Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Vaccine and other products - abortion connection


Recommended Posts

Posted

People object to taking vaccines saying it is abortion tainted however the same people are ready to use products made by companies which donates to Planned parenthood and provides money for abortion.

Isn't that just a hypocrisy?

As per moral theology I understand that both  will likely  come under remote mediate material cooperation

Ash Wednesday
Posted

I think in fairness, a lot of other situations of remote cooperation are rarely discussed in comparison to how much the vaccines are. A lot of those that I know that have criticized the vaccines for this material cooperation are actually not aware of similar issues with touted alternatives, like ivermectin and hydrochloroquine. I don't think people are in the wrong for opposing the testing and manufacturing practices as they see fit, and I think people that do work and lobby for ethical alternative practices in research and development are commendable. 

There's a pretty extensive amount of threads and discussions/debates on here, including some that go into the CDF's rulings on these vaccines -- in a nutshell, per the CDF, one is permitted to take the vaccine, but it is not a moral obligation. That said, everyone is still morally obligated to take measures to prevent the spread of disease. If someone's keeping that in mind, I am not going to judge anyone's decision either way. 

Posted (edited)
On 11/2/2021 at 2:16 AM, PadrePio said:

People object to taking vaccines saying it is abortion tainted however the same people are ready to use products made by companies which donates to Planned parenthood and provides money for abortion.

Isn't that just a hypocrisy?

As per moral theology I understand that both  will likely  come under remote mediate material cooperation

Half the items on your kitchen shelf and the computer on which you write have about as much of a material connection to abortion as the vaccine (at least the Moderna). Let's keep it real that's just a smokescreen justification put forth by many people who simply don't want to take the vaccine for other reasons (political, safety, or whatever).

Edited by Peace
Posted
On 11/3/2021 at 1:12 PM, Peace said:

Half the items on your kitchen shelf and the computer on which you write have about as much of a material connection to abortion as the vaccine (at least the Moderna). Let's keep it real that's just a smokescreen justification put forth by many people who simply don't want to take the vaccine for other reasons (political, safety, or whatever).

One cannot fight every front at the same time.

Choose your battles wisely.

On 11/3/2021 at 1:12 PM, Peace said:

Half the items on your kitchen shelf and the computer on which you write have about as much of a material connection to abortion as the vaccine (at least the Moderna). Let's keep it real that's just a smokescreen justification put forth by many people who simply don't want to take the vaccine for other reasons (political, safety, or whatever).

One cannot fight at every front at once.

Choose your battles wisely.

Posted
2 hours ago, Didacus said:

One cannot fight at every front at once.

Choose your battles wisely.

That's true. But why fight a battle against the vaccine, instead of the bottle of shampoo in your bathroom, or what have you? I don't see the logic of targeting the vaccine in particular.

Credo in Deum
Posted (edited)
58 minutes ago, Peace said:

That's true. But why fight a battle against the vaccine, instead of the bottle of shampoo in your bathroom, or what have you? I don't see the logic of targeting the vaccine in particular.

Well for one the shampoo in my bathroom goes on me and not in me.  Secondly, my government hasn’t mandated I use shampoo or lose my livelihood.  Lastly, shampoo has had a nice history of testing before being made available to the public.

Why mandate an experimental vaccine? Why take something that is only called a vaccine because they’ve changed the definition of vaccine twice already because the current vaccine didn’t meat the standards of a vaccine according to the original definition.  Huh, that sounds like a familiar tactic used not so longe ago in order to legalize another evil thing.


Why get mad and vilify people who objects to such tactics? 

 

Edited by Credo in Deum
Posted (edited)
12 minutes ago, Credo in Deum said:

Well for one the shampoo in my bathroom goes on me and not in me.  Secondly, my government hasn’t mandated I use shampoo or lose my livelihood.  Lastly, shampoo has had a nice history of testing before being made available to the public.

Why mandate and experimental vaccine? Why take something that is only called a vaccine because they’ve changed the definition of vaccine twice already because the current vaccine didn’t meat the standards of a vaccine according to the original definition.  Huh, that sounds like a familiar tactic used not so longe ago in order to legalize another evil thing.

Those are perfectly valid reasons to object to the vaccine.

But it goes back to my point - the abortion issue in relation to the vaccine is simply a smokescreen that is being used to justify a decision to not take the vaccine for other reasons (safety, testing history, etc.). People are just saying "the vaccine is tainted by abortion" because they had decided not to take it anyway. We've all decided that we aren't changing our shampoo, so we don't go around saying "Head and Shoulders (or whatever) was tested on an aborted cell line" or what have you. So in a sense I think its like an "ex post facto" justification in the case of the vaccine.

