Someguynamedmatt Posted July 13, 2004 Posted July 13, 2004 (edited) [quote name='Jake Huether' date='Jul 13 2004, 09:18 AM'] Abortion / Gay marriage 2004 !ALL THE WAY! [/quote] I hate to break it to everyone, but Bush really doesn't give a carp about abortion. He's not going to try to stop abortion because it would be political suicide, so that really shouldn't even factor into your vote this november. As for gay marriage, regardless of its morality or immorality, it would be unconstitutional to continue its ban. It is not the government's job to protect the sanctity of marriage... after all, 50% of marriages end in divorce, so clearly they are not protecting marriage in the first place.[u] It is the CHURCH'S job to protect the sanctity of marriage, and it has done so well.[/u] So let the courts marry all the gay people they want, their marriage won't be valid in the eyes of the church anyway. That being said, I am a Catholic Republican voting for Kerry in 2004 Catholic Conservative Republican Realist PEACE 2004 ALL THE WAY Edited July 13, 2004 by Someguynamedmatt
Circle_Master Posted July 13, 2004 Posted July 13, 2004 Good signature BeenaBobba. I'm also glad that there seems to be some people with common sense that are refuting the dingus's who said MM is a genius and spoke a lot of truth. (dingus is an endearing term, not condescending. I call my friends it all the time!) The movie is *extremely* bias and has many many half truths. It's almost like using statistics to prove cause and effect. It can look true but be 100% a lie.
Circle_Master Posted July 13, 2004 Posted July 13, 2004 [quote name='Someguynamedmatt' date='Jul 13 2004, 11:49 AM'] Bush really doesn't give a carp about abortion. He's not going to try to stop abortion because it would be political suicide, so that really shouldn't even factor into your vote this november. [/quote] Did you forget about this a while ago? Bush has done numerous other things during his term as well that deal with abortion. Get your info right... [url="http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/national/bush233.shtml"]http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/national/bush233.shtml[/url]
Someguynamedmatt Posted July 13, 2004 Posted July 13, 2004 ok i won't continue debating but i will say that the article you posted was from his first day in office and he has done nothing since. Surely if he was going to pursue anti-abortion legislation it would be part of his campaign platform since he has decided to run on moral character alone
Lil Red Posted July 13, 2004 Posted July 13, 2004 actually, i was suggesting that someone move this to the debate table. carry on, by all means.
Someguynamedmatt Posted July 13, 2004 Posted July 13, 2004 [quote name='Lil Red' date='Jul 13 2004, 11:36 AM'] actually, i was suggesting that someone move this to the debate table. carry on, by all means. [/quote] well that's fine, but as i seem to have helped carry this thread into a completely diff topic, i'm done debating.
Jake Huether Posted July 13, 2004 Posted July 13, 2004 Bush is the better candidate. He is against abortion whether he does nothing or something. He is against gay marriage wheter he does something or nothing. On the flip side of the coin we have Karry who WILL do something and that being allowing abortion to continue and allowing gay marriage to continue. I'd rather have someone do nothing and be morally sound, then to have someone activly pursuing and supporting immoral issues. Americans are in a downward spiral. We do not know what's best for us. We don't need a representative who is going to give us what we want when that will only kill us. We need a representative who will give us what we NEED. Kerry may give us what we want, but Bush is fighting for what we need. And you are quite wrong about it being the Churches duty to uphold the sanctity of marriage. A marriage isn't administerd by the Church. It is administered by us, and overseen by the Church. As the administraters of this Sacrament it is OUR duty to uphold the sancitity of it. And therefore, we need to vote in representatives who will uphold it for us. It is your duty to uphold the sanctity of marriage, and by voting for Kerry, you are not doing your duty.
shelly_freak Posted July 14, 2004 Author Posted July 14, 2004 [quote]Abortion / Gay marriage 2004 !ALL THE WAY! [/quote] well think of how many people are being killed in a war we dont have to be in versus what kerry might do to stop it, yes abortion is wrong but more innocent lives are dying in this war than would with abortion. i didnt take everything moore said as hard fact, it raised some points that alot of people were oblivious about.
