Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Sponsa-Christi
Posted
11 minutes ago, fides' Jack said:

Basically, you're saying that the most any one person can do, their highest calling, is to do what God wills for them.  And I absolutely agree with that, completely.  My beef with this position comes when people claim that when 1 person does God's will for them 100%, and another person does God's will for them 100%, that it somehow makes them equally holy, or just equal in general.  That's really not the case.  

God calls some people to a greater holiness than other people.  That's the simple truth.  Not all vocations are equal.  Objectively speaking, a religious vocation is holier than the married life.  The early Church fathers noted this on many occasions.  

Absolutely nothing.  But that doesn't mean that one person submitting to God's will can't be more or less pleasing to God than another person submitting to His will.  

I think we could argue about the definition of the word "holy", and argue about whether one person doing His will is holier than another person doing His will.  That really depends on the definition.  But certainly, God loves some people more than others, and some people are more pleasing to Him.  I would say that's the level of being pleasing to Him is not solely based on the level at which a person does His will.

Edit: removed extra apostrophe... how embarrassing!

This reminds me of that line in the Litany of Humility: "That others may become holier than I, provided that I may become as holy as I should…Jesus, grant me the grace to desire it."

Also, I'm pretty sure that God loves Our Lady more than He loves me, and that Our Lady had a higher vocation than I do. :)

fides' Jack
Posted
Just now, Sponsa-Christi said:

This reminds me of that line in the Litany of Humility: "That others may become holier than I, provided that I may become as holy as I should…Jesus, grant me the grace to desire it."

Also, I'm pretty sure that God loves Our Lady more than He loves me, and that Our Lady had a higher vocation than I do. :)

Exactly!  

truthfinder
Posted
5 hours ago, Sponsa-Christi said:

This reminds me of that line in the Litany of Humility: "That others may become holier than I, provided that I may become as holy as I should…Jesus, grant me the grace to desire it."

Also, I'm pretty sure that God loves Our Lady more than He loves me, and that Our Lady had a higher vocation than I do. :)

Precisely!

I think in Therese's Story of a Soul, she writes about how she couldn't understand how God could give more graces to some people.  One of her sisters took two water glasses of different sizes and filled both with water. The one clearly had more water, but both were equally full - so it is with our souls. (Also reminds me of a couple years ago, a priest preached on the different levels of heaven and how some people are rewarded more.  Some people certainly didn't think that was 'fair'.) Jealousy over spiritual advancement is just as dangerous as any other jealousy or envy.

Posted

 

   http://jimmyakin.com/2006/08/who_does_god_lo.html

2 hours ago, truthfinder said:

Precisely!

I think in Therese's Story of a Soul, she writes about how she couldn't understand how God could give more graces to some people.  One of her sisters took two water glasses of different sizes and filled both with water. The one clearly had more water, but both were equally full - so it is with our souls. (Also reminds me of a couple years ago, a priest preached on the different levels of heaven and how some people are rewarded more.  Some people certainly didn't think that was 'fair'.) Jealousy over spiritual advancement is just as dangerous as any other jealousy or envy.

As I stated previously, the gift to one is a gift to all because all gifts are given for the good of all, for the good of The Church. We ought to rejoice in the gifts to others and be sad at the failings.

Posted (edited)

I think there are a lot of layers in this discussion, and while I think some good points have been made, I don’t agree with all the conclusions.

To say some vocations are higher than others doesn’t mean Christ calls some to a higher level of holiness than others. To say He does would mean you could plot the Eternal Salvations of everyone on a grid, with every single person landing at some fixed point, in relation to everyone else. And you’d have to be able to say that every single person is higher than or lower than this or that other person, in heaven. To say THAT, I think, is to miss the entire point of Heaven and the Blessed Trinity themselves.

The whole point of heaven is that, in the Beatific Vision, I myself am fused with the Trinity. I am fulfilled, 100%, and 100% perfected, and 100% in union with God. Forever. That union is based upon who God made & called me to be and how I cooperated with Him in that call.

