Gov. Cuomo, Cardinal Dolan Spar Over New York Abortion Law Amid Bishops’ Calls For Excommunication

[KnightofChrist]

Dr Peter's is normally very solid, and a trustworthy source, normally. In this case, for me, his position smells funny and I have my doubts. 

[Jack4]

3 hours ago, Peace said:

Have you ever disagreed with them?

Not yet. I haven't read everything they've written, and my knowledge of their fields (Canon law and philosophy) is limited. FWIW I've disagreed with other traditionalist bloggers. 

[CatherineM]

Lawyer, Theological Masters, studied Canon Law. 

I am so torn. I did my pastoral theology thesis on the pastoral care of pro-choice politicians. I want them gone, but I don’t think we need to make pro-choice martyrs. I think it needs to be handled pastorally not publicly. 

There’s probably lots of people receiving communion who shouldn’t due to mortal sin. It’s above my pay grade.