Seven77 Posted July 12, 2019 Author Posted July 12, 2019 3 hours ago, Josh said: I'm out. Have fun. feel free to still join in if you want
Seven77 Posted July 12, 2019 Author Posted July 12, 2019 (edited) A little background to the trilogy-- CS Lewis wrote Into the Silent Planet after a conversation with his friend J.R.R. Tolkien, who had already written the Hobbit but had not published it. I read that they had a kind of friendly competition to write fantasy that somehow spoke about the dignity of the human person created by God to combat all the ideologies that were coming up and them that were destructive and dehumanizing. Anyway, the e-book version didn't have any introduction. I just remember reading this somewhere. I also just finished chapter 1 and want to share some of my thoughts. Please don't read this till you finish chapter 1 Thoughts on Chapter 1 So, we just met the main character, Ransom, who happens to be a philologist--as was Tolkien. That's interesting. It's an important fact that we should keep in mind---a philologist study languages and has an idea of how people communicate with each other. I think that's going to come in handy on his adventure that seems almost imminent now that he's in this strange house. Something weird is going on. Where were they, Weston and Devine, really trying to send the boy? Maybe he's not that smart, but he's scared of going back into wherever they asked him to go, apparently, as their guinea pig. Even though Ransom knows something suspicious is up, why is he sticking around ? About Ransom himself, he seems like the sort of person that you can trust to do the right thing. What do you guys think so far? Edited July 12, 2019 by Seven77
dUSt Posted July 12, 2019 Posted July 12, 2019 Chapter 1 thoughts: Ransom seems like he has interest in doing the right thing, but avoids conflict as much as possible. This is evidenced by the fact that even though he didn’t like the guy from school, he was still friendly and cordial instead of confronting him on any issue he had with him. Ransom also seems to always assume the best in people, even though he’s smart enough to know it’s probably not the wisest thing to do.
Seven77 Posted July 13, 2019 Author Posted July 13, 2019 And it seems that right now, he's really tired and just wants to rest... even though he doesn't really trust the guy, he's really hoping for the best. By the way, can we get the title of this thread changed to something like CS Lewis' Space Trilogy Book Discussion?
little2add Posted July 13, 2019 Posted July 13, 2019 Loved the trilogy, good read Another good read is: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/17343.Till_We_Have_Faces
Anomaly Posted July 14, 2019 Posted July 14, 2019 A couple of things. I’m really curious about WHY Devine and Weston had to bring another person for the Aliens. Whats the symbolism of them being naked in the space ship and the sense of euphoria when in the light? Is it a metaphor for Eden? It is notable that Ransom is the one operating with the least amount of knowledge(as we the readers are). D and W have been there before, they built a hut, and the inhabitants of Malacondra have interacted before. It will be interesting to see what their various perceptions and assumptions are of each other. Are Sorns bad as R was told? What was the creature in the water?
dUSt Posted July 17, 2019 Posted July 17, 2019 3 hours ago, Anomaly said: Are we all caught up through Chapter 5? I am!
Seven77 Posted July 17, 2019 Author Posted July 17, 2019 On 7/14/2019 at 9:48 AM, Anomaly said: A couple of things. I’m really curious about WHY Devine and Weston had to bring another person for the Aliens. Whats the symbolism of them being naked in the space ship and the sense of euphoria when in the light? Is it a metaphor for Eden? It is notable that Ransom is the one operating with the least amount of knowledge(as we the readers are). D and W have been there before, they built a hut, and the inhabitants of Malacondra have interacted before. It will be interesting to see what their various perceptions and assumptions are of each other. Are Sorns bad as R was told? What was the creature in the water? So, in light of what we read in chapter 5, Devine and Weston seem to be following orders from some higher up… maybe one of the inhabitants, a Sorn chief leader has asked for a creature to be sacrificed to his people in exchange for something. About the two villains, one seems to be bent on following orders on some kind idea that what they're doing is making progress for humanity, etc., he's wrong but he is idealistic. I think that you're right about the symbolism… I think that it is hinting to Eden--- and remember that weird dream Ransom had when he was drugged, about a garden? In reality, he really did break into a garden. Oh yeah, I really love those lines about space being alive, warm, lit and not dead, cold, dark. Reading it for the first time gave me about peace about the idea of space. It's the "womb of worlds." ( all caught up by way, ready for chapters 6 through 10 )
Anomaly Posted July 17, 2019 Posted July 17, 2019 Thinking about it being written in 1938 and the current moral attitudes... Did anybody else note the attitude of Weston about using the mentally challenged boy instead of Ransom in their original plan? He felt it was morally okay as his death would likely the only valuable benefit to society?
dUSt Posted July 17, 2019 Posted July 17, 2019 47 minutes ago, Anomaly said: Thinking about it being written in 1938 and the current moral attitudes... Did anybody else note the attitude of Weston about using the mentally challenged boy instead of Ransom in their original plan? He felt it was morally okay as his death would likely the only valuable benefit to society? Yeah I did notice that but didn't think much about it. I guess I just assumed it was because he was a villain so that's how a bad guy would think. Didn't ponder the thought of that just being the common attitude for everyone in 1938. It was interesting to me to read about the spaceship being like a mini planet where the center of gravity was the center of the ship. One thing I didn't understand is how you are able to be in the day on one side of the ship and in the night on the other side. Oh wait. I think I just figured it out. The side facing the sun is the day side. Duh. lol
Anomaly Posted July 17, 2019 Posted July 17, 2019 I’m not sure it was a common attitude, but it is part of the whole “class” system that society struggles to evolve from. I notice it often in older period novels. I’ve read ahead a bit and I want to talk more about this issue in the context of later events.
Seven77 Posted July 17, 2019 Author Posted July 17, 2019 Yeah, glad you mentioned that Anomaly… Weston has that whole, the end justifies the means thing going on. We can use a mentally challenged kid as a guinea pig, we can kidnap some random professor, in the name of progress and furthering humanity, etc. And when Ransom says that it was wrong of them to kidnap him, Weston is like, "you're thinking too much about yourself!"
dUSt Posted July 17, 2019 Posted July 17, 2019 I'll be on a couple flights tomorrow so will probably have read through Chapter 10, at least, by this weekend.
Seven77 Posted July 25, 2019 Author Posted July 25, 2019 Has everyone caught up? If so… They finally made it to the planet Malacandra– – Mars? It's not supposed to be like realistic science fiction, by the way (Ransom and the other two humans being able to breathe), and like a lot of science fiction, all the sci-fi stuff is actually a means to other themes and philosophical questions, etc. it's an interesting planet for sure. The mountains and creatures seem to defy gravity… Everything seems lighter on this planet. I think that Ransom has good survival instincts from his long walks and travels in The countryside. It got ingrained in him even though he didn't know it. Also, the fact that he's a linguist… Maybe there's some reason why it had to be him?He seems to be having what it takes to kind of get along on this planet.
dUSt Posted July 30, 2019 Posted July 30, 2019 Yes! I'm through chapter 10. Gonna try to get through Chapter 15 tonight. I love the descriptions of Malacandra. I can picture this vertical landscape where everything is light and long and wavy. I wonder if it has ever been depicted in art? Update: Found these. Cool!
Anomaly Posted July 30, 2019 Posted July 30, 2019 Okay. I’ll start reading it again. I read another book in the meantime. Excellent book. Exceptional writer. “Washington Black, A Novel”. What she creates with words was astounding. Kinda makes reading Lewis a chore.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now