If everyone is fully fused with & perfected in a union with Christ, we are all as close to Him as possible. No one *is closer to* Him (or closer to the 3 Divine Persons, to be accurate) than any other person is. Because you can’t get any closer than total union with the Beloved. There’s no scenario where some are only sort of united to Him, or united to Him in some lesser way, with others being fully united to Him.

To say that Christ loves His mother more than me is both true and not true. On the one hand, of course he does. And on the other hand, of course he doesn’t. He spilled every last drop of His blood for her. He did exactly the same for me. But then again, on the other hand, *she is his mother*. She is the only one He loves as mother. So of course He loves her uniquely and in a way He loves no one else. All those things are true.

To jump from Our Lady’s unique role in salvation history, to then say that X vocation (e.g., Carmelite nun, Therese Martin) is higher than another (e.g., marriage, Zelie Martin) and therefore God called Therese to a higher level of holiness than her mother is, I think, an opinion that is engulfed in a worldly view.

All of our vocations on earth exist for the Church herself in her pilgrimage to God. Some vocations are higher because of the role they play in advancing the perfection of the Church herself and bringing about the salvations of all. But to think that means that in heaven all the cloistered nuns will be higher than all the mothers is a pretty wild leap.

We know there are rewards in heaven (the crowns of martyrdom and virginity being two – I suspect there are also rewards we will only learn about once we get there). But the rewards themselves are separate from the vocations. A woman can be consecrated as a virgin and then decide to lose her virginity anyway. The vocation and the reward are 2 separate things.

If we are going to start slicing and dicing vocations & holiness & rewards (from our own limited, earthly points of view) it gets very messy, very quickly. Cloistered Dominican nun, virgin, non-martyr. Mother of 5, martyr, non-virgin. Are you really going to say one is “holier” and one is “higher” *in heaven* than the other? How one earth would any of us know?

We know, through Divine Revelation, that certain people have very special roles in salvation history (Our Lady, St. Joseph, Moses, St. Peter). Those roles and their places in salvation history have been *partially* revealed to us. To leap from that partial revelation to conclusions about everyone else who has ever lived and where they will land in heaven, in relation to everyone else, isn’t something that I think is discernible.

Likewise, we know some vocations are considered higher by the Church than others. (See my point about contemplative religious a few posts above, and why they have a special role.) But I see zero basis to conclude that a higher vocation equals a higher level of sanctity, when all is said and done.

I’m also puzzled that the discussion went from: some vocations are higher > and those people are holier > and Christ loves those people more/He loves some people more.

Christ is going to have a unique love for his Mother and His foster father St. Joseph. He’s also going to have a unique love for his patriarchs. And his prophets. And his virgin-martyrs. And his martyrs. And his martyrs in white, as JP II was. And he also has a unique love for every married couple and every family. He has a unique love for the mentally ill who were not well enough to embrace any vocation other than their own illnesses. He has a unique love for the babies who died at 1 day old.

There’s just no way to slice & dice & weigh all of that and say, “These people are holier.” “These people are higher.” “He loves these ones more.” To try to do that is to not grasp the essence of Divine Love.

On 7/9/2018 at 5:20 PM, truthfinder said:

I think in Therese's Story of a Soul, she writes about how she couldn't understand how God could give more graces to some people.  One of her sisters took two water glasses of different sizes and filled both with water. The one clearly had more water, but both were equally full - so it is with our souls.

I've always loved this teaching from St. Therese!

I didn't quote anyone directly above because I was responding to various things, not all of which were said directly, and not all of which anyone here necessarily thinks.

Edited by Laurie
Posted

all ya'll hella more holy than me, with this deep conversation. :D

Ash Wednesday
Posted

My one word answer to the original question was just going to be "prayer" 

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Posted

it'd be interesting to compare it to the love of a parent. do parents love kids to different degrees? it's not politically correct, but i wouldn't rule out some honest parents saying they do love some more than others. i remember one time though i compared it to God's love..... if God loves us all unconditionally, how can he love one more than another? or in other words infinite. how can he love someone more than someone else who he already loves infinitely? are all these concepts i'm using like infinite love just ideas of men, and not the mind of God?

fides' Jack
Posted
19 hours ago, Laurie said:

If everyone is fully fused with & perfected in a union with Christ, we are all as close to Him as possible. No one *is closer to* Him (or closer to the 3 Divine Persons, to be accurate) than any other person is. Because you can’t get any closer than total union with the Beloved. There’s no scenario where some are only sort of united to Him, or united to Him in some lesser way, with others being fully united to Him.

