Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='flip' date='Jul 9 2004, 03:42 PM']
this is one of the most beautiful things ive ever heard...



i do wonder, in heaven, is their hip hop music? will i ever have to stop rapping? in the Great Divorce, Lewsi shows us a painter who is told that he can paint in Heaven of course, he just has to paint for God and not for himself...

i rap for God now... will i be able to do it in His prescence in Heaven, praising Him with it?








if the answer is "yes", than why can i not praise him with hip hop on Earth in His prescence? And where oh wehre is Christ present on Earth? Thats right folks, in the Mass...





Catholic Crusader... man, do you hate modernity. i love hip hop. and when i make hip hop music, it is God inspired and Holy Spirit driven. I you cannot understand that, you are ridiculous... remember, God can take the evil things and sancitify them (take human beings for example). [/quote]
Sometimes people come along that have this idea and it doesn't happen in their lifetime, but when people look back in history they say "Wow, he was way before his time".

"Faith is taking the first step even when you don't see the whole staircase. "
Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.

"If a man is called to be a streetsweeper, he should sweep streets even as Michelangelo painted, or Beethoven composed music, or Shakespeare wrote poetry. He should sweep streets so well that all the hosts of heaven and earth will pause to say, here lived a great streetsweeper who did his job well."
Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.


Be the best hip hop artist for God that you can be.

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' date='Jul 11 2004, 12:48 PM']Gregorian Chant is to have pride of place in the Mass. There should be no hip hop in the mass. Why? Because there simply shouldn't. Get over it. I would never ever go to a Mass with Hip Hop in it unless there was no other way to fulfill my sunday obligation.

The Mass is sacred.  The Mass is ancient.  The Mass deserves reverence.  Hip Hop, though entertaining, is not reverent to the Sacred Mysteries. [/quote]

word.

Posted

who says Hip Hop can not be reverent? Thats like saying God can't understand other languages.

Aloysius and littleflower: i want to know what yall think about my post about praising God in heaven with Hip Hop. Do yall think I will be able to rap and praise Christ in Heaven? Please answer!

ladybug - thanks for the encouragement.

Posted

Heaven will be beyond anything we can imagine on this earth.


Hip Hop is not reverent.

Pax

Posted

I love PhatMass Hip Hop. It's awesome. It's dope. It's off the heezy fo sheezy. There are many words that can be used to discribe it. It is in it's own way spiritually edifying. However, one thing it is not: it is not a reverent form of music. I'm not calling it irreverent, but regardless of the lyrics the style and beats are not what is appropriately reverent during the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass.

So long as you keep it out of the Mass, I'm cool with it. But do it in the Mass and I'll smash up your turntable and cut the cord off your mic. Well, maybe I won't do that, but I'll be quite upset.

Pax Amorque Christi

Posted

if i cant do hip hop in the presence of Christ than what is the point, Aloysius?

I agree that Heaven will be unlike anything we can imagine... so, imagine this: me using the God given talents I have to praise God forever and ever in Heaven. Him looking at me smiling and enjoying His well due praise. Imagine a Church that is truly Universal and meets everysingle person where they are and speaks to them. Imagine all parts of the body making the body of Christ. Imagine sharing in communion with dancers, singers, artists, emcees, poets... imagine all artists using thier gifts to worship, adore, and love the physical Body of our Lord on this world. Imagine a prostitue using her hair, the very thing that she used to attract and make men lust after her, to wash our Lord's feet. Imagine people using thier gifts to serve the Lord.

Now imagine a God that can understand and smile when all music is played to the Glory of His name. IMagine a God who loves Affrikan dance. IMagine a God who loves hip hop. Imagine a God who loves the organ. Imagine a God who loves Gregorian chant. Imagine a God who loves heavy metal guitars. IMagine a God who accepts us and does not care about what we are praising Him with, just as long as we are praising Him.

Imagine a congregation of urban people, who love praising God through Hip Hop. Imagine the entrance song as everyone explodes with joy as the Priest enters. Imagine the GLORIA at the top of our lungs! Imagine the Alleluia at the wonderous message brought from the homily. Imagine the gifts being paraded down the aisle and everyone in joyfull acclamation about what is about to take place. Imagine the entire congregation hitting thier knees and expierencing the Sacrifice of Mass. Imagine all the urban people coming together to Communion with the Church and praying earnestly to make thier hearts and wills conform to God's, and realizing that the are eating the BRead of Life, and that the Lord Christ is truly present in front of them...amen... and then Imagine the sending forth, the wonderful music that sends us out in the world and helps us express the joy to know that our Lord died for us and that we need to live by example in such a tainted world. THis is how i see hip hop Mass.

I hope you don't see it as anything else. Im not talking about a concert here, but im sure you know that...

I don't care if you wont come to a hip hop Mass. You're invited, because Christ invites you (if it ever would exist), but you make that choice. Just as one makes the choice to go to a LIfeTeen Mass with contemporary music, one goes to a black Catholic church with Gospel music, one goes to a Latin Mass, one goes to an afrikaan Mass with dance, one goes to a Spanish Mass with Latin music, one goes to a.... the list goes on.

this is where we disagree:
you say Hip Hop is not reverent
I say it can be...

