vee Posted May 10, 2017 Posted May 10, 2017 Question. Is it against the rules for a priest to distribute the precious blood while a lay person distributes the precious body? To me it seems odd that the priest would choose to do such a thing but that happened today.
Nihil Obstat Posted May 10, 2017 Posted May 10, 2017 I do not know what is and is not permitted legally speaking, but the practice strikes me as inappropriate.
CatherineM Posted May 10, 2017 Posted May 10, 2017 Had a priest do this once. He was trying to get more people to take from the cup.
Anomaly Posted May 10, 2017 Posted May 10, 2017 What? I've seen this done for many years and I haven't attended regularly in more than 5 years, so I'd guess this has been regularly going on at multiple parishes for the last 10+ years. The priest tends to distribute the hosts to the EM's and he and one or two EM's handle the 'blood' distribution Aren't both supposed to be essentially the same thing, theologically?
dominicansoul Posted May 10, 2017 Posted May 10, 2017 I'm confused, because I usually do not receive the Cup. I only receive the Host even when the Cup is distributed. I've always thought the Host took precedence. Not sure where I got that idea...
He is Risen! Posted May 10, 2017 Posted May 10, 2017 At most EF masses I've been to, the people receive the host only, not both species (of course the priest consumes both for a valid mass) and the host contains both body and blood (as does the wine) Maybe there was an issue with the lay person spilling the Precious Blood?
Jubilate Deo Posted May 10, 2017 Posted May 10, 2017 2 hours ago, dominicansoul said: I'm confused, because I usually do not receive the Cup. I only receive the Host even when the Cup is distributed. I've always thought the Host took precedence. Not sure where I got that idea... I don't receive from the chalice, either. I know I receive all of Jesus and not just part of Him when I receive the Host.
Rosary11 Posted May 10, 2017 Posted May 10, 2017 I wish my church offered the blood of Christ. My church only offers the body.
Nihil Obstat Posted May 10, 2017 Posted May 10, 2017 1 hour ago, Rosary11 said: I wish my church offered the blood of Christ. My church only offers the body. You consume both the Body and the Blood of Christ regardless of the species under which you communicate.
vee Posted May 11, 2017 Author Posted May 11, 2017 Another parishioner disagreed with the situation so much that they stepped out of the line and sat back down upon seeing that the priest was not giving the Host. I would rather recieve from a lay person than to depreive myself totally of the sacrament but maybe he wanted to make a statement
hep_rsb Posted May 11, 2017 Posted May 11, 2017 Maybe the priest was ill and wanted to limit his contact with the hosts people were eating. I have attended a mass where the priest was quite sick, and had EMs distribute both the Body and the Blood.
hotpink Posted May 11, 2017 Posted May 11, 2017 15 hours ago, vee said: Another parishioner disagreed with the situation so much that they stepped out of the line and sat back down upon seeing that the priest was not giving the Host. I would rather recieve from a lay person than to depreive myself totally of the sacrament but maybe he wanted to make a statement I have to say, that's a bit extreme. I often go to Daily Mass where the Priest will let the EM (usually a Brother) distribute the Eucharist and he takes care of the cup. He discerned a monistary dedicated to the Precious Blood before becoming a diocean priest. He said that years ago, as a boy, when there were many Priests, it was considered the "lower" task, assigned to the non-celebrant. He felt a special attraction to being able to distribute The Blood. He said it gave him a thrill and a passion for the Eucharist and spoke to him in a way that The Body did not. He had studied plebodomy in college so he also attributed his fascination with The Blood with his own personal interest in regular blood. Still, he said it often troubled him to the point of tears that many priests have been denied the opportunity to offer The Blood, sometimes for decades on end. That said, I think he feared retribution should he try that on a Sunday.
dUSt Posted May 11, 2017 Posted May 11, 2017 17 hours ago, vee said: Another parishioner disagreed with the situation so much that they stepped out of the line and sat back down upon seeing that the priest was not giving the Host. I would rather recieve from a lay person than to depreive myself totally of the sacrament but maybe he wanted to make a statement Why didn't they just receive the Blood from the priest?
