Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Would a Basic Minimum Income dramatically reduce abortions?


Would a Basic Minimum Income dramatically reduce abortions?  

10 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted
On 1/1/2022 at 5:21 PM, Dennis Tate said:

own one hundred and ten acres of land in rural Nova Scotia.....

plus my wife and I have our home on four acres nearly paid off.....

 

Nice 

:lol3: Why beesh about the mega wealthy?   You don’t have anything to complain about as far as finances are concerned.  

Posted
4 hours ago, little2add said:

Nice 

:lol3: Why beesh about the mega wealthy?   You don’t have anything to complain about as far as finances are concerned.  

That is an excellent point.....

technically... my wife and I are probably somewhere in the top five percent of the world's population for relative wealth.........

Probably in the top twenty percent of Canadians?????  But that is just a guess off the top of my head.....
 

Posted

Look at you go

Posted
On 1/11/2022 at 1:57 PM, little2add said:

Look at you go

My hobby is losing elections while simultaneously teaching English to my readers. I campaigned in 2004, 2006, 2008 and 2016. Joe Rogan is hereby CHALLENGED to consider playing the role of me, Dennis Tate, in a semi-reality science fiction film series set in an alternative universe 2012 to 2022!

.... This will give him something to think about.....

PREDICTION.....People with an accent from India and / or Nepal and / or Bangladesh are going to play an instrumental role in bringing the world to the application of "Unified Field Theory of Modern World Problems!"

I say this because if a considerable amount of cracking and sliding of ice were to occur on the West Antarctic Ice Sheet........ twenty to a hundred million climate change refugees could be created in Bangladesh.......... and it is likely that at least ten percent of them will go to India....... which gives the nation of India and everybody with relatives in India an incentive to be willing to promote the Carl Cantrell theory on stabilization of the climate .....

This may be the most effective way to defeat the Bill Gates "Innovatio to zero" theory that is founded squarely on top of the Al Gore Carbon Tax Theory that he put forward in his film An Inconvenient Truth.

The Abraham Peace Accords that President Donald J. Trump and his team set up set the stage for this to take place over the coming years and decades.Carl Cantrell.....  

Quote

 

"So how is our problem of continental drying causing global warming? It all has to do with vegetation and sunlight. When sun light hits a plant, it causes a process which we call photosynthesis where the energy from the sun light creates oxygen for us to breath, water for us to drink, and is stored as sugar for plants and animals to use. When the same sun light hits the soil, all of its energy turns into heat and is radiated back into the atmosphere, carried away by running surface water such as rain fall, is carried away to other areas by our winds, and diffuses down into the soil towards the earth's crust. All of this warms our planet increasing its average temperature.

Therefore, the less vegetation you have on the planet, the more sunlight is being turned into heat and the warmer the planet becomes. This is very critical because warmer and dryer winds dry out other land areas faster decreasing the vegetation on those land areas. Less humidity in the air also reflects less sun light back out into space so that more sun light strikes the earth and more heat is generated.

The truth is that you can do more to decrease global warming by just reducing the average temperature for the Sahara Desert by one or two degrees than if we humans completely quit using fossil fuels and returned to the cave.

So, how would you start working to resolve this problem? Easy, cool the deserts and get some vegetation growing on them as soon as possible. But the method is much more complex than that. You have to use the prevailing trade winds in relation to the deserts to get the best results as quickly as possible and it will be extremely expensive.

Then we build desalination plants along the coast near these water sheds and pipe water to the tops or ridges of the water sheds

This will do a number of things. First, it will increase the moisture in the desert soil so that it will develop water tables and water will begin to run in the streams. This water will increase the amount of vegetation in the area and decrease the amount of heat being generated by sun light cooling the watered area and all areas down wind of the watered area. As more available water evaporates, it will cool the air and reflect more sun light back out into space cooling the area even more. Cooler and more humid air will have less of a heating effect on areas down wind and will reflect more sun light back into space in those areas cooling areas we won't be watering yet. Cooler and more humid air will also have less of a warming effect on our seas and oceans.

