Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Where Should I Put "Messianic Judaism"


Where Should I Put "Messianic Judaism" in the Reference Section?  

19 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

I dont know. because some say they do, some dont. And theirs no distinction like in Protestantism, they all claim to be Messanics, whether they believe in the Trinity or Not. Id put it under Non-C-Christian, but maybe put a special mark or note warning people, not all follow this.

Posted

[quote name='Quietfire' date='Jun 29 2004, 03:02 AM'] There is more than one Messianic Judaism movement out there. That is where the distinction should lay.

I was at one Messianic Jewish site and after posting there realized that they dislike Christians, and try to follow more Jewish practices than anything. They deny the Trinity (still tryin to figure that one out now that I understand the Trinity so much more) and pretty much couldnt wait til I left them alone. They claim the Trinity is a Catholic/christian invention.
Actually, one of there posters left a post stating something like, "Why do we even have to deal with these Christians, cant we have them removed?"

They are very disorganized. But almost militant in their attitude. Not all are like this, but I bet I can find more sites that have the attitude of hostility like the one I am talking about rather than the one where I got that list from.

If Phatcatholic ends up putting this under Non-Catholic:Christian. I would like it strongly noted that not all of those who claim to be Messianic Jews fall under those 'guidelines' that I posted. If they deviate outside of those guidelines, then they cannot be considered anything other than NON CHRISTIAN. [/quote]
Yes! They are extremely hostile towards Christians, they believe they are the 'Nazrenes' Im not upto date on those. But they still hold onto the Anti-Gentile attitude. Very mixed up faith, especially since the apostles didnt have such an attitude towards them, and I dont think Christ did, but theirs something in Matthew that calls gentiles dogs or something. :mellow:

Posted (edited)

Thanks MorphRC,

Look all. I am not saying it needs to be decided right now. One site in particular, where my sis is hanging out is a Messianic type site, yet when I asked them what the tenets of their faith were, NOT ONE of them could give me anything specific...except hostility.

They claim that if they can get 2 or more to agree to something then its law...I mean, thats just plain crazy! They couldnt even agree to spell Yashua the same way, (it's spelled like this, No! like this, No! My way is right.)
Very hostile towards the Church. Dont believe in the Trinity. Dont even understand the Trinity and therefore dont believe in it.

I just dont want anyone to rush into a decision just yet. This is something that is gonna be posted in the reference section and I think we should just be careful to explain to someone visiting the reference section that all Messianic Jews are not like the ones that I put in that list up there. Not all believe in the Trinity. Some are very militant. Some have extreme hostility towards anyone who says theyre Christian.
This, in all honesty, could be scary for someone who doesnt have enough information or is just discovering their faith. They could easily get confused, and I couldnt live with myself if someone were led astray because they thought that the entire Messianic movement is all nicey-nice.

I know there are extremes in all religions. But unless I am wrong, dont all Catholics believe in the Trinity (even if some arent sure exactly how to describe it beyond Father, Son, Holy Spirit.)

Just so you know, the site I speak of believes that God has 7 Spirits (as per Revelations 1:4) not 3 persons. My sis believes this too.


Peace.

Edited by Quietfire
phatcatholic
Posted (edited)

i'm putting them in the non-christian entry. i think i'm being super lenient w/ some of the groups in the christian entry as it is (pentecostalism and seventh-day adventism). messianic judaism is just too much of a stretch.

thanks for everyone's input.

pax christi,
phatcatholic

Edited by phatcatholic
Posted

Good post Quiet :)
& Ok to Phatcatholic.

Posted

First of all,
May God forgive me if I am wrong.
I am not accusing or implying that Messianic Judaism is in any way Non-christian.
I can only go by what I see and what I am told to evaluate any given situation.
I reluctantly visit (but do not post any longer as to date) and read some of their posts and threads. There is a vast confusion there, and it actually makes my stomach turn. One member actually praises and loves Jack Chick and thanks him for his coming to an understanding of Yahweh, and still thinks Jack Chick offers so much good to their cause. Yet they claim they are not Christian.

