Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Canberra ACT - Archbishop refuses to allow breaking the seal


Recommended Posts

cruciatacara
Posted
6 hours ago, fides' Jack said:

I sincerely hope, with all my heart, that you are correct, and that they are all in heaven.  I really do hope that.  But I would never assume that to be the case, specifically because that constitutes the sin of presumption.

And you are assuming that I am presuming. Once again, you leap to judgment without evidence. We have no evidence that babies aren't with Jesus, just as we have no evidence that they are. My hope lies in Him because He is the Resurrection and the Life. He also said that anyone who harms the least of these, it were better for him if he had never been born. I can safely assume (not presume) from this that Jesus really likes little babies. If I choose to assume (not presume) that His mercy is so great as to include the innocents (remember the Holy Innocents) then it is none of your concern. And it is a great presumption on your part to determine my sins.

If I choose to believe that Jesus would care for the unbaptised babies at least as much as He cared for the babies when Herod killed the Holy Innocents, then it is my right to do so. You are the one talking about presumption- I am talking about assumption, based on faith and hope and God's love.

So I still say that conscious children suffer more when they have to endure years of sexual and psychological abuse at the hands of pedophiles. My right to an opinion, just as you have yours.

We can argue about God's mercy until the cows come home (if they ever do) but this is a matter of opinion, not dogma, since the Church is unsure on this point.

fides' Jack
Posted
On 4/3/2019 at 3:48 PM, cruciatacara said:

And you are assuming that I am presuming. Once again, you leap to judgment without evidence. We have no evidence that babies aren't with Jesus, just as we have no evidence that they are. My hope lies in Him because He is the Resurrection and the Life. He also said that anyone who harms the least of these, it were better for him if he had never been born. I can safely assume (not presume) from this that Jesus really likes little babies. If I choose to assume (not presume) that His mercy is so great as to include the innocents (remember the Holy Innocents) then it is none of your concern. And it is a great presumption on your part to determine my sins.

If I choose to believe that Jesus would care for the unbaptised babies at least as much as He cared for the babies when Herod killed the Holy Innocents, then it is my right to do so. You are the one talking about presumption- I am talking about assumption, based on faith and hope and God's love.

So I still say that conscious children suffer more when they have to endure years of sexual and psychological abuse at the hands of pedophiles. My right to an opinion, just as you have yours.

We can argue about God's mercy until the cows come home (if they ever do) but this is a matter of opinion, not dogma, since the Church is unsure on this point.

We're not arguing about God's mercy.  Actually, it sounds like we agree about the basic matter of the argument regarding unbaptized babies: the "Church is unsure on this point".  That's really where our disagreement is, so since you recognize the Church's position, there really isn't an argument at all.

Whether or not you "assume" or "presume", you're really just playing word games.  Assuming is just as bad as presuming.  In fact, in this context, it's really the same thing, and to either assume or presume that unbaptized babies are saved, when the Church herself - guided by the Holy Spirit and with millennia of wisdom - admits to not being sure, is the sin of presumption.  I don't know if you're guilty of that.  I will say that the words you are choosing to use convey an attitude of the sin of presumption.  That's as far as I'm willing to go toward charitable, fraternal correction.

But, reviewing one of my past statements, I did say, "You assume [...] and for you to assume it is probably sinful in itself".  That statement does imply a slight contradiction to what I'm saying in the last paragraph.  For that, I apologize for the poor choice of words; I never personally judged you and never intended to judge you specifically in any way, but rather to make clear the potential moral difference between something terrible and something really bad.

That being said, do you or do you not presume or assume that unbaptized babies go to heaven?  If you say yes, then perhaps my prior statement was correct, anyway.  If your answer is that you want to believe they are in heaven, but like the Church you don't know for sure, then we are of the exact same mindset.

On 4/3/2019 at 3:48 PM, cruciatacara said:

If I choose to assume (not presume) that His mercy is so great as to include the innocents (remember the Holy Innocents) then it is none of your concern.

This is my one real beef with your statement.  This is a public forum.  Specifically a Catholic, public forum.  When you post here and then I post a rebuttal with some clarifying remarks, it doesn't really make sense for you to claim it's not my concern.  If you post in a public place, whether or not it's anyone's concern ceases to be a factor in the discussion.  I can really only respond to the public statements you make.  When you make a statement, it becomes the concern of anyone who wants to read it.

My end goal here is simply to reiterate the Church's position, as I understand it.  And if others can point to an area of Church teaching in which I'm in error (as has happened here in the past), then I can learn from my misunderstandings, and in doing so grow closer to God.

fides' Jack
Posted

-----------------------------------------------------------

One last thought, just to get this back on track: my argument is that if you don't really know where unbaptized babies go, to murder one of them is morally worse than pedophilia since you could be depriving them of even the chance of reaching heaven.  Sure, they would suffer less, but the weight of a sin is not really dependent on the amount of physical suffering it inflicts on other people.

Personally, I believe that the seal of Confession is much more than just a matter of law... Or to put it another way, it's a law based on a specific moral truth, and to remove the law would be to sin against that truth.  It's important enough that the Church has almost always maintained it's necessary for the salvation of souls.  And that is more important than trying to save some people from potential suffering, even when it's an awful, awful lot of potential suffering.  Especially when there's no real evidence that any single person would actually be spared from that suffering.

Posted

Hi. I was reading the replies here and I found this in regards to Jesus and children.

