KnightofChrist Posted April 21, 2020 Posted April 21, 2020 2 hours ago, Delivery said: It's what he said. Did you listen? You are lying. I'd challenge you to post a direct quote but you cannot. Because you are lying.
Guest Posted April 21, 2020 Posted April 21, 2020 1 hour ago, chrysostom said: He did not mention the TLM. She did when she asked the question. She said what if you can't find a Latin Mass?
chrysostom Posted April 21, 2020 Posted April 21, 2020 1 hour ago, Delivery said: She did when she asked the question. She said what if you can't find a Latin Mass? And he didn't, and I think that's quite deliberate. He chose to qualify his response very heavily. This is like insisting that Pope Francis meant the wrong thing in one of his interviews. His interviews are simply sometimes ambiguous, and we have to live with it. In this case of Bp Schneider it is a little ambiguous. I fully understand if someone has a problem with that. That being said, he did not actually say what you accuse him of saying. He was being circumspect, couching his statement in many conditions. He said the ambiguous thing, not the definite thing. Clearly this statement is already enough to cause lots of angry online debates about it, and I don't think Lifesite should even have asked that question, and Steve Skojec is being scandalous.
chrysostom Posted April 21, 2020 Posted April 21, 2020 (edited) But again, what's the point of attacking all trads as a part of this criticism, even if the criticism of Schneider is entirely accurate? Would you be fine with attacking all Catholics of any type any time Pope Francis or Pope Benedict says something wrong? (I have no problem with you taking issue with what he said, though I may argue about what he meant) Edited April 21, 2020 by chrysostom
Aloysius Posted April 21, 2020 Posted April 21, 2020 Bishop Schneider himself, to my understanding, while he does celebrate the extraordinary form he does not do so exclusively, but does sometimes also do the ordinary form. If he was saying what you say he said, he'd either be a hypocrite, a coward, and/or an idiot. Clearly the more likely explanation is that people have cited him stating that you do not have an obligation when the only mass available to you is an abusive one, and those people have a certain definition of what constitutes 'abusive' that basically means anything that is not the TLM/extraordinary form. It is clear that this is not the line he has in mind, as he is someone who is a bishop in good standing in a church where the ordinary form is the norm. The principle in what Schneider says is sound IMHO: if the only mass you have available to you is excessively abusive, you do not have an obligation to attend it. Where that line is, that is debatable. Schneider's line is probably more strict than yours (or mine to be honest) and perhaps he could/should be critiqued on that, but the principle is sound and can be demonstrated by thinking of an extreme example: if the only mass you have available has incorporated outright idolatry into part of it, then even if the core of the mass is valid, you would not have an obligation to attend it. I think that should be uncontroversial. Now where should that line be drawn on less extreme liturgical abuses? I think it's something for a prudent conscience to think about with the basic question--is the abusive thing truly harming my spiritual life? be careful with that, as an agitated emotional state built on ego and haughtiness and false piety could be confused for being harmed spiritually. some agitated emotional states and suffering through things not being exactly as they should be can be offered up and endured in ways that are conducive to grace. but if the answer is truly 'yes, this is spiritually harming me' to a well-formed conscience due to something happening in that liturgy that is wrong according to the church and her traditions, you wouldn't be obliged to attend, in which case you should seek another mass and if one is not available you would not be obliged to attend the excessively abusive mass.
Guest Posted April 21, 2020 Posted April 21, 2020 1 hour ago, chrysostom said: That being said, he did not actually say what you accuse him of saying. He was being circumspect, couching his statement in many conditions. He said the ambiguous thing, not the definite thing. She ask if there's no Latin Mass and all the priests are modernists and support heresies what should people do? He says don't go to Mass. So we can decide that as Catholics? We can find faults with the Mass or the priests and dispense ourselves from the Sunday obligation? Because he just said we could. He said even if the Eucharist is valid he would advise to stay home. 2 hours ago, chrysostom said: Clearly this statement is already enough to cause lots of angry online debates about it, and I don't think Lifesite should even have asked that question, and Steve Skojec is being scandalous. I have no idea if it's causing lots of angry online debates. The exchange I screenshot wasn't that. It was two trads (one of which) is confused how Catholics can dispense themselves from going to Mass on their own judgement that the Novus Ordo is full of abuses and modernist priests. There was no heated exchange their because both believe (like the SSPX do) that the Novus Ordo is evil. What's happening in the conversation is the one trad is feeling conflicted into agreeing with Steve (and the Bishop according to Steve) that Catholics can dispense themselves from the Sunday obligation. 2 hours ago, chrysostom said: But again, what's the point of attacking all trads as a part of this criticism, even if the criticism of Schneider is entirely accurate? My bad on that. To all the non racist trads that don't call the Novus Ordo evil you have my apology. To all the trads who don't agree with Tan Book's racist assentment of an entire race of people you have my apology. 2 hours ago, chrysostom said: (I have no problem with you taking issue with what he said, though I may argue about what he meant) I've got to much into religious commentary on websites. I don't talk about it to people in real life. Nor on Facebook or Instagram. I honestly don't care enough to and most people wouldn't even understand what I was talking about. I just get compelled to comment on this stuff on Catholic websites.