Rain water running off of cooler soil will decrease the heating effect on our oceans and our planet crusts which will decrease catastrophic storm activities for other areas and seismic activity for the entire planet. Also, returning more ocean water to the surface and aquifers of our continents will lower the sea levels providing more usable land for us to farm and build on.

With cooler desert areas and increasing vegetation, less water will evaporate from our deserts increasing the amount of surface water even more and increasing the amount of vegetation and animal life by huge amounts because deserts currently take up more than 20% of our land surface. Populations will be able to spread out and there will be less competition for existing land areas.

This strategy has to be done in steps with the first step being to begin slowing the rate at which our global warming is increasing. We need to focus on that until we have brought it to a point to where the temperature is not increasing any more and is reasonably stable. While we are doing this, we need to come to a global consensus of just how cool we want to cool our planet down to. If we cool it down too much, we will begin to have devastatingly harsh winters in large populated areas and even cause an ice age to set in.

Then we begin cooling the planet down to a point which will be most beneficial for all countries or the planet as a whole. We need to gradually bring the temperature down because there may be a lag effect in which the planet will continue cooling after we stop increasing our efforts to cool it off more. We may even want to stop cooling the planet once or twice before we reach our targeted temperatures to see if there is a lag effect

We need to start working on this as soon as possible because, if the planet reaches a point to where it is warming faster than our technology can possibly stop or reverse this warming trend, then our planet is lost and all life will cease to exist on this planet within a relatively short period of time. We will need to start with the largest and hottest deserts because cooling them will have the greatest benefit in the least time. (Global Warming II by biologist Carl Cantrell)

 

I am just getting started at sixty two.......   

  • 3 weeks later...
Posted (edited)
On 1/2/2022 at 3:24 PM, Peace said:

“Universal” basic income.

the root cause (or reason for lack of a better term), abortion is not the lack of money, never was!  

it's caused primarly by selfishness.  Driven by the seven deadly sins:  pride, greed, lust, envy, gluttony, wrath, and sloth.

this "free lunch" you call Basic Minimum Income. will only foster laziness (sloth)

“Success is the product of hard work; you can’t have one without the other”

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

In 1850 the federal government declared that a black man was not a human being to justify slavery.

In 1973 the federal government declared that a pre-born human being was not a person to justify abortion.  

handing out Basic Minimum Income will only exacerbate the problem.

Edited by little2add
Posted
10 hours ago, little2add said:

the root cause (or reason for lack of a better term), abortion is not the lack of money, never was!  

it's caused primarly by selfishness.  Driven by the seven deadly sins:  pride, greed, lust, envy, gluttony, wrath, and sloth.

this "free lunch" you call Basic Minimum Income. will only foster laziness (sloth)

“Success is the product of hard work; you can’t have one without the other”

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

In 1850 the federal government declared that a black man was not a human being to justify slavery.

In 1973 the federal government declared that a pre-born human being was not a person to justify abortion.  

handing out Basic Minimum Income will only exacerbate the problem.

On the other hand....

if we compare an economy to a body.... money is similar to blood in an economy.  
Much as doctors can give a body blood to preserve life it is possible to use the Bank of Canada, (for example here in Canada)... to create money in a manner that is more just and fair.  

 

Quote

The Bank of Canada was first established by Prime Minister Richard Bennet in 1935 as a private central bank, but was then nationalized by William Lyon Mackenzie King in 1938. By nationalizing the bank, Mackenzie King meant for it to belong to the people so the Canadian government could borrow funds with little or no interest for capital expenditures. The mandate of the newly nationalized Bank of Canada was to act as the banker to the government and to manage the public debt. As Mackenzie King famously said: “Once a nation parts with the control of their currency and credit, it matters not who makes that nation’s laws. Usury, once in control, will wreck any nation. Until the control of the issue of currency and credit is restored to government and recognized as its most sacred responsibility, all talk of sovereignty of parliament and of democracy is idle and futile.”