Guest Posted May 12, 2017 Posted May 12, 2017 At the Last Supper, Jesus consecrated both bread and wine asking that both be done. I think probably for some the problem might be that for many years pre V2 we received only under the species of bread or the host and find it unable to change and get their head around the fact that Jesus asked that we receive both species (bread and wine) and so The Church (insofar as I am aware) changed that we might receive both species and included the "blood of the covenant" or the wine. Powerful words underscoring that we are saved by the death of Jesus shedding His Blood. Both species are the Body and Blood of Jesus. Quote Matthew Chapter 26 "While they were eating, Jesus took bread, said the blessing, broke it, and giving it to his disciples said, "Take and eat; this is my body." Then he took a cup, gave thanks, 16 and gave it to them, saying, "Drink from it, all of you, for this is my blood of the covenant, which will be shed on behalf of many for the forgiveness of sins." "
Jubilate Deo Posted May 12, 2017 Posted May 12, 2017 (edited) 1 hour ago, BarbaraTherese said: At the Last Supper, Jesus consecrated both bread and wine asking that both be done. ... Both species are the Body and Blood of Jesus. And since both species are the Body and Blood of Jesus, people like me who receive the Host and not from the chalice, along with all the people who attend the EF of the Mass who also receive under one species, receive both the Body and Blood that way. No worries. I personally would feel uncomfortable touching the chalice with my unconsecrated hands, just like I would be uncomfortable receiving the Host in my hands. As for the "drink from it, all of you," that you mentioned, it's important to remember that those who were with Jesus at that moment were priests. Edited May 12, 2017 by Jubilate Deo
Guest Posted May 12, 2017 Posted May 12, 2017 Insofar as I am aware, The Church allows option and choice in the matter of receiving Holy Communion under both species or only one species. Says it all for me insofar as others receiving Holy Communion are concerned.
Jubilate Deo Posted May 12, 2017 Posted May 12, 2017 40 minutes ago, BarbaraTherese said: Insofar as I am aware, The Church allows option and choice in the matter of receiving Holy Communion under both species or only one species. Says it all for me insofar as others receiving Holy Communion are concerned. I believe so, too. My post wasn't to point fingers at anyone who chooses to receive under both species. I just personally don't, although I believe I did for my First Communion.
Jubilate Deo Posted May 12, 2017 Posted May 12, 2017 “There is no Divine precept binding the laity or non-celebrating priests to receive the sacrament under both kinds (Trent, sess. XXI, c. i.) (c) By reason of the hypostatic union and of the indivisibility of His glorified humanity, Christ is really present and is received whole and entire, body and blood, soul and Divinity, under either species alone; nor, as regards the fruits of the sacrament, is the communicant under one kind deprived of any grace necessary for salvation (Trent, Sess. XXI, c., iii).” " When one travels all over the world, Catholics in most countries only receive the Holy Host. That is because these countries never ever received permission (indult) to also give the Chalice to the people. Most American Catholics will be very surprised to find out that, when attending Holy Mass at the Vatican, you will only receive the Holy Host. " http://www.traditionalcatholicpriest.com/2014/05/20/only-the-priest-receives-both-forms-of-holy-communion-at-traditional-catholic-latin-mass/ I don't know very much about this website, but the quotes are relevant here.
Guest Posted May 12, 2017 Posted May 12, 2017 (edited) I first received Holy Communion long before V2 when we received only under the Sacred Host (I am 71years of age). After V2 when it was legislated we could receive under both species, I received from then on under both and continue to do so and was very happy, over the moon in fact, when we were able to do so. In Australia, again insofar as I am aware, reception of The Blessed Eucharist under both species is widely effected under certain conditions. I am aware, however, that one receives the Body AND Blood of Jesus under one or other of the species and I have my own personal reasons (as stated above) for receiving under both species. I never take any notice at all who does or does not, too wrapped up in my own reception. I do find the wine particularly strong and if I suspect it might cause me to cough (as strong wine sometimes can), then I receive only the Sacred Host. Sometimes my mouth is quite dry from medication and that will cause me to cough with strong wine. We all probably have differing reasons for receiving either one or both species and all are probably worthy in some way, providing the Doctrine is understood, which ideally it will and should be and for sure. Interesting Vatican Document all ideally should read HERE on Holy Communion and reception of same Rather often, I think, it becomes apparent that adult education in The Faith is inadequate, even in the most important matter of all i.e. reception of The Blessed Eucharist and the related Doctrine. There is a difference, a vast difference, between culpable and inculpable ignorance. Edited May 12, 2017 by BarbaraTherese
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now