Edited by Peace
Credo in Deum
Posted
9 minutes ago, Peace said:

Those are perfectly valid reasons to object to the vaccine.

But it goes back to my point - the abortion issue in relation to the vaccine is simply a smokescreen that is being used to justify a decision to not take the vaccine for other reasons (safety, testing history, etc.). People are just saying "the vaccine is tainted by abortion" because they had decided not to take it anyway. We've all decided that we aren't changing our shampoo, so we don't go around saying "Head and Shoulders (or whatever) was tested on an aborted cell line" or what have you. So in a sense I think its like an "ex post facto" justification in the case of the vaccine.

 It could be that they genuinely didn’t understand the scope of fetal cell line testing in medicine and other products, since had they known they wouldn’t have used such products either.  Plus not knowing the scope, these people didn’t know they should look for it in other everyday items as well as new experimental “vaccines”. 
 

 

Posted
26 minutes ago, Credo in Deum said:

 It could be that they genuinely didn’t understand the scope of fetal cell line testing in medicine and other products, since had they known they wouldn’t have used such products either.  Plus not knowing the scope, these people didn’t know they should look for it in other everyday items as well as new experimental “vaccines”.

That's a fair point.

Posted
1 hour ago, Credo in Deum said:

Why mandate an experimental vaccine?

Send not to know for whom the bell tolls... perhaps the 11 million dead people might ring some bells?  

Perhaps you think the flu vaccine that is created anew through genetic engineering every year is eternally experimental?

Sure, the mRNA is new in humans, but we've been using both DNA and RNA based viruses safely in veterinary settings for years.

1 hour ago, Credo in Deum said:

Why take something that is only called a vaccine because they’ve changed the definition of vaccine twice already because the current vaccine didn’t meat the standards of a vaccine according to the original definition.

No vaccine has ever granted total immunity, 100% of the time.  Some organizations "changed the definition" they broadcast to the public because the old one was being interpreted by people as though vaccines did.

Credo in Deum
Posted
1 hour ago, hakutaku said:

No vaccine has ever granted total immunity, 100% of the time.  Some organizations "changed the definition" they broadcast to the public because the old one was being interpreted by people as though vaccines did.

Ah, yes, how dumb of me.  They changed the definitions to protect US from ourselves; it just so happens to be coincidentally during a time when their “vaccines” were taking a nose dive in “rare” breakthrough cases. 

23BBB951-37FC-4306-AD47-0E6B34854DDB.jpeg.ab64ab950d54cbcab39b7ef49136cde9.jpeg
 

I’m so happy they’re looking out for us! The fact that this definition change coincidently allows them to cover their rears while continuing to rank in tons of money is just a happy accident. 
 

A huge win/win for all of us! 

Posted (edited)

 

9 minutes ago, Credo in Deum said:

Ah, yes, how dumb of me.  They changed the definitions to protect US from ourselves; it just so happens to be coincidentally during a time when their “vaccines” were taking a nose dive in “rare” breakthrough cases. 

23BBB951-37FC-4306-AD47-0E6B34854DDB.jpeg.ab64ab950d54cbcab39b7ef49136cde9.jpeg
 

I’m so happy they’re looking out for us! The fact that this definition change coincidently allows them to cover their rears while continuing to rank in tons of money is just a happy accident. 
 

A huge win/win for all of us! 

That's it? That's the big "definition change" that you are are all worked up about?

That seems like some weak sauce man but I'll give you an opportunity to explain. Why does that matter?

Edited by Peace
Credo in Deum
Posted (edited)
11 minutes ago, Peace said:

 

That's it? That's the big "definition change" that you are are all worked up about?

That seems like some weak sauce man but I'll give you an opportunity to explain. Why does that matter?

Oh Peace, if you don’t see how going from prevent, to immunity, to protection isn’t a problem when calling something a vaccine, well, then I don’t know how any rational explication could help you, bud.  The bar to call something a vaccine has been lowered so much they could label anything that offers even a smidgen of “protection” a vaccine. 
 

You might as well give them total authority to use all of us a Guinea pigs. 