Colleen Posted July 14, 2004 Posted July 14, 2004 [quote name='shelly_freak' date='Jul 13 2004, 10:28 PM'] well think of how many people are being killed in a war we dont have to be in versus what kerry might do to stop it, yes abortion is wrong but more innocent lives are dying in this war than would with abortion. i didnt take everything moore said as hard fact, it raised some points that alot of people were oblivious about.[/quote] shelly_freek, you should really check out this thread: [url="http://phorum.phatmass.com/index.php?showtopic=14039&hl=the+numbers"]http://phorum.phatmass.com/index.php?showt...&hl=the+numbers[/url] So far, 887 soldiers have died in Iraq, but every single year, over a million innocent babies are aborted.
track2004 Posted July 14, 2004 Posted July 14, 2004 I haven't seen the movie, but I talked to my mother about it and she said it was politically charged and propaganda, but it also made her reconsider how the events of the last few years have unfolded. I'm not sure I am going to see this because I'm not really interested in paying to have Michael Moore's politics shoved down my thoat, but I'm not interested in having anyone's politics thrust upon me, liberal, conservative or otherwise. I did watch Bowling for Columbine with some friends and although I really don't like MM in the movie (he's just annoying) I didn't dislike the movie as a whole. I am under the impression that movie should make you think for yourself, but at least let you know there are (at least) two sides. He takes people and ideas and molds them into what he wants to show you (which we all do), but then tries to pass it off as wholy factual.
DancesforLove Posted July 14, 2004 Posted July 14, 2004 I don't agree with Michael Moores opinion of our president or the troops in Iraq, but I understand his wanting to show another side to the whole story but he glorifies Iraq by showing little kids flying kites and playing (as he said in an interview the bad side was shown enough it is time to show the better side). I think what he is trying to do is just to make people think but there are some things he has done in my opinion are out of line and could have been handled in a better way.
Aloysius Posted July 14, 2004 Posted July 14, 2004 what exactly is John Kerry going to do to stop the war in Iraq? nothing. he can't. Abortion has killed more people than all American wars combined since 1776. Abortion is priority. Abortion is ALWAYS and EVERYWHERE evil and immoral, whereas wars are not necesarily immoral and the death penalty is not necesarily immoral. If Abortion is not stopped, we will never have peace.
crusader1234 Posted July 14, 2004 Posted July 14, 2004 A few things here. First of all, this isnt a right-wing left-wing battle. Don't let your political patronage woo you in either direction: The war on Iraq and the Bush administration have made quite a few mistakes, this is a fact (regardless of whether the war is injust or not there have been mistakes). Abortion is wrong, this is another fact. Facts don't cancel eachother out, they connect together to make the truth, and we can't ignore any parts of the truth otherwise we don't get a balanced view of where the world is today. And if anybody here read the Time article on Mr. Moore, his closing words were something to the effect of "I went after Mr. Bush and you can bet anything that if Mr. Kerry is elected I'll be going after him from day 2". Peace, Rich
BeenaBobba Posted July 14, 2004 Posted July 14, 2004 [quote name='Someguynamedmatt' date='Jul 13 2004, 12:49 PM'] I hate to break it to everyone, but Bush really doesn't give a carp about abortion. He's not going to try to stop abortion because it would be political suicide, so that really shouldn't even factor into your vote this november. [/quote] Hi Matt, I agree that Bush certainly could be doing more for the pro-life movement. He's not 100% pro-life, and I'm very disappointed in that; however, he doesn't support the unabashed murder of millions of babies without limitation, unlike John F. Kerry. Did you watch the March For Women's Lives on TV, where many pro-"choice" speakers lashed out at Bush for being "anti-choice"? ([url="http://www.sadlyno.com/archives/000493.html"]Here's[/url] a tiny tidbit about that.) It's no secret that the pro-"choice" industry views Bush as a threat. Visit the Planned Parenthood, NOW, NARAL, etc. websites, and do research on this. You'll see for yourself. (You can start [url="http://www.prochoiceamerica.org/bushvchoice/"]here[/url], [url="http://www.plannedparenthood.org/library/facts/030114_waronwomen.html"]here[/url], and [url="http://www.now.org/eNews/may2004/051704march.html"]here[/url].) Compare this to John Kerry's stance. (You can read about him and abortion [url="http://www.johnkerry.com/issues/women/"]here[/url] on his own site.) [quote]As for gay marriage, regardless of its morality or immorality, it would be unconstitutional to continue its ban. It is not the government's job to protect the sanctity of marriage... after all, 50% of marriages end in divorce, so clearly they are not protecting marriage in the first place.[u] It is the CHURCH'S job to protect the sanctity of marriage, and it has done so well.