Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hey! Is it okay to own statues of gods from mythology, like Athena or Anubis? I'm not talking about using them for worship, of course, but  to own them as decorative pieces. Thanks! 

Archaeology cat
Posted

I’m an archaeologist (well, I was one) and I own replica papyri with Osiris and Anubis. Don’t know if that helps you.

Posted
8 hours ago, Archaeology cat said:

I’m an archaeologist (well, I was one) and I own replica papyri with Osiris and Anubis. Don’t know if that helps you.

Thanks! That does help. I recently had a few of my Catholic friends tell me that it's a sin to have pagan statues in your home. 

Posted

Probably prudent to consider the source and the overall effect.

Buying an historical replica because you have an interest in the topic or its artistry? Cool. Classical mythology has been a source of inspiration for some incredible artwork throughout history, but especially in the Renaissance, Baroque, and Academic periods. For example there's a local antiques dealer near me that has had an absolutely beautiful bronze Diana figurine on display for a few years now, and I would buy it in a heartbeat if I could afford to drop five grand on art right now.

Buying from Heathenism-R-Us mail order catalogue that supplies Baphomet statues and pentagram altars for black masses because you like the 【 aesthetic】? Maybe not so cool.

Posted

Play it safe.  Don't.  It could also be an occasion for scandal.  

Nihil Obstat
Posted
On 10/1/2022 at 12:02 PM, Norseman82 said:

Play it safe.  Don't.  It could also be an occasion for scandal.  

Tell that to Michelangelo.

image.png.7df34d349296ae772d37df65aa164138.png

Posted
On 9/27/2022 at 4:02 PM, Nihil Obstat said:

Probably prudent to consider the source and the overall effect.

Buying an historical replica because you have an interest in the topic or its artistry? Cool. Classical mythology has been a source of inspiration for some incredible artwork throughout history, but especially in the Renaissance, Baroque, and Academic periods. For example there's a local antiques dealer near me that has had an absolutely beautiful bronze Diana figurine on display for a few years now, and I would buy it in a heartbeat if I could afford to drop five grand on art right now.

Buying from Heathenism-R-Us mail order catalogue that supplies Baphomet statues and pentagram altars for black masses because you like the 【 aesthetic】? Maybe not so cool.

Thanks for your response! I purchased a small statue of Athena at a charity shop awhile back (I keep it in my study) for only $5! I later found out that it's made out of alabaster and handmade in Greece. You can find it online for $55. https://www.amazon.com/Estia-Creations-Goddess-Strategy-Sculpture/dp/B06XC87WBN 

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Not the least obeisance made he; not a minute stopped or stayed he;
    But, with mien of lord or lady, perched above my chamber door—
Perched upon a bust of Pallas just above my chamber door—
            Perched, and sat, and nothing more.
 

Credo in Deum
Posted (edited)

I don't think there is anything against it, however, given that these "gods" represent devils, I personally wouldn't let them have a place in my home. I also agree that it could give scandal to those who visit your home, giving guests the wrong impression of the Catholic faith.  I absolutely disagree with Nihil's use of Michelangelo's Delphic Sibyle, since Michelangelo included her as a part of a larger context of the Sistine Chapel. 

"In one glorious motion Delphica turns toward us, her eyes looking in the direction of the Judith scene, her mouth open in a cry of wonder, her hair and cloak blown by what has been described as the wind of the Spirit. As she listens to the words read into her ear by one beautiful attendant putto from a book upheld by the other, she rolls up almost unconsciously the scroll of her prophecies as if it were no longer of any meaning" -- Source: https://www.michelangelo.org/the-delphic-sibyl.jsp

 

r10_1052_m.jpg.c659e4d9d65ca2f4cdcb52c1fe42b3c0.jpg

 

This is not the same as a Catholic having a pagan statue with zero context as to why within the setting of their home. 

 

 

Edited by Credo in Deum
Nihil Obstat
Posted

How about Botticelli? Are Primavera and The Birth of Venus scandalous pagan idols? Or are they masterpieces which represent some of the greatest artistic genius of which man, by the grace of God, is capable? His religious work is equally spectacular - is it the work of a rank idolator?