So the Bank of Canada was nationalized in 1938 and the government could now borrow money with little or no interest. And it worked. The Canadian government built freeways, public transportation systems, subway line, airports, the St. Lawrence Seaway and funded a national health care system and the Canada Pension Plan. But then Trudeau, under the influence of the international financial group called Basel’s
Committee’s Recommendations (The Basel Committee on Banking Supervision) made the decision to halt the borrowing of money from the Bank of Canada, and instead, chose to borrow from the private banks who instead of lending to the government at no interest, or low interest, introduced higher interest rates along with compound interest.

All banks know very well the magic of compound interest. And Pierre Trudeau must have known that the mounting compounded national debt would lead to Canadians eventually owing a dollar fifty for every dollar of their disposable incomes. After all, he studied economics at the London School of Economics. Surely the professors there knew about compound interest.

So Pierre Trudeau, instead of feeling blessed that Canada, unlike the US, had a nationalized central bank, signed our bank away to the private banks. Couldn’t Trudeau, such an educated man, surmise that citizens in a few years would be struggling to make car payments and meet rent and mortgages and student loans and to buy healthy food while last year’s profits for the big five (that’s Royal Bank, TD Bank, Scotiabank, Bank of Montreal and CIBC amounted to $31.7 billion?) If he did, he didn’t care. But it doesn’t have to be this way. It really doesn’t. Our Bank of
Canada is still there. Next time." (Ms. Betty Krawczyk)

https://bettysearlyedition.blogspot.com/2015/07/how-pierre-trudeau-turned-us-into-debt.html

 

The situation in the USA is similar.... a high percentage of extremely wealthy people want to use central banking policy in such a way that economic pressure is put on women that pressures them toward feeling that if they do not choose abortion..... that they are doomed to never be able to finish their education.. .which seems to doom them and their child to a life of poverty.  

 

https://www.michaeljournal.org/articles/social-credit/item/the-history-of-banking-control-in-the-united-states

Quote

 

Abraham Lincoln was elected President of the United States in 1860, under the promise of abolishing the slavery of the blacks. Eleven southern States, favourable to the human slavery of the black race, then decided to secede from the Union, to withdraw from the United States of America: that was the beginning of the Civil War (1861-1865). Lincoln, being short of money to finance the North’s war effort, went to the bankers of New York, who agreed to lend him money at interest rates varying from 24 to 36 percent. Lincoln refused, knowing perfectly well that this was usury and that it would lead the United States to ruin. But his money problem was still not settled!

His friend in Chicago, Colonel Dick Taylor, came to his rescue and put the solution to him: "Just get Congress to pass a bill authorizing the printing of full legal tender treasury notes, and pay your soldiers with them, and go ahead and win your war with them also."

This is what Lincoln did, and he won the war: between 1862 and 1863, in full conformity with the provisions of the U.S. Constitution, Lincoln caused $450 million of debt-free Greenbacks to be issued, to conduct the Civil War. (These Treasury notes were called "Greenbacks" by the people because they were printed with green ink on the back.)

 

.....

Quote

 Lincoln was re-elected President in 1864, and he made it quite clear that he would attack the power of the bankers, once the war was over. The war ended on April 9, 1865, but Lincoln was assassinated five days later, on April 14. A tremendous restriction of credit followed, organized by the banks: the currency in circulation in the country, which was, in 1866, $1,907 million, representing $50.46 for each American citizen, had been reduced to $605 million in 1876, representing $14.60 per capita. The result: in ten years, 56,446 business failures, representing a loss of $2 billion. And as if this was not enough, the bankers reduced the per capita currency in circulation to $6.67 in 1887!