Wow - I just discovered the "quote selection" feature.  amesome!

I think the point is that 100% of 1 person is not the same as 100% of another person.  So, yes, I believe that God could, if He wanted to, project people's different levels on a graph or chart and show how each is different.  I do believe He loves some people more than others.  The obvious example is His Blessed Mother - I would think He should love Our Lady more than He should love me.  I don't know if that's a theologically accurate statement, but that's how it seems to me.  And if there's just one single example, it negates the entire idea of "everyone is equal in Heaven".  

Or is Our Lady just the 1 exception to the rule?  And if there's 1 exception, why not more? 

Priests are indelibly marked by the sacrament of Holy Orders.  They remain priests for all eternity.  That bestows on them certain powers, as well as certain responsibilities, for all eternity.  People who are not priests, then, do not partake to the same degree, or at the very least all the same actions, as priests do in Heaven.  Do priests get another exception to the rule?  

What about martyrs?  

And also, what about the angels?  We know there are definitely hierarchies to them.

17 hours ago, linate said:

it'd be interesting to compare it to the love of a parent. do parents love kids to different degrees?

I think the analogy of a parent is useful when it's kept simple, but I don't think God's love can be quantified the same way as a human's love can.  Additionally, God is much more to us than a simple Father.  He has other equally important roles that human parents don't have.  For these reasons I don't think we can use this analogy as an argument for why or why not some people might be loved more by God, or why some paths in life might or might not be objectively holier than others.

Interestingly, mathematically, 2 x infinity (or for simplicity, infinity + 1) can be described as being equal to infinity and not equal to infinity, simultaneously.

Posted
1 hour ago, fides' Jack said:

Wow - I just discovered the "quote selection" feature.  amesome!

It is!

 

1 hour ago, fides' Jack said:

I think the point is that 100% of 1 person is not the same as 100% of another person.  ...

I agree.

1 hour ago, fides' Jack said:

 And if there's just one single example, it negates the entire idea of "everyone is equal in Heaven". 

Everyone can be equally united to the Beloved without having to be equal in all aspects. As you point out, the angels exist in a hierarchy. I was waiting to see if someone would bring them up... But to say there are hierarchies in angels doesn't mean one angel is more loved than another, and it doesn't mean one is holier/more full of grace than another. They are all fully, full of grace, & fully united to God.

There's no dichotomy in saying a priest has a special status as priest in heaven. It's absolutely true. But it doesn't mean that all priests in heaven are going to be higher or holier or more loved by God than these other persons, because they are priests.

And, again, I myself would never mush together theological hierarchies, with levels of holiness, with how much someone is loved (more or less than another).

 

Posted (edited)

It’s just occurred to me to state 2 things.

I think some of the discussion here assumes that if someone “is equal to” someone else, that somehow must mean “they are the same.”

You can be *not the same* and still *be equal*. E.g., man & woman.

Added to that, you can be first, in an order of hierarchy, and still be equal to those who fall lower in the hierarchy than you do.

God the Father is FIRST. He is first in the sense that HE IS FATHER. In the hierarchy, He alone is Father, and that IS a hierarchy, over the Son. They are both equally Divine. One did not pre-exist the other. One is not *more God* than the other; and yet, they are also not *the same*. One is Father, one is Son.

They have a unique love for each other. And, *I* have a unique love for them. I love one as Father and one as Christ the Son. And the 3rd as Holy Spirit.

Do some of us, here on earth, love one Person of the Trinity more than another? Probably. Will we in heaven? No. Which is not to say we will love each of them *the same*. We will love each of the Persons of the Blessed Trinity equally, yet uniquely to who each of them Is.

