Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Can Hip Hop music ever be Sacred?  

43 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

I think that Fr. Stan has done it already...

Posted

it can be sacred in its own way, however, it is not sacred in the sense of how music for the mass must be sacred. it can lead people to Christ, but it's proper place is not within the Holy Mass.

Posted

so tell me, give me a list of styles of Music that does belong in Sacred Mass, Aloysius.

CatholicAndFanatical
Posted

Great question flip.

I asked my kids mom this same question. She does not like rap/hip hop at all. But I do and listening to you and the rest on here keeps me away from the eminems of the world.

What I like to do is drive around town, windows down, cranking my Catholic Hip Hop in the hopes that people listen to some of the words and it might get them thinking. You wouldnt believe some of the looks I get when they hear lyrics in true Catholic form coming over my speakers. I think to myself 'Roman Catholic...thats right!'

But I asked my kids mom, when you hear something like this (hip hop/rap) can you hear the lyrics at all, or just hear that its rap and then automatically tune out?

She had said that for her, as soon as she hears its rap/hip hop she tunes out because its not her style.

This is why I chose option 2 above. I think only those that are open minded enough to listen to even a little hip hop (from the radio) might come on board. But definitly those that all ready like Hip Hop would deem this as Sacred.

I cant tell you how many times that PhatMass CD has brought me back from some dark times.

God Bless

Posted

i believe it can be sacred, but i also believe it doesnt belong in mass. I love the silent and calm mass. Although i can hardly find any here. I just think that it would turn the mass into something that it's not. a "Show".

Posted

Yeah... there are times and places for it... and yes Father Stan has done an excellent job at doing it - I saw him for the first time this weekend... he was great.

The way I see it is that yes Hip hop can be sacred but the whole hip hop genre couldn't be... perhaps I'm wrong but the whole image isnt sacred and there are only a few artists out there - most unknown to the majority of listeners who promote a sacred image.

perhaps I'm not making sense, I dunno... just a brief thought.

Posted

"elements from the traditions and cultures of individual peoples"(Sacred Liturgy, 37, 40). The use of vernacular languages and cultural symbols and adapted rituals within the Church's liturgy is a sign of Catholic unity and serves to bring all peoples and cultures into the worship of God, who rejoices in the beauty of everything he has made.

posting this here from one of ladybug's posts...

Posted

in the procession everybody will be doin the cripwalk

Sammy Blaze
Posted

dude that's the "Christ" - walk :cool:

~S.

Posted

i started last night wokring on some new music. its hip hop...with gregorian chant. hows that for sacred?

  • 2 weeks later...
ilovechrist
Posted

[quote name='flip' date='Jul 13 2004, 11:54 AM'] i started last night wokring on some new music. its hip hop...with gregorian chant. hows that for sacred? [/quote]
that is the kind of stuff that i'd like to see...

but i'm not sure if you're describing what i like...

i want gregorian chant--with a beat behind it. that's it. a dope beat, and you've got it made :cool:

i think that hiphop can be sacred.. but its different when it comes to Mass. think of it this way--

if there's a hiphop song being played for the entrance.. our body language will most likely respond. should we be bouncing around (even though we're not meaning to), while in Mass?

Posted

SAcRED 4 sure!
It has been done its sooooooo


of Da Heeeezeeeee :D

theculturewarrior
Posted

I tend to agree with Aloysius, although perhaps I would have put it milder.

Any style of music can have sacred songs, but is it a sacred style of music? I think for mass one should only use sacred styles of music, if that makes any sense. However, this is just my personal preference, and I am often disappointed.

I would hate to see a bluegrass mass, or a New Orleans Jazz mass. These have the possibility of being sacred, but they are secular styles unassociated in the minds of the average joe with the Holy.

On the other hand, many countries have folk music that is often directed to God, like in West Africa or Latin America. I've been to a Mexican pholk mass and it was lovely. The songs were humble and simple and quite Christocentric.

Posted

I love hip hop and all forms of music, there is a time and place for that music to be played. In Mass, we should stick to the basics......such as chant, guitar, piano,..and some other instruments. I've already witnessed many times, the music offset or overriding the Mass. Sometimes, we need to just smell of elderberries up our pride and save our creativity for after the Mass.

ProfessorJT
Posted

I went to "stacks" the other day, a record store and said, "do u happen to have any christian or catholic hip-hop, anything secular or something like that" and the guy looked at me all confused and asked the manager, "do we sell any sacred hip-hop?" So if a record store clerk thought it was sacred im pretty sure it can be sacred.

  • 2 weeks later...
Soldier4Him
Posted

[quote]should we be bouncing around (even though we're not meaning to), while in Mass? [/quote]


ilc~you went to steubenville right? i'm sure you saw people "bouncing around" during songs in mass. God loves it when we lift our hands to him in song and clap and shout to Him. It's in the psalms! It's a form of prayer. Granted I do agree that if the music takes the focus off the purpose of the mass, it shouldn't be used.

Posted

It is sacred, just a matter of keeping it sacred.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...