say concerning the actual topic of a thread, I suggest you try it out.
Nihil Obstat Posted January 24, 2017 Posted January 24, 2017 Yeah, but these women's marches were actually about abortion.
Ice_nine Posted January 24, 2017 Posted January 24, 2017 57 minutes ago, Nihil Obstat said: Yeah, but these women's marches were actually about abortion. True.
little2add Posted January 24, 2017 Posted January 24, 2017 The real reason Clinton lost to trump was their pledge(s) for the next Supreme Court justice. The Russian's had nothing to do with it!
Anomaly Posted January 24, 2017 Posted January 24, 2017 22 minutes ago, little2add said: The real reason Clinton lost to trump was their pledge(s) for the next Supreme Court justice. The Russian's had nothing to do with it! The reasons why Clinton lost was because she was so duplicitous, people could not have confidence in her. They disliked her more than the disliked the loudmouth, two dimensional, anti-politician. Even though the Russians probably were behind the DNC Email hack, they didn't make it up. Clinton Org still cheated against Sanders and were shown to be slimey. Even though no charges were filed about her email server, we all know the whole point to use her own server was to hide some emails from government oversight. Even though many/most Americans believe some abortion should be legal, and he vast majority belive it should be rare, NOT government funded, not late term abortion of viable fetuses, and not just a matter of snipping off a skin tag. A significant number of Voters were/are tired of the hyper sensitive, politically correct, micro-aggression, fear mongering, and perceived polarizing bias in the media and political world. Flailing about in distress and tears and demonizing each other isn't going to accomplish much positive. That's how we got Hillary and Donald.
little2add Posted January 24, 2017 Posted January 24, 2017 6 hours ago, Anomaly said: The reasons why Clinton lost was because she was so duplicitous, people could not have confidence in her. They disliked her more than the disliked the loudmouth, two dimensional, anti-politician. Even though the Russians probably were behind the DNC Email hack, they didn't make it up. Clinton Org still cheated against Sanders and were shown to be slimey. Even though no charges were filed about her email server, we all know the whole point to use her own server was to hide some emails from government oversight. Even though many/most Americans believe some abortion should be legal, and he vast majority belive it should be rare, NOT government funded, not late term abortion of viable fetuses, and not just a matter of snipping off a skin tag. A significant number of Voters were/are tired of the hyper sensitive, politically correct, micro-aggression, fear mongering, and perceived polarizing bias in the media and political world. Flailing about in distress and tears and demonizing each other isn't going to accomplish much positive. That's how we got Hillary and Donald. Yes that too, but her pro abortion platform swung a lot of votes over to trump, enough to put him over the top
Anomaly Posted January 24, 2017 Posted January 24, 2017 2 minutes ago, little2add said: Yes that too, but her pro abortion platform swung a lot of votes over to trump, enough to put him over the top It's ironically sad that the "pro-life" Democrats get all worked up about mean Republicans who immediately re-instate the Mexico City compromise to not provide Government funds for abortions, want to keep the Hyde Ammendment, are not pro-life enough. Then on the other hand, the nice, life affirming Democrats specifically restrict both abortion limits and rally to promote women's reproductive health (AKA Abortion). Why isnt the pro-life movement having better success at converting the Democrat Party to being pro life, but think supporting Dems is pro life? Is it possible they've been duped?
Ash Wednesday Posted January 24, 2017 Posted January 24, 2017 Even putting aside their pro-choice platform -- some of the signs, attire and slogans at the Women's March were downright vulgar and I find it offensive that anyone would call such a march "God-filled."
dUSt Posted January 24, 2017 Posted January 24, 2017 @McM RSCJ Can you please let us know your stance on abortion and gay marriage?
Peace Posted January 24, 2017 Posted January 24, 2017 1 hour ago, dUSt said: @McM RSCJ Can you please let us know your stance on abortion and gay marriage? Whoa. This is the most scandalous inquiry since the dubia. Will the Church stand?!