I also understand that Christ led his apostles slowly into their new understanding and knowledge, much like some Messianic movements might be doing. We may find that in a hundred years, literally thousands of Messianic Jews eventually become Catholic over time because they were able to digest this a bit at a time, bringing a richer depth to Catholicism because of their deeper knowledge of Judaism. ( I hope I am making sense here)

Catholicism came from Judaism with a deeper knowledge of understanding of what God wanted from us for Him. God was tired of the sacrifices that the Jews were offering, their many laws (almost 700) that made it nearly impossible for any to follow with earnest. The dietary restrictions and contact restrictions with Gentiles and/or Pagans, just to name a few. Try to explain this to some people and they call you an idol worshipper.

I do think though, that with the exception of that one site that I originally listed concerning their tenets of faith, that there is unequally more sites that do not follow those tenets. This is where we, as Catholics, must be careful in explaining to those who wish to learn.
To simply state that all Messianic Jews are Non-Catholic Christians would lead far too many people to think that 'they are on their way home.' For far too many who post on these very non-christian sites that claim they are M.J.'s, this would be a dangerous assumption on our part. These same people get angry if you were to call them christian. Again, there is such an underlying layer of hatred there, that any sane person would flee from these sites.

Also note that some of their members do not like even being called Messianic Jews. They claim they dont wish to be catagorized and labeled, yet cannot explain rationally as to why they feel that way.

I hope some of my thoughts make sense. I had urged that a note be included with the listing, so that everyone would understand upon visiting the reference section that not all groups that claim to be Messianic Jews are actually Messianic Jews in the sense of our understanding.

Thanks for letting me ramble.

Peace :peace:

phatcatholic
Posted

ur thoughts are one reason why i included this group in the "non-christian" entry. i also included a note saying that messianic jewish beliefs often depend upon the particular church or synagogue you join.

  • 3 weeks later...
Posted

I am new to this site, but not new to Christianity...
I would consider them Christian... because they believe that Jesus is the Christ...do they not?.....
"Christian" is a pretty all encompassing title these days that usually refers to anyone... who believes in Jesus... That he is the savior of the world... in not so specific terms... or God... or both ofcourse...
We don't want to over generalize the Messianic Jews.... because that is what many protestants do... taking small snipets of quotes and drawing all kinds of conclusions from them... usually concluding that WE are not Christians... according to their Standards of course... :)

phatcatholic
Posted

yes, but they are inconsistent both in their beliefs about Jesus and the Trinity. essentially, you're right, their beliefs cannot be generalized. so, b/c of this, and especially their inconsistency regarding Jesus and the Trinity, i decided to add them to the "Non-Catholic, Non-Christian" entry along w/a disclaimer informing the reader that Messianic Jews vary in their "Christian-ness"

(woh, new word)

pax christi,
phatcatholic

Posted

I don't understand the purpose of the catorigization?
When it comes down to it... Only God knows who the true Christians are.
St. Augustine said that "There are those inside the Church who are actually outside the Church and there are those outside the Church who are actually within the Church." (not exact quote, from memory)..
We all stand alone before God.
I do not believe that Jesus is fretting over the official doctrines to which people claim to ascribe...

phatcatholic
Posted

[quote name='mikeymc' date='Jul 27 2004, 04:09 PM'] I don't understand the purpose of the catorigization?
When it comes down to it... Only God knows who the true Christians are.
St. Augustine said that "There are those inside the Church who are actually outside the Church and there are those outside the Church who are actually within the Church." (not exact quote, from memory)..
We all stand alone before God.
[/quote]
much could be said in response, especially regarding this sentence:[list]
[*]I do not believe that Jesus is fretting over the official doctrines to which people claim to ascribe...
[/list]but i wish not to engage in debate on this issue (note: debate in the apo board is forbidden). i have already made my decision about the reference section and see no need to change it, especially since, w/ my disclaimer, i have left open the door for either intrepretation.

if you wish to discuss this topic further, i suggest starting a new thread in the debate board.

pax christi,
phatcatholic

catholicguy
Posted

I think all heretics should be grouped together; however, since these claim to be jews, they should be receive under the label: deicide.

catholicguy
Posted

[quote]St. Augustine said that "There are those inside the Church who are actually outside the Church and there are those outside the Church who are actually within the Church." (not exact quote, from memory)..
[/quote]

Actually, St. Augustine said quite the opposite:

"If you wish to be a Catholic, do not believe, nor say, nor teach, that infants who die before baptism can obtain the remission of original sin."

