Soldier4Him Posted July 3, 2004 Posted July 3, 2004 (edited) I was headed into the grocery store to buy some soup (I had a craving for a specific brand of Wild Rice) and there was a girl, probably 17ish sitting outside. She looked up at me sadly and asked if I had any spare change for gas. She didn't look very good. I said Sorry, I don't. And she looked down kind of dejectedly and nodded and I continued inside. After going in, it kept plaguing me. The verse about "when you didn't do this for the least of my brothers, you also failed to do it for me" entered my head and my heart sank. I failed to help someone in need, therefore I failed to help Christ. I was wearing a religious t-shirt, and thought what a hypocrite am I! I decided on my way out I'd slip her five bucks. But she was gone, no where in sight. I had already failed my test! Learn from my mistake.... Edited July 3, 2004 by Soldier4Him
immaculata Posted July 3, 2004 Posted July 3, 2004 S4H, Obviously you didn't completely fail if you learned something from it! It's a tough decision to make, especially in this day and age when it seems like everyone's out there to scam you. Be thankful that you're feeling guilty about this, because it means that at least your conscience is alive and functioning properly! Take it as a learning experience, and next time when you come across a homeless person or someone asking for help, you'll be more aware and maybe find a way to help them. The best thing you could probably do is say a few extra prayers for that person tonight. God bless! ~Kat
Iacobus Posted July 3, 2004 Posted July 3, 2004 I used to give people like that money when I saw them. It was really only in cities like Chicago, Byron doesn't have them. But when I did it once and they harssed me for an hour and I was worried about getting mugged I decided there has to be a better way. I still get mad and sad when I walk past them, I can't look at them, but I still help by proxy.
immaculata Posted July 3, 2004 Posted July 3, 2004 [quote name='Iacobus' date='Jul 2 2004, 11:28 PM'] but I still help by proxy. [/quote] That's a good point. Probably the best thing to do is to help at a homeless shelter, soup kitchen or something like that, so that you're SURE that you're helping people get a warm bed and a hot meal. Plus, you get to see the fruits of your labor, which is infinately rewarding. :wub:
Rebirth flame Posted July 3, 2004 Posted July 3, 2004 ok, Immaculata completely took the words right out of my mouth! sometimes, too, money isn't the best thing to give people, either... money can be tempting... it can be used for alot of different purposes... i try to be as creative as possible when someone asks me for money... grant you, car gas is a hard one to improvise with, but what i do is if they ask for money for food, i give them food. if they ask for money for gas, i give them a tank of gas. i remember a thread from a long while ago where thicke was talkin about how he keeps cans of soup or something in his car along with some plastic-wear in case someone he comes across asks him for money... i have run into too many scams and stuff to give people money, and thus i go straight to the root of their problem. not only that, but what you do still counts as tithing! i hope that helped somehow (no matter how miniscule...)! May the Peace and Blessings of the Most Holy Trinity reside within your Heart for all eternity! ~rebirth
Iacobus Posted July 3, 2004 Posted July 3, 2004 [quote name='immaculata' date='Jul 2 2004, 10:33 PM'] That's a good point. Probably the best thing to do is to help at a homeless shelter, soup kitchen or something like that, so that you're SURE that you're helping people get a warm bed and a hot meal. Plus, you get to see the fruits of your labor, which is infinately rewarding. :wub: [/quote] Yeh that is about what I do. But I like what Rebirth said about what Thicke said (Whoa something tells me that is the start of an urban legend, well this guy I knew on this phorum knew this guy on this phorum... ). I may have to try that. Even beyond that it is probly smart, at least here in the winter, to carry some "rations."
Philippe Posted July 3, 2004 Posted July 3, 2004 one of the best things is ... if u see a homeless person give them a gift certificate to the grocery store. By doing that ur sure that your money is well spent by them
BurkeFan Posted July 3, 2004 Posted July 3, 2004 [quote name='lifeteener' date='Jul 2 2004, 11:08 PM'] one of the best things is ... if u see a homeless person give them a gift certificate to the grocery store. By doing that ur sure that your money is well spent by them [/quote] Grocery stores still sell booze.
Philippe Posted July 3, 2004 Posted July 3, 2004 ya but they dont sell hard drugs that they may want if u have any better ideas... its still better then cash
Iacobus Posted July 3, 2004 Posted July 3, 2004 [quote name='BurkeFan' date='Jul 2 2004, 11:15 PM'] Grocery stores still sell booze. [/quote] That is one thing I LOVED about the Link Card in IL. It is the IL's food stamps program and it is like an ATM card. The state puts so much money in it at the start of the month and it can be used to buy things at all Link accpeting stores in IL. I used to work at one. The Link system in all computerized and so was the stores. I would scan say milk, bread, hot dogs, beer, and a cartoon of cigerettes. It sorted them out. The Link would pay for the milk, bread, hotdogs all tax free, and than leave them for pay the full price and full tax on the "sin" items.