Posted

excuse me while i point out the utter absurtity of your argument

by your logic, that you should be able to perform your rap in the physical presence of the Lord, EVERYONE should use their talents in the Mass, right? We should have painters painting pictures for our Lord during the Mass, we should have actors acting out skits, drummers drumming, rappers rapping, organists playing, folk music singers singing. heck, everyone should bring their talents to the Mass? why not have politicians campaigning, teachers teaching, gymnists doing their gymnatics....

you see the absurdity of it? should every single form of talent be allowed at Mass on the basis that if they can't do it in front of the Physical Presence of our Lord it's somehow pointless? no.

Pax Amorque Christi

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' date='Jul 11 2004, 04:53 PM'] excuse me while i point out the utter absurtity of your argument

by your logic, that you should be able to perform your rap in the physical presence of the Lord, EVERYONE should use their talents in the Mass, right? We should have painters painting pictures for our Lord during the Mass, we should have actors acting out skits, drummers drumming, rappers rapping, organists playing, folk music singers singing. heck, everyone should bring their talents to the Mass? why not have politicians campaigning, teachers teaching, gymnists doing their gymnatics....

you see the absurdity of it? should every single form of talent be allowed at Mass on the basis that if they can't do it in front of the Physical Presence of our Lord it's somehow pointless? no.

Pax Amorque Christi [/quote]
i guess you are right. im absurd. i actually lead an arts ministry at my college that is exactly what you described (wihtout the poloticians and teachers). I mean, i was just thinking about music... cause we have music in Mass. we dont have painting or dancing, so i was specifically speaking about music, since music is an artform that we have in Mass...

sorry for being so absurd.

do you think the people who wanted to change the Mass from Latin to vernacular were called absurd? Probably. The people who started LifeTeen? Probably.


Does my description of the Hip Hop Mass not make you smile and overjoyed? I wonder what God is thinking about this idea...

Posted

I have talked to the Apologist many times. One thing that you get while talking to him is his love of rap and hip-hop for the Lord and the Church. I'm sure Mc Just can vouch for that.

Yet, as much as he loves making music, he can't rap, due to his obedience to his superiors. What is amazing to see is his sacrifice and love for God, putting Christ before himself and what he loves to do. When it came down to it, a choice, rapping/making music and his physical service for Christ, he put Christ first.

[quote]I don't care if you wont come to a hip hop Mass. You're invited, because Christ invites you (if it ever would exist), but you make that choice. Just as one makes the choice to go to a LIfeTeen Mass with contemporary music, one goes to a black Catholic church with Gospel music, one goes to a Latin Mass, one goes to an afrikaan Mass with dance, one goes to a Spanish Mass with Latin music, one goes to a.... the list goes on.[/quote]

The Mass is meant for [b]everyone[/b]. The Mass is [u]not[/u] meant to be [b]exclusive[/b]. The Holy Church defines what is acceptable for everyone, not just for a certain taste, or preference.

Lifeteen didn't have to wait for Rome to tell them it was wrong, some of the kids already knew it. Does that make them Lifeteen bashers? No, it makes them defenders of the Holy Mass. I am a youth minister and have been working on the diocesan and parish level for 7 years. The kids just want to understand the Mass. They don't need dancing, they don't need the Top 40 being played, they just need the Eucharist, truly Jesus Himself. That's why our youth have a HUGE love for the Pope and not Justin Timberlake or Jay-Z. Our Pope stands for something that is and forever will be.

Music is nothing but petty details in regards to the Mass. Everything that is not on the altar should supplement since everything else is secondary. The arts ministry you have is VERY different from the Holy Mass.

Mass is God's time, not ours.

God Bless.

Posted (edited)

then why do we have different music in other Masses? could be that certain music speaks to different types of cultures???

I am talking about hip hop that would support, promote, and supllement the Sacrifice of the Eucharist.

The cry of my heart is to speak the Eucahrist to the inner city hip hop kids, Not to have a performance.

Im also NOT talking about top 40. Hip Hop is everything but top 40... learn the culture first...

and that is dope for the Apologist. much props. Priests give up being married to be a priests. thats dope as well. If I was in a situation where it was either Christ or Hip Hop... i would choose Christ. DUH. do yall not think I love Christ just as much as you? Im not a heretic, so dont treat me like one. i just have a passion for clarifing the gospel to kids that dont understand it...

Edited by flip
Posted

Flip, you know very well no one is calling you a heretic.

We [i]all[/i] have a passion for helping kids. I mean, that is why Phatmass is here, right? That is why we promote Catholic music? For the youth?

Do what you have been doing. Putting your rap talents to work for the youth.

I put the Top 40 as an extreme. I thought you would have known. My point was that the kids need Jesus, in the Eucharist, in the Mass.

God doesn't need our rap or any music presented to Him in Mass. God needs the kids souls and you and Phatmass, and others help bring him that, by using your talents to bring them to the Mass itself.

I really hope you don't misunderstand me again. We have to help each other.

God Bless.