Edited by Credo in Deum
Posted
18 minutes ago, Credo in Deum said:

Oh Peace, if you don’t see how going from prevent, to immunity, to protection isn’t a problem when calling something a vaccine, well, then I don’t know how any rational explication could help you, bud.  The bar to call something a vaccine has been lowered so much they could label anything that offers even a smidgen of “protection” a vaccine. 
 

Who cares? You can call it a “vaccine” or a “smidgen of protection shot” for all I care. The specific efficacy rates are published for each of the shots, so each person can know what he is taking, regardless of what it’s called.

Smugly writing “Oh peace” doesn’t change the fact that you’ve demonstrated this to be nothing other than a matter of semantics.

But please feel free to explain why it should be considered more than that.

18 minutes ago, Credo in Deum said:

You might as well give them total authority to use all of us a Guinea pigs. 

I’m not watching the video. What is your point? A Guinea pig has no say in whether or not tests are performed on it. You have a choice to take or not take the shot, so there is no authority to use anyone as a Guinea pig.

You don’t appear to have a point. I realize that you believe that you have a point, and you may very well have a point, but you certainly have not explained it here.

So are you going to explain it your point or not?

Credo in Deum
Posted (edited)

Have you been living under a rock the past couple of months?! These “vaccines” are being mandated to the point of get the shot or lose your job and livelihood.  That’s not a choice, that’s coercion.  You call my argument one of semantics, um, duh since we’re talking about DEFINITIONS!

Lowering the standards of “vaccines” to being anything that provides protection is like calling condoms a vaccine for STDS and then mandating people wear them in order to prevent the spread of HIV. 

Edited by Credo in Deum
Posted
6 hours ago, Credo in Deum said:

Have you been living under a rock the past couple of months?! These “vaccines” are being mandated to the point of get the shot or lose your job and livelihood.  That’s not a choice, that’s coercion.  You call my argument one of semantics, um, duh since we’re talking about DEFINITIONS!

Lowering the standards of “vaccines” to being anything that provides protection is like calling condoms a vaccine for STDS and then mandating people wear them in order to prevent the spread of HIV. 

Well yes in fact I have been living under a rock. Peter.

I call this a matter of semantics because the change in definition in this case does not appear to have any substantive impact on the ultimate outcome. For example, if we change the definition of "homicide" from "the intentional killing of a human being" to "crossing the street when the light is red," without changing the penalty, I and many other people are going to jail. The change in the definition matters.

I fail to see how it matters in the case of the vaccine, but perhaps you can explain that to me.

For one, making vaccination a requirement for a particular job is not what we typically think of as "coercion". If I hold a gun to your head and say "take the vaccine or I will blow your brains out" that is what we typically think of as coercion, because you have a natural right to life. But there is no natural right to any particular job, and employers have always been free to mandate particular requirements for a job. For example,  one of my previous employers required me to take drug tests, and to be working at my desk at 9AM every morning. Now, I would much rather smoke a joint for breakfast and start working at 1 in the afternoon, but I took the drug tests and got to my desk at 9AM because I wanted to keep the job. I suppose you also think that is also "coercion"?

Secondly, and more importantly I think, is that there is no direct correlation between the labeling of any particular substance as a "vaccine" and a mandate to take it (as a condition for employment, for example). There are all types of things that are labeled vaccines that are not mandated (the Flu shot, the hepatitis vaccines, the malaria vaccine, etc.) And there are all types of things that are not labeled vaccines (my drug test, for example) that are mandated. In this particular case the COVID vaccine has been mandated in some places, but not simply because it met some particular definition of "vaccine". If you called it a “smidgen of protection shot” the same employers who are mandating the shot now, could continue mandating the shot in the future. So in this case the definition does not appear to have any substantive effect on ultimate outcomes, hence I call all of this a matter of "semantics".

Have a nice day.

Posted
18 hours ago, Credo in Deum said:

Ah, yes, how dumb of me.  They changed the definitions to protect US from ourselves; it just so happens to be coincidentally during a time when their “vaccines” were taking a nose dive in “rare” breakthrough cases. 

Correct.  The covid vaccine isn't uniquely bad, it has higher efficacy than the flu vaccine, the Moderna numbers are comparable to the whooping cough vaccine.

People who prioritized politics over public health were popularizing the proposition that breakthroughs proved the vaccinated was pointless.  The language change was to defuse that false charge.

  • 2 months later...
Posted
On 11/9/2021 at 3:24 PM, hakutaku said:

The covid vaccine isn't uniquely bad, it has higher efficacy than the flu vaccine

This has been proven false.  And now we know Pfizer fudged their numbers from the beginning.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...