Was Bouguereau causing great scandal by painting The Abduction of Psyche or Flora and Zephyr, or his own Birth of Venus? Is it balanced out by his Queen of the Angels or his Pieta? Masterpieces, all of them.

There is nothing inherently scandalous in the artistic depiction of classical subjects.

Posted

Faith is in the eye of the beholder.

Credo in Deum
Posted (edited)
17 hours ago, Nihil Obstat said:

How about Botticelli? Are Primavera and The Birth of Venus scandalous pagan idols? Or are they masterpieces which represent some of the greatest artistic genius of which man, by the grace of God, is capable? His religious work is equally spectacular - is it the work of a rank idolator?

Was Bouguereau causing great scandal by painting The Abduction of Psyche or Flora and Zephyr, or his own Birth of Venus? Is it balanced out by his Queen of the Angels or his Pieta? Masterpieces, all of them.

There is nothing inherently scandalous in the artistic depiction of classical subjects.

I think you're making a false equivalency here because we're not discussing what Catholic artists should or should not paint, but what is prudent in terms of decor for the Catholic laity in their homes. I acknowledged earlier that there is nothing particularly wrong with it. However, I think the possibility of scandal should make one think about whether it is prudent to put such items in your home, at the very least, whether you should put them in the public spaces of the home. 

Edited by Credo in Deum
Nihil Obstat
Posted
2 hours ago, Credo in Deum said:

I think you're making a false equivalency here because we're not discussing what Catholic artists should or should not paint, but what is prudent in terms of decor for the Catholic laity in their homes. I acknowledged earlier that there is nothing particularly wrong with it. However, I think the possibility of scandal should make one think about whether it is prudent to put such items in your home, at the very least, whether you should put them in the public spaces of the home. 

I do not think that is a false equivalency. How many people are inspired to burn incense to Venus after a stroll through the Uffizi? I would predict that number to be hovering around zero. Where is the scandal? How is it more scandalous in the home as opposed to a gallery?

If someone builds a temple to Venus and buys up all of the artwork depicting her, then we can talk about scandal.

On a more realistic level, I think that cultivating and celebrating good taste is potentially an act of virtue. We live in an increasingly progressivist society which ignores or minimizes the classics when they have the gall not to conform to the new materialist subjective orthodoxy. In consciously elevating the best examples of classical art, we can offer a potent reminder of the inherent worth of tradition and cultural heritage. Now granted, a mass marketed statuette is not in itself a cultural treasure, but it does point towards those works on which it is based. Same as, perhaps, a photograph of a famous sculpture, or a printed reproduction of an oil painting.

Treasures ought to be displayed and honoured.

Credo in Deum
Posted
On 10/8/2022 at 4:05 PM, Nihil Obstat said:

I do not think that is a false equivalency. How many people are inspired to burn incense to Venus after a stroll through the Uffizi? I would predict that number to be hovering around zero. Where is the scandal? How is it more scandalous in the home as opposed to a gallery?

If someone builds a temple to Venus and buys up all of the artwork depicting her, then we can talk about scandal.

On a more realistic level, I think that cultivating and celebrating good taste is potentially an act of virtue. We live in an increasingly progressivist society which ignores or minimizes the classics when they have the gall not to conform to the new materialist subjective orthodoxy. In consciously elevating the best examples of classical art, we can offer a potent reminder of the inherent worth of tradition and cultural heritage. Now granted, a mass marketed statuette is not in itself a cultural treasure, but it does point towards those works on which it is based. Same as, perhaps, a photograph of a famous sculpture, or a printed reproduction of an oil painting.

Treasures ought to be displayed and honoured.

I like how you start by saying you don't think you're presenting a false equivalency but then say "now granted, a mass marketed statuette is not in itself a cultural treasure".  Wake up, friend.  The entire thread is about decorating your home in pagan nick-nacks.  No one is calling for classical pieces to be stripped away or for Michelangelos' work to be taken down or to ban people from owning pictures or oil paintings of such work.  