Posted

[quote name='jmjtina' date='Jul 11 2004, 08:37 PM'] God doesn't need our rap or any music presented to Him in Mass. God needs the kids souls and you and Phatmass, and others help bring him that, by using your talents to bring them to the Mass itself. [/quote]
Beautifully put...

Posted (edited)

I feel like I'm jumping in the middle of something, but at the teen mass at my parish at home, we were a predominately afro-american parish, I think it was actually listed as one of the US's HomeMissions Parishes (formally the Missions for Colored People and Native Americans) and it was Full Gospel. In New Orleans, Chicago, Detroit, and D.C. there are a number of these type parishes and it's all Gospel - tamborines, organ, piano, drums, guitars, you name it :band:

I'm at home this weekend and I actually went today and it was beautiful; the evangelism that pours out this ministry is amazing.

Edited by M.SIGGA
Posted

okay, now i think flip is getting it a little too harsh from some thoer posters.

A good point that Aloysius made about Hip-Hop not being sacred.
Some music is sacred, some isn't.
Somebody(ies) determines that. Several good points, such as Mass isn't exclusive.

Posted

Flip....you will never get these cats to feel the way you do about hip-hop, and therefore...most (MOST) cannot see how it can be reverent... but I assure you that if some things are allowed in churches such as electric guitar, Ive even seen light drums, then there is no way people can exclude hip-hop.

by the way convincing these people is pointless. I commend you for trying to reach a higher target such as that director at the lifeteen website. That is where this topic should be brought up.

I love hip-hop...I love Jesus...I love phatmass.

MTB

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

[quote]Aloysius and littleflower: i want to know what yall think about my post about praising God in heaven with Hip Hop. Do yall think I will be able to rap and praise Christ in Heaven? Please answer![/quote]

i dont think we can even begin to imagine what and how heaven will be like. :)

i didn't mean anything uncharitable in any of my posts, so sorry if it came across as such.....

and heres a link to the GIRM :)
[url="http://www.usccb.org/liturgy"]click here[/url]
(click on roman missal)

pax.

Posted

[quote name='flip' date='Jul 11 2004, 12:45 PM'] i just thought...


The LifeTeen program thrives in mostly white suburban areas around America. Mainly, becuase the music of contemporary worship is geared toward that demographic. We find this problem in College Campus Ministries across America as well.

In the Catholic Church, we have many many churches in underdeveloped and non-affluent neigborhoods... what if LifeTeen had an urban ministry that focused on the youth in these communities? Instead of the "white suburban contemporary" songs, we would have the music of thier culture... which would probably be Hip Hop... [/quote]
You are right Flip.

It seems to be a prejudice against urban people and I believe hip hop can be christianized in such a way that it would not distract from the eucharist and would not be much different from the folk music that they started playing in the 60's that only appeals to the ex-hippies who are of caucasian descent in my parents generation. This Peter, Paul, and Mary music is so cheesy I end up fighting back laughter.

My church STILL has traditional mass in the morning at 8:00.

But they are playing this corny hippy folk music and trying to appeal to the parent who go to mass.

What is going to happen when you are a parent or grandparent yourself, and you are at mass with your children or grandchildren? Will they still be playing 60's style folk music? Most of the masses across the US are stuck in the 60's and 70's, and no one dares say anything.

Either take ALL of the music away, or let every culture be represented.
Don't pick and choose which cultures are appropriate. (they usually only approve
the music that the upper and middle class listen to)

I have a question. If we are supposed to bring the whole world into Catholicism what is going to happen to the African American Southern Baptists when they convert who for generations have sung this BEAUTIFUL gospel that stirs the soul, with so much beauty and passion and tears. These people that have worshipped through the years with their old traditional negro spirituals that helped them get through slavery....will they be forced to sit down and shut up and act white?

If you are at a little church in a dominately urban environment, let's say, in the middle of the Bronx, I think there is a way to have a youth group sing in their own language about Jesus...and it could be done at the beginning of mass, not at the processional to receive the Eucharist.

My church has children sing their Sunday School songs and they do body movements to the songs, and this is approved by our Bishop. We do it at the beginning of mass, and then when it's time for the Eucharist, there is a very extremely soft instrumental that gets everyone ready to meditate on what they are about to receive.

I think Flip has something, a spiritual stirring that is not going away.

True, we have to be obedient. And I will be obedient in this matter. But giving suggestions and ideas to the leaders in a respectful way and speaking to them from your heart about how you feel is not a sin. It's only suggestions and ideas. No one is going to defy their Bishop and the Pope and do something without approval.

But we need to be open to the day when the Pope could say it is okay. And if the Pope says it, we should not have any idols or attachments to prevent us from following what the Pope says.

Posted

yeah. ladybug - you are such an inspiration... that's exactly what i feel.


and Mo, you are right... this topic belongs in the hands of the leaders of the Church, and the Leaders of LifeTeen... to which I have already started talking to. I appreciate everyone's comments, but i think i have reached a point where I will agree to disagree.

I agree that Hip Hop could lead the urban youth in reverence, meditation, and honor to the Eucharist in Mass.

Most of yall disagree wiht this statement.

ok - fine. The only thing that we have to find out is if the Leaders of the Church and the Holy Spirit agrees with me, or against me...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...