McM RSCJ Posted January 25, 2017 Author Posted January 25, 2017 (edited) To Dust: My beliefs about abortion and gay marriage are those of the Church. Now, may I ask why you are asking me this? (It felt like an attack to me, but maybe you didn't mean it that way?) I and many other women religious across the country (and, now I know, around the world) participated in these marches and every report I have seen us has focused on the joy and solidarity and the sense that God is working among us. "Lo! I am doing something new. Can you not perceive it?" The apostolic vocation is to be sent and to find God in all things and, as Pope Francis reminds us in The Joy of the Gospels, to learn from what society is trying to reveal about God's action to the Church. Discernment. . . . Paying prayerful attention to the signs of the times. . . . People on this website who did not participate in the marches are nevertheless certain it was vulgar and offensive and focused only on anti-abortion. But they weren't there. And that was not my experience. Now if the point of this inquiry about my beliefs is to tell me I should not post on this website anymore, please just say so. (I had been wondering if that were how I was supposed to interpret the remark of the Mediator that she had hoped my post would sink into obscurity. I couldn't tell if that were humorous sarcasm or expression of a shared judgment that my views are not welcome here. ) We are taught the twelve fruits of the Spirit are Charity, Joy, Peace, Patience and so on. Well, I experienced some of those fruits during the March. And the next day after Mass in the parish when so many of us, men and women, who did not even all know one another, spontaneously just stood outside the Church and talked about how much the previous day had meant to us. And it has been the same in the workplace and classrooms yesterday and today. . . . Edited January 25, 2017 by McM RSCJ errors
Anomaly Posted January 25, 2017 Posted January 25, 2017 Not sure if you're overly defensive or just sanctimonious but hey, you're not mousey. dUSt is highly tolerant of any opinion. You wouldn't be asked to leave. He is sensitive to posters who represent themselves to be Catholic but espouse positions that are in conflict with the Church. I could argue for abortion and gay marriage and be welcomed to debate and defend my opinion. You likely would have been given a phishy label, but certainly not directions to the exit if you supported them too.
Ash Wednesday Posted January 25, 2017 Posted January 25, 2017 2 hours ago, McM RSCJ said: People on this website who did not participate in the marches are nevertheless certain it was vulgar and offensive and focused only on anti-abortion. But they weren't there. And that was not my experience. I did not say the entire march was vulgar and offensive. But there was vulgarity and offensive messages that were a part of it (and we only had to watch the news to know this without being there), hence that and their pro-choice platform is why I object to it as being described as "God-filled."
Peace Posted January 25, 2017 Posted January 25, 2017 2 hours ago, McM RSCJ said: To Dust: My beliefs about abortion and gay marriage are those of the Church. Now, may I ask why you are asking me this? (It felt like an attack to me, but maybe you didn't mean it that way?) I and many other women religious across the country (and, now I know, around the world) participated in these marches and every report I have seen us has focused on the joy and solidarity and the sense that God is working among us. "Lo! I am doing something new. Can you not perceive it?" The apostolic vocation is to be sent and to find God in all things and, as Pope Francis reminds us in The Joy of the Gospels, to learn from what society is trying to reveal about God's action to the Church. Discernment. . . . Paying prayerful attention to the signs of the times. . . . People on this website who did not participate in the marches are nevertheless certain it was vulgar and offensive and focused only on anti-abortion. But they weren't there. And that was not my experience. Now if the point of this inquiry about my beliefs is to tell me I should not post on this website anymore, please just say so. (I had been wondering if that were how I was supposed to interpret the remark of the Mediator that she had hoped my post would sink into obscurity. I couldn't tell if that were humorous sarcasm or expression of a shared judgment that my views are not welcome here. ) We are taught the twelve fruits of the Spirit are Charity, Joy, Peace, Patience and so on. Well, I experienced some of those fruits during the March. And the next day after Mass in the parish when so many of us, men and women, who did not even all know one another, spontaneously just stood outside the Church and talked about how much the previous day had meant to us. And it has been the same in the workplace and classrooms yesterday and today. . . . I at least appreciate the perspective that you bring to the site. That is not to say that I necessarily agree with you.