This strategy of using central banking policy to decrease the population can be traced back to Malthusian Catastrophe Theory but the concept is actually much older than that.

 

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malthusianism

Quote

This event, called a Malthusian catastrophe (also known as a Malthusian trap, population trap, Malthusian check, Malthusian crisis, Malthusian spectre, or Malthusian crunch) occurs when population growth outpaces agricultural production, causing famine or war, resulting in poverty and depopulation.

 

Posted
8 hours ago, Dennis Tate said:

money is similar to blood in an economy.  

Baloney 

 

 

Posted (edited)
On 2/6/2022 at 9:55 AM, little2add said:

the root cause (or reason for lack of a better term), abortion is not the lack of money, never was!  

Nobody said that the "root cause" of abortion is money. But its silly to suggest that economic factors do not play a role in the decisions of individual women to have a child.

The legality of abortion via Roe v. Wade is not the "root cause" for abortion, either. Does that mean that we cease our efforts to have this case overturned?

On 2/6/2022 at 9:55 AM, little2add said:

it's caused primarly by selfishness.  Driven by the seven deadly sins:  pride, greed, lust, envy, gluttony, wrath, and sloth.

That's nice, but we can't exactly regulate "selfishness". What are you going to do, pass a bill in Congress that states "be less selfish"? Look, economic factors play a role in the decision-making of some women who chose to have an abortion, even if the "root cause" is selfishness. If we can pass legislation that affects those economic factors in a way that reduces the likelihood of abortion in individual cases, then we should do it.

What do you want? A "moral" victory by proving that women who abort are selfish, or practical policy that actually reduces the number of abortions?

On 2/6/2022 at 9:55 AM, little2add said:

this "free lunch" you call Basic Minimum Income. will only foster laziness (sloth)

Sure, just like the "free lunches" you have received and continue to receive makes you lazy.

Look, I have received plenty of "free lunches" (both literally and figuratively) during my life. My family went to the food pantry almost every month. We were on welfare. We paid with food stamps at the grocery store. Strangers paid for my education, up and through college. None of these "free lunches" made me lazy. They offered me real support that I was in need of, and helped me be where I am today.

On 2/6/2022 at 9:55 AM, little2add said:

“Success is the product of hard work; you can’t have one without the other”

Well that's simply not true. Some idiot sons are born with a silver spoon in their mouth and have everything handed to them on a silver platter their entire lives. Some folks stumble upon a successful idea by sheer luck.

Does hard work matter? Absolutely! But let's not fool ourselves like we are living in a pure meritocracy whereby "good old talent and hard work" accounts for the entire difference between the have's and the have-nots.

On 2/6/2022 at 9:55 AM, little2add said:

handing out Basic Minimum Income will only exacerbate the problem.

Maybe it will, but you simply stating that on the internet is not evidence that anyone should value.

What happened to beating a dead horse though?

Edited by Peace
Posted
55 minutes ago, Peace said:

Nobody said that the "root cause" of abortion is money.

What does the name of this tread suggest (1. Would a Basic Minimum Income dramatically reduce abortions?) to you?

Posted
1 hour ago, Peace said:

What do you want? A "moral" victory by proving that women who abort are selfish, or practical policy that actually reduces the number of abortions?

The truth

 

 

I want the truth and only the truth.

life begins at conception!

Posted
2 hours ago, little2add said:

What does the name of this tread suggest (1. Would a Basic Minimum Income dramatically reduce abortions?) to you?

It suggests that nobody said that the "root cause" of abortion is money.

2 hours ago, little2add said:

life begins at conception!

Absolutely.

Now ensoulment on the other hand, I think is still an open question in the Church.

Posted
5 hours ago, Peace said:

Absolutely.

Now ensoulment on the other hand, I think is still an open question in the Church.

in your mind, in church teaching however the meaning of “life and ensoulment” are one and the same. 