Edited by Laurie
Posted

1 At that time the disciples 2 approached Jesus and said, "Who is the greatest in the kingdom of heaven?" He called a child over, placed it in their midst, and said, "Amen, I say to you, unless you turn and become like children, 3 you will not enter the kingdom of heaven.

Whoever humbles himself like this child is the greatest in the kingdom of heaven.

And whoever receives one child such as this in my name receives me.

(Matthew Ch18)

 

Posted

 

this says some vocations are superior to other vocations...

"This doctrine of the excellence of virginity and of celibacy and of their superiority over the married state was, as We have already said, revealed by our Divine Redeemer and by the Apostle of the Gentiles; so too, it was solemnly defined as a dogma of divine faith by the holy council of Trent, and explained in the same way by all the holy Fathers and Doctors of the Church." (Pope Pius XII, Sacra Virginitas, 32)

but i now common talk amoung catholics is that all vocations are equal. i might want to be quick to saying there's a contradiction afoot, but i realize one has to be careful with out to parse out these things, and ya'll have been doing a good job of in this thread. 

if you want to read more on a related subject, from this site.... "are all vocations equal?"

some say priests are best because without priests there are no sacraments. some say married are best because without married there are no priests. some say religious like sisters and brothers are best, because priests are "perfectoers" but the religous are "perfected", there are interesting arguments all around. 

Posted

I don't think it is a question of "better or best" personally.  I think all the vocations are linked with each other and exist in The Church under the inspiration of The Holy Spirit for the common good - the good of The Church.  And being for the good of the whole Church, they are for the good of all mankind.

I think objectively theologically speaking, the vocations can have a hierarchy and :

"From everyone who has been given much, much will be required; and from him who has been entrusted with much, even more will be demanded." (Luke Chapter 12)

The subject of this thread is "Holiness" and there can be the risk of holding to a concept that the higher theologically a vocation might be means the more holy will be the person in that vocation i.e. closer to God.  Such 'measuring' does not apply at all.    The person called to Holy Orders must strive to be a holy priest - God's Will for him.  The married person must strive to be holy in marriage - God's Will for that person.  And so on and so forth with all the various vocations.  If the married person, as an example only, tends to neglect the obligations of his or her state in life in order to spend more time in prayer - then that person has things amiss.

Who is going to be the most holy?  The one who strives to love and obey the Will of God no matter their vocational call.  God's Will is not something only connected to one's vocation, His Will is an ongoing 'conversation' for the whole of life in  all the vocations.

Posted

Jesus has expressed The Will of God for all mankind at all times in all walks of life, in all vocational calls:

"Teacher, 21 which commandment in the law is the greatest?" He said to him, 22 "You shall love the Lord, your God, with all your heart, with all your soul, and with all your mind.

This is the greatest and the first commandment.

The second is like it: 23 You shall love your neighbor as yourself.

The whole law and the prophets depend on these two commandments."

(Matthew Chapter 22)

 

  • 2 weeks later...
fides' Jack
Posted
On 7/11/2018 at 12:23 PM, Laurie said:

Everyone can be equally united to the Beloved without having to be equal in all aspects. As you point out, the angels exist in a hierarchy. I was waiting to see if someone would bring them up... But to say there are hierarchies in angels doesn't mean one angel is more loved than another, and it doesn't mean one is holier/more full of grace than another. They are all fully, full of grace, & fully united to God.

There's no dichotomy in saying a priest has a special status as priest in heaven. It's absolutely true. But it doesn't mean that all priests in heaven are going to be higher or holier or more loved by God than these other persons, because they are priests.

And, again, I myself would never mush together theological hierarchies, with levels of holiness, with how much someone is loved (more or less than another).

 

I guess that's where we disagree.  I will take that step.  God loves some more than others.  That doesn't necessarily directly correspond to hierarchical organizations.  

I would say not all in Heaven on equidistant from God.  Some are closer, some are farther away.  But all are perfectly happy.  Those closest to God will be the ones who love Him the most (and in turn are loved the most by Him).  My view of Heaven is probably somewhat closer to the view that Dante had in Paradiso.  

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...