havok579257 Posted January 25, 2017 Posted January 25, 2017 3 hours ago, McM RSCJ said: To Dust: My beliefs about abortion and gay marriage are those of the Church. Now, may I ask why you are asking me this? (It felt like an attack to me, but maybe you didn't mean it that way?) I and many other women religious across the country (and, now I know, around the world) participated in these marches and every report I have seen us has focused on the joy and solidarity and the sense that God is working among us. "Lo! I am doing something new. Can you not perceive it?" The apostolic vocation is to be sent and to find God in all things and, as Pope Francis reminds us in The Joy of the Gospels, to learn from what society is trying to reveal about God's action to the Church. Discernment. . . . Paying prayerful attention to the signs of the times. . . . People on this website who did not participate in the marches are nevertheless certain it was vulgar and offensive and focused only on anti-abortion. But they weren't there. And that was not my experience. Now if the point of this inquiry about my beliefs is to tell me I should not post on this website anymore, please just say so. (I had been wondering if that were how I was supposed to interpret the remark of the Mediator that she had hoped my post would sink into obscurity. I couldn't tell if that were humorous sarcasm or expression of a shared judgment that my views are not welcome here. ) We are taught the twelve fruits of the Spirit are Charity, Joy, Peace, Patience and so on. Well, I experienced some of those fruits during the March. And the next day after Mass in the parish when so many of us, men and women, who did not even all know one another, spontaneously just stood outside the Church and talked about how much the previous day had meant to us. And it has been the same in the workplace and classrooms yesterday and today. . . . I think the issue people are having with this is you represent the church. You represent all the things that the church preaches and teaches. So what you do does reflect on the church. So with that said we know for a fact (there is video of this, cnn aired some of the speches from the womens march live. I know I watched one of them.) that the speakers/leaders of the march were pushing and protesting that Donald Trump not take a women's right to abortion away. That he not take away government funding to planned parenthood which is the biggest abortion provider in the world. Not to mention the leaders telling pro life women they are not welcome at the march because you can't be for women's rights unless your for the right to having an abortion. So this was being pushed by the march's leaders/speakers. This was one of their agenda's. Sure they had other agenda's, but this was a major one. So to see someone so closely tied to the church at a rally supporting these things is disheartening. I am sure you would feel no different yourself if a priest went to a movement about men's rights and one of the things that was being promoted by the leaders/speakers was that we should remove the ability for women to vote. Sure the rest of the platform could be for solidarity for men, equality for men in an every changing world and so on. Yes, some of these reasons are good and noble but I would wager a guess that you would be shocked that a priest would be at a rally that the leaders/speakers were pushing for women to lose their ability to vote. Would you be ok if when you asked a priest about his inolvement in this march he told you it was about unity and all these others things that are good and just ignored the fact that the leaders/speakers pushed for the right for women to vote be removed? No matter what good you felt from the march or what good things the march talked about it was still promoted by the leaders/speakers that one of their platforms was that they did not want Trump to take away a women's right to have abortions. Its a fact that they promoted this during the march. There is no arguing about this. So it comes down to asking, how do you as a women of the church, a women who the public ties to the church, join and be in support of something that supports abortion? You said you support the church's position on abortion, so how do you square your support for a march that, that was one of their big issues? We are not talking about having to vote between two pro abortion candidates. We are talking about freely joining and supporting a march that one of its big issues was Trump not taking away a women's right to abortion. So the question is, how do you square your support for it when their position is so against church teaching and God's law?
Norseman82 Posted January 25, 2017 Posted January 25, 2017 (edited) 4 hours ago, McM RSCJ said: To Dust: My beliefs about abortion and gay marriage are those of the Church. Now, may I ask why you are asking me this? (It felt like an attack to me, but maybe you didn't mean it that way?) I and many other women religious across the country (and, now I know, around the world) participated in these marches and every report I have seen us has focused on the joy and solidarity and the sense that God is working among us. "Lo! I am doing something new. Can you not perceive it?" The apostolic vocation is to be sent and to find God in all things and, as Pope Francis reminds us in The Joy of the Gospels, to learn from what society is trying to reveal about God's action to the Church. Discernment. . . . Paying prayerful attention to the signs of the times. . . . People on this website who did not participate in the marches are nevertheless certain it was vulgar and offensive and focused only on anti-abortion. But they weren't there. And that was not my experience. Now if the point of this inquiry about my beliefs is to tell me I should not post on this website anymore, please just say so. (I had been wondering if that were how I was supposed to interpret the remark of the Mediator that she had hoped my post would sink into obscurity. I couldn't tell if that were humorous sarcasm or expression of a shared judgment that my views are not welcome here. ) We are taught the twelve fruits of the Spirit are Charity, Joy, Peace, Patience and so on. Well, I experienced some of those fruits during the March. And the next day after Mass in the parish when so many of us, men and women, who did not even all know one another, spontaneously just stood outside the Church and talked about how much the previous day had meant to us. And it has been the same in the workplace and classrooms yesterday and today. . . . Considering what Hillary said about people needing to change their religious views, the revelations that people in the Clinton campaign wanted to "instill a springtime in the Catholic Church" (codeword for changing it sviews on moral isues), and the general hostility of the previous administration to our religion by pushing the contraception mandate, what you did was the equivalent of a rabbi attending and praising a Nuremberg rally in the 1930s. Edited January 25, 2017 by Norseman82
dUSt Posted January 25, 2017 Posted January 25, 2017 @McM RSCJ I'm happy that you agree with the church. The people above me have expressed my confusion better than I could have.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now