Even stronger, he stated:

"Whoever says that even infants are vivified in Christ when they depart this life without the participation of His Sacrament (Baptism), both opposes the Apostolic preaching and condemns the whole Church which hastens to baptize infants, because it unhesitatingly believes that otherwise they can not possibly be vivified in Christ."

Even babies who are not Baptized, which certainly is not their personal fault, cannot be saved. How are we to treat those, then, who have reached the age of use and still claim to be Christians yet have not received from the living water the Sacrament without which there is no salvation? Certainly they are not Christians!

Posted (edited)
:o I feel like I am part of a Phatmass inquisition or something..
I am trying to "discuss" this matter... A discussion can be an open dialogue...
But.. it seems like my "wording" and personal nuances of expression are being critiqued like I was claiming to speak from the Chair of Peter...
To the person who said that my St. Augustine quote was wrong.... how do claim to know that?...
I think it would be good for us all to reflect on Jesus's life.... when the Pharasees and scribes were bickering over weather it was lawful for him to heal a man on the sabbath... Jesus healed the man and said... "The sabbath was made for man, not man for the sabbath"... Also... "I desire mercy, not sacrifice"...
I think it is a big Phat waste of time to bicker over "doctrinal nuances", lets leave that to the men who's job it is... like Cardinal Ratzinger and the Bishops.....
My point over "Jesus Fretting" is that I do not believe that the measure of a Christian, is in how well he know's Catholic Doctrine... or claims to adhere to it...
I believe the measure of a Christian is in The New Testament and outlined by the Church... Jesus Said that the two greatest commandments are "To love the Lord your God with all your Heart, Mind and Soul" and " To Love your neighbor as Yourself".....
So.... my contention comes from the parable of the Good Samaritan.... Who is our Neighbor... who was the Neighbor of the beaten man?..... it wasn't the men who were concerned over violating the letter of the law.... but the man who had compassion and mercy... The Samaritan took care of the other man as if he were his brother.....
Love is the measure of a Christian Man...
Jesus specifically warns against Presuming and Judging another...
"Do not Judge lest you be judged" and "First Remove the plank in your eye before you try to remove the Spec from your brother's"
As far as the Messianic Jews go... Are you really trying to Judge them?.... At the bottom of all my posts is a quote from Fulton Sheen... the actual breadth of it goes something like this.... "First off when you get to heaven you will be suprised that you made it... then... you will look around and be suprised that some people aren't there that you were sure would be there.... then... you will be further suprised.. That there are people there that you did not think would be there." (again...from memory... It was on the show "Life is worth living".. and probably in the book)

This is not a debate... but a discussion.
Does anyone disagree with me or with Fulton Sheen?
Are my points off?
Another one of my favorite quotes comes from a priest I admire....
"May your actions be so loud that people no longer listen to what you are saying."
I believe... The measure of a Christian is not in what he says... but Who He Is and What He Does...
I have been around the block a little bit as far as Theology goes and having "debates" with people..... I have studied "Orthodox" Theology in College... and that is all good stuff... don't get me wrong... but it also has little bearing on my Salvation... God does not Care how much Theology we know..., That's like saying...if you know alot of Biology you are Holier... Theology is a Science... "The Science of God"..
I think He is concerned over how much Faith and Love we have...(Romans 13).... Or what we have done FOR our Neighbor lately... Edited by mikeymc
Posted (edited)
:sadder:
Do not take personally my comments.
I have no ill will..

I was asked at the beginning of this Post to "Please Explain Why"
I somewhat did that, and was disagreed with, and directly quoted at that....
Thus opens up the "Discussion"....
I like what you guys are doing with this site... and the Phorum...... We are all on the same team.. all Brothers... I used to have discussions like this with my buddies in College... and still do now...

The difference between a discussion and a debate... is... in a Debate... you are only trying to prove you are Right...
In a discussion.... We are both open to the truth... saying what we think... and listening to what the other has to say.... Not concerned with weather we are right or not, but with what the Truth is... what is at the Heart of the reality...
Socratic Method... The Dialectic.
Isn't our first concern to bring eachother to heaven?...not kiss eachother's behind.
Peace. Edited by mikeymc
phatcatholic
Posted

start a thread in the debate board

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...