[/u] So let the courts marry all the gay people they want, their marriage won't be valid in the eyes of the church anyway. [/quote] See, I don't buy this. Your statement would hold true if society wasn't affected by governmental decisions, but that's not the case at all. The State began recognizing marriages because of their benefit to the State. How does marriage benefit the State? By providing children, future citizens. Gays, by the very nature of their unions, can never sire their own children as a result of their unions. Their unions do not benefit society and should not be recognized by the State. In opposition to this argument, gay "marriage" advocates argue that some heterosexual couples cannot have children, or choose not to, so they shouldn't be able to marry if gays aren't allowed to marry. That is logical folly -- an argument on individuality rather than collectivity. Collectively, heterosexual marriage brings forth children. Collectively, gay "marriage" does not and, emphatically, can [b]never[/b] bring forth children. It should also be noted that the State has the obligation to uphold the Natural Moral Law. Allowing legalized murder, for example, would be unjust in that murder goes against the Natural Moral Law. Homosexual activity goes against the Natural Moral Law -- and homosexual "marriages" shouldn't be legally recognized because of this. If gay "marriages" are allowed, that also means that polygamy, bestiality, incest, pedophilia, etc. "should" be allowed as well. After all, if gay "marriages" are allowed, why shouldn't the rest be allowed as well? Logically, what'd stand in the way of their legalizations if the State took a completely libertarian view towards marriage? I'm also concerned about the religious freedom of those who disagree with gay "marriage." Will government officials who refuse, on the basis of their religion or morality, to recognize gay "married" partners lose their jobs? From what I've been seeing in this news with other countries that allow gay "marriage," I'd have to answer in the affirmative. I, for one, think that people's [b]constitutional right[/b] towards religious freedom should take priority over gay "marriage." After all, there's no "right to marry whoever [i]or whatever[/i] one pleases" in the Constitution. Two men, or two women, cannot produce a child together. Whether one believes in God or not is irrelevant -- human beings are created in a way in which homosexual procreation is impossible. If two women were meant to procreate, and to therefore raise children together, why wouldn't God, or "evolution," have provided the natural means to do so? If men and women have been procreating together, and if they've been raising children together by extension, it'd follow that both a man and a woman raising a child together would be the natural, most beneficial way to raise a child (or children). God bless, Jennifer
crusader1234 Posted July 14, 2004 Posted July 14, 2004 By the way, on the whole 'war kills more than abortion' front.. thats totally (and unfortunately) inaccurate. Also, its important to note that the 800 soldiers killed was the AMERICAN count. Countless Iraqi's have been killed as well, and if the war is unjust, they were innocent.
crusader1234 Posted July 14, 2004 Posted July 14, 2004 [quote]Some argue that some heterosexual couples cannot have children, or choose not to, so they shouldn't be able to marry, either, if gays aren't allowed to marry. That is logical folly -- an argument on individuality rather than collectivity.[/quote] Hey Jen, I think Pio Nono said something about this in the Q & A. It is, in fact, invalid if a couple gets married with the knowledge they cannot (note: sterility is different from impotence or low sperm count) have kids or they chose not to. Thats contrary to being open to life which is what marriage is all about. So yeah, heterosexual couples who can't have kids aren't allowed to marry according to Catholic natural law.
BeenaBobba Posted July 14, 2004 Posted July 14, 2004 [quote name='crusader1234' date='Jul 14 2004, 02:39 AM'] Hey Jen, I think Pio Nono said something about this in the Q & A. It is, in fact, invalid if a couple gets married with the knowledge they cannot (note: sterility is different from impotence or low sperm count) have kids or they chose not to. Thats contrary to being open to life which is what marriage is all about. So yeah, heterosexual couples who can't have kids aren't allowed to marry according to Catholic natural law. [/quote] Hi Rich, I know that. I was just arguing from a governmental standpoint. Proponents of gay "marriage" usually say that sterile couples shouldn't be able to marry. I just wanted to point out that heterosexual marriage, collectively, brings forth children -- unlike gay "marriage" which, collectively, cannot. Could the government stop couples who choose not to have children from marrying? I'm not sure. Maybe. Anyone know about this? It seems it'd be hard to enforce, though. God bless, Jen
BeenaBobba Posted July 14, 2004 Posted July 14, 2004 For the record, I wouldn't have a problem with the government refusing to recognize the "marriage" of couples who choose not to have children. Like I said, I know very little about this, but if someone here (more knowledgeable about this than I am) could show me that these governmental "marriages" (where the heterosexual couple refuses to have children) should be outlawed, I'd gladly and willingly modify what I said regarding this. God bless, Jen
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now