Peace Posted July 11, 2018 Posted July 11, 2018 2 hours ago, fides' Jack said: I also don't agree with Trump on everything. But I do expect him to do his job. And his job is not to interpret existing law, but to enforce it. The law dictated that children should be removed from their parents. That wasn't his decision, and in fact it happened during Bush's and Obama's administrations. Whether that's a good law or not is not up to Trump to decide. You are right, though, in that their hearts have to change, and we won't see any views change on the left. Well one must interpret a law in order to enforce it. When you wrote that did you mean something like "do something other than what you believe the law requires, after you have interpreted it"? I don't think anyone, yourself included, expects or desires the executive branch to strictly execute all of the existing laws. What we expect and desire is for the executive branch to exercise discretion, prudence, and to make reasonable decisions concerning the allocation of the scare resources that are available to enforce laws. For example, in almost every place in the united states jaywalking occurs rampantly. We expect police officers to ignore jaywalking laws, so that they do no spend 90% of their time handing out tickets for relatively harmless offenses, while taking away their time and ability to protect us against serious criminals. Whether it is prudent to strictly enforce a law that requires the separation of families under the present circumstances is also a matter of discretion for the executive branch. You apparently believe that it is prudent to do so, which is fine. But let's not sit here and pretend that what we really want is for the law to be applied strictly and by the books in every situation, under some pretense that the executive branch has the duty to enforce the law but not interpret it. Unless you think that the police should be spending their time handing out 1000 jaywalking tickets every day, and citing us for the other innumerable minor legal violations that we commit daily.
little2add Posted July 17, 2018 Posted July 17, 2018 If you were a Illegal immigrant trying to enter the United States at the Mexican border and you knew for a fact that your minor children traveling with you would be taken away from you , would you? Obviously taking away minor children from the arms of their parents is a sin. Isn’t it also a sin for the parents of said children to willingly give up their children to circumvent the sovereignty of another country especially when there is a method that millions have used in the past to enter The United States legally. I do not condone separating families. It is truly a horrendous situation, sinful for both parties
dUSt Posted July 19, 2018 Author Posted July 19, 2018 On 7/17/2018 at 8:41 AM, little2add said: Isn’t it also a sin for the parents of said children to willingly give up their children to circumvent the sovereignty of another country especially when there is a method that millions have used in the past to enter The United States legally. Depends on how bad their situation was from where they came from. If giving up their children in the United States is better than the alternative of them growing up with a 90% chance of dying of gang violence or starvation, then no, I don't think it's also a sin. I think it's trying to do best for your family.
fides' Jack Posted July 20, 2018 Posted July 20, 2018 On 7/11/2018 at 12:25 PM, Peace said: Well one must interpret a law in order to enforce it. When you wrote that did you mean something like "do something other than what you believe the law requires, after you have interpreted it"? I don't think anyone, yourself included, expects or desires the executive branch to strictly execute all of the existing laws. What we expect and desire is for the executive branch to exercise discretion, prudence, and to make reasonable decisions concerning the allocation of the scare resources that are available to enforce laws. For example, in almost every place in the united states jaywalking occurs rampantly. We expect police officers to ignore jaywalking laws, so that they do no spend 90% of their time handing out tickets for relatively harmless offenses, while taking away their time and ability to protect us against serious criminals. Whether it is prudent to strictly enforce a law that requires the separation of families under the present circumstances is also a matter of discretion for the executive branch. You apparently believe that it is prudent to do so, which is fine. But let's not sit here and pretend that what we really want is for the law to be applied strictly and by the books in every situation, under some pretense that the executive branch has the duty to enforce the law but not interpret it. Unless you think that the police should be spending their time handing out 1000 jaywalking tickets every day, and citing us for the other innumerable minor legal violations that we commit daily. All I was really pointing out was the most general level of what the president's job is. With each administration the roles of our government's branches have been getting increasingly murky, to the point where they are now greatly overlapping each other. That is extremely dangerous for the country, as it only leads to abuse in power. That being said, I think you made a great argument. Of course the president has to utilize prudence in allocating resources as he is able. However, I have a problem with people taking issue when he is executing his office according to the letter of the law. That's exactly what he was elected to do. If we have a problem with things being handled by-the-book, then we shouldn't get angry at the president, we should change the book. Lastly, I would just say that I have sympathy for those children who are legitimately removed from their parents during an illegal crossing of the border. I also have sympathy for the (seemingly same number of) children who are being used to pretend to be moving a family across in order to smuggle something into the country (sometimes the child him/herself for sex trafficking). When a huge percentage of the kids who are brought over belong to the 2nd category, I think it's absolutely best that all the children are removed from their supposed parents while the truth can be ascertained. I would have 10 kids removed from their parents for a short time to find the 1 who is being used and probably abused. All indications, though, show that number to be much higher. On 7/17/2018 at 7:41 AM, little2add said: Obviously taking away minor children from the arms of their parents is a sin. That really depends on circumstances. If they are being abused, then no, it's not. However, that excuse is used FAR too much. I think both parents should be given every opportunity to show that they are not harming children, and I think most of the time, that's not happening. Too often kids are pulled from one or both parents without any opportunity for the parent to defend their own rights. I would not extend the same argument to those trying to enter illegally. Especially for the reasons I gave above.
Anomaly Posted July 20, 2018 Posted July 20, 2018 I understand the concept of it is immoral to steal, but taking care of your family makes it okay to steal a loaf of bread. But does that translate into the baker giving away free bread to everyone who claims they need it or not stopping any shoplifters? A regulated border is not immoral as long as there are reasonable means of crossing the border according to need. Just as it is worthwhile helping a bread thief find a job to enable the purchase of bread instead of thinking the entire solution is handing out free bread, it is worth while to ask why refugees can’t fix problems in their own country.
little2add Posted July 20, 2018 Posted July 20, 2018 6 hours ago, fides' Jack said: That really depends on circumstances. If they are being abused, then no, it's not. In the context of undocumented immigrants attempting to cross the border with minor into the United States it is a sin. However escorted children (not parent or legal guardian) of immigrants attempting to enter the United States could be. IE: drug smugglers, gangs, terrorist could use them children as cover...
Guest Posted July 21, 2018 Posted July 21, 2018 2 hours ago, little2add said: In the context of undocumented immigrants attempting to cross the border with minor into the United States it is a sin. Worry about your own sin. I'm for a wall and strict immigration but people trying to get in because it's dangerous where they live I don't blame them.
little2add Posted July 21, 2018 Posted July 21, 2018 More than 653,000 immigrants naturalized in the United States in fiscal year (FY) 2014, people of all nations are welcome here, 653,000 immigrants naturalized in the United States without having to resort to abandoning their minor children or using them barter. if I were to treat my own child in such a way I would be in jail for child abuse, and rightly so! Over the past decade, the annual number of naturalizations has ranged from about 537,000 to just more than 1 million, depending on factors including processing times and backlogs as well as the financial constraints and personal motivations of immigrants themselves. the tactic of using unescorted children to expedite naturalizations is both wrong and unnecessary. Willfully putting innocent children in to mortal danger to sneak into the country is a sin. It can be done safe and legal and is every day.
little2add Posted July 21, 2018 Posted July 21, 2018 20 hours ago, Josh said: Worry about your own sin. dito
Guest Posted July 21, 2018 Posted July 21, 2018 10 minutes ago, little2add said: dito I already do. You're the one going on and on about the sin of people coming here who's lives are in danger. No-one cares that you think it's a sin. When your back is against the wall you do what you have to do in life.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now