Sojourner Posted July 3, 2004 Posted July 3, 2004 Yeah, I never give money directly to people. And in fact, I rarely carry money so I can say with a clear conscience, "Sorry, I don't have any cash on me." I figure giving to my church or to a shelter is a better use of the money.
little_angel202 Posted July 3, 2004 Posted July 3, 2004 there was a guy i knew once and he always gave homeless people a cup of coffee or a sandwich if they asked for money and some of these homeless people actually had the cheek to refuse him or acsept the food and then throw it away!!!! i thinks it better giving money to an actual charity~ katy
theculturewarrior Posted July 3, 2004 Posted July 3, 2004 Maybe giving money directly to someone in dire straits is bad, because they could spend the money on booze or drugs or even a knife or some kind of weapon. Try buying food for whoever you see. Pray to God that they'll still be there when you get back, but if not, you tried. Maybe they will be insulted by the prospect, or maybe they will be angry that you spent "their money" for them. Most will be grateful. Just remember, it is not our responsibility to read people's hearts. That belongs to God. God is our judge, yours and theirs. If you offer your gift to them, and if you offer it up to God, I promise you it will go well for you. They way I read the Gospels, we should give everyone the benefit of the doubt. That said, be safe, and be street smart. Don't go get yourself killed.
Ash Wednesday Posted July 3, 2004 Posted July 3, 2004 I think it's best to buy them food if you feel the need to give SOMETHING to them -- like fruit, a bagel or a sandwich, or a vitamin-supplemented drink. If they have shotty clothes, consider getting them an item of clothing. Or even give them a bible or pamphlet for a religious devotion. No way I'm giving my money directly to them to possibly be used on booze or a hooker. Giving money to charity to help them is fine, though.
StMichael Posted July 3, 2004 Posted July 3, 2004 I live and work in New York City. Hands are out everywhere and that is just the local government & police. Anyway, there are those who sit on the sidewalk, different cardboard sign everyday, saying stuff like "Hatting Life" (not a misspelling, that's an actual sign), yet are clean, smoking cigarettes (NYC price for butts - $7.50 - $9.00 a PACK). Bottom line, won't give'em a dime because it is going to drugs. You can help those who really need it. If they are asking for money for food, buy'em a slice of pizza and a soda, etc. But in the big city one has to be careful that you are not helping along a drug habit. You know who really needs it and who doesn't. For those you are unsure of give an extra donation in the poor box that Sunday.
Carrie Posted July 3, 2004 Posted July 3, 2004 I agree with you completely St Michael. I live in NYC too and there are so many hands out asking for money. It drives me crazy to see someone begging for money and wearing the newest designer sneakers. This happens on the subway alot. Though, there are some that seem ok. There is a group who rides the subways collecting extra food people have in their purses or briefcases for the homeless they come across. I don't know the group's name, but I see them every morning. I've gotten into the habit of carrying an extra bagel and fruit with me to give to them. But I won't give cash because drugs are just too accessible here. Like St Michael said, you can always give extra in the poor box.
Norseman82 Posted July 3, 2004 Posted July 3, 2004 I live in Chicago and working downtown I see everything. The gas thing seems to be something new and no doubt a lot of it is a scam. One day at a gas station someone asked for some money for gas. I gave him some change, then he went across the street to the liquor store. So pardon me if I don't just hand out money to everyone. Another scam was when someone was in the parking lot asking for money for bus fare because he just got out of the hospital and needed to get home. I asked which hospital he got discharged from and where he had to go - turns out he went two miles in the opposite direction of where he had to go to ask for money! Sorry, sir, I don't fall for that either. A few weeks back I was walking to the local 7-11 and two teenage girls said they needed money for the bus and were very pestering, stating "they would do anything for me" (like I can't smell solicitation and a possible sting). I realy wanted to ask them why they didn't have the brains enough to make sure they had enough money with them in the first place. I have bought food for them. And there are food coupons that are good at some downtown fast food places. And I would sometimes ask them to breathe on me so I could determine if there was alcohol on their breath. And I have just had them pump a gallon of gas on my card just to get them going for a bit. But if they refuse direct help, it is a sign of a scam and you should feel no remorse. And Iacobus, if someone harasses you, keep walking. There are also laws against agressive panhandling in some cities. And Soldier, [quote]I decided on my way out I'd slip her five bucks. But she was gone, no where in sight. I had already failed my test![/quote] You did NOT fail! Remember what Christ said about the two sons who the father asked to go out to work in the fields, there was one who initially refused but then changed his mind, and he is the one who is regarded as doing his father's will? THIS IS YOU! (Besides, maybe he fact that the person was not there when you got out is a sign that it may have been a scam after all and the person was trying to manipulate your religious feelings). So don't beat yourself up over this, OK?
Crusader_4 Posted July 3, 2004 Posted July 3, 2004 In the Cathedral in our diocease at the parish hall there htye have a sign that actually requests ppl instead of giving money to ppl they see on the street to support charities or give them food, clothing, etc.
P3chrmd Posted July 3, 2004 Posted July 3, 2004 also, she could have been lying to you! I HAVE BEEN TOO nice before...and given them money! If they ask for gas, I say, Ok...well you can follow me to the gas station and pay for it! I NEVER GIVE THEM THE MONEY!!!!!! One time I said this to a guy...to follow me to the gas station...and he got in his care and went the other way! SEE...he just wanted the money!!!!! Jesus wants you to be giving.....but NOT stupid! Be smart about these things! Perhaps you did the right thing! I know that sounds terrible :-(
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now