And you're right, we do live in an increasingly progressivist society which seeks to minimize the classics by pushing relativism.  A professed Catholic who displays pagan god nick-nacks in their homes, at first glance, doesn't really help fight against that ideology. 

 

 

Posted
3 hours ago, Credo in Deum said:

I like how you start by saying you don't think you're presenting a false equivalency but then say "now granted, a mass marketed statuette is not in itself a cultural treasure".  Wake up, friend.  

 

 

I like how you managed to read that and still ignore what it said. ¯\_(ツ)_/ ¯

Posted
On 10/5/2022 at 9:12 PM, Nihil Obstat said:

Not the least obeisance made he; not a minute stopped or stayed he;
    But, with mien of lord or lady, perched above my chamber door—
Perched upon a bust of Pallas just above my chamber door—
            Perched, and sat, and nothing more.
 

Then this ebony bird beguiling my sad fancy into smiling,

By the grave and stern decorum of the countenance it wore,

“Though thy crest be shorn and shaven, thou,” I said, “art sure no craven,

Ghastly grim and ancient Raven wandering from the Nightly shore—

Tell me what thy lordly name is on the Night’s Plutonian shore!”

            Quoth the Raven “Nevermore.”

3 hours ago, Credo in Deum said:

I like how you start by saying you don't think you're presenting a false equivalency but then say "now granted, a mass marketed statuette is not in itself a cultural treasure".  Wake up, friend.  The entire thread is about decorating your home in pagan nick-nacks.  No one is calling for classical pieces to be stripped away or for Michelangelos' work to be taken down or to ban people from owning pictures or oil paintings of such work.  

And you're right, we do live in an increasingly progressivist society which seeks to minimize the classics by pushing relativism.  A professed Catholic who displays pagan god nick-nacks in their homes, at first glance, doesn't really help fight against that ideology. 

 

 

I haven't had the leisure to respond to the comments in this thread, for which I apologize. I will, however, recommend you check out this article: https://www.sacredarchitecture.org/articles/god_the_father_of_lights_c._s._lewis_on_christianity_and_paganism 

If you have the time, I'd like to hear your thoughts, as well as everyone else's, on the article. Off the top of my head, I know St. Basil wrote a short work on pagan literature, which discusses how Christians can use "pagan lore" with profit. Though he is dealing with literature, I think his principles can be applied to pagan art as well. The pagan "idols" are no longer worshipped and are now received by most of us as literary motifs and characters. In my opinion, having a statue of Athena is no different than having a bust of the Bard or Homer. 

Posted
On 10/8/2022 at 5:05 PM, Nihil Obstat said:

I do not think that is a false equivalency. How many people are inspired to burn incense to Venus after a stroll through the Uffizi? I would predict that number to be hovering around zero. Where is the scandal? How is it more scandalous in the home as opposed to a gallery?

As opposed to a public gallery?

There are many classical art pieces that are Christian and are also worth having in the home.  I agree that context is immensely important, especially when you are dealing with pagan characters or themes, and especially when we know many of those pagan characters and themes have a demonic origin.

On 10/8/2022 at 5:05 PM, Nihil Obstat said:

On a more realistic level, I think that cultivating and celebrating good taste is potentially an act of virtue. We live in an increasingly progressivist society which ignores or minimizes the classics when they have the gall not to conform to the new materialist subjective orthodoxy. In consciously elevating the best examples of classical art, we can offer a potent reminder of the inherent worth of tradition and cultural heritage.

This is very true, and increasingly so.  But there are so many good pieces that are not pagan that we could get rid of all "good" pagan art and we wouldn't be missing anything.  Of course, as was argued earlier, not all depictions of pagan characters would constitute pagan art.  The piece from the Sistine Chapel is a great example.

Throughout the bible, every time God's people turn away from the idols and turn once again (over and over again) to God, a necessary part of that is destroying all the idols (and I can argue, artwork) that did nothing to glorify God.  Beauty is worthless if it is not in some way directed toward God.