Aloysius Posted April 21, 2020 Posted April 21, 2020 it is an interesting dilemma, should an individual Catholic feel dispensed from their Sunday obligation on their own judgment? Consider a scenario in which every mass began with an invocation to the Caananite god moloch, but otherwise still went on as usual and the priest still intended to do what the Church does. maybe this priest believes moloch is just symbolic and is a relativist on such things, but he still has the proper intention and hence the Eucharist is still valid. can an individual Catholic decide not to be obliged to go? absolutely, based on a well-formed conscience telling them it was spiritually harmful to them. But this is a dangerous line of thinking, especially with modern ppl inclined to think they should "vote with their feet" or "vote with their wallet" how they want things to be--such an attitude would be incredibly prideful when applied to a liturgy. If the Mass just has a guitar and some happy clappy music but is still otherwise valid, then I'm sorry if you're emotionally agitated by it but I don't think a well-formed conscience should consider that spiritually harmful.
Guest Posted April 21, 2020 Posted April 21, 2020 (edited) 13 minutes ago, Aloysius said: Bishop Schneider himself, to my understanding, while he does celebrate the extraordinary form he does not do so exclusively, but does sometimes also do the ordinary form. If he was saying what you say he said, he'd either be a hypocrite, a coward, and/or an idiot. Clearly the more likely explanation is that people have cited him stating that you do not have an obligation when the only mass available to you is an abusive one, and those people have a certain definition of what constitutes 'abusive' that basically means anything that is not the TLM/extraordinary form. It is clear that this is not the line he has in mind, as he is someone who is a bishop in good standing in a church where the ordinary form is the norm. If that's the case (and if you think it is that's good enough for me) I apologise to the Bishop. My fault. I went by Steve's tweet and his assessment on what the Bishop said. And I know the Bishop is affiliated with One Peter Five. And when I heard the interview it seemed he was saying that. But I have no problem admitting I was misunderstood. 13 minutes ago, Aloysius said: The principle in what Schneider says is sound IMHO: if the only mass you have available to you is excessively abusive, you do not have an obligation to attend it. Where that line is, that is debatable. Schneider's line is probably more strict than yours (or mine to be honest) and perhaps he could/should be critiqued on that, but the principle is sound and can be demonstrated by thinking of an extreme example: if the only mass you have available has incorporated outright idolatry into part of it, then even if the core of the mass is valid, you would not have an obligation to attend it. I think that should be uncontroversial. Now where should that line be drawn on less extreme liturgical abuses? I think it's something for a prudent conscience to think about with the basic question--is the abusive thing truly harming my spiritual life? be careful with that, as an agitated emotional state built on ego and haughtiness and false piety could be confused for being harmed spiritually. some agitated emotional states and suffering through things not being exactly as they should be can be offered up and endured in ways that are conducive to grace. but if the answer is truly 'yes, this is spiritually harming me' to a well-formed conscience due to something happening in that liturgy that is wrong according to the church and her traditions, you wouldn't be obliged to attend, in which case you should seek another mass and if one is not available you would not be obliged to attend the excessively abusive mass. Thanks for this perspective. Appreciate it. Edited April 21, 2020 by Guest
Guest Posted April 21, 2020 Posted April 21, 2020 1 hour ago, Delivery said: heated exchange their because both believe (like the SSPX do) that the Novus Ordo is evil. *there
Guest Posted April 21, 2020 Posted April 21, 2020 (edited) Taylor Marshall Edited April 21, 2020 by Guest
Aloysius Posted April 21, 2020 Posted April 21, 2020 I'm not a fan of this kind of guilt by association, Schneider clearly supports the thesis of Dr. Marshall's infiltration book. is he right or wrong on this? there's something we could debate. but does his support for Marshall's thesis on infiltration imply he is connected to this other person who appears to be (at least sympathetic to if not an outright proponent of) alt-right white identitarianism? I don't think so. That's something to critique Marshall for, does Marshall support that same stuff? I really hope not. I don't agree with the guy but I really hope he hasn't gotten himself entangled in such vile stuff. The bug comment is rather problematic, though tone and context would be important to judge whether it was truly a mean-spirited thing or some kind of joke not actually intended to be mean-spirited or dehumanizing. your screen shots of this woman with Marshall seem to be relating to a satanic mass she was protesting? is this before or after the incidents of daily stormer/unite the right stuff you're mentioning? has Marshall stated anything for or against what she said at unite the right or daily stormer? there is indeed a problem in radtrad communities that, mostly due to their niche marginal position, they do attract some people with other niche marginal ideologies, some of which are vile like this. in my experience I don't think the majority of the radtrad community is like this, at least i definitely hope not. probably the present political environment has seen a seeping contagion from the present configuration of the extreme right / alt-right of the US political spectrum, unfortunately. but I don't think this kind of discourse trying to build guilt by associations and endless decries of being offended is a healthy way to root it out.