Question: "Why did Jesus say, ‘Let the little children come to me’?"

Answer: At one point during Jesus’ earthly ministry, some children were brought to Him so that He could lay hands on them and pray for them (Matthew 19:13). The disciples tried to turn the children away, but Jesus said, “Let the little children come to me, and do not hinder them, for the kingdom of heaven belongs to such as these” (verse 14). Mark 10:14 (KJV) adds that Jesus was “much displeased” with His disciples for their actions. He then blessed the children (Matthew 19:15).

There are two potentially puzzling elements to this story. First, why did the disciples try to keep the children away from Jesus? Also, what did Jesus mean when he said, “Let the little children come to me . . . for the kingdom of heaven belongs to such as these”?

It is important to remember that children in Jesus’ time were not necessarily regarded as special or particularly endearing, except to their own parents. Many cultures today look on children as especially sweet, innocent, and even wise. Jewish culture in that day probably did not see children in such optimistic terms. The disciples most likely rebuked those bringing the children to Jesus because they felt bringing children to Jesus was socially improper or because they thought the children would bother Jesus. It is likely that their move to hinder the parents from bringing their children to Jesus was motivated not by unkindness but by a desire to respect Jesus’ position as a teacher. But Jesus wanted the children to come to Him. He said, “Let the children come,” because He wanted to bless them.

It is wonderful to think of Jesus interacting with a child. Children are needy and dependent, and they know almost nothing about life. They function mostly on emotion rather than reason. Yet Jesus said, “The kingdom of heaven belongs to such as these” (Matthew 19:14). Scripture often compares believers to children (e.g., Luke 10:21; Galatians 4:19; 1 John 4:4). In fact, Jesus told those following Him, “Truly I tell you, unless you change and become like little children, you will never enter the kingdom of heaven. Therefore, whoever takes the lowly position of this child is the greatest in the kingdom of heaven” (Matthew 18:3–4; cf. Mark 10:15).

Jesus’ command to “let the little children come to me” reveals several truths: 1) Children need to be blessed by the Lord. 2) The Lord wants to bless children. 3) Parents should be encouraged to bring their children to Jesus at an early age and teach them His ways. 4) Jesus has regard for the weakest and most vulnerable among us. 5) No matter how compassionate Jesus’ followers are, Jesus Himself is more compassionate still. 6) Those who come to Christ must do so in childlike humility, faith, and simplicity.

Like children who implicitly trust their parents, believers trust God. Faith is not about knowing everything or doing everything right. It is about knowing that, no matter what happens, our Father will take care of us. That trust in Him, even when life is terrifying and sad and makes no sense, is what makes a believer like a child. “All those the Father gives me will come to me, and whoever comes to me I will never drive away” (John 6:37). God loves His children.

God bless....

cruciatacara
Posted

@Gary david you seem to get what @fides' Jack appears to miss.

4 hours ago, Gary david said:

Like children who implicitly trust their parents, believers trust God. Faith is not about knowing everything or doing everything right. It is about knowing that, no matter what happens, our Father will take care of us. That trust in Him, even when life is terrifying and sad and makes no sense, is what makes a believer like a child. “All those the Father gives me will come to me, and whoever comes to me I will never drive away” (John 6:37). God loves His children.

 

fides' Jack
Posted
5 hours ago, Gary david said:

Faith is not about knowing everything or doing everything right. It is about knowing that, no matter what happens, our Father will take care of us. That trust in Him, even when life is terrifying and sad and makes no sense, is what makes a believer like a child. “All those the Father gives me will come to me, and whoever comes to me I will never drive away” (John 6:37). God loves His children.

"Faith is the virtue by which we firmly believe all the truths which the Holy Catholic Church teaches, because God has revealed them."  (So you're right, it's not about knowing everything or doing everything right, it's about belief - do I believe what the Church teaches?)  

"Hope is the virtue by which we firmly trust that God will, in His mercy, give us eternal happiness and the means to obtain it."  (This speaks to what you're talking about - so it's not about faith, it's really about hope)

"Charity is the virtue by which we love God above all things for His own sake, and our neighbor as ourselves for the love of God."  If anything, I would say the virtue of love has more to do with doing what's right, and also what drives us to know more about God.  Love is the most important of the 3 theological virtues, and is what leads to faith and hope.  

What do we have to do to go to heaven?  We have to "know, love, and serve God in this world".  Trust (hope) is important, but it stems from faith and love, and if you want to go to heaven, is less important than faith and love.  "He who does not believe will be condemned" (Mark 16:16).

Posted

What else do we really have without complete trust in God? We either choose God or man.

  God bless.....

fides' Jack
Posted

That is an aspect of living as a Catholic - complete trust in God (which doesn't mean we have complete trust that ourselves and all our loved ones will go to heaven).  Choosing God means a whole lot more than having complete trust in God, though.  And it's important not to fall into the common protestant heresy where for them complete trust in God literally translates into the false doctrine of faith alone.  There's a lot outside of trust that we have to do, and say, and believe, and adhere to.

Posted

Trust in God for me is not a general statement. Trust in God is trust in Jesus and all that He taught us. Trusting in God should be a living statement not hidden to others. It will be.displayed in all that we do and say. Its about faith through the good times and the difficult. There are no false doctrines if one in fact does trust.in Jesus in all matters. It is what Jesus expects of us. He has shown us what a loving God we have. I for myself need no more evidence of what I just stated. Well thats my opinion driven by my faith.

  God bless you....

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...