23 hours ago, Credo in Deum said:

A professed Catholic who displays pagan god nick-nacks in their homes, at first glance, doesn't really help fight against that ideology. 

:cheers:

Posted
1 hour ago, fides' Jack said:

As opposed to a public gallery?

There are many classical art pieces that are Christian and are also worth having in the home.  I agree that context is immensely important, especially when you are dealing with pagan characters or themes, and especially when we know many of those pagan characters and themes have a demonic origin.

This is very true, and increasingly so.  But there are so many good pieces that are not pagan that we could get rid of all "good" pagan art and we wouldn't be missing anything.  Of course, as was argued earlier, not all depictions of pagan characters would constitute pagan art.  The piece from the Sistine Chapel is a great example.

Throughout the bible, every time God's people turn away from the idols and turn once again (over and over again) to God, a necessary part of that is destroying all the idols (and I can argue, artwork) that did nothing to glorify God.  Beauty is worthless if it is not in some way directed toward God.

:cheers:

Did you read the article I posted in my previous post? :)

 

Quote

He explained (in another scholarly work, “Hero and Leander”) that “gods and goddesses could always be used in a Christian sense” by a medieval or Elizabethan poet. Dante, Sidney, Spenser, and Milton all recognized that the redeemed gods could perform all sorts of good, true, and beautiful tasks. As he wrote in his magnum opus, English Literature in the Sixteenth Century, for them “the gods are God incognito and everyone is in the secret.” They understood paganism as “the religion of poetry through which the author can express, at any moment, just so much or so little of his real religion as his art requires.”

 

Credo in Deum
Posted
22 hours ago, CS937 said:

Then this ebony bird beguiling my sad fancy into smiling,

By the grave and stern decorum of the countenance it wore,

“Though thy crest be shorn and shaven, thou,” I said, “art sure no craven,

Ghastly grim and ancient Raven wandering from the Nightly shore—

Tell me what thy lordly name is on the Night’s Plutonian shore!”

            Quoth the Raven “Nevermore.”

I haven't had the leisure to respond to the comments in this thread, for which I apologize. I will, however, recommend you check out this article: https://www.sacredarchitecture.org/articles/god_the_father_of_lights_c._s._lewis_on_christianity_and_paganism 

If you have the time, I'd like to hear your thoughts, as well as everyone else's, on the article. Off the top of my head, I know St. Basil wrote a short work on pagan literature, which discusses how Christians can use "pagan lore" with profit. Though he is dealing with literature, I think his principles can be applied to pagan art as well. The pagan "idols" are no longer worshipped and are now received by most of us as literary motifs and characters. In my opinion, having a statue of Athena is no different than having a bust of the Bard or Homer. 

I like the link you posted since it also deals with using pagan lore for profit to evangelise and point others towards Christ.  This is what was done with the pagan temples, which were converted to churches. It was why Michelangelo incorporated them into the Sistine Chapel, and so forth.  Now, I think using St. Paul as an example of this is wrong though since St. Paul doesn't point to a specific pagan god to draw a parallel to Christ, but points to their acceptance of their own ignorance of the gods, which is why he drew them to the spot dedicated to the unknown god in order to point them towards the True God, Christ. 

With that said, these motives differ from buying pagan nick-nacks simply because you like the look of them in your house. Now if you are going to arrange such pieces in your house in a way that will likewise point towards the Kingship of Christ and thus edify those who visit your home then, by all means, go for it.   

 

Posted
3 hours ago, fides' Jack said:

But there are so many good pieces that are not pagan that we could get rid of all "good" pagan art and we wouldn't be missing anything. 

Of course we would - we would be missing those pieces we got rid of. Art is not really fungible - one piece is not replaced by another piece, even if they are both equally artistically valuable.

If we ever lose Botticelli's Birth of Venus, through theft or war or accidental damage (God protect us), we will have lost an irreplaceable cultural treasure. Yes we will have many equally worthy pieces of religious art, but regardless we would have lost something that is effectively priceless.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...