Anastasia Posted April 22, 2020 Posted April 22, 2020 While I have nothing to say re: the above Bishop Schneider is worthy of respect because he said what the whole Church should of say: "As long as supermarkets are open and accessible, and as long as people have access to public transportation, one cannot see a plausible reason for banning people from assisting at Holy Mass in a church,” Bishop Schneider said. “One can guarantee in churches the same and even better hygienic protective measures.” https://remnantnewspaper.com/web/index.php/articles/item/4826-exclusive-interview-bishop-athanasius-schneider-on-church-s-handling-of-coronavirus To me at least his point of view gave some comfort.
Guest Posted April 22, 2020 Posted April 22, 2020 (edited) 7 hours ago, Anastasia said: "As long as supermarkets are open and accessible, and as long as people have access to public transportation, one cannot see a plausible reason for banning people from assisting at Holy Mass in a church,” Bishop Schneider said. “One can guarantee in churches the same and even better hygienic protective measures.” This was printed March 27th. Ridiculous and unscientific advice. It's the Remnant though so I wouldn't expect anything different. You're not shoulder to shoulder in a grocery for an hour not moving. The "plausible reason" Mass was suspended was to save lives. Michael Matt has said the same idiotic things throughout the pandamic. Not surprised at all. He's always been an *******. Again in real life I pay no mind to fanatics like Matt and The Best Catholics of All Time. But on the internet I fall victim. It was actually refreshing to agree with Steve Skojec once in my life about his views on the pandamic. He has consistently tweeted responsible information about the virus and how dangerous and deadly it is. And also defending the Church's authority on closing to save lives and not spread the virus and overwhelm hospitals. Edited April 22, 2020 by Guest
Guest Posted April 22, 2020 Posted April 22, 2020 (edited) 34 minutes ago, Delivery said: The "plausible reason" Mass was suspended was to save lives. I said that wrong. Mass wasn't suspended. Rather the laity being able to attend. My bad. Edited April 22, 2020 by Guest
little2add Posted April 23, 2020 Posted April 23, 2020 6 hours ago, Delivery said: 6 hours ago, Delivery said: I said that wrong. Mass wasn't suspended. Rather the laity being able to attend. My bad.
Anastasia Posted April 23, 2020 Posted April 23, 2020 Quote >> You're not shoulder to shoulder in a grocery for an hour not moving. The "plausible reason" Mass was suspended was to save lives. Yes, this is a very popular augment yet it does not work being considered closely. Let’s take a huge cathedral and the early Mass that gathers five-ten people at most (I am speaking about the situation in a town I live). It is very easy to space them, one person per… five benches etc. In supermarkets people move chaotically and come much closer than that But even if this is somehow “dangerous” (it is not) I cannot see how Mass or Liturgy can be different from… a takeaway. Just like with takeaways people could wait outside of the church building (being spaced of course), listen to Mass done inside and then a priest could give communion to the believers. It is possible to organize such things if they are desired of course. If Holy Communion was considered to be as important as food then it would be done. The horror of a current situation, to me at least that the Church stopped being “essential” – not just for the world (it is expected) but for itself. The discussed Bishop has a strong sense of the Church/Eucharist as essential. He and many others simply cannot understand how it is possible that takeaways and retails are open and churches are closed (and even more, how churches can be closed regardless anything else). The argument boils down to a sense what is acceptable and what is not. “Logically speaking” anything can be proved and excused, especially “for the good of others” like “we do not have communion because we want to save lives”. To me it is oxymoron; to others it is perfectly reasonable. To make a total: if we believe in the Real Presence than we cannot simply close the churches. Via shutting down the churches we shut down the Presence of Christ. One may argue it is not so, He is still there, in Tabernacle – but the sight of the "shut down churches" obliterated that knowledge. 6 hours ago, Delivery said: I said that wrong. Mass wasn't suspended. Rather the laity being able to attend. My bad. Well, you expressed the Eastern Orthodox point of view . To us, the Liturgy done by the clergy only, is incomplete and "not normal" so to speak. "Liturgy" is translated as "the common business" or "something all congregation does" an understood as such.
Lilllabettt Posted April 23, 2020 Posted April 23, 2020 10 hours ago, Anastasia said: It is possible to organize such things if they are desired of course. If Holy Communion was considered to be as important as food then it would be done. This is true.
Lea Posted April 23, 2020 Posted April 23, 2020 10 hours ago, Anastasia said: Let’s take a huge cathedral and the early Mass that gathers five-ten people at most Well, I live in an area that allows public services with max. 15 attendees. Without singing together, holy water, signs of the cross (touching ones face), an altered distribution of the Eucharist - the priest will stand as far away as possible, says nothing like "The body of Christ!", wears gloves or disinfects hands after each person, it seems rather strange to me. The lists for attending are incredibly long, but I personally decided against it. 1. I don't want to take the opportunity away for persons possibly living alone and that are starving more than I do. 2. It's a way to stand in solidarity with those who are not allowed to join Mass right now because they are high risk or for other reasons. And I know even vowed religious who have decided likewise.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now