Whether or not you except this fact is really arbitrary

The statement “Whether or not having money would reduce abortions” is pretty clear that it’s all about money 

Posted (edited)
4 hours ago, little2add said:

in your mind, in church teaching however the meaning of “life and ensoulment” are one and the same. 

No, the Church has not dogmatically taught that ensoulment occurs as the moment of conception. And the Church has not taught that life and ensoulement are the same thing.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ensoulment#Catholicism
 

Quote

 

At the same time, the Catholic teaching has acknowledged that we do not know when the embryo, which is a human "being", becomes a human "person" (called philosophically "ensoulment"). And probabilism may not be used where the life of a human person may be involved,[45] and so the human being must be treated as a person from conception.[46] In relation to elective abortion, Pope John Paul II wrote about ensoulment in his 1995 encyclical letter Evangelium Vitae that:

Throughout Christianity's two thousand year history, this same doctrine of condemning all direct abortions has been constantly taught by the Fathers of the Church and by her Pastors and Doctors. Even scientific and philosophical discussions about the precise moment of the infusion of the spiritual soul have never given rise to any hesitation about the moral condemnation of abortion.[47]

While the Church has always condemned abortion, changing beliefs about the moment the embryo gains a human soul have led their stated reasons for such condemnation, and the classification in canon law of the sin of abortion, to change over time.[21][48]

 

Personally, I think that its most reasonable to conclude that ensoulment occurs at the moment of conception, but the Church had not yet taught that. It is an open question. It has been an open question for a thousand years.

4 hours ago, little2add said:

The statement “Whether or not having money would reduce abortions” is pretty clear that it’s all about money 

Nonsense. If I write "Whether reversing Roe v. Wade would reduce abortions" does not mean that I think abortion is all about Roe v. Wade.

Edited by Peace
Posted
  • It would dramatically increase abortion, as the proponents of both are the same
Posted
8 minutes ago, fides' Jack said:
  • It would dramatically increase abortion, as the proponents of both are the same

The absence of logic on this forum never ceases to amaze me.

Democrats support paid maternal leave in far greater numbers than Republicans.

I suppose you also think that paid maternal leave would increase the number of abortions?

Posted (edited)
1 hour ago, Peace said:

The absence of logic on this forum never ceases to amaze me.

Democrats support paid maternal leave in far greater numbers than Republicans.

I suppose you also think that paid maternal leave would increase the number of abortions?

Relax, it's just @fides' Jack logic, right?  Which is the absence of logic?

I was adding an option to the vote.  I did not attempt to give an explanation, because it would have been too long.

Nor did I make the argument that you seem to think I did, which is that because the left supports both abortion and universal basic income, that the result due to that fact would be an increase in abortion.

I see how you could interpret what I said that way, though.

 

Please provide evidence that democrats support paid maternal leave in far greater numbers than republicans.  I don't believe that's true.

Edited by fides' Jack
Posted
6 hours ago, fides' Jack said:

Relax, it's just @fides' Jack logic, right?  Which is the absence of logic?

I was adding an option to the vote.  I did not attempt to give an explanation, because it would have been too long.

Nor did I make the argument that you seem to think I did, which is that because the left supports both abortion and universal basic income, that the result due to that fact would be an increase in abortion.

I see how you could interpret what I said that way, though.

 

Please provide evidence that democrats support paid maternal leave in far greater numbers than republicans.  I don't believe that's true.

How about we just "Google" and click on the first link that we find?

https://today.yougov.com/topics/politics/articles-reports/2021/10/20/paid-maternity-parental-paternity-leave

Asked about paid maternity leave:

Republican support: 46%

Democrat support: 83%

Posted

If a company wants to offer paid maternity leave as an incentive or benefit, that's fine, but it should not be forced by the government. It puts an unfair burden on businesses, being forced to pay two people for the labor of one. I don't know where some get the idea that a business is sitting on a pile of gold and all that is needed is laws to make them pay everyone a "decent wage."

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...